February 2003: Initial Auditions for "Superman: The Man of Steel" and LL Callbacks
- Location
- the point is of no return and you have reached it!
Kershner graciously accepts the offer of a month away from the project, joking that the he expected his break from retirement to last much longer. Miller, calmed but still clearly holding his emotion back, agrees to think things over and consider how he could make Kershner's proposal work. The three of you part quickly after that, each happy to get out of the situation. You smile and pretend you don't hear Kershner's jokes about meddling producers.
Unfortunately, with the discussions on Batman: Year One pushed back and the slow process on script development, there's much less material for you to cover on the topic of Catwoman with Snyder. Zack suggests pushing the meeting back to March for mutual convenience; he'd like some time to familiarize himself with more of Catwoman's iconic runs before sitting down with you. Frank Miller's Year One, Mindy Newell's companion piece Her Sister's Keeper, Ed Brubaker's run from Anodyne through Relentless and Wild Ride, Chuck Dixon's The Catfile and Doug Moench's Catwoman: Year Two are among the materials he's picked up to draw inspiration from. For now, Snyder's only question is on The Batman: how big of a role is he allowed to have in Catwoman?
While you mull the Gotham productions over, there's news and progress on the Superman front.
The first auditions for the new Superman are underway under Branagh and Ford's supervision. With thirteen candidates to select from, Branagh decides to run a series of group auditions for the actors, giving each actor some time to interact with the others in the role of Clark Kent and in the role of Superman. Besides provoking some interesting questions on the question of "how would Clark Kent handle meeting Superman," it quickly sorts out some candidates certainly not fit for the role.
Jon Hamm's take on Clark Kent has a level of sleaze you didn't think was possible, and when he puts forward his Superman read, he brings out a level of menace you've never wanted in the character. D. J. Cotrona brings enthusiasm to the role, showing a Clark Kent that's half-hyperactive-puppy and half-annoying-kid, but can't stick the landing on his Superman take. Idris Elba—you can see what Branagh was going for, maybe, but it's not working here.
Henry Cavill and Jude Law come alive in the first group audition, stealing the show with their impressive interplay and natural charm in the role. They're circled to move on to the individual interviews and auditions almost immediately.
The second group audition is a bloodbath. While Ian Somerhalder, Stephen Amell and Matt Bomer were quietly average in the first set, they can't keep up with the raised bar of performances and quickly burn out their welcome. Orlando Bloom swings from a high point in his first audition to something unwatchable. Coster-Waldau lingers at an average performance, never reaching the highs Branagh believed he could bring. Even Cavill has a misstep, bringing a truly forgettable performance that vamps off the energy of his first.
Brandon Routh and Christian Bale take off whatever weights were holding them back in the first group audition, murder their performances and rise back from the dead. There's something different about their auditions, no doubt fueled by a raw hunger for the role the other candidates just don't bring. Even Jude Law's persistence excellence and floor-raising performance in the second set can't pull you away from Bale or Routh.
When the group audition ends, your top choices are clear: Christian Bale, Henry Cavill, Jude Law and Brandon Routh. They'll progress to the next round of individual auditions, screen-tests with potential love interests and antagonists, script readings and role revisions. Jude Law's age marks him as an outlier in the group, necessitating a much older love interest than the other options and pushing the minimum age of your desired "older Luthor" another decade back. It's unfortunate to consider, but you can already imagine him being cut from the process to make the other castings easier despite his consistent and strong performances.
With a better idea of who your Superman will and won't be, you and Branagh shift gears to the first call-backs for the "LL Roles" of Lois Lane, Lana Lang and Lex Luthor. You're going to tackle first before you take a look at the love interests.
Pierce Brosnan (49) … You can already hear his voice. "Luthor. Lex Luthor." The iconic James Bond actor is interested in taking on a more villainous role after his long performance as the British superspy. There are certain creative choices you'd have to make in order to bring him on—for instance, as part of his contract as Bond, Brosnan agreed not to wear suits in any other movie—but that certainly wouldn't be the end of the world. Brosnan would bring some much-appreciated star power to the film and help drive audiences, but you worry about his long-term availability or commitment to the role should the first film not be a smash success.
Michael Chiklis (39) is fresh off of an Emmy Award for his performance in FX's The Shield as a vicious, law-breaking detective willing to do anything to survive and protect his own. His take on Lex Luthor is more direct and more angry than the script, bundled around a core of arrogance and selfish need for the world to bend to his will. Chiklis admits he's more of a Marvel fan than a DC fan, namedropping The Thing as his favorite comics character, but he's well-read in both. Chiklis adores the opportunity and views Lex Luthor as a role he can impress his kids with.
