- Location
- Somewhere in the area
- Pronouns
- He/She/They
[X] Plan: Peace and Science
Warhammer 40K is a grimdark setting.
Before talking about morality and how to apply it (and removing taboos on scientific research), we should first heavily strengthen ourselves. because in our current state we have the same power as an amoeba compared to anyone.
Lmao unironically something a chaos cultist would say.No this is just imperial apologia. The imperium has one size fit all answers because it's a fascist cargo cult worshipping a corpse. It has purged the ability to think and adapt from its own systems a long time ago. This is explicitly textual. Even the newer material that tones down the over the top satire and makes imperial protagonists more sympathetic doesn't sugarcoat its dysfunctional nature. There are good individuals stuck in that system, and even small pieces of it that works and keep struggling against the death spiral but the overall machinery is rotten to the core and it's all downhill from there. This is in fact the fundamental concept of 40k.
Uhm... What?
Uhm... What?
Like... What?
Criticism of Imperium automatically equals supporting Chaos?
Where do you get that idea from?
Em yes it basically chaos speech in-lore? Classical rotten carcass + dead corpse is standard combination. And pretty much yes, criticizing too much makes you a traitorous heretic, regardless if that is true or not. And at that point those guys either die, hide or get ensnared by chaos. The classic stuff basically.Uhm... What?
Like... What?
Criticism of Imperium automatically equals supporting Chaos?
Where do you get that idea from?
Try it maybe for the next vote? Even if new parties are struggling getting those first 3 votes. It would be interesting and less divisive for sure. Still yes that bit before was 100% chaos talk, just add maybe the Death to the False Emperor and then you really get the classic CSM line.I'm tempted to make a new party next round focused on restarting innovation in a way that's more focused on idealized belief about the old mechanicus and DAoT humanity. It'll probably have less friction than the current radicals while still opening up more doors than a conservative approach.
Em yes it basically chaos speech in-lore? Classical rotten carcass + dead corpse is standard combination. And pretty much yes, criticizing too much makes you a traitorous heretic, regardless if that is true or not. And at that point those guys either die, hide or get ensnared by chaos. The classic stuff basically.
Try it maybe for the next vote? Even if new parties are struggling getting those first 3 votes. It would be interesting and less divisive for sure. Still yes that bit before was 100% chaos talk, just add maybe the Death to the False Emperor and then you really get the classic CSM line.
I'm tempted to make a new party next round focused on restarting innovation in a way that's more focused on idealized belief about the old mechanicus and DAoT humanity. It'll probably have less friction than the current radicals while still opening up more doors than a conservative approach.
New coalition partners!I'll consider the new party next vote if anyone else expresses interest.
Em yes it basically chaos speech in-lore? Classical rotten carcass + dead corpse is standard combination. And pretty much yes, criticizing too much makes you a traitorous heretic, regardless if that is true or not. And at that point those guys either die, hide or get ensnared by chaos. The classic stuff basically.
Yeah, just got confused a bit on IC/OOC.
You are reading too much in what I wrote. I just said that what you said would unironically be said by a chaos cultist in a book or something. Classic rotten carcass + dead corpse and that you only miss the False Emperor bit to get the classic 100% CSM lineAre you really contesting the core theme of the imperium, that it's on a perpetual downward spiral? Really? Because it's very much textual in the lore and the vast majority of 40k lore is not from the chaos point of view.
The imperium took a blow it never recovered from with the heresy, and it got much worse when the remaining primarchs died or disappeared, then got even worse when the ecclesiarchy went for their little coup. Every time it faces a crisis, something gets broken that it forgot how to repair. In the case of the mechanicus, that's even more literal since it's running a pile of archeotech and obsesses over leftover STCs rather than try to rebuild non rote knowledge.
The emperor is very much a vegetable on life support, you don't need the chaos gods to point out he hasn't been in charge of anything except shining in the warp like a human lighthouse for 10 millenias. The imperium mostly run on inertia and that gets less and less workable every time a piece of the machinery breaks.
It's quite telling that the only way GW found to give it some hope was to give it a final blow then resurrect a primarch to gather the pieces.
As a faction of the AdMech willing to give a second look at pre-imperial practices like internal democracy, I feel like we can't be blind to that trend, otherwise we would never have gone digging for those lost practices. It's up to us to leverage our healthier political system into answers to the inertia and decay.
You are reading too much in what I wrote. I just said that what you said would unironically be said by a chaos cultist in a book or something. Classic rotten carcass + dead corpse and that you only miss the False Emperor bit to get the classic 100% CSM line
True while chaos lead rebellions do happen (and yes chaos corruption does work kind of like evil magic that turns people into heretics), often they seem to be caused by some Governor or other leader who gets greedy and decides to split away to get more power. Then they either get killed by Imperials, get killed by xenos or turn to chaos by corruption and sometimes by desperation when fighting one of the previous two. Tyrannids and Tau infiltrations also exist, but I'm not sure in how often they happen compared to the other more mainstream kind of rebellions.Well, there's a reason there are so many rebellions against the Imperium and it's not because chaos is magic that automatically turns people onto heretics
True while chaos lead rebellions do happen (and yes chaos corruption does work kind of like evil magic that turns people into heretics), often they seem to be caused by some Governor or other leader who gets greedy and decides to split away to get more power. Then they either get killed by Imperials, get killed by xenos or turn to chaos by corruption and sometimes by desperation when fighting one of the previous two. Tyrannids and Tau infiltrations also exist, but I'm not sure in how often they happen compared to the other more mainstream kind of rebellions.
Yeah, I want to be the bad guy.Not really, the vast majority of rebellions happen because the Imperium is the cruellest regime imaginable and abuses its own population into rebellion, no traitorous leader requires
sure that sounds coolI'll consider the new party next vote if anyone else expresses interest.
Eh no thats clearly false, while some of them happen because of that for sure most dont. Take a look at the Lexicanum list of anti-imperial rebellions.Not really, the vast majority of rebellions happen because the Imperium is the cruellest regime imaginable and abuses its own population into rebellion, no traitorous leader requires
Eh no thats clearly false, while some of them happen because of that for sure most dont. Take a look at the Lexicanum list of anti-imperial rebellions.
That is actually one of the biggest reasons why most rebellions are Chaos related since a simple peasants revolt can't hope to fight the Imperium they become desperate for any help which is when Chaos makes its play if they weren't there from the start.Most of the rebellions caused by tyranny are going to be small and short lived enough they don't make any list except the "silent casualty of imperial enforcement" one. Meanwhile, chaos rebellions are going to be disproportionately represented in lists of rebellions with narrative impact because they have literal supernatural backing.
Unfortunately the Imperium is a necessary evil which is brought up multiple times in lore and out of universe. Even Eldrad admitted that the Imperium is the greatest bulwark against the various threats in the galaxy. Besides even if we do manage to declare independence what happens then? A single independent world cannot survive on its own in 40k and the only examples are worlds forgotten about until something finds them. What is gonna stop Imperial and Mechanicus reprisal? Or things like the Orks, the Dark Eldar, Tyranids, Chaos, or worse things in the Ghoul Stars?
That is actually one of the biggest reasons why most rebellions are Chaos related since a simple peasants revolt can't hope to fight the Imperium they become desperate for any help which is when Chaos makes its play if they weren't there from the start.
I do.
Yes, it's part of the charm of the setting.The imperium is the main source of misery feeding chaos in the warp and chaos recruits in real space so it causes just as many problems as it solves on its best day. It's also keeping all of humanity's potential on a leash by forbidding all innovation or more efficient organizing of resources.