Sirian said:
I do believe that most would allow that a sizable bust is considered an attractive feature both in the Exalted setting and in the Zero no Tsukaima setting, as well as in EarthScorpions hybrid universe. Louises desire for a larger bust and Marisalons comments considering this feature is a quite strong indication for this.
But everyone knows that it's an increase in Essence which increases bust size, not an increase in Appearance! It represents the increase in talent!
...
More seriously, it should be noted that, in-universe, if we are to trust Word of Saito, Louise is already very attractive. Maybe, you know, she's still 16, and naturally on the short, petite side; she's a delicate, almost Ophelian beauty, who doesn't conform to either modern demands for disproportionately large breasts without the curves elsewhere that come with it, or the more rounded ones wanted in the similar Earth-history era. And Creation is vast, and sexually diverse; you really can't generalise like that.
Heh. And the Maiden of the Mirthless Smile does canonically have a higher Appearance rating than the Lady Clad In Chains And Not Much Else, Apart From On The Cover Of Abyssals, Where She's Actually More Attractive Because She Put Some Damn Clothes On. Despite that.
And I should probably note that the physiques of the humans in AGSITV have been "realised" a bit. After all, last chapter Kirche was complaining that they were getting in the way when she was trying to run, and complaining that if she'd known she was going to be running, she'd have bound them. If Tiffania was human, she'd be having back problems (but she's not, but in return is actually a bit uncanny valley because of them).
Kirche, incidentally, is built like a barbarian princess. She takes after her ancestors quite a lot, who swept into Eastern Tristain at the head of their steppe hordes burning, pillaging, and ravaging as they clawed out an empire which became modern Germania, declaring themselves to be the new nobility. Hence, she's busty, but she's also not a frail little maiden with narrow hips and a narrow waist. Interestingly, a lot of the Germanian nobility are darker and have the same sort of different ethnicity to the Brimiric nobility (who have their own differences from the peasantry of both countries).
I refuse to confirm that Kirche gets the urge, when she looks at a monastery, to loot it, take the attractive monks to be her slaves and cutting off the heads of the unattractive ones before mounting them on spikes, and then burn the building to the ground, before riding off into the sunset on her ill-tempered pony, her new slaves marching behind her.
I will merely imply it heavily.
One can of course argue that
attractive and
desirous does not
necessarily imply sexual desire or sexual attractiveness.
This would lead to the situation that increases in Appearance leads to people thinking that the character is a cute young child and wants to possess it (most likely through some form of adoption). While this might lead to some form of social advantage it is outweighed by the dissadvantages.
In my opinion such an interpretation would go against the intentions of the writers.
Not necessarily. Yes, Louise will probably fill out a bit when she gets older, but... well, people seem to find Summer Glau attractive, to name but one waif-like individual who would also probably play a Slayer if there was an Exalted film. Or possibly a Sidereal. Nah, she'd probably play a Scourge, but one with Malfeas Charms. Or possibly Adorjan...
Where was I? Basically, Appearance is a lot harder to judge than Strength, say, but Louise
is meant to be the equivalent of an Appearance 3 or 4 character already.
1) Louises exaltation resulted in an increase in her bust, therefore it is most likely considered an imperfection to have a too small bust.
Nope. Explicitly wrong. It explicitly didn't; it removed all scars, made her features slightly more symmetrical, made her eyes slightly wider and darker, and replaced her toenails and fingernails with brass, but it didn't affect her bust at all.
It's funnier that way, because even getting fused to a neomah won't help her. Even the control of By Rage Recast can only make them fractionally larger, and that's the same thing that can give her razor-edged butterfly-like wings made of emerald and brass.
There is another interesting way of dancing around the whole issue and it fits rather well.
Instead of allowing increases in Appearance to alter Louises appearance it could alter how attractive everyone considers her to be.
Malfeas personification of lust and desire is his thirteenth soul
Ipithymia - the Street of Gold Lanterns. She actually takes the form of a street but occasionally takes mortal shape. Her favorite form is that of a golden-skinned, four-armed young woman in the scant clothing of a dancer or courtesan. In this form, she appears young, usually a bit too young for her highly sexualized dress and manner.
What, you mean the Third Circle Demon who simultaneously represents Malfeas' desire to make the pain go away through self-indulgence (and which make Ligier cringe), and his desire to see the Unconquered Sun as a loli genderflipped self-indulgent whore degrading herself in pursuit of pleasure?
Yeah. Um. There's a reason that Hell has golden-lantern districts, not red-light.