Your world-building is really top-notch.
Do you have your notes on Estalia and Tilea gathered in one place somewhere?
A lot of other Warhammer quests and stories would benefit from them.

I don't have my notes gathered in any one place, really. I draw inspiration from what published material I can from both official material (I've been leaning a fair bit on Barony of the Damned for the Mousillon parts) and fan-made material (I have the Estalia army book from Warhammer Armies Project on my computer), but I don't feel constrained by the source material as I'm not going to try and integrate all three decades and change of Games Workshop fiction here as I haven't read even a quarter of all the books they have published. For out-of-setting inspiration, I've been binging the Ring of Fire books by Eric Flint to help me with modes of speech and vocabulary and I have a few bookshelves worth of source material on things like criminality in Europe from the 800s to the 1400s or society during the Wars of Religion. I spend probably 90% of my 'writing' time doing things like cross-referencing varieties of cheese in France for names for knights, then flicking through a different site on vexillology to try and bring together a coherent set of heraldry for a knight that probably won't see much screen time. It would be unreasonable for me to ask other quest writers to do the same, though if they did I'd enjoy seeing the fruits of their labor.

That said, I do have notes of a sort for parts of the setting that haven't really been explored yet, like the role of formal and informal duels in Estalian political, legal and social life or the complex relationship the coastal cities of Araby have with Ulthuan merchant houses. My original plan was to shake some of those loose when it came time to interact meaningfully with them, but if people were interested I could write some of them up ahead of schedule.

What Solar ever turned down a chance at a quest

Busy ones, cautious ones, some of the contemplative ones.

What manner of Exalt would we be if we balked at danger?

"An old one!"
-Iralan Silveredscales, yelling at a bullheaded suicidal determined Korlovac Merkava-haine the Thrice Smiling again

What manner of Eclipse would we be if we shied away from treating with inhuman powers?

Obviously an ill-mannered one that's more interested in horsemanship or making a lot of cash than being a diplomat.
 
We should eventually go off and Conquer the Border Princes. Every Solar needs a Kingdom Eventually. . .Plus we can use that campaign to hone our war skill as a practice run for our eventual unification of Estalia
 
I'm quite sure we can manage better than a Border "kingdom."

Not A Border Kingdom, THE Border Kingdom.

The Border Princes would be excellent practice for uniting Estalia. It's a bunch of petty kingdoms and city states, all working at cross purposes to each other, all under arms.

Much like the various cities of Estalia.

It's a proof of concept for when we go off to unite Estalia under our Banner.

Then we'll have two kingdoms under our control.
 
Not A Border Kingdom, THE Border Kingdom.

The Border Princes would be excellent practice for uniting Estalia. It's a bunch of petty kingdoms and city states, all working at cross purposes to each other, all under arms.

Much like the various cities of Estalia.

It's a proof of concept for when we go off to unite Estalia under our Banner.

Then we'll have two kingdoms under our control.

Entirely possible as an objective, though Sal won't call himself a king unless the voters specifically vote to as the only King the Estalians claim to have had is Tylos, the only Queen Myrmidia. There have been monarchs that have been arrogant enough to claim to be their equal, but few last and fewer manage to convince others to address them as such. For most, 'prince' or 'princess' is sufficient, though of course there are always grand dukes, grandmasters of knightly orders or high abbot of such and such monastic order governing a place.

Salvadore has a number of possible 'take over the Border Princes' routes, anywhere from traditional "claim a crown and defeat any who care to contest my claim" to purchasing it out from under someone or even orchestrating a network of alliances and coalitions among the current rulers that cements Salvadore Chavez as the first among equals without claiming an inch of soil between the Blackwater to Myrmidens.

That said, Estalia is not the Border Princes is not Tilea (even if Imperial scholars have a tendency to paint them with the same brush), the same techniques won't work equally well in each region. You can certainly pioneer methods in the Border Princes for use elsewhere, but expecting to unite an impoverished, balkanized region where the most stable form of government is an anarchic sort of banana republic the same way you'd unite wealthy, mostly stable city states whose histories go back centuries instead of months is perhaps ill-conceived.

Don't let me stop you from voting to move on to empire building if that's what you want, though.

Every Solar needs a Kingdom Eventually.

