Imaginary Stories: A DC Producer Quest

February 2003: Initial Callbacks for "Catwoman"
You open February by putting out notice of Aronofsky's departure from the Batman: Year One project and putting out feelers for potential co-directors or supporters for Frank Miller's directorial debut. Frank has his own shortlist that he's contacted: From Dusk till Dawn's Robert Rodriguez, Pulp Fiction's Quentin Tarantino, RoboCop 2's Irvin Kershner, the Mask of the Phantasm pair of Eric Radomski and Bruce Timm and the amateur comics aficionado Zack Snyder. It'll be the middle of the month by the time discussions between agents have gotten to the point where you can reasonably make a push for any specific director, but you don't expect too huge of a delay to come forward so long as the eventual co-director is willing to deliver on the shared vision you've established so far.

The first wave of auditions and interviews with potential Catwoman candidates has concluded, bringing forth a crop of amateur actresses looking to find their big break with Warner Bros. along struggling actresses in search of a career resurgence. You've been prepared with short briefs on the stand-out auditions and the actresses responsible by your casting director, and while few names have the star power as the Big Four being considered before, you're sure you have something to work with here.

Eliza Dushku (22) is a journeymen actress most well known for her role as Faith on Buffy the Vampire Slayer and brings with a clear capability for action-focused acting. Young, talented and looking to sign on to a new franchise amid rumors of Buffy the Vampire Slayer coming to an end, she's become a bit of a studio darling for the role. Her character there hit many of the same notes the studio expects Catwoman to hit. Outside of her BtVS credit, Dushku has played roles in a number of 90s movies and early 00s movies that show her ability to play to an ensemble. Her most recent film project, Wrong Turn, is set to release in the next few months. With Sarah Michelle Geller uninterested in the project, a part of you wonders if they brought Eliza in as the "next best thing."

Janina Gavankar (22) is an amateur actress out of Chicago looking for her big break with her primary experience so far coming from short films and live theatre acting. The actress is an outspoken "nerd," highly interested in non-traditional acting roles and crossover appearances in potential video games or web-attached forms of storytelling. Janina performed above expectations in her auditions and interviews, but did not blow the casting team out of the water. Like Ms. Dushku, her youth and willingness to commit to a long-term project are clear benefits in the studio's eyes… though there are worries on whether or not she'll be capable of holding attention or selling tickets as a film's star.

Eva Green (22) is the clearly talented daughter of the French acting veteran Marlène Jobert, already set to make her screen debut in the adult-rated film The Dreamers later this year with an attachment to Ridley Scott's long-awaited Kingdom of Heaven sometime in the future. Already nominated for a Molière award for her acting on stage, there is little question of her talent and more concern about whether or not the budding actress will willingly sign on to a potential franchise role. Green calls the prospect of joining a film already late in development "exciting," a welcome change from the auteurs and talent who run away from the possibility of development hell.

Kareena Kapoor (22) is a Bollywood actress looking for inroads to film abroad and a starring, global role after her career's meteoric trajectory was brought back down to Earth by a series of failures last year and a serious worry of becoming typecast as a love interest or damsel-type character. Catwoman represents a way for her to reintroduce herself to global audiences and show her acting chops in a much more modern, risqué and action-oriented way. Her past performances have won her acclaim for excellent emotion, patience and control in difficult scenes or productions and complex character portrayals. There's a perhaps overly ambitious hope that Kareena will boost the film's international sales and make in-roads for DC's cultural conquest of the Indian comic book markets.

Élodie Yung (~22) is an amateur French actress with a high level of skill and knowledge in martial arts. While she has made some appearances in French soaps like La vie devant nous, it's largely her martial arts knowhow, early potential and her strong impression in the auditions that suggest she could be fit for the role. Though Yung's interests are more inclined towards pursuing law school and a career as a judge, the prospect of becoming the face of the first modern female superhero excites her. Yung wants to play a Catwoman that's more than a "badass ninja" or a "badass killer," she wants to bring a sense of personality and verisimilitude to the character.

Michelle Rodriguez (23) is an established actress off the merit of Girlfight alone, but she's become much closer to the dream of becoming a household name by her performance in The Fast and the Furious and her frequent bouts of legal drama. Nonetheless, she has clear skill as an action-lead and the grace necessary for Selina Kyle's more subtle character traits. Outspoken in the industry and allegedly willing to walk off set on The Fast and the Furious when decisions made in the film struck her as inconsistent or sexist, much of the media has labeled her as a diva and firebrand. Maybe that's something that fits the Catwoman.

Maggie Gyllenhaal (26) has long been under the impressive shadow of her more famous and younger brother, Jake Gyllenhaal, but has slowly developed a following of her own for her character work and devotion to her roles. Gyllenhaal has a long tradition of playing characters that are either morally ambiguous or morally compromised, and the character of Catwoman falls neatly into that typing without being so confining of a fit as to typecast her. The cynic in you wonders if trying to cast Maggie is someone in the casting team's idea of making in-roads with her brother.

Kate Beckinsale (29) is a mid-tier actress with a strong sense of action and motion in her performances and a proven capability to lead films as a protagonist. Beckinsale imagines the role of Catwoman as something more akin to a James Bond story than a traditional serial, adopting and telling great stories from the Catwoman mythos rather than trying to string a constant narrative across a long series of films. To her, the character is the story, and the story is the character; tying it down with long-term commitments and building narrative arcs goes against what makes the Catwoman work. She's absolutely on board with multiple installments, so long as that wish is respected.

Thandie Newton (30) has found success throughout the years in a number of acclaimed films, from Beloved and Besieged to Mission Impossible 2 and Interview with the Vampire, but has never seemed to break through into the public's consciousness as a star. She's hopeful that Catwoman would offer her the chance to do so. Newton is interested in making Catwoman into something of a 'statement film' if she receives the position, not just about the Catwoman of the comics but about the situations and abuses people in Selina Kyle's situation—evidently, she's heard some of Aronofsky's old plans for the character—and profession undergo. Exploring that space, reclaiming that space, revolutionizing that space are glimmers in Thandie's eye when she interviews for the role.

Rachel Weisz (32) is a star without a series, looking to attach herself to a new franchise after complications with The Mummy's future direction and developments. The casting team fawns over her, from her performance in the audition to her comments in the interviews, but there are concerns from your production team about her already deeply busy schedule cutting into goals for Catwoman and Batman: Year One cross-connectivity or long-term commitment to a serialized product. She's commented a few times about what a shame it is that Aronofsky is no longer attached to the project. Still—it's hard not to imagine what her star power could bring in terms of sales and hype for the project.

You're not in a position just yet where it's necessary to bring any of these candidates in for follow-up interviews or negotiations, but it would give you a head-start on future production and avoid further delays in production to establish a rapport with candidates you're interested in. Taking charge and showing a quick casting cycle would also be a strong statement against the development hell Catwoman has gone through, so long as it doesn't backfire and bring on accusations of a rushed casting later on. It isn't too far gone to try and contact any of the initial Big Four candidates for the role, but news of an open casting call will certainly color any discussions with them.

[] [CASTING-CALL] Select a name of an actress you'd like to reach out to. The top actress(es) chosen this way will be reached out to for future interviews.
[] [CASTING-CALL] Do not reach out to any of these actresses. Continue looking for other options.





The first results for your ongoing Script Bounty on Catwoman have been trickling in these past two weeks, with three major treatments coming in so far: Chuck Dixon and Jane Goldman's "The Catfile," Darwyn Cooke's "Selina's Big Score," and the Vijay Sahni's "King Tut" story. There's word that David Fincher is collaborating with Ed Brubacher on their own script for a Catwoman film, an adaptation of the acclaimed Anodyne/Relentless stories, though there's no telling how long such a script or treatment will take to complete.

