[Exalted, ?] Most High

Eh, I'm still standing by the idea of "More meaningful assets is typically more desirable than a single overwhelmingly powerful asset".

Because Odyssial went the latter way, and he lost in the end. Despite Rihaku's best efforts of advocating his infalliablity and perfection.
 
Eh, I'm still standing by the idea of "More meaningful assets is typically more desirable than a single overwhelmingly powerful asset".
And I wholeheartedly agree with you on this score. We shouldn't disregard our previous choices and efforts to build a harmonious civilization in favor of nabbing shiny, powerful combatants that synergize very poorly with what we're trying to create.
 
A compromise option won the last time around. If you're going to be passive-aggressive, at least get your facts straight.

'Probably' is not a guarantee; probably is just probably. To give an example, if we ignore the warnings we've been given, we will probably hurt one of our friends.

For the sake of argument, let's assume she buys that the guy who just beat her up and stole her armor on top of introducing himself as an 'honorless knave' is really a good Samaritan at heart and wants to help the peasants. Ok, she does that. With Ulyssian's help, soon the peasants are all fed and happy and not at all up in arms that the good King Sesus has been deceived by the Anathema's wiles. What next? Why, she leaves, of course! Because she's a Knight Errant, and this land has been made safe!

We just convince her to acknowledge us as her "lord" and that we still have a LOT of work to do in making the Realm and Creation a better place and her strength will be needed as one of our swords as well as someone who can challenge our assumptions so we may better tweak and improve our arguments and our plans (basically training AND another perspective)
We can also have her win over the populace by taking advantage of "Worshipful Lackey Acquisition" if anyone attacks her so everyone watching will be affected iirc.

Experience is valuable, guys. We can't just sit on our asses and be content with the trickle from arguments and fanworks. Those options exist for a reason. More personal power in the long run might be better against Syn, because it's not like the Lily would be glued to our side if we did ally with her.

The only reason those options give us Xp is because they're badbad/dangerous decisions and to make them look attractive so we'll do something silly that could get us killed
 
And I wholeheartedly agree with you on this score. We shouldn't disregard our previous choices and efforts to build a harmonious civilization in favor of nabbing shiny, powerful combatants that synergize very poorly with what we're trying to create.

A "harmonious civilization" means nothing if it gets stomped, if we want to make it we need POWER and the Lily gives us that in spades and is able to buff us as well as cover our weakpoints.
 
We just convince her to acknowledge us as her "lord"

That's... extremely improbable. You're hardly Zhuge Liang, "all virtues' height."

We can also have her win over the populace by taking advantage of "Worshipful Lackey Acquisition" if anyone attacks her so everyone watching will be affected iirc.

She can apply Worshipful Lackey Acquisition just from winning an argument or making a compelling speech, actually.

The only reason those options give us Xp is because they're badbad/dangerous decisions and to make them look attractive so we'll do something silly that could get us killed

Mm, not always. They're mostly options I think you guys wouldn't go for without the XP, or options that empower your personal strength.

Time is even more precious than XP in my eyes, especially this 10+ days before Anys returns.

Would you be willing to perform a Sorcerous Working that applies some effects of either the Wyld, Malfeas, or the Labyrinth to the city in exchange for favorable modest time dilation?
 
We just convince her to acknowledge us as her "lord"
Right, because that's going to be easy, and there's no risk whatsoever of the process being reversed at all and us finding up an adherent of her ideology, thus destroying much of what I like about Ulyssian. Such optimism you have.
and that we still have a LOT of work to do in making the Realm and Creation a better place and her strength will be needed as one of our swords as well as someone who can challenge our assumptions so we may better tweak and improve our arguments and our plans (basically training AND another perspective)
We need less distractions far more than her strength. Zao is a stronger ally, who we risk losing by Limit Breaking at this absurdly inopportune time, in addition to all the other consequences that I have elaborated on at length in other posts.
We can also have her win over the populace by taking advantage of "Worshipful Lackey Acquisition" if anyone attacks her so everyone watching will be affected iirc.
This just gets better and better. You want her to fight and brainwash our population? Nevermind that this will do nothing whatsoever to mitigate the fallout of people on the Blessed Isle discovering that we have an Anathema waltzing about under our protection, we'll basically invite anarchy by splitting Luseng along the lines of those for the Lily and those opposed to her. Also, giving an Exalt beholden to the Gardener control of Luseng's people? Nope, no way that could go wrong.
Time is even more precious than XP in my eyes, especially this 10+ days before Anys returns.
Time is precious, but we chose the option that took the least of it. A couple days at maximum, by my guess? We can still train and prepare.
 
The only reason those options give us Xp is because they're badbad/dangerous decisions and to make them look attractive so we'll do something silly that could get us killed
Lol, didn't you vote for killing the Seeds? It's just an additional incentive to go for something or an abstraction of how the option makes us stronger.
 