While any Solar would of course be the best candidate for rulership a nation could ask for, to say that a Solar needs a kingdom is like saying a Solar needs oxygen or needs tools. Most find them useful, but while the Solar God-King model has a proven track record for GLORIOUS SOLAR RULERSHIP it is also viable to play a mendicant healer or hermit-sage.

I'm quite sure we can manage better than a Border "kingdom."

This is 100% true.
 
I think the old plan was to hijack a Black Ark, redecorate it to fit GLORIOUS SOLAR AESTHETICS - call the result a Gold Ark if you want - park it in the Tilean Sea or Black Gulf (because the open ocean between Magritta and Araby is too exposed), and make it our floating capital.
 
So, how much longer exactly until we can get started on our empire building and/or Black Ark hijacking goals? Because personally, I'd just like to point out that as a Solar, we can definitely do both.
 
I, for one, am nowhere near ready to settle down and give up swashbuckling and exploring. Especially without the skills, charms, and resources to do anything meaningful with rulership.
 
So, how much longer exactly until we can get started on our empire building and/or Black Ark hijacking goals? Because personally, I'd just like to point out that as a Solar, we can definitely do both.

Technically, you could saddle up on a horse and ride away. More probably there will be options to engage in activities elsewhere at the end of the current arc that could lead to laying the groundwork for sniping a Black Ark. Be advised, however; I'm not planning on making hijacking a Black Ark anything but a difficult task that you'll need to work at. They're physical symbols of Druchii force projection that have withstood Ulthuan's attempts to sweep them from the sea, and while Salvadore is Exalted he cannot yet make bricks without clay. To that end, if you want to take control of a Black Ark through main force a bit of empire building first might not be a bad idea.

I think the old plan was to hijack a Black Ark, redecorate it to fit GLORIOUS SOLAR AESTHETICS - call the result a Gold Ark if you want - park it in the Tilean Sea or Black Gulf (because the open ocean between Magritta and Araby is too exposed), and make it our floating capital.

Or flying capitol, depending on which one you want to aim for. Though redecorating an Ark to look appropriately Solar is going to be a project all on its own. Just, the manpower needed to remove all those tacky chandeliers alone is astounding, and the only people with enough gold laying around to gild the entire outer wall are notoriously reluctant to let any of it slip through their fingers. And that's before getting into making the victory banner that can be read miles at sea reading "Now I have an Ark, ho ho ho" in four different languages...

I'm still of the opinion that we should seduce the goddess before we unite her kingdom.

But Bretonnia is already unified, and I have it on good authority that the Lady is still crushing on some Giles fellow. /deliberately misunderstanding your statement

Discussion is now 'how to woo a goddess'. Flowers and chocolates alone won't get your foot in the door here, she's not so easily impressed. (Also, if trophies from slain enemies were her thing Ulric would have made a lot more progress over the centuries)
 
Or flying capitol, depending on which one you want to aim for. Though redecorating an Ark to look appropriately Solar is going to be a project all on its own. Just, the manpower needed to remove all those tacky chandeliers alone is astounding, and the only people with enough gold laying around to gild the entire outer wall are notoriously reluctant to let any of it slip through their fingers. And that's before getting into making the victory banner that can be read miles at sea reading "Now I have an Ark, ho ho ho" in four different languages...
Just scrubbing all the blood off, both the old stains and the fresh stuff from conquering the Arc is likely to be a task that will keep thousands of sailors with extensive experience in deck-scrubbing busy for months and years.
 
Honestly it would be a lot less work and *shudders* manual labor to get shipshape another type of moving island instead of a Black Ark and like sail to Lustrian waters and wrestle into submission a giant turtle or leviathan or some other manner of monstrous beast able to support our summer villa upon it's back.
 
Discussion is now 'how to woo a goddess'. Flowers and chocolates alone won't get your foot in the door here, she's not so easily impressed. (Also, if trophies from slain enemies were her thing Ulric would have made a lot more progress over the centuries)

I have no real idea but I'm certain the pc is better with women then I am. For me, my main question would be would we have to get her parents permission to court her. I can imagine doing a grand quest for both Verena and Morr to get permission to try and court her and then another grand quest to try and win her over after having got permission.

As for her not liking trophies, I would imagine that it's not that she doesn't like Ulric killing her enemies for her because I'm sure she appreciates it. It's that he's doing it the wrong way to get affection and acknowledgment. She's a goddess of tactics and wisdom and he's a lot more into personal strength. I would imagine that he will charge headlong into solo fights against bosses and continue to make no progress unless he tells his followers to respect her work as a tactician.

