[X] Vendetta
-[X] Perfect Merger [50 Arete]
Okay, I have a Vendetta argument I've been brewing for a while, and there's no better time to try to articulate it (well, after a good night's sleep would probably be better but what are the odds of that hahahahhahahahhaaaaaa oh god)
I believe Birdsie articulated a thesis that there's a conceptual symmetry between this end of the Quest and its immediate backstory. It was a very interesting idea, and in true Age and Treachery fashion, I'm now going to use it against him. In brief, there's a Hero, a Tyrant, faithful Companions - and a Maiden. In the first story, the Maiden was Hunger's wife. Here, it's The Maiden herself (I'm going to give her a capitalized The every time, in defiance of grammar, for clarity's sake).
...Or, is it? Under this thesis The Maiden's claim to the role of "the Maiden" is important to her conceptual weight in this scenario, metaphysically speaking. But we actually have a potential challenger to that title. With the nature of high-ISH combat being so very conceptual/metaphysical, subsuming The Maiden's role as "the Maiden" in the story could utterly vitiate her ability to meaningfully effect her will, while simultaneously empowering her usurper accordingly. This angle also synergizes with Blood Halo. To wit:
*Add the Domain of Battles to the wielder's repertoire and maximize his ability therein. Within the context of battle he can easily manipulate virtually any circumstance, phenomenon or outcome. Effects of symbolic importance are heightened further still.
Emphasis added.
From my selected vote I'm sure you can guess who I'd propose as the challenger here, but let me spell it out. Gisena can usurp the role of "the Maiden" in the story from The Maiden. She's been by Hunger's side from the very beginning of this story - there was a Maiden before her, but the effects of Hunger's own Shattering Blow frayed the memory of her so severely that that linkage has already been eviscerated. Instead, it's been Gisena who has been by his side at every turn - and who has time and again made herself the very lynchpin of his success. This maneuver also makes them flirting up a storm every time they're on screen together into
combat-relevant preparation for victory against the final boss, for that matter, and you can't put a price on
that.
Moreover, this conceptual maneuver actually turns The Maiden's own infinite prep time against Hunger
against her in this contest. The Maiden has spent untold time building her own claim to the title that is her very name, long before ever coming across Lord Hunger. However, by spending infinite time focusing solely upon Hunger, she has proportionately infinitely diminished the metaphysical valence of her prior life. She has infinitely inflated the importance of her relationship to Hunger in determining her role in the story by spending infinite time focusing solely on him.
But, this is entirely one-sided. The Maiden has spent an eternity focusing solely upon Hunger. But from Hunger's perspective, she is only one more transitory obstacle - win or lose, her appearance in his story will be over in a flash. For The Maiden, this confrontation with Hunger is the culmination of an obsession that spanned infinity. For Hunger, it's Wednesday.
The power of Perfect Merger, in particular, helps support this (though it could still be attempted even with base Vendetta). By elevating Gisena along the ISH, her conceptual weight in general will be enhanced, better equipping her for the audacious maneuver of utterly usurping The Maiden's place in this story. This is a maneuver that Ending True
cannot replicate, incidentally - by eliminating Gisena, it would eliminate the vital element enabling a challenge to The Maiden's role as "the Maiden" here.
There are more advantages here. We don't know for sure what The Maiden's trump card could be, but (especially given her conceptual weaponization of Beauty) there's strong speculation that it's tied to weaponizing her link to Hunger's dead wife through Ceathlynn to attack him on some level, since Hunger's wife was the first "the Maiden" in his story. Just imagine the look on her face when she plays her trump card only to find it's less of a coup d'état and more of a belly flop, as we've already filled the role of Hunger's Maiden in the story - leaving no room whatsoever for some Janey-come-lately last-minute challenger wearing a dead woman like a meat suit.
This strength also notably contrasts with the definite
weakness of Closing the Fist against the same kind of maneuver from The Maiden. Not only does it leave the role of Hunger's Maiden glaringly open, but that +Simping is an absolutely lethal chink in our armor against an attack of this nature. And an attack of this nature is all too likely to be the kind of trump card The Maiden would play. She's The Maiden after all - her chief weapons are Grace and Beauty. Her trump card was never going to be some brutish attack based on mere strength and force. Light, heat, or anything else Aobaru could help contest? Mere byproducts of her
true weapons.
Lastly, why not turn our gaze to the future? Vendetta, especially with Perfect Merger, buys us by far the best improvement to our odds in the future. This is not speculation. It is stated explicitly in the option itself. I remember that when we were voting on how much to buff The Maiden by I argued for taking fewer options to improve our odds of securing victory, and the rebuttal I faced (which proved victorious) was that it wasn't just about winning now, it was about focusing on improving Hunger's outcomes in the epilogue. Whence this heady talk now? Has your courage fled so swiftly, upon seeing that the challenge voted for will be a challenge in truth, that now you focus solely upon arguing for what you imagine might bring victory now and never mind what best supports our future? I say thee
nay. I don't merely choose victory today. I am not content with a transitory triumph. I choose victory now, and
forever, until the Hidden Masters themselves are brought low and made to PAY.
In particular, let it be noted that Vendetta (again, especially with Perfect Merger) has far and away the most synergy with the Geas mitigation we chose. We chose to be able to bring companions with us, with the intent that Gisena - who has already been so vital, so important to our success and progress - would always be the first of those companions chosen. Ergo, the stronger Gisena becomes, the more valuable that mitigation becomes. We have a finite number of stage of mitigation we can ever achieve. Even if you weren't happy with the form of mitigation chosen at the time, that's no excuse for squandering it now.
Choose the most artful usurpation, that The Maiden will find her hole cards worthless against, and that shall see her very conceptual role outflanked and stolen from her very hands. Choose victory not just for the moment, but for all time and Tasks to come. Choose Vendetta.
Choose the Perfect Merger.
1160 words