A "harmonious civilization" means nothing if it gets stomped, if we want to make it we need POWER and the Lily gives us that in spades and is able to buff us as well as cover our weakpoints.
A harmonious civilization in Creation means everything; it's a virtual impossibility, a shining answer that demonstrates the supremacy of our own ideology and provides peace and prosperity for its citizens. You might as well claim Camelot is meaningless because King Arthur died and the civilization fell; an ideal has worth, even if its physical manifestation passes from the world. And this civilization? It's not going anywhere, not as long as Ulyssian is there to protect and uplift its citizens. But to do that, we need time to work in peace and their trust. The Lily denies us both of these things.
 
This is always how these goddamned decisions turn out. There hasn't been a new argument over the entire course of the day. Extending out the voting period only allows those posters most vociferously in favor of a choice and who lack any other interests outside the thread to just spam the same hyperbole, doomsaying, and outright fallacious arguments over and over again. Victory goes to whichever side doesn't get sick and tired of repeating this over and over again and finally shuts up or drifts away because you can only take so much.

I actually did two write-ins for this, but my contribution is worth far less than @Orm Embar spamming the thread endlessly with such gems as "Lily will be too stupid to stay out of sight" and "Lily won't stick by our side forever" and "Lily is a really dumb Kantian and so has to die to preserve our amoral utilitarian supervillain worldview" and "Lily will start the Realm Civil War" and "all our subjects will hate us if we don't kill her" and "we can't use Lily for anything despite being surrounded by Raksha and beastmen and needing to clear Jade Mountain" and "if we don't kill her you're voting to kill Moon," and on and on and on. If he spent half as much effort on this as he did writing omakes for Limit Reduction our limit track would be down to zero.
 
Thinking about it, Lily can only mitigate us if she's there to help and the only way we can assure she'll always be there to mitigate it is if she's always at our side. And Rihaku admitted that she could very well go somewhere else once she sees Luseng is safe because she's a Knight-Errant.

That means we'd have to convince her to always be close to us while she could be trying to convince us it would serve our goals better if she can go out and do her thing and she is better at social fu than us. Hopefully if she sees how we get in a limit break that would convince her to say to keep an eye on us.
 
Last edited:
Meh, I don't feel that Orm really cares about Limit Break, he's never been shy about portraying that he wants to play as an unfettered ubermensch who answers to nothing, does what they want, and crushes anything that dares oppose them. I suspect he'd advocate for keeping us in Limit Break all the time given how we got confirmation that Odyssial redesigned it to always work for him, and Odyssial was basically the platonic ideal of the superman who does what they want and never suffers consequences for it, and Rihaku continually reinforces that opinion by always pointing out that Odyssial was perfect and never made any mistakes under any circumstances.

(EDIT ON THAT POINT FOR CLARITY: Rather, Rihaku reinforces it by always stating that Odyssial never made mistakes by his reckoning, which is a key point,but one that falls flat when arguing against someone who thinks running a sociopathic optimization machine is awesome)

The only exception he makes is Moon, and so he uses "Oh hey we have to Limit Break here so we don't Limit Break in her sight", when he'd probably argue for Limit Break at every other option just because it creates his dream character who gives no fucks about anything but their own personal ideals.
 
Last edited:
A harmonious civilization in Creation means everything; it's a virtual impossibility, a shining answer that demonstrates the supremacy of our own ideology and provides peace and prosperity for its citizens. You might as well claim Camelot is meaningless because King Arthur died and the civilization fell; an ideal has worth, even if its physical manifestation passes from the world. And this civilization? It's not going anywhere, not as long as Ulyssian is there to protect and uplift its citizens. But to do that, we need time to work in peace and their trust. The Lily denies us both of these things.
King Arthur wouldn't have gotten anywhere without the knights of the round table.
 
This is always how these goddamned decisions turn out. There hasn't been a new argument over the entire course of the day.
mrttao did hit upon a nice point that Limit Breaking around Moon could wind up severing our alliance with Zao, and the issue with rehashing arguments cuts both ways.
I actually did two write-ins for this, but my contribution is worth far less than @Orm Embar spamming the thread endlessly
Sorry, omakes require inspiration, and all I've been inspired to churn out lately are arguments against the way things are going. For the record, I'm pretty sure your contributions are worth more than mine, or at least are worth enough that my side is still losing horribly. Really, you're the one winning here, so I don't see how you can claim to be the underdog in this fight. Anyway, you're mischaracterizing a number of my arguments, but at this point I simply don't have the energy to correct you or drag this particular dead horse out for another beating. The points have been made and remade, and for all your grousing about me, you will probably still win in the end anyway.
 
Last edited:
Actually he died because Mordred killed him.

Except Mordred wouldn't have killed him if he didn't drive Lancelot out of the country and then grind the Knights of the Round Table against his redoubt for a while, most of them being wounded or dead, and then the battle of Camlann happened.

And this all happened because he had the hubris to go "Hey, I wanna marry Guinevere, despite the fact that Merlin is constantly telling me that this is a terrible idea and will lead to my certain ruin".
 
Except Mordred wouldn't have killed him if he didn't drive Lancelot out of the country and then grind the Knights of the Round Table against his redoubt for a while, most of them being wounded or dead, and then the battle of Camlann happened.

And this all happened because he had the hubris to go "Hey, I wanna marry Guinevere, despite the fact that Merlin is constantly telling me that this is a terrible idea and will lead to my certain ruin".
I guess the moral of the story is to always check if your loyal subjects want to bang your wife?
 
.
This just gets better and better. You want her to fight and brainwash our population? Nevermind that this will do nothing whatsoever to mitigate the fallout of people on the Blessed Isle discovering that we have an Anathema waltzing about under our protection, we'll basically invite anarchy by splitting Luseng along the lines of those for the Lily and those opposed to her. Also, giving an Exalt beholden to the Gardener control of Luseng's people? Nope, no way that could go wrong.
Why do you even care? You keep bitching about how Lily won't be accepted by the people, they'll turn against us yadda yadda and WLA means she can win over the populace with kind acts just by winning a competition or an argument and most of the people reside in the city anyway plus I'm sure Uncle Pan would be willing to back us up on how the Anathema thing is bullshit since Lily is yet another person to defend the Citizenry which is one of the things he cares about.
 
Last edited:
Not really, because you're operating under the assumption that anyone who could conceivably check Odyssial reborn needs to die? Because he never makes a bad decision because Ideals and Gives No Fucks?
No, I'm arguing that simply voting to have someone around for the sole purpose of being a ball and chain, so that she'll inevitably come into conflict with a Limit Breaking Odyssial, is inefficient and shortsighted, especially when she introduces other complications to along with the collateral from that fight. If I wanted to kill anyone who could conceivably be a threat, I would both have a much longer hit-list and would never actually get around to them all. I did vote to spare Flame, if you recall. Hatred and paranoia can be just as unproductive as a lack of conviction and recklessly given trust.
Why do you even care? You keep bitching about how Lily won't be accepted by the people, they'll turn against us yadda yadda and WLA means she can win over the populace with kind acts just by winning a competition or an argument and most of the people reside in the city anyway and I'm sure Uncle Pan would be willing to back us up on how the Anathema thing is bullshit since Lily is yet another person to defend the Citizenry.
The Lily would win over the city eventually, yes. I suspect there would be riots and unrest, along with other assorted unpleasantness, but if we gave her free reign to mindrape everyone into compliance, she could totally do it. The issue is what happens when word of that reaches the Imperial City, and the long-term ramifications of having someone who's beholden to the Gardener commanding the loyalty and adoration of all those people, who we ostensibly want to turn into our Sorcerously empowered foot-soldiers. The short-term unrest is just icing on the cake of unpleasantness, or at least it would be if the short term were not so terribly important... We have Anys Syn to deal with, and need time to train and develop before she arrives.
 
Last edited:
I'm just sick and tired of this digression. It was an extremely taxing vote just to challenge Lily and try to win her over, and now the side which was adamantly opposed to doing that is agitating furiously to just kill her. What was even the point of voting to try this if Rihaku is going to toss and incentivize yet another vote to completely obviate the previous vote?

And then to actually do that, the most negative and frustrating trends of Quest voting strategy crop up in spades. I'll say this; unless the choice is so stupid as to be obvious to everyone (on the order of "stab ourselves with the soul-eating blade, we'll totally get cool powerups") it usually isn't going to lead to disaster. And "ally with a powerful Exalt who largely shares our aims for Luseng" is not an obviously stupid move. Throwing out the specter of the Realm Civil War, or of Luseng turning on Ulyssian, or of her turning him into a completely different person, etc and etc are simply the usual grabtastic doomsaying scenarios which sound really alarming and which the average reader probably won't take time to think and realize how implausible or disconnected from any realistic scenario they are. In any case Ulyssian is not stupid, so any supposed downside that can be countered by an elementary school student is not something that will actually come about.

The timing of the Limit Break is, as I see, the only real point raised here. And I would take the risk that Ulyssian might undergo it around Moon, which we can't eliminate forever anyway, over the certainty of killing the Lily to provoke it. Also I'll take the chance of getting E5 over the certainty of not doing so at this juncture with no idea how long it will be before we can attempt an E5 worthy feat again, which is probably an underrated consideration.
 
Back
Top