Screenwriter Jane Goldman pairs with comic-writer Chuck Dixon for an adaptation of "The Catfile" storyline—Vol. 2, #15-#18—that tells a rather ridiculous international Catwoman story that when completed will play "on humor, non-linear storytelling and constantly escalating thrills." An attempted heist of a high tech, artisan knife from the Gotham City Museum goes bad when Catwoman is confronted by rival thieves and comes to realize the situation is a set-up; though she succeeds in fleeing with the dagger, a remote defense mechanism of the dagger is activated and leaves her poisoned and unconscious. She awakens to members of The Agency brooding and discussing over her, quickly learning that they set up the knife as a trap to lure out Gotham's greatest thieves and use them to their own purposes: the hunt for the Crown of the Swan King, a priceless and mythical artifact held in the possession of Prince William Kapreallian. As insurance for her compliance and in case of her failure, they've installed a kill-switch in Catwoman that can be remotely activated.

The Prince is an easy mark for Selina Kyle, falling apart like jelly in her hands once she arrives and sets off on her mission—but the rest of the mission falls apart around her. William Kapreallian appears a complete pompous idiot, obsessed with the idea of hunting safaris and old, "droll adventures" over anything real in life. His perfect honeymoon would be a night of exotic poaching and ivory collecting in South Africa. It's clear he spends far more than he can afford. The Corsican mafia invade the Kapreallian Estate for reclamation of past debts, targeting the Swan Crown themselves as the greatest symbol of the Kapreallian wealth. To prevent the Crown from being stolen by the mafiosi, Catwoman works together with the Prince on its defense in an escalating series of close calls and near losses. There's some level of romantic chemistry between the Prince and Selina, though how much of it is real on Selina's end and how much of it is a game she plays to make the Prince vulnerable to her manipulations is left unclear. Finally, Catwoman persuades the Prince to let her appear to 'steal' the Crown and escape, drawing the mafiosi away from the Kapreallian Estate and onto a hunt for her. They set up a rendezvous point for her to meet back up with the Prince and return the Crown once the immediate situation has passed, which Selina ignores in order to rendezvous with The Agency and attempt to trade it for her freedom. Unbeknownst to Selina, the Prince confides in his old mentor Henri Ducard he intends to propose to Selina when they meet again, finding her the only woman through the years to free him from his malaise and bring back his flight of fancy. Ducard tracks after Selina Kyle, following her subtly as she reneges on her reunion with the Prince.

Her attempt is no-good, and they pressgang her into a hunt for their next target, a local Boccatoria oil-painting whose frame conceals blackmail material on a number of French and Romanian public figures and politicians based on their collaboration with Nazis throughout the century. Her attempted theft of the Boccatoria goes awry from the start, as Henri Ducard has captured her inside man Shapleigh and taken on his role in the heist. When local mafiosi recognize her from the raid on the Kapreallian Estate and take the opportunity to gun her down, Ducard goads Kyle and taunts her with her failure while he promises to leave whatever's left of her giftwrapped for The Prince. Rather than escape from the art museum with the Boccatoria as planned, she seals herself into the Boccatoria Vault on a gamble that the Vault's security mechanisms will protect her from the remote activation of The Agency's kill-switch. The Boccatoria Vault is suspended and made of see-through materials, under the watch of countless surveillance cameras, and it becomes international news immediately. The Prince, aware he's been duped but mortified by Selina's situation, heads off for vengeance, while The Agency closes in and sends in their own operatives to take out Catwoman and destroy evidence of the operation. Within the suspended vault and the chaos of collapsing enemies, Selina faces a race against time: find a way to cut the kill-switch out of her body before she dies of suffocation or open the hatch for air and let the kill-switch do its work. She uses the cat-claws of her suit to dig beneath her skin and rip the kill-switch receiver out of herself, staining the glass walls of the Boccatoria vault in the process. Selina climbs out of her bloody trophy-case with The Agency's desired documents as gauss over her wounds as The Prince arrives in an outfit resembling The Mask of Zorro, equipped with a sword and all. Catwoman tries to weave an escape through the three-way shootout between the mafiosi, the Agency goons and Ducard, relying on The Prince's ridiculous antics to distract and give her time to make an escape in spite of her injuries. She succumbs to her injuries just as Ducard kicks the last of the Agency goons present through a priceless sculpture of the Sisyphean struggle.

When she awakens, she sees the Prince, Ducard and their maids discussing over her (mostly) naked form, with measurements spread across the wall. The Prince is pleased to see her wake up and cheerfully confides that his maids undressed her to prepare her for their wedding—the thought of which nearly gags Selina by itself—and that Ducard is standing by for insurance. Forced to play along at the start, Kyle is pushed forward towards an inevitable wedding ceremony, desperately looking for plans to escape or take the Prince as a hostage while Ducard looms over her. William's maids willingly return Selina's clothes to her, giving Selina the opportunity to re-activate her communicator with The Agency and pretend to "accidently" share her and the Prince's new location on a hidden, mountain-range castle. The Agency attacks, sending their leader Galiant in full this time to lead their attempt to take out Catwoman. In the action-packed conclusion, as the wedding ceremony approaches, Galiant and his helicopter shoot through the stained-glass of their wedding ceremony room and leave the crowd crippled and confused. Selina grabs the Prince and uses him as a human shield, pulling him aside while he mumbles into her hand. Ducard is town between killing Selina and killing Galiant, and struggles at his attempts to do both while Galiant offers Ducard a better deal and new offer to turn on The Prince and work with him instead. With Ducard distracted, Selina releases the Prince and goes to run, but is stopped when the Prince's mumblings are finally heard: he's talking about his safari gun. The two rush together to the safari-gear the Prince had prepared for his ideal, future honeymoon, and Selina grabs the heavy-duty hunting rifle within and knocks the Prince out with its butt-end. Selina sneaks out the safari-room's window and travels along the building's balcony, lining up a shot on the helicopter with the rifle and with two clean shots blowing it out of the sky and on a death-spiral towards the wedding room.

Dropping the rifle and descending down the balcony's side to escape the now burning chateau, Selina spots a sports-car driving down the mountain-side road in the distance and gives a holler out to the young men driving it. It slows and they turn to face her, with the camera panning over just how wild Catwoman looks in that moment and flashing back through each of the 'lives' she lost over the course of the film. FIN on the Catfile.



Darwyn Cooke presents "Selina's Big Score" largely unaltered from its comic origins. Selina flees from Morocco with a priceless stolen artifact, only to realize that she stole a fake and find herself destitute. She returns to Gotham City as a shade of her former self, but is reinvigorated by a meeting with her old associate Swifty and a meeting with amateur burglar Chantel, who reminds her of her younger self and her past adventures. Chantel and Selina work together to set up a major heist that will put Selina back on her feet and give Chantel a chance to leave the life of crime behind her, before the film's narrative flashes back to Selina's past and her first "big score" that would have let her retire. Selina decides to reconnect with her associate from a past score, Stark.

Selina, Stark, Swift and Chantel work together to set up the heist and end up involving a few other associates, incl. an engineer named Jeff, a weapon's dealer named Mom and more. They plan to steal a significant sum of money being used to purchase Montreal heroin and being transferred on freight cars. Chantel is spying on Falcone as a source of information for the planned heist, using her relationship with Frank Falcone to listen in. In the background, Selina learns that she's being hunted by private eye Slam Bradley on the orders of Gotham's Mayor Dickerson. Jeff develops a rocket-enhanced boarding car that Selina will pilot to break into the train and make their big score. Slowly, more and more of the details of Stark and Selina's past together are revealed, with Stark going as far as to share with Jeff that Selina betrayed them on a past job. Selina manages to evade Slam Bradley's pursuits by convincing him that the Catwoman has "died" and having him agree to end the investigations.