I mean something like destroy a chaos army of equal size without losing a man relying on the principals of war from her college and then at the victory dinner, create romantic poetry about the battle in the form of a prayer that both shows your love and devotion and requests the right to court her.

sounds really nice, for all that it would not work.

I would also say that turning the borderlands into a theocracy where she is the main god might also work but I figure enough people have conquered in her name before that it wouldn't stand out.
 
Turning to look at his lover in surprise, Sal took a glancing blow from a bolt meant for her instead. "I'll be fine, gosling. Keep them busy." Beatrice was already pulling another wad of powder free from her bandoleer.
Without checking to see if the bolt had rebounded or penetrated, Salvadore joined the mass of Remean sailors attempting to swarm the elven corsairs.
And here we see the genesis of Senor Chavez's personal antipathy for the druchii.
More than a little of it is transferred self-loathing, like all the best grudges, for failing to properly check on his beloved after knowing she took injury.

She was also normally proportioned, unlike the woman's younger assistant whose mother had apparently been skimping and only gave the girl three fingers on either hand and a misaligned jaw that gave her a sullen cast.
Hmm.
Something in the water thereabouts? Shouldn't be so many birth defects in the area.
Especially birth defects that are healthy enough to make it to adulthood.

Can't be Rossi just collecting strays, could it?
Madame Rossi snorted contemptuously. "Any patient who knows anything useful is just going to lie to you. And this one's an Estalian scoundrel, their heads are almost as empty as yours is. He's just a pretty face without the sense Rhya gave a goose."
Ah, but the lies they tell you are as informative as the truths.
Bet you the Shallyans talk to their patients.
:p
It wasn't the worst he'd ever been hurt of course, but a strega was the sort to salt a wound to make sure the injured person would remember the pain of the moment and spare her the work in the future. Salvadore suspected if he didn't ham it up she'd rub some stinging ointment in just in case.
Nowadays we just use iodine:V

Giving his third most annoyingly understanding smile, Salvadore wordlessly signaled his understanding. Charming woman. An absolute harridan, but charming all the same.
:eyebrow::eyebrow:
Sometimes, Slamu, the contents of your brain worry me.

You heard that a large fleet of elves passed through here mere weeks before we arrived, yes? That ship we fought was a straggler I think, a weak fish trailing the school looking for any last worms in the dirt that might be snatched up before moving on."
It says something that Sal here doesn't seem to distinguish between types of elves.
And neither, apparently, does his kid cousin, so it's not just a private prejudice. And Estalians are not tight enough with the dwarves to share their racial prejudice against the elves.

An artefact of living so far away from the focus of elven attentions in the Empire?
Or is Estalia and Tilea the dumping ground for the black sheep of Ulthuan, while the better sort like Teclis head for Brettonia and the Empire?

The bounty boards of many seaside tavernas in Remas have standing bounties on credible news of the movements and status of any slaver-elf ships, and the promises for Black Arks were...substantial. Also rarely claimed.
Tempting.
Not until we crack Sorcery though.

His first mate shook his head. "No, the second man was tall, broad shouldered and bald. Strong chin, if you like that sort of thing. Had some good armor in his room, saw some use before too. Either a gryphon or a demigryph painted on it, didn't see too much. He lead the villagers to us."
So possibly a Blood Dragon then, though those guys aren't known for seeking reinforcements.
Definitely not a Brettonian, since they have no association with griffons that I can recall.

More likely, an elite Imperial Knight, from the Order of the Griffon, whose crest is:


Why one would be walking with a Kislevite is beyond me though.

===================================
[X] Maleagent has treated fairly with the Chavez's so far, and a slight detour is a small favor to ask. Accept.

The FUN choice.
To be honest, too often the sea is a sideshow in Warhammer Fantasy.
Deadly serious for the druchii and the elves of Ulthuan, but the world could be won and lost without anyone else smelling salt water.

EDIT
Or flying capitol, depending on which one you want to aim for. Though redecorating an Ark to look appropriately Solar is going to be a project all on its own. Just, the manpower needed to remove all those tacky chandeliers alone is astounding, and the only people with enough gold laying around to gild the entire outer wall are notoriously reluctant to let any of it slip through their fingers. And that's before getting into making the victory banner that can be read miles at sea reading "Now I have an Ark, ho ho ho" in four different languages...
Steal Invent the concept of Sorcerous Workings from 3E; they probably already exist, since Black Arks are as much magic as constructs. Gather the necessary reagents. Then science the shit out of re-aspecting the enchantments from whatever the unholy shit they currently run on to something more wholesome.

