I... hesitate to make this critique since it could be seen as just complaining about losing, but I think it is worth saying: it's odd to change over to straight d100 for strategic level actions since none of our actual abilities apply or mitigate this. I mean just an example Lorgar has maximum precognition, there are gifts that allow re-rolls and I think charms as well, but none of them are designed to interact with this layer of the game so we remain at the mercy of very swing-y dice with only a +5.
A fair argumdnt so let me explain a bit more on what the 1d100s do.
What they are is events, crysis or opportunities that happen. Similar to a hurricane hitting your city or finding a massive oil well, etc.
This is how you met Settra, Zabius and Thalassa. They can be good or bad, but they can never be outright a loss or a win.
Events are capped in that manner. They are an opportunity. One you can flip to your side, like you did with Settra or fail, like you did when Lorgar failed to convince Kairos to sucumb to death.
Here, i do not want to go too deep into it but part of the reason why your argument failed to convince them you should not be worshiped is because, funnily enough, because of the covenant.
In the past a great hero saved the planet. They had a prophasy that a hero will return and make Colchis great again. The Covenant proclamed Lorgar as that hero and tried to chase you down in turn 3, i think. And This is before the mass resurection.
You were fighting a lot of the Covenant's left over beliefs and that was why you needed a year of effort to fix it.
All the Nat 1 did was allow him to reveal his story, which was hell of a compelljng one, especially since he attributed being made immortal to Lorgar.
Worse? Lorgar does not know enough to say if he did make Tiberus immortal or not.
Simply put? You had a lot to oversome and that Nat 1 only added fuel to thd fire. This was why I warned you in the last post that the vote will be important.
More on this next turn as some of the leftover covenant beliefs will come to light.