Hmmm...if plan sleeve won't work, then how about this? It's a bit high-risk, high-reward.
[X] Deploy Bible pages around you for teleportation. If necessary, use your scripture armor for it.
[X]
"And Shepherds we shall be..."
[X] Judge the Moon Presence's velocity. As it leaps with its hind legs to attack you with its remaining arm, do a power slide inside its reach, right below its ribs. Stun it with a jab from the bident.
[X]
"For thee, my Lord, for thee..."
[X] Complete your teleportation and materialize far up in the Dreaming sky. As you start to fall, make it rain weapons: normal bayonets, explosive bayonets, those weapons you picked up in the Nightmare...even the inert Amygdalan arms.
[X]
"The Power hath Descended forth from Thine Hand...."
[X] Teleport again before you hit the ground. Take a moment for the aerial bombardment to land, then materialize on the Moon Presence's bony spine. Swing down with the Boom Flail and break its back.
[X]
"...That our Feet may Swiftly carry out Thine Command!"
The riskiest part of this plan is the initial teleportation and power slide. Anderson may not be able to do a power slide with a fractured shin.
At this point, honestly, I'm going for drama
.