Honestly. The only way I see that everything could be different is Mami did not start shooting people.
 
Change my vote to:
[X] T - A tiny room with a shiny ... door? It's split down the middle and is made of metal. It's an elevator with a metal door.

I don't know the other two options. But lets not go to Warhammer 40k in till we get some very serious power ups. And who wants to drink/eat angel blopd/flesh.:lol
 
What will happen if we somehow figured out how to turn the soul jems into their ring forms,and wear them as jewelry.
 
[X] C - It's bright and sunny, and you can see a lot of white buildings with huge windows.

So what Wonderland we'll be arriving to?

Hmm, Wonderland... Flandre, Flandre in Wonderland... wait, wasn't there a song call that, *Google search*, knew it. Here the song, incase your wondering:
 
[X] C - It's bright and sunny, and you can see a lot of white buildings with huge windows.

Let's see how Flan handles someone with not only all the tolerance in the world, but the firepower to back it up. Either that, or if we end up early-series, can we please vampirize Nanoha?
 
After I figured out what MGLN is. And all I got to say is...[X] C - It's bright and sunny, and you can see a lot of white buildings with huge windows.

HELL FUCKING YES.
EDIT: Serious though we really need to eat/drink some angel blood/flesh after we get Alf.
 
Last edited:
[X] It's bright and sunny, and you can see a lot of white buildings with huge windows.

A carriage appeared in the middle of the street? That's Remi's flashy style, I think the real one just made an appearance but was mistaken for the fake, and she was too late to stop Flan from hopping to another world. I'm starting to think Remi is the final boss battle of our quest. I bet she grew out of the "humans are trash" mindset in Gensokyo, and we're not allowed out because we can't comprehend living things aren't playthings. Now she's going to drag us back to the mansion and make us play nice by force.

Good luck with that.

I think we handled PMMM well, we still have grief seeds and soul gems we can turn into minions later. And the way we got ejected really drives the unspoken warning home, a lack of discretion will result in premature ejection, and all the lost opportunities and possible death that entails.

I'm curious, what would have happened if we approached Oriko instead of Madoka's mom? Would the military still have attacked us, and would the magical girls ever be forced into the fighting?
 
Last edited:
Alright, so here's what I have regarding things that could have changed/happened differently. If there are other specific questions, feel free to ask.
Cheated:
Nothing particular to remark. Flan would have met up with a Witch and Kyouko in any of the scenarios, although not always the same way - they would have met separately if Flan had gone Aggressive, since that would have made her meet Kyouko first.

Youkai and Red Hair:
Sitting and Watching would have ended with Kyouko withdrawing, but aware of Flan; attacking her would have ended with her death and early acquisition of her Soul Gem. Leaving would have ejected Flan back where she entered, since she would have backtracked to there. If she Left, Kyouko would not have been aware of Flan. Breaking the Youkai would not have aroused any particular suspicions on Kyouko's part - not every Witch drops a Grief Seed, after all.

Four of a Kind:
Killing Kyouko would have led to early acquisition of her Soul Gem, as well as keeping the Grief Seed, and would lead to a hostile encounter with Mami if she ever found out that you did it. Threatening or Intimidating her would have led to her backing down - primarily because both options would have involved Flan driving the spear through her own skull and basically telling Kyouko to fuck off. That would have led to a neutral but very wary encounter with Mami eventually, and she wouldn't have started with the kid gloves on; she also might have been more willing to bargain with Flan instead of being a Crusader. Running would have pissed off Kyouko, but she'd have let Flan go; one Grief Seed isn't that big a deal. However, relations with all the Mitakihara girls would have been rather sour. Trying to be 'Lost and Afraid' would have failed, because Kyouko's not dumb, but there would have been more information exchanged before Kyouko decided to call up Mami.

Consequences:
If Flan had struck out on her own, Kyouko would have let her; the Mitakihara girls would have tried to keep Flan under surveillance, but only Homura would be successful. There would have been a timeskip to Flan at the railway station.