Bryan Cranston (46) has received a lot of buzz and acclaim for his performance on Malcolm in the Middle over these past years, but Cranston's acting chops are far deeper than that. As Lex Luthor, he would want to bring a politician's styling and charm to the role rather than emphasizing Luthor's comic genius in invention. He suggests a Ronald Reagan or Jack Kennedy type styling to the character and thinks that it could add a new level to the Superman-Luthor rivalry. On the other hand, there's a part of you that thinks Cranston would do really well with a more stripped back Luthor performance… "bald and intimidating" has a pedigree of its own when it comes to the character.
Ralph Fiennes (40) is a longtime fan of Kenneth Branagh's work with Shakespeare and a Shakespeare interpreter himself, possessing a Tony Award for his Broadway performance as Prince Hamlet. Branagh's clearly already had a talk to him, as Fiennes' agent emphasizes many of the same points on Lex Luthor that Branagh has in your talks: the larger-than-life stature of the character, the theatric tragedy inherent in the character, the descent to madness over years as humanity's self-appointed defender… Fiennes is interested in highlighting Luthor's mad obsessions and brilliance, prefers an inventor-styling over a political or billionaire styling and is willing to fully commit to the character's appearance for the duration of any potential franchise.
Tom Hanks (46) needs no introductions. The Forrest Gump star has expressed interest in being a superhero movie for years now—as a villain. Hanks is a household name and face that would surely transform Lex Luthor's depictions in years to come should he take the role on, but with his level of star power, you can expect he'll play a heavier role in the movie than Luthor was originally planned to. Of course, that isn't necessarily a bad thing. Hanks wants a role where he can "get in there" and be a part of the action, but as long as you promise him that, you expect he'd be willing to stick around for a sequel or two.
Tommy Lee Jones (56) may have been a part of the trainwreck of a movie Batman Forever, but that certainly wasn't Tommy Lee Jones's fault. The actor is interested in working with DC again in a more positive setting than the Batman Forever production and finds the Lex Luthor role a compelling one. He would like to highlight the quiet comedy of the role in his signature dry style and stay away from "the buffoonery these comic movies fall into."
Richard Schiff (47) has been having a stellar run on The West Wing and members of your production team have taken notice of his talent. While a much smaller name than some of the other options available to you, that brings its own benefit in lacking any faces that the audiences will confuse Lex's character for. Schiff is talented, kind and a career actor, able to bring a supportive veteran presence to the film and the younger actors in consideration for the Superman, Lana Lang and Lois Lane roles.
Mark Strong (39) has been brought up as the potential casting for Lex Luthor numerous time in the studio's past discussions of the character and it's not hard to see why. The actor is a perfect visual match for older, balder depictions of Lex Luthor, like the one you're pursuing here. Like Schiff, Strong is a relatively smaller name and less likely to be recognized as a different character by viewing audiences.
[] [LUTHOR] Pierce Brosnan
[] [LUTHOR] Michael Chiklis
[] [LUTHOR] Bryan Cranston
[] [LUTHOR] Ralph Fiennes
[] [LUTHOR] Tom Hanks
[] [LUTHOR] Tommy Lee Jones
[] [LUTHOR] Richard Schiff
[] [LUTHOR] Mark Strong
[] [LUTHOR] Write-in
[] [LUTHOR] Continue Casting Call
These are only a curated selection of the first answers to the role's casting call. You could always wait until later in the production or try to reach out to other actors specifically that you think would be fitting for the role if unsatisfied with these candidates.
As your discussions on Lex Luthor come to an end, you and Branagh head to the studio's mail-room, where one of your interns has been long at work sorting a pair of manilla folders labeled 'LANA' and 'LOIS.' Flipping them open, you see over two-hundred names scribbled onto the inner cover, marked with the date of their audition and the mailing date for their footage—all in the last week—and with another scribble of their agent's phone number.
You scan through the names for just a moment—
—and decide that you'll wait until there's been a bit more selection and trimming of the options before you weigh in on the Lois and Lana casting processes.
Unfortunately, with the discussions on Batman: Year One pushed back and the slow process on script development, there's much less material for you to cover on the topic of Catwoman with Snyder. Zack suggests pushing the meeting back to March for mutual convenience; he'd like some time to familiarize himself with more of Catwoman's iconic runs before sitting down with you. Frank Miller's Year One, Mindy Newell's companion piece Her Sister's Keeper, Ed Brubaker's run from Anodyne through Relentless and Wild Ride, Chuck Dixon's The Catfile and Doug Moench's Catwoman: Year Two are among the materials he's picked up to draw inspiration from. For now, Snyder's only question is on The Batman: how big of a role is he allowed to have in Catwoman?