Slam Bradley follows his investigative instincts and stumbles in on the aftermath of Chantel being beaten raw by Falcone's men, leading Bradley to burst in, kill Falcone's men, hear Chantel's last wishes and unintentionally kills Frank Falcone while torturing him for information and attempting to understand what's going on in the Selina-Stark-Swift case. Falcone's men use the information they beat out of Chantel and shared to set up traps for the planned heist, sabotaging the planned escape boats Swifty had prepared. Specifically, they warn Falcone's man on the other side of the heist, LaPerier.

The film concludes with the heist itself, culminating in the death of all members of the Heist team except for Selina herself, and a rejoining of Selina and Slam for a final battle in the end. LaPerier takes out Jeff with a sniper's shot and would have succeeded in taking out Stark and Selina with another set of shots if it weren't for Slam's timely arrival and intervention, but LaPerier's own henchmen intervenes and evens the odds again. Selina uses herself as a decoy to give Stark time to take down LaPerier and his henchmen, but Stark's gun is out of bullets, and LaPerier is able to turn the situation on him and kill him. Before he dies to the gunshots, Stark grapples with LaPerier and turns his gun against him, forcing the two to die atop each other; in Stark's last words, he confesses his real name to Selina. Selina and Slam have their last confrontation, with Slam deciding that he'll have to take Selina in for this no matter how it started, and Selina shooting Slam and escaping so that she can go and take care of Chantel and Stark's families.

A much fuller synopsis of "Selina's Big Score" is available here.



Vijay Sahni, a relative unknown in the screenwriting game with some times to Bollywood superhero productions, has presented a Catwoman story involving King Tut and harkening back to the Adam West TV show and its depiction of Professor William Omaha McElroy. Making use fantastical artifacts including Tutankhamun's headdress, the pitch is the most mystical and high-fantasy Gotham approach of any in discussion right now.

It brings in side characters including The Eraser, The Magpie, The Calculator and King Croc alongside more traditional Catwoman support characters like Holly Robinson. Many of the characters experience their own turn of being empowered by the Egyptian Gods, though the gifts seem impermanent for all members except Catwoman herself. While certainly a fun script and a strong action romp, there's some concern that it's asking the audience to accept too much too quickly with little lasting impact—perhaps more in line for an animated special episode over a feature length film.

A synopsis of Sahni's treatment is available here. A few screenwriters have put out interest on the initial draft, suggesting that some revised versions or some scripts inspired by this version may appear as the script bounty continues into next month.

[] [SCRIPT BOUNTY] Emphasize scripts in line with "The Catfile."
[] [SCRIPT BOUNTY] Emphasize scripts in line with "Selina's Big Score."
[] [SCRIPT BOUNTY] Emphasize scripts in line with "Catwoman and King Tut."
[] [SCRIPT BOUNTY] Continue as is.
 
Last edited:
MORIATORIUM 8 // VOTE 8
Voting will open at 12:00 PM CST 12/29/2022, ~approx. 4 hours from the time of this post. Voting is now open.

We'll be hitting on Superman and Batman's director search next. I'm going to skip on some of the trivia that went into these specific options this time, as work has me awfully tired tonight, but maybe tomorrow I'll edit in the inclusions for that in this post.

[] [CASTING-CALL]
[] [CASTING-CALL] Select a name of an actress you'd like to reach out to. The top actress(es) chosen this way will be reached out to for future interviews.
[] [CASTING-CALL] Do not reach out to any of these actresses. Continue looking for other options.

[] [SCRIPT BOUNTY] Emphasize scripts in line with "The Catfile."
[] [SCRIPT BOUNTY] Emphasize scripts in line with "Selina's Big Score."
[] [SCRIPT BOUNTY] Emphasize scripts in line with "Catwoman and King Tut."
[] [SCRIPT BOUNTY] Continue as is.
CoreBrute: 3 Contribution Points for Vijay Sahni's Catwoman and King Tut treatment
KreenWarrior: 1 Contribution Points for Lucas Wainwright's Supergirl and the Rise of Bizarro treatment + (???) Supergirl Interest
 
Last edited:
Lucas Wainwright's "Catwoman: Diamonds are Forever"
Decided to work on my Catfile revisions

Catwoman: Diamonds are Forever by Lucas Wainwright


We can keep the intro - Selina Kyle pulls a risky job and is caught in a sting. They have a job for her - steal the Prince of Kaprellia's signet ring, part of the country's Crown Jewels. Supposedly magical, it's supposed to have belonged to Merlin himself. (Later scenes involving the Agency members talking among themselves will reveal that whether or not it's 'magic' they believe it to be the key to something they've been looking for 'for a long time'). He's hosting a ball where he'll be wearing ceremonial regalia - she can switch it out for a fake.


Cue extravagant masquerade ballroom scene, Selina appearing Cinderella style on the stairs in a cat-themed mask and meeting the Prince, dancing with him and trying to make the switch. Prince William is young, handsome, charming, and informs her that his country's intelligence ID'ed her before she got into the country and knows what she's here for. However, he assures he has no interest in catching her and instead is flirtatious and charming. He invites her to stay at the palace and basically dares her to go after the ring, explaining the unique vault system.

The next few days see Selina hosted at the palace, her every need attended to by servants and taking tea with nobility. In the evening, she leaves the palace and goes and finds the dark side of Kaprellia - the slums and destitute portions of the population. Prince William catches up to her in one of these areas and she tries to shock him by taking him on a night of carousing and teaching him basic pickpocketing skills. He seems unphased, and assures her he will be enacting reforms to fix all this when he becomes king. She makes a comment about growing up in Gotham and the unreliable promises of rich men, perhaps an ambiguous reference to Bruce Wayne, perhaps not. Regardless, she points out that he could be doing a lot now, and he's not.

Prince William takes her to tour the glass vault, indeed an almost impossible place to crack. After the tour, she breaks off and begins to strategize. The only way to get in will involve cutting the power, distracting security and securing an escape plan. This requires putting together a team, which Selena does by infiltrating the local underworld, including a stint in an underground fighting ring where she can show off her martial arts skills, and promising extravagant cuts to each of the criminals. The Agency are sure that she'll be planning to escape with the ring and they have a plant on the team.

The heist goes off, a tense sequence which ends with Selina alone with the Agency plant. He demands she turn over the ring to him, she reveals she always knew he was a plant and they engage in a fight in the glass vault, breaking through panels and using mirrors to deflect lasers once the power suddenly comes back on. Selina escapes through a shaft used for a vaccuum based fire suppression system and a ventilator.

Both Kaprellian security and an Agency retrieval team (delivered by helicopter) engage in a running gun battle through the Kaprellian palace. Prince William fights one of the Agency's henchman, an intimidating heavy who's been built up throughout the fight. The fight goes out of him when the Agency gives the kill-switch order and Selena slumps to the ground. However, when the henchman comes to retrieve the ring, Selina takes him by surprise, having indeed removed the device much earlier in the vault, and chokes him out. Prince William lies slumped, bleeding out from a stab wound, and in desperation Selina puts the ring on him and closes his hand. The light catches the ring, almost a glow. He coughs and wakes up. Magic or was the wound just not as bad as it seemed?

The Prince offers her the ring, but she shakes her head, saying it seems like power always seems to come with a price. She makes her own way and his life is just another type of trap. She tells him to look her up if she's ever in Gotham. Taking the henchman's keys, she gets in the Agency's helicopter and remarks it's got to be worth something. We zoom in on her pocket, where the ring lurks - it's implied the Prince drew on her pickpocketing lesson to give it to her.
---
Merlin thing is there cause we were talking about Etrigan.
 