Bloodbath:
As mentioned, the d100 roll for this update was for whether Homura would intervene in a fight, and if so on which side. The roll was weighted towards helping Mami's group - not that she would have done much besides irritate Flan - but the result was that Homura decided to help Flan if she needed it. Deciding to be ready for the fight meant that it was unnecessary.

A non-hostile result from this encounter would have required Flan volunteering that she normally eats snacks that have blood in them; Kyouko would have suggested a blood bank, and Mami would have been willing to release Flan to Kyouko's custody. Best Girl Minion Get.

Hungry Flan:
If people had voted for "green-haired girl" to win, Hitomi would not have died. It would have been a random girl with green hair. If the vote for not attracting attention had won, Flan would have just hit a mall or something, and public reaction would have been largely hostile. The private club she did hit wasn't illegal or anything, but it was a well-known mob place; it was just classy.

Youkai Again:
No options for Youkai would have had a different result - unless something like "Help Youkai" had won - because poor Kirsten was going to be bondaged by Mami anyway. Immediate hostility toward magicians would have resulted in both Mami's and Sayaka's deaths a second time, although Flan would probably have taken Sayaka's Soul Gem if she noticed it. Mami may have perma-died, due to the location of her Soul Gem.

Don't Lose Your Head:
Leaving would have resulted in Mami becoming hostile once she realized you'd attacked the club, but Flan wouldn't have been world-famous since there wouldn't have been a fight to draw the helicopter. Likewise, attacking immediately would have killed Mami permanently and not drawn the helicopter.

You're Famous:
Leaving would have resulted in Flan not being famous, because the helicopter wouldn't have seen her (or Sayaka, for that matter). But between the fight and the gang shootout, the town would have been very much on edge. Attacking Sayaka would not have killed her, because Homura would have intervened. Homura would also have tried to talk with Flan.

Negotiation:
Trusting Homura would have been difficult, so without a reason for Flan to trust her, I can't say what would have happened. Flan would have had Homura's assistance with some things, though. Attacking her would have resulted in her death, although her Soul Gem was hidden well enough that Flan wouldn't have found it (although Homura did leave a note with Madoka, asking her to find it and take care of it if she didn't come back).

What a Mess:
Killing all of them would have resulted in less damage to Flan's clothes. So would waiting for them to leave. In both cases, Homura would have agreed to some form of service, and Homu-minion would have been acquired. Leaving one alive for questioning would have led to Flan learning that the three of them saw what she did and decided to stop her, because she was doing bad things. Flan could have learned about Kyubey, but not much about Grief Seeds.

As it is, two of them died by Flan's hand, and the third is dying. For the record, Eri's Soul Gem and Ring were on her body, but since her Wish was to avoid being seen, when she accidentally retreated into her Soul Gem to get away from Flan terrorizing her, her magic covered them. Eventually her Soul Gem will shatter, causing her to hatch into a Witch.

Causing a Fuss:
Not much here; choosing to go to sleep would have time-skipped to Homura's decision.

Shopping Interrupted:
So, first major thing -
Choosing to talk to either Junko or Oriko locked you out of Homura as a maid. The only way to keep Homura as a maid would have been to keep straight on to the shops, where I would have done my damnedest to make it as cute and happy as I could. Flan would have found a nice lady to help her find wonderful dresses, and she'd have promised that her big sister would pay for them when she came to get her. No one would have shot her. :(

Choosing to talk to Oriko would have gotten Flan a couple extra outfits that were copies of her normal clothes, because being a precog is awesome. Likewise, Flandre would have gotten forewarning of the Kyubey Strike Force incoming, because having a precog as an ally is awesome. It is unlikely that Flan could have gotten them as long-term assistants, however, because as a precog Oriko realized that getting the fuck out of Mitakihara was the best option. Again, no one would have shot at Flan.