While you mull the Gotham productions over, there's news and progress on the Superman front.
The first auditions for the new Superman are underway under Branagh and Ford's supervision. With thirteen candidates to select from, Branagh decides to run a series of group auditions for the actors, giving each actor some time to interact with the others in the role of Clark Kent and in the role of Superman. Besides provoking some interesting questions on the question of "how would Clark Kent handle meeting Superman," it quickly sorts out some candidates certainly not fit for the role.
Jon Hamm's take on Clark Kent has a level of sleaze you didn't think was possible, and when he puts forward his Superman read, he brings out a level of menace you've never wanted in the character. D. J. Cotrona brings enthusiasm to the role, showing a Clark Kent that's half-hyperactive-puppy and half-annoying-kid, but can't stick the landing on his Superman take. Idris Elba—you can see what Branagh was going for, maybe, but it's not working here.
Henry Cavill and Jude Law come alive in the first group audition, stealing the show with their impressive interplay and natural charm in the role. They're circled to move on to the individual interviews and auditions almost immediately.
The second group audition is a bloodbath. While Ian Somerhalder, Stephen Amell and Matt Bomer were quietly average in the first set, they can't keep up with the raised bar of performances and quickly burn out their welcome. Orlando Bloom swings from a high point in his first audition to something unwatchable. Coster-Waldau lingers at an average performance, never reaching the highs Branagh believed he could bring. Even Cavill has a misstep, bringing a truly forgettable performance that vamps off the energy of his first.
Brandon Routh and Christian Bale take off whatever weights were holding them back in the first group audition, murder their performances and rise back from the dead. There's something different about their auditions, no doubt fueled by a raw hunger for the role the other candidates just don't bring. Even Jude Law's persistence excellence and floor-raising performance in the second set can't pull you away from Bale or Routh.
When the group audition ends, your top choices are clear: Christian Bale, Henry Cavill, Jude Law and Brandon Routh. They'll progress to the next round of individual auditions, screen-tests with potential love interests and antagonists, script readings and role revisions. Jude Law's age marks him as an outlier in the group, necessitating a much older love interest than the other options and pushing the minimum age of your desired "older Luthor" another decade back. It's unfortunate to consider, but you can already imagine him being cut from the process to make the other castings easier despite his consistent and strong performances.
With a better idea of who your Superman will and won't be, you and Branagh shift gears to the first call-backs for the "LL Roles" of Lois Lane, Lana Lang and Lex Luthor. You're going to tackle first before you take a look at the love interests.
Pierce Brosnan (49) … You can already hear his voice. "Luthor. Lex Luthor." The iconic James Bond actor is interested in taking on a more villainous role after his long performance as the British superspy. There are certain creative choices you'd have to make in order to bring him on—for instance, as part of his contract as Bond, Brosnan agreed not to wear suits in any other movie—but that certainly wouldn't be the end of the world. Brosnan would bring some much-appreciated star power to the film and help drive audiences, but you worry about his long-term availability or commitment to the role should the first film not be a smash success.
Michael Chiklis (39) is fresh off of an Emmy Award for his performance in FX's The Shield as a vicious, law-breaking detective willing to do anything to survive and protect his own. His take on Lex Luthor is more direct and more angry than the script, bundled around a core of arrogance and selfish need for the world to bend to his will. Chiklis admits he's more of a Marvel fan than a DC fan, namedropping The Thing as his favorite comics character, but he's well-read in both. Chiklis adores the opportunity and views Lex Luthor as a role he can impress his kids with.
Bryan Cranston (46) has received a lot of buzz and acclaim for his performance on Malcolm in the Middle over these past years, but Cranston's acting chops are far deeper than that. As Lex Luthor, he would want to bring a politician's styling and charm to the role rather than emphasizing Luthor's comic genius in invention. He suggests a Ronald Reagan or Jack Kennedy type styling to the character and thinks that it could add a new level to the Superman-Luthor rivalry. On the other hand, there's a part of you that thinks Cranston would do really well with a more stripped back Luthor performance… "bald and intimidating" has a pedigree of its own when it comes to the character.
Ralph Fiennes (40) is a longtime fan of Kenneth Branagh's work with Shakespeare and a Shakespeare interpreter himself, possessing a Tony Award for his Broadway performance as Prince Hamlet. Branagh's clearly already had a talk to him, as Fiennes' agent emphasizes many of the same points on Lex Luthor that Branagh has in your talks: the larger-than-life stature of the character, the theatric tragedy inherent in the character, the descent to madness over years as humanity's self-appointed defender… Fiennes is interested in highlighting Luthor's mad obsessions and brilliance, prefers an inventor-styling over a political or billionaire styling and is willing to fully commit to the character's appearance for the duration of any potential franchise.