Discussion is now 'how to woo a goddess'. Flowers and chocolates alone won't get your foot in the door here, she's not so easily impressed. (Also, if trophies from slain enemies were her thing Ulric would have made a lot more progress over the centuries)
*Points above*
Getting a foot in the door is easy, relatively speaking.

One of Myrmidia's lesser aspects, at least in Tilea, involves also the portfolio of science and the fine arts, in addition to the art and science of war. She coincidentally, has very strong sun and lion associations in her heraldry. The first time Solar Sal, Eclipse Caste flares totemic, she's going to sit up and take notice. Possibly come running.

After that it's up to Sal.
Maybe just pull an Eclipse charm steal trick and duplicate one of her lesser powers after seeing it, then use it to put on a little show.

Admittedly, stealing a Black Ark is more Manann and Ranald's schtick.
But aspecting it's enchantments to the sun would be more of a seal the deal project. He might want to ask women tips from Ranald to at least get his foot in the door; IIRC Ranald is part of the family.

EDIT
Actually, is there any reason Ranald isn't a lady? Or can't be in this AU? God of trickery and deception after all.
 
Last edited:
So possibly a Blood Dragon then, though those guys aren't known for seeking reinforcements.
Definitely not a Brettonian, since they have no association with griffons that I can recall.

More likely, an elite Imperial Knight, from the Order of the Griffon, whose crest is:


Why one would be walking with a Kislevite is beyond me though.

Could be a Member of Kislev's Gryphon Legion. They're the WHFB Equivalent of the Winged Hussars. Would explain why he's hanging with a Kislevite. . .
 
We should unite Tilea and Estalia as King eventually. Tiger Warrior training to make the deadliest human navy ever witnessed. Make it not worth it for pirates and slavers to be anywhere within 100 miles of us. Then get the goddess to manifest an avatar to waifu.
 
If you're a Solaroid, and you aren't constantly up in Murphy's face yelling, "BRING IT!" I'm not sure you deserve the title at all. :V

We should unite Tilea and Estalia as King eventually. Tiger Warrior training to make the deadliest human navy ever witnessed. Make it not worth it for pirates and slavers to be anywhere within 100 miles of us. Then get the goddess to manifest an avatar to waifu.
The real problem keeping Tilea and Estalia separate, even if each one is individually unified, is the giant metropolis full of ratmen right in between. On a scale of "roman candle" to "Tsar Bomba," how big of a boom would a protoshinmaic vortex create if it goes off? I think Myrmidia might appreciate an artificial sunrise dedicated in her honor.
 
If you're a Solaroid, and you aren't constantly up in Murphy's face yelling, "BRING IT!" I'm not sure you deserve the title at all. :V
See, the only problem there is that the Solars who lived spent a while buffing up before taunting Murphy.
Sal's still a baby. And no babysitter to haul his beef out of the fire.

The real problem keeping Tilea and Estalia separate, even if each one is individually unified, is the giant metropolis full of ratmen right in between. On a scale of "roman candle" to "Tsar Bomba," how big of a boom would a protoshinmaic vortex create if it goes off? I think Myrmidia might appreciate an artificial sunrise dedicated in her honor.
Eh. Castle Bravo, maybe?

Big, but not that big in the grand scheme of things. Especially since the ratmen are just as likely to start throwing WMDs right back, from warpnukes to Clan Pestilens bioweapons. And Sal is an Eclipse, not a Twilight. Mad Solar Science is not his bailiwick; dude probably went drinking and wenching while they were teaching calculus.

You'd be better off rushing for Celestial or Solar Sorcery.
 
On a scale of "roman candle" to "Tsar Bomba," how big of a boom would a protoshinmaic vortex create if it goes off?
There are way better uses for those things than for WMDs.

As for the Skaven city. We kill them. Not with an army. With precise application of Bureaucracy charms to make it harder for them to organize. A few pushes and they will be murdering each other even more than they usually do. Then we send in the army to murder them.
 
Skaven "organization" barely works in the first place. It shouldn't take much to send it collapsing.
 