Choosing to talk to Junko, however, meant that Homura freaked out once every news agency in the region began live broadcasting and someone notified Madoka that, "Hey, your mom is talking to the world-famous crazy thing!" and decided to keep Junko safe by using the sniper rifle to peg Flan, because Homura understands violence but not people. She wasn't expecting Flan to rip the table out and hurt Junko, but she was ready to go into Time Stop and get her out of there ... and then get Sayaka to heal her up. Junko and Sayaka had a little talk, too, so - because Flan was not a monster and reacted to attacks against her (usually) - talking to Junko did allow Sayaka to be gained as a minion. Junko also told Madoka about what happened.

It's worth noting that attacking Junko might have gained Sayaka as a minion, because when Madoka Wished Flan away from Mitakihara, Sayaka would have been dragged through with her, and depending on where you ended up, she might have sided with Flan (because the alternatives were worse).

Shopping Uninterrupted:
There was a binary roll here, which was to determine whether Oriko would leave a Care package for Flan someplace where Flan would find it. Roll was 'No,' so no package was left. :( Also, the car that met Flan was military - soldiers were set up in the area to discourage looters, but they decided that the orders to GTFO if Flan showed up were more important than making sure she paid for her clothes.

Hunting:
Staying at the Station would have gotten Sayaka as a minion - temporarily, because the Kyubey Strike Force would have made collapsing the station their first move against Flandre, and Flan wouldn't have dug Sayaka out of the rubble. Sayaka would have survived.

Choosing a different lair would have made Sayaka Flan's Minion at least until the end of Mitakihara, because she promised Junko she would do her best to take care of Flan and not let her rampage unabated. It would also have affected the Kyubey Strike Force's attack, since they would have had to make an attack in a place Flan considered her lair.

However, choosing to Wander meant that Sayaka met three girls from the Kyubey Strike Force, tried to get them to back off from Flan, got into a fight, and died when one of their actual fighters got called in. The three scouts died when Homura took action, but she was driven off shortly before Flan arrived. The Kyubey Strike Force was aware of Flan's movements, however - they found her when she killed Suleika - and so they were able to get a first strike in against her, and they did this by manipulating her sight so she thought it was nearly dawn, forcing her to an unprepared sanctuary, allowing them to draw her into Elsa Maria's Barrier.

For Reference, the nine Magical Girls of the Kyubey Strike Force that Flan fought all have between one and two years of experience. Here are their Wishes and fates:
1) A girl who never had privacy because of her paralyzed legs, Wished to be able to walk in other places, allowing her to create a second body/clone of magic. She is now dead.
2) A girl who was teased because of her appearance, Wished to be able to control what other people see, allowing her to manipulate other peoples' sight. She survived.
3) A girl who wanted to be helpful, she Wished to be able to guide people wherever they needed to go; while her primary ability is simply giving perfect directions, applying it to combat allowed her to accurately point out weak points in enemies. She is now dead.
4) A girl whose mother was dying in surgery, she wished to save her, granting her exceptional healing abilities. She is now dead.
5) A girl who was second-best in her dojo, she wished she was good enough to beat her teacher, granting her superb swordsmanship. She survived.
6) A girl with (among other issues) extremely brittle bones, she wished she wasn't so sick, granting her extreme durability. Her Soul Gem was taken by Flandre, and it is Orange.
7) A girl who was always bullied by her social superiors, she wished she could hurt anyone, granting her the ability to inflict pain on others. She is now dead.
8) A quiet girl who was very curious, she wished she knew what people were thinking, granting her the ability to read minds. Her Soul Gem was taken by Flandre, and it is Turquoise.
9) A homeless girl orphaned by her parents, she wished it wasn't so cold, granting her the ability to manipulate the local temperature; applying it to combat allowed her to create blades made of supernatural ice, heat beams, and igniting the air to make explosions. She is now dead.

These girls were specifically picked by Kyubey to take on Flandre; she could not have negotiated with them.