Last edited:
February 2003: Directorial Search for “Superman: The Man of Steel” and Follow-Up with Catwoman Actresses
It's taken a while to hear back from all of the feelers your team sent out earlier this year, but you've received enough call-backs and polite refusals that you think you're in a good place to tackle the topic of Superman: The Man of Steel's director. While you've received some feedback from Alex Ford on his preferred directors, you've come to assume that his preferences are based more on his baseline impressions of the directors that he's already heard about rather than directors with actual desires or interests in the project. So long as your favored director doesn't push back too harshly on Alex Ford's vision, you expect that a strong working partnership will develop. With that in mind, it might be best to steer away from auteur directors and avoid another Aronofsky situation.

Though they had been interested in helming Superman projects of their own, directors Tim Burton, J.J. Abrams and Wolfgang Petersen are much less interested in helping deliver Alex Ford and the studio's vision of Superman. Bryan Singer remains tentatively interested in the project, so long as certain elements of his script and plan can be reintroduced, but you're almost certain that'll be throwing a live grenade into the middle of the tight negotiations you've made so far. Still, there are a number of other directors and aspiring directors whose names have caught your attention.

Kenneth Branagh, a seasoned director and a Shakespeare aficionado, has expressed interest in the position and provided numerous compliments to Alex Ford's script. Branagh suggests that superhero worlds are the modern Shakespearean stage, faced with problems of mind and soul that resonate deeply with the struggles faced by King Lear, Hamlet, Macbeth and the other protagonists of the theatre. Bound together by threads of seriousness, formidability, comedy and even tragedy, the world of superheroes is a stage like no other. As the icon of icons, Superman above all others embodies that intermingling tradition of superhero and theatre. In addition to his interest and passion, Branagh is recognized among the studio for his own talent as an actor and his many connections to Shakespearean, live-theatre and British acting talents.

Luc Besson is a French director best known to American audiences for the 1997 classic The Fifth Element, though there are a number of other English-language works within his catalogue. His style involves a level of camp and fantasy that the studio envisions as a perfect handling for the more fantastical elements of superhero stories. Though the director hasn't expressed any interest in any non-Superman projects, his past work on Nikita (1990) provides a potential guiding influence on Catwoman and any crossover projects down the line while his work on Atlantis (1991) provides potential experience and guidance on later Aquaman projects. The heroes of Besson films fight vigorously as conscientious resistors to the malaise and malice our human condition brings on, and in Superman: The Man of Steel, that resistance is writ large.

Chris Columbus—ask anyone around, and they will tell you that you are witnessing a legend in his prime—has completed work on the absolute success stories of Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone and Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, winning him more leeway and authority as a director with Warner Bros. than you could have imagined. Physically and mentally exhausted from the first two Harry Potter films, Columbus has stepped away from the franchise to pursue other directing endeavors and recover. The daunting task of the Superman reboot is far from a recovery project, but you can hope that vast difference in material, scope and setting would provide a new source of energy and a different sort of reprieve for Columbus and his production crew. A few slight delays might even be sensible to bring in the masterful director and avoid burning his candle out.

Joe Johnston is a director whose tried his hand at comic book adaptations in the past and been burned for it, but that was a decade ago. Now, fresh off of the box office smash of Jurassic Park III, he's willing to return to work on the dream of a great comic book movie. His work throughout the years has shown an excellent balance of character stories and high-octane, high-budget action, making him a decidedly fitting pick for the Superman franchise. Still, his greatest personal talent may lie elsewhere, in visual effects: the Star Wars and Indiana Jones alum has an Academy Award for Best Visual Effects, after all. With Alex Ford driving the story and the overarching narratives of the series, and Joe Johnston providing visual and technical excellence, the pair could be the yellow sun your Kryptonian hero needs.

Louis Leterrier is another candidate for the position, bringing alongside himself co-director Corey Yuen, known more for his work as an understudy of Luc Besson than for his solo work. The pairing of Leterrier and Yuen produced the widely successful French action film The Transporter, praised for its advanced action sequences and Leterrier's artistic direction. The inexperience and youth of the directing pair's careers suggests that Alex Ford might take a larger part in the film's direction and prepare the screenwriter to be a primary director of later films in the franchise; at the same time, it gives ample room for you and the studio to step in and provide authoritative guidance to the film's production, separate from the deeply held beliefs and desires of auteurs and older directors.

There are a number of other candidates, including Ang Lee, Bryan Singer and Brett Ratner, who have failed to catch your team's eye in the same way but are still available for later call backs and discussion. If none of these first picks pan out, it might be worth giving them some more consideration.


[] [Director] Kenneth Branagh
[] [Director] Luc Besson
[] [Director] Chris Columbus
[] [Director] Joe Johnston
[] [Director] Louis Leterrier
[] [Director] Continue search.





You're able to attend the follow-up auditions for Ms. Kapoor, Ms. Dushku and Ms. Weisz thanks to some luck in your scheduling, allowing you much more access and chance to mingle with the potential Catwoman and cast members. You've been told it's different casting a franchise than it is casting a film. Raw talent must sometimes be trumped by dedication to the role, ability to commit to a schedule and amiability with the other committed members of the franchise. With the three candidates auditioning today, you have three wildly different takes on the character with clearly divergent goals in a franchise.

Kareena Kapoor is nothing if not willful, exuberant about the role and almost jealous of the chances the others have at it. She makes her claim on it almost immediately, announcing triumphantly that this will be her Alien and she will be the new Sigourney Weaver; that this will be her Terminator 2 and she will be the next Sarah Connor. Her enthusiasm is infectious, and even after two poor readings to the crew, she's still smiling and continuing to weave her story into the role and inflect her interests onto the Catwoman script. When she returns for a third discussion and attempt after the half-hour break, she carves through the mark and makes it her own. Dismissing pieces of the hastily-made sample script for her own takes and phrases, Kapoor breathes new life and new sound into Catwoman.

Eliza Dushku came in under an invitation to audition for supporting roles, but her charm with the crew and support from the studio's higher ups have a way of toppling those plans. Soon enough, she's stepping in to the studio's prepared audition set with an infectious smile, giving a kind little wave to your casting director, and soon enough after that she's in a mock-up of the Catwoman mask giving her own takes and efforts. Much more traditional in her readings of the script, Dushku makes a point of incorporating certain physical actions that you're confident were included as points of interest in Sarah Michelle Gellar's audition: certain flicks of her hair, an over-expression of her hands, a sort of lithe and sway to her movement designed to give a demure appearance. When it works, it works well, and you can certainly see her fitting the Catwoman role—but when it fails, it tanks, and you question if you aren't watching a high schooler's first attempt at dance-night seduction.

Rachel Weisz enters a consummate professional, kindly greeting the staff and her competitors but largely refusing to engage in their greater conversations or efforts. Her readings of Catwoman are certainly more consistent than either of her competitors, showcasing her excellent practice and the discipline that goes into her acting career. The failings of her performance may have more to do with the mock-up script itself than with her acting, as she soars past the material when she dismisses the material and takes charge of the audition with quotes from other Catwoman adaptations and renditions of Michelle Pfeiffer's iconic scenes.

The first day of casting concludes with something of a stand-still between the actresses, and each of the candidates are invited back the next day for the second set of follow-up auditions.

On day two, Kapoor is magic. The momentum of her third performance carries forward seamlessly into the day, and Kapoor gleefully brings Catwoman through a range of emotions, confrontations and escapades that each shine with her spirit and devotion before grinding the character back down to a grounded, realistic and still ethereal take. As she leaves the casting room, Kapoor turns back and makes a declaration—almost a plea—that she will make Catwoman hers: "This is a film that will change our lives." Still glowing from her performance and with raw hunger in her eyes, it's hard not to believe her.