Honestly it would be a lot less work and *shudders* manual labor to get shipshape another type of moving island instead of a Black Ark and like sail to Lustrian waters and wrestle into submission a giant turtle or leviathan or some other manner of monstrous beast able to support our summer villa upon it's back.

But a giant turtle, however effective, won't have the same political cache as "Malekith ripped this fortress from Ulthuan's shores and terrorized the world with it. I have taken it from Malekith, for he was obviously too weak to hold it." (This is a handy social tool for interacting with the Asur, by the way)

Just scrubbing all the blood off, both the old stains and the fresh stuff from conquering the Arc is likely to be a task that will keep thousands of sailors with extensive experience in deck-scrubbing busy for months and years.

Technically speaking, they don't have to be sailors. Being as large and stable as it is, an Ark is a bit more forgiving about that. Mostly you'll want to keep it stocked with sailors while you're at sea anyway, especially if you're using it as a mobile port of sorts like the Druchii do, but if all you're interested in is cleaning then rounding up all the urchins in a city and tasking them with cleaning the common areas will do for most of the manpower needs, though sensitive areas you'll want professionals who handle things themselves.

I have no real idea but I'm certain the pc is better with women then I am.

Given his possession of Appearance 5 and Presence 5 I suspect this is rather likely to be true. I haven't met you in real life so I'm hesitant to assert that this is absolutely true, but given the likelihood of encountering someone with once-in-a-generation good looks and a command of the rhetorical arts that borders on the superhuman out of a randomly selected population I like my chances.

For me, my main question would be would we have to get her parents permission to court her. I can imagine doing a grand quest for both Verena and Morr to get permission to try and court her and then another grand quest to try and win her over after having got permission.

It depends. While gods tend to make their own rules, assuming all the personalities involved were humans of equal-ish standing it sort of falls along the Estalian/Tilean split. Under widespread (though not universal) Tilean custom, as an unmarried woman living under her father's roof and eating at his table, official legal courtship has to be approved by him. This is often granted, usually with conditions and concessions, because of an unofficial custom of ensuring that the patriarch will say 'yes' when asked. This is usually accomplished by being vetted by the rest of the family, in this case Verena and Shallya, determining not just your character but your means both financial and social. If you couldn't afford to support a wife, or if your social network was suspect, they would tell Morr "no", or at least "not yet". Occasionally the prospective gentleman courter would give gifts to sway the women's opinions of him but that isn't as common as you'd think listening to Estalians demeaning their fellow coreligionists. Assuming Morr gave the okay, an announcement would be made (from plazas near the steps of government if the people involved are important enough, but usually in guildhalls or taverns or some other common gathering areas appropriate to the families' professional standing) and an arbiter would be informed of any conditions Salvadore could court Myrmidia. These conditions can be as elaborate as the patriarch wants, and you can generally tell when the father is against a potential match but has to agree to give the young man a chance by how arduous the stipulations are. Most agreements include requirements to be able to demonstrate advancement in your trade, attendance at certain social events (what events are largely formulaic depending on the location and trades involved, feastdays and naming days for family members are common while dooming days are inauspicious) and wearing a token to demonstrate that you are courting, such as a blue flower on your tunic. The patriarch can end the courtship when given cause, either by noncompliance with the courtship agreement or 'outrageous behavior' and the arbiters are generally predisposed to rule in the patriarch's favor. That said, if the patriarch's stated cause is spurious or has a history of leading potential courters along before ending the courtship agreement the arbiter will usually rule in favor of the courter.