Tom Hanks (46) needs no introductions. The Forrest Gump star has expressed interest in being a superhero movie for years now—as a villain. Hanks is a household name and face that would surely transform Lex Luthor's depictions in years to come should he take the role on, but with his level of star power, you can expect he'll play a heavier role in the movie than Luthor was originally planned to. Of course, that isn't necessarily a bad thing. Hanks wants a role where he can "get in there" and be a part of the action, but as long as you promise him that, you expect he'd be willing to stick around for a sequel or two.
Tommy Lee Jones (56) may have been a part of the trainwreck of a movie Batman Forever, but that certainly wasn't Tommy Lee Jones's fault. The actor is interested in working with DC again in a more positive setting than the Batman Forever production and finds the Lex Luthor role a compelling one. He would like to highlight the quiet comedy of the role in his signature dry style and stay away from "the buffoonery these comic movies fall into."
Richard Schiff (47) has been having a stellar run on The West Wing and members of your production team have taken notice of his talent. While a much smaller name than some of the other options available to you, that brings its own benefit in lacking any faces that the audiences will confuse Lex's character for. Schiff is talented, kind and a career actor, able to bring a supportive veteran presence to the film and the younger actors in consideration for the Superman, Lana Lang and Lois Lane roles.
Mark Strong (39) has been brought up as the potential casting for Lex Luthor numerous time in the studio's past discussions of the character and it's not hard to see why. The actor is a perfect visual match for older, balder depictions of Lex Luthor, like the one you're pursuing here. Like Schiff, Strong is a relatively smaller name and less likely to be recognized as a different character by viewing audiences.
[] [LUTHOR] Pierce Brosnan
[] [LUTHOR] Michael Chiklis
[] [LUTHOR] Bryan Cranston
[] [LUTHOR] Ralph Fiennes
[] [LUTHOR] Tom Hanks
[] [LUTHOR] Tommy Lee Jones
[] [LUTHOR] Richard Schiff
[] [LUTHOR] Mark Strong
[] [LUTHOR] Write-in
[] [LUTHOR] Continue Casting Call
These are only a curated selection of the first answers to the role's casting call. You could always wait until later in the production or try to reach out to other actors specifically that you think would be fitting for the role if unsatisfied with these candidates.
As your discussions on Lex Luthor come to an end, you and Branagh head to the studio's mail-room, where one of your interns has been long at work sorting a pair of manilla folders labeled 'LANA' and 'LOIS.' Flipping them open, you see over two-hundred names scribbled onto the inner cover, marked with the date of their audition and the mailing date for their footage—all in the last week—and with another scribble of their agent's phone number.
You scan through the names for just a moment—
Lois Lane Casting Options said:Jaimie Alexander (18), Morena Baccarin (23), Jessica Biel (20), Kate Bosworth (20), Alice Braga (19), Nazanin Boniadi (22), Julia Chan (23), Arden Cho (17), Olivia Cheng (23), Jenna Coleman (16), Marion Cotillard (27), Alexandra Daddario (17), Rosario Dawson (23), Emily Deschanel (26), Zooey Deschanel (23), Natalie Dormer (20), Caitlin FitzGerald (19), Megan Fox (17), Stefani Germanotta (16), Greta Gerwig (19), Janina Gavankar (19), Eva Green (22), Amber Heard (16), Anna Hutchison (17), Gillian Jacobs (20), Jameela Jamil (16), Zoe Kazan (19), Sibel Kekilli (22) …
Jessica Parker Kennedy (18), Pom Klementieff (16), Keira Knightley (17), Mila Kunis (19), Mélanie Laurent (23), Kate Mara (19), Rooney Mara (19), Roxanne McKee (22), Lea Michele (16), Ashley Suzanne Johnson (19), Linda Park (24), Natalie Portman (21), Aubrey Plaza (18), Maggie Q (23), Talulah Riley (17), Krysten Ritter (21), Emmy Rossum (16), Léa Seydoux (17), Amanda Seyfried (17), Jenny Slate (20), Cobie Smulders (20), Liliane Sobieski (20), Jewel Staite (20), Abigail Spencer (21), Olivia Wilde (18), Katherine Waterson (22), Jodie Whittaker (20), Mary Elizabeth Winstead (18), Perdita Weeks (17), Ellen Wong (18) …
—and decide that you'll wait until there's been a bit more selection and trimming of the options before you weigh in on the Lois and Lana casting processes.
Last edited: