[Exalted, ?] Most High

[X] Night

C'mon guys, let's be the Assassin with a heart. Preferably there's.

Seriously though, any reason the rogue almost always seems to lag behind on the fighter/mage/rogue calls on this site?
 
[X] Night

C'mon guys, let's be the Assassin with a heart. Preferably there's.

Seriously though, any reason the rogue almost always seems to lag behind on the fighter/mage/rogue calls on this site?
In this case it's because while Odyssial will doubtlessly become a terror no matter what choice we pick Night offers the least in terms of post Primordial War options.
 
In this case it's because while Odyssial will doubtlessly become a terror no matter what choice we pick Night offers the least in terms of post Primordial War options.

Couldn't we hang around and kickstart the gold faction? Let a few solars outrun a hunt? Just the right amount of chaos in the right place so that Lunar succeeds with their plan. That sort of thing.
 
Okay, at this point you guys have gotten 74,000 XP from participants, and an additional 25,800 XP from discussion and fanworks. There is also roughly 150,000 XP equivalent (not yet set in stone) for fanworks from the past thread, so you're at 248,800 XP total. That's a lot more than I expected this early on, and nearly enough to get you from 9 to 9.5 already, or from 6 to 8.

Oh yes, could someone tally the current votes?
 
Last edited:
Okay, at this point you guys have gotten 74,000 XP from participants, and an additional 25,800 XP from discussion and fanworks. There is also roughly 150,000 XP equivalent (not yet set in stone) for fanworks from the past thread, so you're at 248,800 XP total. That's a lot more than I expected this early on, and nearly enough to get you from 9 to 9.5 already, or from 6 to 8.

Oh yes, could someone tally the current votes?
Wait we are using XP to boost Greatness? That kinda cheapens it for me honestly, you'd think that would be something we would acquire from decisions rather than XP expenditure. I suppose it's understandable though if you want to just get through the Prelude into Ulyssian's story.
 
Last edited:
Wait we are using XP to boost Greatness? That kinda cheapens it for me honestly, you'd think that would be something we would acquire from decisions rather than XP expenditure. I suppose it's understandable though if you want to just get through the Prelude into Ulyssian's story.
I think its more than we can spend to XP to boost Greatness.
 
Wait we are using XP to boost Greatness? That kinda cheapens it for me honestly, you'd think that would be something we would acquire from decisions rather than XP expenditure.

Mmhm, you don't lose the XP, it's still spendable. Because Greatness is such an important stat, this is a way of mitigating Dawn's immense natural advantage and gives the other options room to breathe, as it were. However, I imagine the bulk of your Greatness will accrue - or fail to - from decisions. There are just as many decisions that decrease Greatness as there are ones that increase it, after all. And if you guys want to go the other route and shoot for maximum Greatness, you will need all the help you can get. It wouldn't be fair if you guys put forth an utmost effort and weren't somehow rewarded for it.
 
Okay, at this point you guys have gotten 74,000 XP from participants, and an additional 25,800 XP from discussion and fanworks. There is also roughly 150,000 XP equivalent (not yet set in stone) for fanworks from the past thread, so you're at 248,800 XP total. That's a lot more than I expected this early on, and nearly enough to get you from 9 to 9.5 already, or from 6 to 8.

Oh yes, could someone tally the current votes?
You know what's really nice? Not having to merge the votes of two threads.

Vote tally:
##### 3.21
[X] Dawn
No. of votes: 23
AZATHOTHoth, KleverKil'Vanya, Salbazier, SirLagginton, Derkan, Orm Embar, CrawlingChaos74, Alectai, Mask, Tylonius, Mannan, Vanguard_D, Robotninja, Timaeus, a11behringer, Dark Lord Bob, MiracleGrow, Nezi karaketas, sithmor, trebius, OkayishGatsby, useofstrike32, HymnOfRagnarok

[X] Twilight
No. of votes: 13
drake_azathoth, meianmaru, dash931, Anasurimbor, Kaldi97, Quest, veekie, Vanestus, Serous, Quantumboost, Happerry, kellanved, Da Boyz

[X] Night
No. of votes: 2
Delwgun, Dream Logic
 
Last edited:
Mmhm, you don't lose the XP, it's still spendable.
I'm afraid I don't understand this, are you saying that the XP put into greatness will be refunded or that we are using XP spent in stats as a benchmark for Greatness?
Because Greatness is such an important stat, this is a way of mitigating Dawn's immense natural advantage and gives the other options room to breathe, as it were. However, I imagine the bulk of your Greatness will accrue - or fail to - from decisions. There are just as many decisions that decrease Greatness as there are ones that increase it, after all. And if you guys want to go the other route and shoot for maximum Greatness, you will need all the help you can get. It wouldn't be fair if you guys put forth an utmost effort and weren't somehow rewarded for it.
Ah you're saying that while we can acquire greatness from our actions we need to have a high Greatness stat to perform great feats. So in other words we would be spending XP to acquire Greatness to use to perform feats that would give us Greatness.
...damn.

Come on think of all the fun that we could have playing around as a Twilight during the Primordial War! Learning and broing it up with Autocthon, rewriting creation to suit our whims, not just punching our problems to death because in Exalted that inevitably just causes more problems!
 
Last edited:
[X] Night - Strike out alone, and further, performing forward reconnaissance. You will have to trust in the ability of Nio and your lieutenants to discern the proper strategies. In the meantime, you, most capable of your tribe's scouts, must find a place for the tribe to shelter, during the darkness to come. Always you have been alone, forging the path, finding the way. Though you are their chieftain, in many ways you are an outsider to your own clan. But that does not mean you will fail to protect them.

I'm not going to base my choice on the previous quest(s) version of Odyssial, he was a neat character but I prefer to put a new swing on things in iterative games. It seems absurd to try and choose a 'most powerful' out of a set of solar exaltations being given to a paragon of ability. Sure, there are significant gaps in Greatness, but if you stand two posthuman gods next to each other and tell me one has a higher powerlevel, I doubt I could pick out the winner. I just don't care if we're a little less impossibly superb than we could have been.

Heartlessness is a factor, and I like that Night has a little less. The idea that distance and isolation would make him less of a monster is neat, and I'd like to see Rihaku work with that. Furthermore, less heartlessness means greater odds of seeing something wrong with the Deliberative in the coming millenia. Of course, that ties into the next bit I like.

Superlative Perception is a big god-damned deal. Power and ability will never be lacking for Solar Odyssial, and there are an absurd number of problems in the setting which he needs to know about. Anything that improves our chances of finding out about the Great Curse is huge, an improved capacity to analyze the Primordials and (hopefully) eventually the Yozi, opportunities to see the Usurpation coming, this does some neat stuff. It's also a component of Wisdom, a stat which Exalted lacks for a reason. Being able to see problems is half of it, and it's up to us players to manage the decision making. I hope that Night will put us in a position to improve everyone's lot.

As for the other options, they're fine and dandy. Dawn would be a blast, I love how Rihaku writes determined characters and superhuman abilities, and it would suit to a T. Twilight would be amazing, the setting has so much to explore in its science-magic that I'd love to play with. My reasons for not picking Dawn are: a desire to be contrary to the thread, hope that I can get this post in before Rihaku writes a last ditch advocation for the losing option, and a mild preference not to re-tread territory more than we need to. For Twilight, I think Nio actually has good odds of attracting one, given her drive and the relatively slim population and high turnover we can look forward to in the Primordial War.
 
I'm afraid I don't understand this, are you saying that the XP put into greatness will be refunded or that we are using XP spent in stats as a benchmark for Greatness?

Well, right now you just have a giant blob of XP until I figure out the mechanics, and it's your total XP (along with your actions) at the end of the Prelude that determines Odyssial's final Greatness score. Those actions, plus his Greatness and Heartlessness, will determine his legacy in the world of Creation.
 
Last edited:
As for the other options, they're fine and dandy. Dawn would be a blast, I love how Rihaku writes determined characters and superhuman abilities, and it would suit to a T. Twilight would be amazing, the setting has so much to explore in its science-magic that I'd love to play with. My reasons for not picking Dawn are: a desire to be contrary to the thread, hope that I can get this post in before Rihaku writes a last ditch advocation for the losing option, and a mild preference not to re-tread territory more than we need to. For Twilight, I think Nio actually has good odds of attracting one, given her drive and the relatively slim population and high turnover we can look forward to in the Primordial War.
Creation is 100 times larger at the bare minimum then it is in the Age of Sorrows. Unless it's the way Rihaku wants to run the story that way it's mathematically impossible for Nio to attract an Exaltation. Also your vote is trailing by 20.

Don't be stupid be a smarty, come and join the Twilight party!
Well, right now you just have a giant blob of XP until I figure out the mechanics, and it's your total XP (along with your actions) at the end of the Prelude that determines Odyssial's final Greatness score. Those actions, plus his Greatness and Heartlessness, will determine his legacy in the world of Creation.
Oh so the leftover XP will be the amount of weight Odyssial will be able to throw around after we're done. Ok yeah that makes sense, it just represents later feats.
 
Last edited:
For Twilight, I think Nio actually has good odds of attracting one, given her drive and the relatively slim population and high turnover we can look forward to in the Primordial War.

I think the Primordial War population of humanity is actually near or above First Age levels. The Age of Glory was really, really big, and Odyssial's tribe is just one of innumerable civilizations.
 
[X] Night - Strike out alone, and further, performing forward reconnaissance. You will have to trust in the ability of Nio and your lieutenants to discern the proper strategies. In the meantime, you, most capable of your tribe's scouts, must find a place for the tribe to shelter, during the darkness to come. Always you have been alone, forging the path, finding the way. Though you are their chieftain, in many ways you are an outsider to your own clan. But that does not mean you will fail to protect them.

Was originally going to vote Twilight, but while Exalting as a Twilight while literally watching the first twilight is amazingly poetic, I really feel like Night best fits Odyssian's methods as shown in the first post.

Of course, it also seems like Twilight better fits the skills he uses to carry out those methods.

In the end, I think it was the lower threshold for Heartlessness that decided it for me, even if it's pissing at the tide.
 
[X] Twilight

Wow, we get to play as Odyssial? Pretty cool.


Anyways, Twilight is my choice because it has a different playstyle to it then the other Exalted quests had- more strategic.
 
Hm, I think that you guys should focus your votes on what you mostly want to be doing, not necessarily what the Superlative Quality alone says. For all of you who voted Dawn, do you enjoy combat and conflict in quests?
 
Back
Top