In Estalia things are far more sensible. As a free woman under arms, who has fought in at least one battle and provides her own defense she can legally do more or less as she pleases. If any of her siblings took umbrage at the arrangement and could provide circumstantial evidence that the courtship harms her or her family, the Chavez family must present a response or have an impartial arbiter keep them separate for a year and a day. Generally this response takes the form of a duel to first blood, though in this particular case it would likely involve Shallya giving everyone puppy eyes until everyone relents. There is a one lunar month grace period allowed before a dalliance must become a legal courtship (the pious tend to claim the reason is linked to the declaration of the Verenian calendar, while cynics often mention it gives everyone time to decide if someone needs to take offense at the lady missing a monthly visitor). Myrmidia would have certain social obligations should Salvadore's mother came to visit (which she should before any wedding occurs) while Salvadore is expected to pay Myrmidia's father a visit in turn where Morr would give him a task to fulfill. This is another case where you can see how well the father wants a match to fare, as the task in question could range from 'hand me that pitcher of wine' to 'slay a specific monster with this wooden spoon under the light of the new moon'. Typically the task is suited to the nature of the gentleman's profession (stand proxy in a duel, or present to me a work of art made by your own hand, etc) and the courtship and even wedding can continue even if Sal refused or failed this task. Doing so often results in familial disharmony and occasional feuds though only rarely vendettas. Exactly how long the courtship lasts is variable but most places require at least a year and the mutual consent of their spiritual counselors (technically this being any priest, but almost always being the Cult of Myrmidia, which could prove...complicated). If vendetta was declared against Sal, Myrmidia would be expected to stand proxy for any duels he is challenged to (and he her, as they are both considered (wo)men under arms). If he were attempting to woo a Shallyan she would not be expected to fight a martial duel, though a proxy for this proxy generally volunteers because seriously, who wants to fight a Shallyan? As a courtship continues, tokens of esteem are exchanged, usually of negligable financial worth but meaningful to the lovers.

Of course as these are divinity, the usual methods...may not apply.

And here we see the genesis of Senor Chavez's personal antipathy for the druchii.
More than a little of it is transferred self-loathing, like all the best grudges, for failing to properly check on his beloved after knowing she took injury.


Mostly correct, but in the bit you quoted it was Salvadore that was shot, not her. The dream ended before anything bad happened to her.

Something in the water thereabouts? Shouldn't be so many birth defects in the area.
Especially birth defects that are healthy enough to make it to adulthood.

Can't be Rossi just collecting strays, could it?

A bit of both. Bretonnian peasants tend to be inbred, and Mousillon peasants are worse off than most of the rest of Bretonnian peasants. There are villages of actual mutants that are overlooked because they don't look too much different from the other lowlies in the area. But Rossi also has a soft spot for those that need help, even if she's a bit brusque around those that should be able to pour water from a boot when the instructions are on the heel. If you ask "What would Granny Weatherwax do?" you're probably on the right track for the stereotypical strega.

Bet you the Shallyans talk to their patients.
:p

A young, pretty and tenderhearted Shallyan will generally do her best to alleviate your hurts and shield you from the cruelties of the world. An older Shallyan tends to have more in character with a senior nurse on the ward, who has seen everything and knows the difference between 'healing' and 'pandering'. Either will likely talk to you, but unless you have a disease of the spirit or brain the Shallyans are prone to claim men have and put you in specially-made hugging jackets they tend to fall somewhere on the "oh you poor dear"-to-"well if it hurts stop poking at it dipstick" spectrum.

Sometimes, Slamu, the contents of your brain worry me.

Did you know that you can just buy goats blood?

It says something that Sal here doesn't seem to distinguish between types of elves.
And neither, apparently, does his kid cousin, so it's not just a private prejudice. And Estalians are not tight enough with the dwarves to share their racial prejudice against the elves.

An artefact of living so far away from the focus of elven attentions in the Empire?
Or is Estalia and Tilea the dumping ground for the black sheep of Ulthuan, while the better sort like Teclis head for Brettonia and the Empire?

Largely an artifact of distance. What's the difference between a Nordlander and an Ostlander to an Estalian? There's an acknowledgement that there are differences between the two, but neither are in particularly good odor among Estalians (that care) right now; the druchii obviously aren't great neighbors but the asur similarly tend to leave a bad taste in peoples' mouths. Even leaving aside the elven army traipsing through Estalia, no one has forgotten Ulthuan's long and extensive support of Araby, nor how efforts by Magritta to open up greater contact with the elves of Lothern resulted in the dandelion-eaters talking to Marienburg of all places. Add in their 'sea taxes' and whenever something really bad happens you can almost always find an elf nearby...why be charitable?

Why one would be walking with a Kislevite is beyond me though.

"Wait, Kislevites can get off their horses?"
"I know, it surprised me too but there you have it."
"This raises so many questions."

To be honest, too often the sea is a sideshow in Warhammer Fantasy.
Deadly serious for the druchii and the elves of Ulthuan, but the world could be won and lost without anyone else smelling salt water.

There are a few other factions at play, but you can't really talk about naval powers without mentioning Ulthuan and Naggaroth, with anyone else being regional powers at best.

Steal Invent the concept of Sorcerous Workings from 3E; they probably already exist, since Black Arks are as much magic as constructs. Gather the necessary reagents. Then science the shit out of re-aspecting the enchantments from whatever the unholy shit they currently run on to something more wholesome.

I'm stealing borrowing Sorcerous Workings from 3e, yes. Tweaks in background mechanics very likely, but the overall concept I'm willing to play with. Making your own Ark or reaspecting an existing one isn't going to be an easy thing though, fair warning.

He might want to ask women tips from Ranald to at least get his foot in the door; IIRC Ranald is part of the family.

Ranald is 'part of the family' because he stole a portion of divinity from the one god who demonstrably gives a shit about the common man and who would probably have given him some of her power if he'd just asked. Shallya has forgiven him this, but she's a softie. No one else in the family has, nor plans to.

EDIT
Actually, is there any reason Ranald isn't a lady? Or can't be in this AU? God of trickery and deception after all.

AU? This entire quest is canon. Not just any canon, but super ultra mega canon. I talked to Games Workshop, if we get this done right they're willing to retcon the End Times nonsense with this quest, it'll be awesome. Got it cleared with some guy named Ronald and everything.

Also, why should Ranald be a lady? Sure he could probably dress like one, act like one, but why does he need to be one? How would the setting be improved if he was the goddess of trickery and deception?

Could be a Member of Kislev's Gryphon Legion. They're the WHFB Equivalent of the Winged Hussars. Would explain why he's hanging with a Kislevite. . .

True fact, every time the Griffon Legion charges into battle Screaming Krwiopijca, Martial God of the Griffon Legion starts air guitaring Sabaton. The Ancient Widow found it amusing at first but finds the joke wearing thin by now, much to Screaming Krwiopijca's acute lack of caring.

See, the only problem there is that the Solars who lived spent a while buffing up before taunting Murphy.
Sal's still a baby. And no babysitter to haul his beef out of the fire.

Sal's borrowed dream-memories include Iralan complaining about how Korlovac was just like his predecessor. Given how Korlovac didn't make it to Essence 4 and stayed in Creation even with the existence of a fate-ninja panopticon and Shogunate era Wyld Hunt goon squads we can reasonably infer that this Exaltation doesn't select for strong survival instincts.

The real problem keeping Tilea and Estalia separate, even if each one is individually unified, is the giant metropolis full of ratmen right in between. On a scale of "roman candle" to "Tsar Bomba," how big of a boom would a protoshinmaic vortex create if it goes off? I think Myrmidia might appreciate an artificial sunrise dedicated in her honor.

An unstable protoshinmiac vortex is everyone's problem. It's more an industrial accident than a weapon of war to boot. What you want is something more like a war manse or a soulbreaker orb. It's like comparing Chernobyl to Hiroshima; both things I acutely don't want to happen anywhere near me, but one is a tool of war and the other a product of something going wrong.

Though I'm impressed that you think the Skaven are a greater threat to cross-Myrmidian unity than centuries of animosity and cultural drift.

dude probably went drinking and wenching while they were teaching calculus.

"Probably"

Though, point of information, calculus as we think of it isn't a thing in setting. There's a trend towards it, and numerous mathematical models attempting to predict the motion of celestial bodies, but so far the best the academic establishment have managed is "correct-ish for a given time period and with the caveat that Morrslieb is a shit no we can't call it that in an academic paper perpetually considered but unaccounted variable".

As for the Skaven city. We kill them. Not with an army. With precise application of Bureaucracy charms to make it harder for them to organize. A few pushes and they will be murdering each other even more than they usually do. Then we send in the army to murder them.

That's certainly one possible approach.
 
Though I'm impressed that you think the Skaven are a greater threat to cross-Myrmidian unity than centuries of animosity and cultural drift
It occurs to me with some horror that given the aspect splitting that Warhammer Fantasy gods do when their worshipers have drastically different opinions on their nature/beliefs/actions, if Salvadore successfully married Myrmidia there's a good chance that a bunch of Tileans would go "nuh-uh, she would never marry an Estalian" and Myrmidia would promptly split her personality into married and unmarried faces. And wouldn't that be awkward for everyone involved?
 