Where Kapoor ascended to new heights with the second day, Dushku's nerves clearly eat at her, and the sleek confidence of Catwoman is nowhere to be found for the first half of her audition. When she returns for her second attempt at the day, fresh off the phone with her talent director and confidantes, Dushku brings back the demure kitty from day one and runs with it. It isn't her strongest audition attempt, but with her nerves still clearly bothering her, it's impressive all the same. After her performance comes to an end, she bows her head and thanks the crew for the opportunity in carefully measured words then makes a quick escape from the public eye. She's certainly a raw actress, even with her television experience, but she improved remarkably over the course of her auditions even in spite of her nerves.

Weisz enters the day impatient, but delivers another measured and practiced performance in her first set of the day. The second set of the day is haunted by Weisz's slowly building questions on the material and her improvisational takes on several scenes Aronofsky had planned for Catwoman; by the midway point of the session, it's hard to say if she auditioned at all in the timeslot or if she had just come to complain about the movement away from her boyfriend's work. That bit of Hollywood gossip had escaped the casting crew, and the air only turned more awkward after it was realized and the prim professionalism of her prior performance come to be understood as her keeping her emotions at bay. Even looking past the quasi-temper tantrum she'd built up to over her auditions and finally let loose, what bits of performance she brought into that last set were bad. If she were a lesser name, you expect your casting director would have kicked her out. By her quick departure soon after the session's time ends, you're sure she knows it too. Still, bad audition aside, you know that she has the talent to carry the role if you could only rekindle a working relationship...



Kareena Kapoor's Audition Results: Day 1 (10, 13, 23), Day 2 (25, 26).
AVG—19.4 | R-AVG—13.4
Eliza Dushku's Audition Results: Day 1 (7, 5, 21), (11, 19).
AVG—12.6 | R.AVG—11.2
Rachel Weisz's Audition Results: Day 1 (12, 11, 21), Day 2 (9, Nat. 1).
AVG—10.8 | R-AVG—7.6​



[] [CASTING-CALL] Offer (Actress Name) the role of Catwoman and (Actress Name) a major supporting role.
[] [CASTING-CALL] Offer (Actress Name) the role of Catwoman and decline to cast the others.
[] [CASTING-CALL] Decline to cast any participants and continue the general casting call.
 
Last edited:
MORIATORIUM 9 // VOTE 9
Voting will open at ~7:00 AM CST 2/2/2023, ~approx. 3 hours from the time of this post. // Voting is now open.

Hello. We're back! New Year's Eve, hell of a time, wouldn't recommend it to anyone. No, seriously, it was bad.

Rachel Weisz was living with and dating Aronofsky at this point in time, which is a bit of celebrity gossip that was hinted at in her prior blurb but not openly confirmed, and that combined with her poor rolls made a clear characterization for her performance. Kareena Kapoor's excitement about the role and her comparisons to Alien's Sigourney Weaver and Terminator 2's Linda Hamilton are based on an interview on her performance on Jab We Met and Tashan, where she describes Tashan as the film that's going to "change her life" and make her "like Uma Thurman in Kill Bill." That exact comparison doesn't work in this context, since Kill Bill hasn't come out yet in story, but that same sentiment is appearing here with different action heroines.

The five directors selected for Superman come after a fair amount of trimming on my part, and none are strongly connected to Superman's historical developments. Directors Bryan Singer and Brett Ratner are two historical candidates for the role, but in light of their significant scandals in recent years, I didn't exactly feel interested in giving them full pitches as candidates here. If desired, I can provide larger blurbs for them and their interests in a Superman film, but I'd rather stayaway from the topic where possible. The "Superheroes as Shakespeare" argument is more often made about Batman than Superman, and it is an exceedingly fitting one for Batman in American film (Ben Affleck has famously called Batman the American Hamlet, after all!), but I certainly think it fits here as well. It's a fun coincidence or benefit of Warner Bros. machinations that two accomplished directors have just been freed from the Harry Potter franchise and made available here.

I've combined discords with friend @TruckOnEmptyRoad for this DC Producer Quest and his FoX Producer Quest. If you're interested in joining, there's a permalink to the Discord here, where rolls are posted and conducted when updates call for them. The "AVG" number linked to a character is that character's average roll including modifiers, which come in two forms (talent and trait), while the "R-AVG" number linked to a character's result is the character's average rolls without modifiers. Traits are revealed after a character is cast or as casting processes progress.

[] [Director] Kenneth Branagh
[] [Director] Luc Besson
[] [Director] Chris Columbus
[] [Director] Joe Johnston
[] [Director] Louis Leterrier
[] [Director] Continue search.
[] [CASTING-CALL] Offer (Actress Name) the role of Catwoman and (Actress Name) a major supporting role.
[] [CASTING-CALL] Offer (Actress Name) the role of Catwoman and decline to cast the others.
[] [CASTING-CALL] Decline to cast any participants and continue the general casting call.
CoreBrute: 3 Contribution Points for Vijay Sahni's Catwoman and King Tut treatment
KreenWarrior: 1 Contribution Points for Lucas Wainwright's Supergirl and the Rise of Bizarro treatment + (???) Supergirl Interest; 1 Contribution Points for Lucas Wainwright's Diamonds are Forever treatment + (???) Jane Goldman collab. interest
 
Last edited:
???'s Musings on Hawkman & Hawkworld
Hey there!

I kinda got interested in Hawkman (which I still don't know much about) and I wanted to challenge myself to try and create a pitch for a Hawkman movie with minimal knowledge of the character.

So I put together a basic outline for this movie, and while it definitely needs some more fleshing out, I think I got the main setting and some of the plot points down. I'll admit, I'm not super familiar with the original Hawkman story (more like know next to nothing), but I'm loving where this version is going!

The vibe is egyptian mythology meets cyberpunk with some shenanigans involving sci-fi concepts such as time travel, cryosleep, memory uploads, parallel universes...

Anyways, I'd love to hear your thoughts and feedback. Feel free to add anything you think would make the story even cooler!

You can also share the doc, edit stuff, add your own ideas!

docs.google.com

Hawkworld

Synopsis: (Pitch) The movie "Hawkworld" follows the journey of Soraya Thal as she is transported to a parallel dimension. In this world, she finds herself in the body of Shayera Thal, a high-ranking police officer in the corrupt city of Nekhen. The city is surrounded by the dangerous and impenet...
 
February 2003: Roundtable on "Superman: The Man of Steel" with Alex Ford and Kenneth Branagh
The initial meeting between Branagh and Ford goes smoothly.

Branagh's past experiences of working with inexperienced writers and actors shine through as they discuss the topic, gently directing Ford's ideas forwards while giving him ample time to explain his plans and the plot changes that've been in work since your last meeting with Ford. Branagh expresses a hint of disappointment at the removal of Ford's monologues from the script—"surely not all of them," he pouts—but he nods along to the decisions made elsewhere and lights up at the discussion of Metallo's origins and ailments. Branagh would certainly like to highlight the tragedy of Metallo's condition and its asymmetry with Superman's own condition. He thinks there's something to be made of the difference between Metallo's Luthor-hired hanger-ons and Superman's true companions.

From Clark Kent and Lex Luthor, to Lois Lane and Angela Chan, the characters of the film are all larger than life. The script does a great job already in highlighting that in Clark Kent and Lex Luthor's scenes, and starts the work for Lois Lane and Angela Chan, but it's something that he really wants to breathe into the script. To breathe the essence of the Superman-myth into the screen, "ordinary" betrays itself. Every character is extraordinary in their own ways, and when a character must be designated as "ordinary," Branagh wants them to become so ordinary that that itself makes them extraordinary and eye-catching. Ford smiles along and occasionally chimes in while Branagh continues, moving on to the importance of color palettes, intentionality in dialogue reworks, iterating thematic costuming and scene framing.

