I don't think Ruby or Yang would know about the bird forms of Raven and Qrow.
I agree with this. Also isn't Raven supposed to be one of the maidens at this point in time. I may be wrong as it has been a while since I have watched RWBY compared to reading fanfiction of it.
More like a memento of their relationship that's mostly dead/defunct, Weiss' mom ain't dead, she's just a depressed alcoholic.
The previous Spring Maiden ran away and ended up with Raven's tribe a decade before canon, and Raven apparently made a token effort to "train" her for what sounds like less than a year before going "F*ck it." and killing her, gaining the powers either intentionally or unintentionally. So she's had them for awhile, which is the only way it works out because she's passed the somewhat arbitrary age limit on when you can be a recipient since then.I agree with this. Also isn't Raven supposed to be one of the maidens at this point in time. I may be wrong as it has been a while since I have watched RWBY compared to reading fanfiction of it.
I was never sure if i actually believed Raven there. Sure, thats what she effectively said is what happened (though she still avoided explicitly confirming it), but raven is so obssessed with seeming strong and never a failure, that i could very well see her claiming to have killed or let her die on purpose when she actually failed to protect or save her, because shed rather be seen as a monster than weak.The previous Spring Maiden ran away and ended up with Raven's tribe a decade before canon, and Raven apparently made a token effort to "train" her for what sounds like less than a year before going "F*ck it." and killing her, gaining the powers either intentionally or unintentionally. So she's had them for awhile, which is the only way it works out because she's passed the somewhat arbitrary age limit on when you can be a recipient since then.
Totally fair, but I think it's slightly more likely Raven killed her, just because she has a bunch of bandit minions to throw between the girl and any threat. Unless she died in a stupid training accident like "Take on all these Grimm by yourself... Whoops, thought you had a better grasp on your Maiden powers than that."I was never sure if i actually believed Raven there. Sure, thats what she effectively said is what happened (though she still avoided explicitly confirming it), but raven is so obssessed with seeming strong and never a failure, that i could very well see her claiming to have killed or let her die on purpose when she actually failed to protect or save her, because shed rather be seen as a monster than weak.
I think M&K answered in an interview or QA that based on the Ozluminati's in-universe observations of women becoming Maiden's, the age limit doesn't seem have an exact cut off point and varies ("Magic works on stupid, arbitrary rules." to paraphrase Qrow), but their estimated limit is around 30 years old.Do we know what the age limit is? Also if it accounts for aura users having slower aging?
Eh, maybe. But if that were the case then Raven would have "confidently" and directly told Yang that "Yeah I killed her, what of it? I'm stone cold." when she questioned her about it. Instead she remained silent and shifty, and when Yang surmised what happened she immediately tried to deflect blame and justify herself by calling it a "mercy". Doesn't sound like someone who wants to be seen as a monster.I was never sure if i actually believed Raven there. Sure, thats what she effectively said is what happened (though she still avoided explicitly confirming it), but raven is so obssessed with seeming strong and never a failure, that i could very well see her claiming to have killed or let her die on purpose when she actually failed to protect or save her, because shed rather be seen as a monster than weak.
[!] Sow & Harvest - Belief is a power all its own, and the title of Reaper carries belief with it. Already, Ruby Rose has begun to gather belief, and in her darkest moments that belief may just be enough to keep her standing. Of course, Ruby is not the first Silver-Eyed Reaper... [This trait provides Ruby with minuscule buffs based on "belief" in the Reaper. Belief from people she's personally interacted with is slightly stronger, and from those she's saved stronger still. However, even the strongest soul's belief is only a tiny increase to her capabilities.]
[!] Sow & Harvest - Belief is a power all its own, and the title of Reaper carries belief with it. Already, Ruby Rose has begun to gather belief, and in her darkest moments that belief may just be enough to keep her standing. Of course, Ruby is not the first Silver-Eyed Reaper... [This trait provides Ruby with minuscule buffs based on "belief" in the Reaper. Belief from people she's personally interacted with is slightly stronger, and from those she's saved stronger still. However, even the strongest soul's belief is only a tiny increase to her capabilities.]