Last edited:
A bit of both. Bretonnian peasants tend to be inbred, and Mousillon peasants are worse off than most of the rest of Bretonnian peasants. There are villages of actual mutants that are overlooked because they don't look too much different from the other lowlies in the area. But Rossi also has a soft spot for those that need help, even if she's a bit brusque around those that should be able to pour water from a boot when the instructions are on the heel. If you ask "What would Granny Weatherwax do?" you're probably on the right track for the stereotypical strega.
Given the amount of inbreeding necessary for physical deformities to show up?
Just gonna write it up to Warhammer being Warhammer.

Or maybe the result of a grand ritual which drains the vitality and luck of the peasantry in order to empower Brettonia's frankly bullshit cavalry. Wouldn't be the first time those guys and their gods did something shady.
I mean, what happens to all the potential male mages?

Did you know that you can just buy goats blood?
Lol.
Goats are good eating, if you're teeth are good.
Add in their 'sea taxes' and whenever something really bad happens you can almost always find an elf nearby...why be charitable?
See, here's the problem.

It would be one thing if they didn't really bother with the difference between the Asur and the Asrai; they have little contact with the Wood Elves. But given how critical sea trade seems to be to Estalia and Tilea, one would expect that they'd be acutely aware of the difference between the Asur and the Druchii, since it is literally a matter of life and death, and more importantly, mercantile success.

After all, as long as you aren't bearing symbols of Chaos, Asur might turn up their nose at you. At worst.
They'll still generally share the sea and trade, and are the only reliable source of goods from Indus and Cathay. Might even help for free. And are generally no worse assholes than the dawi, or most people.

Druchii will torture you to death on general principles. If you're lucky.

Besides, I wasn't aware the asur taxed human(or dawi) trade on the great ocean anyway.
Aren't they supposed to be resource-rich but relatively manpower-poor? Can they even afford the ships to spare from their feud with fending off Naggaroth while watching Chaos?

Tariff merchants that visit Ulthuani ports, yes. That makes sense. Tariffing the general sea trade doesn't.
I'm stealing borrowing Sorcerous Workings from 3e, yes. Tweaks in background mechanics very likely, but the overall concept I'm willing to play with. Making your own Ark or reaspecting an existing one isn't going to be an easy thing though, fair warning.
Wholeheartedly approve.
The entire sorcery subsystem is the one undisputed improvement to Exalted mechanics and fluff that came in with 3E. And it translates very well to Warhammer, where various warp spirits are all too willing to offer sorcerous initiation for a low, low, price.

Ranald is 'part of the family' because he stole a portion of divinity from the one god who demonstrably gives a shit about the common man and who would probably have given him some of her power if he'd just asked. Shallya has forgiven him this, but she's a softie. No one else in the family has, nor plans to.
I didn't realize he stole it.
The sources I came across suggested he either tricked her, or was somehow related to her. Not like he harmed her by drinking her tears; dude is supposed to be averse to violence.

Of course, this assumes that the story that he stole it is true, and not simply put out to explain why she(or the other gods) don't make more gods. Sigmar ascended somehow, after all.

Also, why should Ranald be a lady? Sure he could probably dress like one, act like one, but why does he need to be one? How would the setting be improved if he was the goddess of trickery and deception?
God of deception. Wouldn't the ultimate scam be that he's not the sex most people think?
Just an idle thought.

An unstable protoshinmiac vortex is everyone's problem. It's more an industrial accident than a weapon of war to boot. What you want is something more like a war manse or a soulbreaker orb. It's like comparing Chernobyl to Hiroshima; both things I acutely don't want to happen anywhere near me, but one is a tool of war and the other a product of something going wrong.
Though I'm impressed that you think the Skaven are a greater threat to cross-Myrmidian unity than centuries of animosity and cultural drift.
This is Warhammer.
A weapon whose mechanics basically state that it soulrips everyone in a roughly eighty square mile area might as well be setting out a welcome carpet for Greater Bloodthirsters.

Get a terras mortar. That will only burn the area to ash.
It occurs to me with some horror that given the aspect splitting that Warhammer Fantasy gods do when their worshipers have drastically different opinions on their nature/beliefs/actions, if Salvadore successfully married Myrmidia there's a good chance that a bunch of Tileans would go "nuh-uh, she would never marry an Estalian" and Myrmidia would promptly split her personality into married and unmarried faces. And wouldn't that be awkward for everyone involved
You mean they'll be asserting he was a Tilean at heart, or somewhere in his genealogy.
Obviously.
 
Back
Top