Prey:
Leaving the youkai alive would have made the initial plan of using Elsa Maria to kill Flan unworkable, since Flan wouldn't have moved so aggressively toward its location. Likewise, slaughtering the witches instead of trying to capture their Soul Gems would have made it fail because Flan would have shattered their confidence. Of the nine witches, the only ones who weren't standing in front of Flan when she turned were #s 1 and 8 (making a second body and mind-reading); they were behind the torch, keeping Elsa Maria docile and waiting for something they could use to spring the trap.

Witches = Wood:
Fleeing would have resulted in Flandre breaking out of Elsa Maria's grip and escaping from the barrier. She would have returned to the school, bleeding and crying, and then fled; Homura and Madoka would have found her, and Madoka would have insisted on taking her home, at least for the rest of the day. The KSF would have left Flan alone while she was under Madoka's protection, because Kyubey wants Madoka to contract, and would be trying to get her to make a Wish involving Flan.

Voting to Lose Control would have resulted in a much faster destruction of the KSF, and Flan continuing to rampage and pretty much mindlessly attacking the school. Madoka would have made a Wish to send Flandre away, and she would be sent to her next world in a highly destructive state.

Thrilling Fight Denied:
Waiting for nightfall - if it had succeeded - would have resulted in Flan having regained some of her control; she would not have needed to feed immediately, but it would have been something she greatly desired to do. She would have targeted another club, or people who were obviously 'trouble' of some kind.

Running away would have resulted in Homura contacting her later in the day, after school, and asking how the fight went. She would have seen Flan running away, since she was aware of the destruction of the Barrier, and would have tried to use it to rein her in.
Ask if something seems confusing; I haven't been at my best today.

[X] H - It's an old-time town (and you're five centuries old, so that's saying something!). It looks kinda like someone blew it up already, though. The sun hasn't quite begun to set just yet, but it should soon.
2

[X] C - It's bright and sunny, and you can see a lot of white buildings with huge windows.
8

[X] T - A tiny room with a shiny ... door? It's split down the middle and is made of metal. It's an elevator with a metal door.
1

[X] K - It's dark and underground, but it looks like there's some kind of ruined city! Everything is thick and blocky.
1
Votes are not locked, and will be open for a while.
 
A non-hostile result from this encounter would have required Flan volunteering that she normally eats snacks that have blood in them; Kyouko would have suggested a blood bank, and Mami would have been willing to release Flan to Kyouko's custody. Best Girl Minion Get.
So would waiting for them to leave. In both cases, Homura would have agreed to some form of service, and Homu-minion would have been acquired.
Choosing to talk to either Junko or Oriko locked you out of Homura as a maid. The only way to keep Homura as a maid would have been to keep straight on to the shops, where I would have done my damnedest to make it as cute and happy as I could. Flan would have found a nice lady to help her find wonderful dresses, and she'd have promised that her big sister would pay for them when she came to get her. No one would have shot her. :(
Damn.

We need to try harder to acquire minions.

What better way to show Big Sister Remilia that we're responsible, than to acquire as many servants and minions as possible?
 
Damn, we were SO CLOSE to netting Sayaka. We had a 2/3rds chance of getting her.

But darn, it's hard to guess which options would lead to what...
 
This missed opportunity makes me angry and sad.

Hopefully we have better luck in next world.

P.s any luck in returning to pmmm world,
 
If Madoka's wish did indeed push us out on that universe, then PMMM is probably locked out until Homu loops again and the wish is "undone".

Also, in a more meta sense, it would be dependent on whether Entropy Judge would be willing to retread ground and give us a second shot at that universe, given he just gave us the "behind the scenes" of our actions.

Also, take note people. Going full psycho "murder-hobo" WILL cost us opportunities, including some possibly quite fun ones.
We got punished pretty harshly (in opportunity cost) for our decisions in this world...
 
Last edited:
Back
Top