Branagh names a number of past collaborators—production designer Tim Harvey, film composer Patrick Doyle, costume designer Alexandra Byrne, recognizable after consideration as his team from Hamlet—who he views as essential to capturing that spirit. It's not an area of the industry where Ford has much to say in counter, though he makes a gentle ask on the availability of John Williams and the possibility of reusing or interpolating the Donner films original Superman soundtrack. With Williams attached to the Harry Potter franchise at the moment, you're able to consider the possibility of tapping him more seriously than a shot in a dark at one of the greatest film composers of all time might otherwise deserve—though the scheduling seems dreadful to work out.

When the topic turns to locations, there's more division. You know that the studio's preference for filming is down under (more specifically, in Sydney Australia) with relatively sparse usage of New York City and Chicago to flesh in Americanisms and create recognizable locales without attaching Metropolis to any one city, but that isn't the only way that the film could be handled. Metropolis's skyline was originally based not on New York, but Toronto, and there's a sizeable financial incentive to filming in Toronto compared to the Big Apple.

On the other side of things, Branagh is interested filming in a mixture of American cities outside the top names—emphasizing Atlanta, Cleveland, Milwaukee and Philadelphia as major components in their place—to create a Metropolis that feels like a composite of American lives and cities, more fitting for the epic scale of the story than any one city could be. Ford is more interested in filming on location, either in New York City itself or in Philadelphia, and strongly characterizing Metropolis with that East Coast New York feeling that Metropolis has always clearly embodied to him. There's less discussion over where the Smallville components of the story will be filmed, or of specific locations for the Daily Planet , Luthor's business headquarters and Metropolis Reactor sets to be handled, but you expect those details to be tackled more seriously once Branagh's production crew is assembled and brought up to speed on the project.

Then comes the topic of casting.

While there hasn't been an official casting call made for Superman: The Man of Steel, unofficially, your superiors and your predecessors have been on the hunt for a long while. What was once a "short list" of candidates has become a mockery of that name—and that's before considering the first considerations Alex Ford and Kenneth Branagh bring to the discussion. You've trimmed out the fat of that short list and presented something much more compact and reasonable to your collaborators at the meeting. First, the known unknowns: actors you're confident you could lock down for at least a trilogy, potentially the whole heptalogy Ford desires.

Stephen Amell (21) is an unknown actor from Canada whose made some buzz among studio affiliates in Toronto. Young, eager and without any previous roles to attach his face to, his name is a recent addition to the studio's list of potential actors—if not for Superman, than perhaps for Aquaman, Hawkman or Booster Gold down the line. Amell's jawline isn't the perfect cleft chin that Superman is known for, but it remains recognizable and strong in the traditional way.

Matt Bomer (25) isn't a complete unknown, but to the audiences you'll be reaching, he might as well be. He's looking to move away from TV filler and guest appearances towards something more, and this role would certainly be that. Traditionally tall, dark and handsome without being intimidating, there's something of a natural fit for Bomer in the Superman role—and he certainly has a jawline fitting for the traditional Superman appearance.

Henry Cavill (19) is a new face in the British acting scene and a complete unknown to the world at large. Coming off buzz for his positive performances in both BBC productions and Kevin Reynolds' The Count of Monte Cristo, there's a sense around the man that he's a star to come. He's excited about the possibility of portraying Superman to a large audience, calling the Man of Tomorrow the most recognized and revered hero in all of comics and cinema—and his chin sings Superman.

D. J. Cotrona (22) is another unknown, recently passed over by Fox for a leading role in The O.C. and looking for a different role to build his career. Even more than Amell, he's untested with audiences and the pressure of a major production… still, there's at least one good reason for the buzz around him and his inclusion in the short list. He's a striking visual match for Kal-El with an immediately recognizable jawline and chin.

Brandon Routh (23) has spent half a decade in bit roles and guest appearances on Hollywood, but ever since his first audition with the studio, he's been a mainstay on the list for the Superman role. There's something about him that effortlessly embodies the Clark Kent persona without compromising his heroism or ability to project awe in the red and blue. It's an interesting thought, casting someone who's a more natural fit for the Clark Kent role than the Superman one… in any event, he certainly has the right jawline.

Ian Somerhalder (25) is a heartthrob in the making, little known to general audiences but already holding some experience in Hollywood from his work on Life as a House and The Rules of Attraction. There's some reservations at the studio on bringing the actor in after the publicity his role as a bisexual man in The Rules of Attraction received, but nothing too stark in opposition. Who knows—a careful level of controversy can always drive media attention and sales.



There's a few of better-known actors that the studio has considered for the role in the past as well. With their past experiences and accolades, these actors are more likely to negotiate against trilogies or long-term commitments that don't afford them significant creative control, but the fanbases they might bring and their talent as actors is undeniable.



Christian Bale (28) has been around for around a decade now and already commands starring roles wherever he goes in Hollywood, beating out even Leonardo DiCaprio for his market slashing hit performance as Patrick Bateman in American Psycho. A method actor and a physical chameleon, Bale prides himself on adapting and becoming whatever character he takes on and fully bringing out their physique, persona and psyche. From softer looks and sweater vests, to sharp suits and roughneck biker-wear, Bale looks comfortable in any costume and you're certain he'd look comfortable in Superman's iconic suits. Christian Bale welcomes work in a trilogy, so long as he's allowed a certain level of creative control and veto on Superman's own actions, but committing to the role for longer than that becomes a more complicated subject.

Orlando Bloom (26) stunned the world as the effeminate elven archer, but he may well be poised to do it again as the everlasting masculine ideal of the Superman. Well acquainted with Kenneth Branagh, the star represents an opportunity both to lock down an incredible talent from the role and to poach Bloom away from competitors. Though the golden locks of Legolas aren't quite a fit for the boy scout superhero, Bloom's natural hair while short is a remarkable match for the character and his jawline proudly bears that super-heroic flair. From his willingness to commit to the Lord of the Rings franchise, you expect Bloom to be reasonable in negotiations over a trilogy (or longer) once you get him in the door. It might be a hard sell to get him to commit to Superman so soon after his work on Lord of the Rings, but Branagh is confident he could bring the man in.

Josh Hartnett (25) has been crowned the next Leonardo DiCaprio by Hollywood's media and America's youth. He's more than the next big thing; to fangirls around the world, he's the big thing. Every major studio has offered him a franchise role, and inevitably, he's turned each of them down, unwilling to commit to any role that might see him typecast for the rest of his career. He's already turned down the role of Superman to your predecessors three times, and the thought of being turned down again is daunting, but if he could be convinced… Josh Hartnett's Superman could rule the world.

Jude Law (30) has been in talks since the turn of the millennium for the role of Superman and brings a veteran, more mature take to the character. Like Bloom, Law is well acquainted with Branagh and has worked in similar theatre circles before. Of the candidates, Law is considered by many at the studio to be the most talented option, though he lacks the sheer star power of some of the other known options. Law's made his interest in the role clear in the past, and with Branagh joining the project, you expect that he'll have only grown more attached to the idea. As long as you give him time between film installments, you expect he'll stick around as long as the rest of your crew does.

Branagh has a few names more names he wants to throw out as well, early in the process, to expand the horizons and highlight some of the talents he's hoped to work more with: Broadway talent John Barrowman (35), Danish theatre and European film talent Nikolaj Coster-Waldau (32), stubbled American theatre-turn-film talent Jon Hamm (31) and black English film, television, theatre and musical actor Idris Elba (30). You don't have nearly as much to go for when it comes to these candidates, but you brought Branagh in for a reason and it stands to reason he might have a better hand on the pulse of talent to come than your ever eager agents.

Of course, there's always the option to pull the bell and put out an actual Casting Call for Superman—as long as your team feels ready to deal with the tens of thousands of audition tapes and personal requests that will follow after you go public.



This is a discussion update.