[!] She Will Answer - When you are alone and the Grimm close in...call the Reaper, and perhaps she will answer, as she has for others. Her silver gaze searches always [Ruby's eyes already buff her abilities while defending others from the Grimm, but this trait strengthens the effect significantly and allows it to activate as long as she is acting in defense of others, even from non-Grimm threats. Specifically provides a substantial speed boost when rushing to the aid of another.]
But does Ruby want to be a legend, or would she rather be a defender?Sow and Harvest just means she has to become legend. She is well on her way.
But does Ruby want to be a legend, or would she rather be a defender?
There's nothing about this I don't love. The moment the crowd joined in, I found myself smiling. And when it echoed Obsidian with "she will answer," I felt a number of feelings too tangled to adequately describe.
Canonized. Take a question, and choose:
[!] Sow & Harvest - Belief is a power all its own, and the title of Reaper carries belief with it. Already, Ruby Rose has begun to gather belief, and in her darkest moments that belief may just be enough to keep her standing. Of course, Ruby is not the first Silver-Eyed Reaper... [This trait provides Ruby with minuscule buffs based on "belief" in the Reaper. Belief from people she's personally interacted with is slightly stronger, and from those she's saved stronger still. However, even the strongest soul's belief is only a tiny increase to her capabilities.]
[!] She Will Answer - When you are alone and the Grimm close in...call the Reaper, and perhaps she will answer, as she has for others. Her silver gaze searches always [Ruby's eyes already buff her abilities while defending others from the Grimm, but this trait strengthens the effect significantly and allows it to activate as long as she is acting in defense of others, even from non-Grimm threats. Specifically provides a substantial speed boost when rushing to the aid of another.]
I'm not dead, although life has been crushing me for a bit. I'll do my best to have a chapter out soon; I've missed having time to work on Devourer, and I'm eager to get back to the girls.
Ask our dear QM about the other ideas "people", have pitched about the girls being gods. Whether its to play off or stand apart, it's something that might interest you.This is incredibly sweet of you. I'm so glad you loved it, and thank you so much for describing how it made you feel.
Everyone's thoughts on the choices are interesting, so far. While She Will Answer would have plenty of use, I also find myself pretty sorely tempted by the really interesting lore implications of Sow & Harvest.
Would Ruby notice what was going on? Perhaps Obsidian would notice if she doesn't, and I suspect it is something Obsidian would find fascinating to study. Perhaps belief could even be something Obsidian could harvest herself as a renewable source of power. She is powerful enough to be able to do a fair impression of a goddess anyway. And if believing in Obsidian as Humanity's benevolent goddess of knowledge and protection gave Obsidian a connection to the believer in addition to granting Obsidian power, that would enlarge Obsidian's perception of the world quite substantially.
And funnily enough in Remnant just the belief that there's no need to fear because something exists that won't let the worst happen is enough to make a difference all by itself. Settlements outside the walls that trusted in Obsidian's protection might not draw Grimm in the first place.
On the other hand starting and managing a religion is no end of trouble. XD
The final interesting thing about Sow & Harvest that no one has mentioned is that hint about Ruby not being the first silver-eyed Reaper. It makes me wonder about the effects accumulating a legend might have on the line of Ruby's warrior ancestors, since even dead they shared a part in creating the belief and in being the object of whatever power it grants even now.
It makes me wonder if the trickle of power might create...impressions, of them. Recreations of them at their heroic best that linger.
What villain quest?Ask our dear QM about the other ideas "people", have pitched about the girls being gods. Whether its to play off or stand apart, it's something that might interest you.
Also the whole summoning ghosts harkens back to a certain villain quest involving a badass "cat-Faunus".
I'm half certain that Always Late is referring to Ashes to Ashes, Dust to Dust. The protagonist of the quest was Salem. There was at least one person who was killed and brought back as a puppet copy from semblance shenanigans. I vaguely remember that there might have been rumours that the cover identity for Salem was a secret faunus of some variety because of her treatment of the faunus community. Also 5 minutes in the thread shows a media post with a picture of the protagonist that is labeled "Totally not a catgirl" so that helps.