Highlight potential cast choices among those offered here, put forward names of other potential Superman actors and consider if there are points of order to discuss with Alex Ford and Kenneth Branagh together here. Weigh in with your preferences on the location debate, and if you're inclined, put forward opposing options for the film's Film Composer, Costume Designer or Production Designer from outside of Branagh's planned crew. Consider Directors of Photography and other production-involved roles that you'd be interested in bringing into the project.

From now on, in any voting period, you are welcome to vote to OPEN THE CASTING CALL for Kal-El / Clark Kent / Superman. Expect to be overwhelmed by the sheer number of options if and when you do. As the first recasting of Superman since the days of Christopher Reeve, whoever secures the role will be put on a trajectory towards superstardom and Hollywood iconicity.
 
Last edited:
DISCUSSION UPDATE ((VOTE 10))
There's no moratorium tonight (as this is primarily intended to be a discussion update). Chatters in the discord have been spit-balling ideas on a Jonah Hex story and on potential enemies for Justice League films down the line, but there haven't been any major developments along either line. I might end up putting out a pitch of my own for a Jonah Hex film, thanks to some of the inspiration from there, but I can't help but feel like any of my attempts at doing so are just rewriting Django Unchained in a different font :V

There were about forty other names I cut from this list before posting the update, largely for my sanity in including image link. If people would be interested in the full version of the "short list" mentioned in the update, I can edit this post and include it here. I do not envy the work of actual casting directors.
CoreBrute: 3 Contribution Points for Vijay Sahni's Catwoman and King Tut treatment
KreenWarrior: 1 Contribution Points for Lucas Wainwright's Supergirl and the Rise of Bizarro treatment + (???) Supergirl Interest; 1 Contribution Points for Lucas Wainwright's Diamonds are Forever treatment + (???) Jane Goldman collab. interest
Thinker90: (+) Hawkman Interest and (+) Hawkgirl Interest for ??'s Hawkman and Hawkworld Thoughts
 
February 2003: Roundtable on "Superman: The Man of Steel" with Alex Ford and Kenneth Branagh, Pt. II
For the second part of the roundtable, you take a much more active role in the conversation. Henry Cavill and Brandon Routh are the highlight candidates for the role in your mind, and with neither Alex Ford nor Kenneth Branagh having major objections to them in the role, you're open to bringing the two of them in for early auditions, interviews and talks on the role.

Though he doesn't have a major objection, Branagh does hum a bit at the prospect. The two are still quite inexperienced, and he's hoping for an actor with presence and capability to match his Epic-styled aspirations. If one of those younger candidates is brought forward, he'd like assurances that proper acting coaches and backups are made available for the production. It isn't all bad on Branagh's side; he admits he's enjoyed working with the child talent on the Harry Potter sets and felt a rekindling of his early passion in helping his colleagues develop their careers, though he imagines there'll be a different style of ego involvement in the case of Superman compared to Ron Weasley.

Ford, on the other hand, has a more personal take on it. Do these young stars have the personality to handle being Superman? Stardom changes people, and more than any appearance, Superman's core is his kind heart and germane nature. If the actor doesn't fit Superman on and off camera, it'll come out and taint the project in the long run. There's a part of you that wants to object that the potential for bad publicity comes with any actor signing, but it isn't a real answer to Ford's point. Screening the Superman candidates for fitting personalities isn't a horrible idea—maybe legal can work up some agreements and contracts that incentivize best behavior for your cast members.

The ball is in your court on how to move forward. It isn't technically necessary to begin the casting process for Superman yet, but it'd be a clear sign to executives and the world that the ball is moving on the new Superman production.



[] [SUPERMAN-CASTING] Bring in your top candidates for interviews.
[] [SUPERMAN-CASTING] Bring in all current candidates for interviews.
[] [SUPERMAN-CASTING] Open up a Casting Call for Superman.
[] [SUPERMAN-CASTING] Hold off until later in production



The discussion branches off from Superman to a few smaller parts. You've got some ideas of who in the industry you could tap for the role of Lex Luthor, but it's clear that Alex Ford and Kenneth Branagh do as well. Ford calls for a point of order in the discussion before any actor profiles are discussed. In his scripts, he's been careful to avoid locking Lex Luthor into any specific age range, but it is a decision that needs to be made and resolved to determine the characterization of his and Superman's relationship.

Traditionally, Lex Luthor is an older individual than Kal-El who has already risen to the top of the Metropolis hierarchy through his own merit and genius—but the hit TV Superman adaptation, Smallville, instead puts Clark and Lex in the same age range and develops strong past relationships between the two to better characterize their rivalries and personal connections. As much as the comics purist in Ford wants to dismiss Smallville or ignore it entirely, he feels obligated to bring it up and discuss whether the changes it made would be right for this film adaptation too.

A younger Lex Luthor is a much more personal villain. The two are mirrors of each other, usually past friends or at least acquaintances, driven away from each other and incapable of resolving their key difference. There is more tragedy to their connection in most cases, and at the same time, there is more malice to their connection. A younger Lex Luthor brings his father with him into the picture, whether that be Smallville's Lionel Luthor or the rarely mentioned Jules Luthor of the comics, and in doing so creates a mirror character for Jor-El that can be explored.

An older Lex Luthor is less of a personal enemy and more a reminder of humanity's refusal to accept Superman. Over the years, and in more ways than just the iconic hair he stole from his predecessor, Luthor has become the Ultra-Humanite of old comics and a stubborn refusal to accept a humanity beholden to magic, aliens or outside powers. In some ways, there's a honor to that Luthor's war on Superman and his unaltering, unshakable determination that humanity will decide their own fate. Too often, that same Luthor becomes the pawn of the alien menaces or AI-led schemes that Superman ends up defending the Earth from instead.

From another perspective, an older Lex Luthor represents the status quo of the world and the consternations of a society faced with a new world order. He needs not be the standard-bearer of the humans first movement; it's enough that he is the establishment, viciously resisting any attempts for societal or institutional change and desperately holding on to the privileges his wealth and reputation allows him. A younger Lex might support the establishment, but he is too far an outlier to be the establishment, buoyed too high by his own genius and risen too far too quickly to sit comfortably among the blue-bloods and royals he would call peers.

Branagh is undecided on the topic, appreciating both the personal tragedy and theatrics of Clark and Lex sharing an age and past and the maddened grandeur an older Luthor demands of his actor. He admits he's not too interested in exploring symmetries in Luthor's father and Jor-El, but there are other ways of using a Luthor Senior that he would be more interested in exploring. Perhaps the Luthors could be both—the father taking on elements of the older Lex Luthor adaptations and the son taking on the more personal vendetta?



[] [LUTHOR] Adapt a younger Lex Luthor and incorporate his father in a supporting role.
[] [LUTHOR] Adapt a younger Lex Luthor, but do not incorporate his father in any role.
[] [LUTHOR] Adapt an older Lex Luthor.
[] [LUTHOR] Adapt both a younger and older Luthor family member, with the elder taking Lex's role in the script.
[] [LUTHOR] Adapt both a younger and an older Luthor family member, with the younger taking Lex's role in the script.
[] [LUTHOR] Do not decide on Luthor's age until an actor is decided, avoiding potential plots that relate to Luthor and Clark's ages.



The next topic of discussion is Metallo and his portrayal. You've already agreed with Ford on a more tragic depiction of the Metallo character, based on the thief John Corben being punished and tortured by Lex Luthor through the Metallo device grafted into his body, powered by a Kryptonite heart slowly irradiating the machine, the mind and the body. His hate for Luthor is only matched in the end by his hate for Superman, who he wrongly regards as the only man in the world who could have saved him from his condition.

Branagh loves the concept, but he has more practical questions to ask. What, exactly, does Metallo look like? Why is he called Metallo in the first place, before he's revealed to be made of metal? How far will the studio let him take the concept of "raw data feed" senses and separation from reality?

James Cameron's The Terminator (1984) provides one clear inspiration for Metallo's visual style, matching strongly with Ford's intended scenes and the third-act showdown wherein Superman burns away Metallo's skin to reveal the machinery beneath. A fleshy exterior over hard metal is a classic android trope and a surefire way to land Metallo's situation with the audience, although it strays further away from Metallo's traditional comic appearances.

On the other hand, the metal interior needn't define his appearance at all if his design instead emphasizes Metallo's Kryptonite Heart and the potential irradiated extrusions that come from it. John Corben's Metallo could remain primarily human, but with clear indicators of his cybernetic modifications; an always visible set of face-plates, artificial veins and power conduits that run across his skin or just beneath it and a vital green glow of Kryptonite throughout all of active parts of his system.

Or maybe Metallo doesn't need skin at all. Having Metallo clearly robotic from the very start would distinctly color his scenes throughout the film, and raise more than a few questions to the jokes in scenes where onlookers confuse Metallo and Superman for each other, but it would handily answer the question of why everyone knows to call him Metallo and provide the costume designers much more space to work. Does a skinless Metallo wear clothes, or is the android naked and exposed to the world? You might need to change the scenes where Luthor's watchers attempt a seduction of Metallo to keep him docile—or maybe highlighting his robotic and alien nature is exactly what that scene needs.

There is also the semi-iconic 70s Curt Swan design to consider for Metallo: a full-body covering suit in a blend of orange and greens, highlighting the Kryptonite Heart as a centerpiece of his design without revealing any potential areas of skin or metal. There's a sense of riveted power armor in the design, creating a Metallo appearance that is ultimately a 'closed system' to the outside world. Decisions would have to be made on if there was flesh, metal or indeed nothing at all beneath Metallo's outer shell, but there's potential for the design to work and make Metallo more than just a robot—or to fail and be a spectacularly colorful eyesore.



[] [METALLO] Flesh and metal. Take inspiration from The Terminator for Metallo's design.
[] [METALLO] Heart and steel. Metallo is clearly human with cybernetic spunk.
[] [METALLO] Rust and bolts. Metallo is all metal, all the time.
[] [METALLO] Green and orange. Metallo wears his iconic 70s design.



There are a wide number of minor roles that need to be filled for the film: Daily Planet employees, police and military members, the Mayor of Metropolis, Clark Kent's family and so forth. Kenneth Branagh is interested in appearing in the film in the role of Perry White, the Editor-in-Chief of the Daily Planet, which is admittedly a very bit role in the greater scope of the movie, but he isn't insistent on it if there's a different pick that sticks out to you or Ford for the role.

Lois Lane and Lana Lang are the two larger roles that need to be filled for the film and tested in cooperation with your potential Superman actor. Even though the decisions have been made to stick with Lana as the initial love interest, everyone present is in agreement that a Lois who doesn't have chemistry with Clark is a nonstarter. Like the casting of Superman will propel whoever is chosen to stardom, you can expect a similar halo to follow your potential Lois and Lana should the film succeed.

Lois Lane is traditionally a white woman with black hair who prefers functional, sporty outfits. In film, she's been portrayed before by Margot Kidder, starring along Christopher Reeve, who personified the Donner production's desired three Ps of Lois Lane: "pretty, pert and perky." Having famously stumbled into the room for her first ambition, an exaggerated bit of Kidder's clumsiness went along way into shaping the last cinematic Lois Lane's charm. While it's not necessary to follow in the direction of Margot Kidder's Lois, you can expect it to be the version of the character first to mind with adult audiences.

Lana Lang has less conformity to her appearance across renditions, often taking on exaggerated femininity to contest Lois's posh appearance or more rural elements to contrast her city sensibilities. One of the consistent points of contrast between Lois and Lana's appearance is in hair: Lana is a natural redhead. Lana's most iconic appearance in the public perception is certainly her role on Smallville, where she is an on-and-off love interest of the leading man and portrayed by a half-Chinese actress. Branagh suggests that emphasizing that and bringing on another actress with a Chinese background could be a good marketing angle with overseas fans, if you were so inclined…

The major decision to be made now for Lois and Lana is simple. Do you want to run a joint casting call for the characters or separate casting calls that highlight the differences between the characters? While they aren't ultimately as important members of the cast as Kal-El himself, ensuring chemistry and positive relationships between each member of the love triangle is essential, and that means bringing in candidates early in the process is a must.



[] [LOIS-and-LANA] Run a joint casting call for Superman's love interests.
[] [LOIS-and-LANA] Run separate casting calls for Superman's love interests.
[] [LOIS-and-LANA] Hold off on running any casting calls for Superman's love interests.



Discussions slow after that, and the meeting is quick to conclude. You'll meet again in a few weeks time to discuss the progress that's been made, but your other projects need more direct attention. Catwoman's starlings need direction (and a director) and Frank's ready to talk co-directors and the next serious step forwards on the Batman project.
 
MORIATORIUM 11 // VOTE 11
Voting will open at 12:00 PM CST 2/5/2023, approx. ~4 hours from the time of posting. There is a good chance I will not be awake at that point in time (fingers crossed, actually!) but the update demanded to be written. Voting is now open.

We're going to come back to the topic of filming location down the line, but that's a topic that can wait a bit and that I can prepare more guidance in voting before we hit it again. I think I'm going to push the abstraction up a little bit and just have Branagh bring in his desired crew rather than involving negotiation processes over it, but there's time to convince me otherwise (or we can handle it on a case-by-case basis, if there are strong feelings some other time). I've been successfully incepted with thoughts of Zack Snyder and Hawkman, so there's a good chance that a Snyder-Hawkman pitch will show up in the apocrypha sometime down the line.

[] [SUPERMAN-CASTING] Bring in your top candidates for interviews.
[] [SUPERMAN-CASTING] Bring in all current candidates for interviews.
[] [SUPERMAN-CASTING] Open up a Casting Call for Superman.
[] [SUPERMAN-CASTING] Hold off until later in production

[] [LUTHOR] Adapt a younger Lex Luthor and incorporate his father in a supporting role.
[] [LUTHOR] Adapt a younger Lex Luthor, but do not incorporate his father in any role.
[] [LUTHOR] Adapt an older Lex Luthor.
[] [LUTHOR] Adapt both a younger and older Luthor family member, with the elder taking Lex's role in the script.
[] [LUTHOR] Adapt both a younger and an older Luthor family member, with the younger taking Lex's role in the script.
[] [LUTHOR] Do not decide on Luthor's age until an actor is decided, avoiding potential plots that relate to Luthor and Clark's ages.

[] [METALLO] Flesh and metal. Take inspiration from The Terminator for Metallo's design.
[] [METALLO] Heart and steel. Metallo is clearly human with cybernetic spunk.
[] [METALLO] Rust and bolts. Metallo is all metal, all the time.
[] [METALLO] Green and orange. Metallo wears his iconic 70s design.

[] [LOIS-and-LANA] Run a joint casting call for Superman's love interests.
[] [LOIS-and-LANA] Run separate casting calls for Superman's love interests.
[] [LOIS-and-LANA] Hold off on running any casting calls for Superman's love interests.
CoreBrute: 3 Contribution Points for Vijay Sahni's Catwoman and King Tut treatment
KreenWarrior: 1 Contribution Points for Lucas Wainwright's Supergirl and the Rise of Bizarro treatment + (???) Supergirl Interest; 1 Contribution Points for Lucas Wainwright's Diamonds are Forever treatment + (???) Jane Goldman collab. interest
Thinker90: (+) Hawkman Interest and (+) Hawkgirl Interest for ??'s Hawkman and Hawkworld Thoughts
 
Last edited:
Back
Top