Voting is open
[Continuation] Schwarz-Rot-Gold: An Interwar Germany Quest
Created
Status
Ongoing
Watchers
218
Recent readers
0

The red flag once flew over Hamburg. The eagle once flew over Koenigsberg. The Schwarz-Rot-Gold still flies over Berlin, battered beautiful Berlin.

It is 1920. The fate of Germany is still unclear. The guns have fallen silent, but they remain close at hand.
A sequel to Schwarz-Rot-Gold.
Introduction

mouli

Terrible QM
Location
United States
Schwarz-Rot-Gold: An Interwar Germany Quest

Let us lift Germany, so to speak, into the saddle. Surely when that is achieved, it will succeed at riding as well
-Otto von Bismarck to the Parliament of Confederation, 1867
This is a continuation of the thread here - it is not needed to read that thread to participate here.

The Unter der Linden is cold in March, in the year of the Lord 1920. The leaves fall like tears from the weeping trees, on the places where the protesters fell. The wind almost seems to howl a lament, a song of wailing cadence akin to saga-song sung of vengeance and grief. The streets near the Unter der Linden in the city of Berlin are empty, bare of the people that normally would throng it to meet under the linden trees. Here in March there are no couples walking hand-in-hand to welcome in the spring and celebrate their closeness, there are no aged or elderly walking slowly with cane in hand as if to simply take in the air before they no longer can. Here in March, there are patrols of gray-uniformed infantry with rifles in hand and twitchy trigger fingers, walking as always in pairs.

For here in Berlin in March of 1920, it was not advised to walk alone.

It began two weeks ago, as anyone in the city would have told you. It was two weeks ago that General Luttwitz and Herr Kapp decided that the government was in the wrong and the nation had been wronged, that the fragile experiment of Weimar's liberal democracy was an easily corrected mistake.

They acted ahead of the police, the same black-uniformed police that warned them off and told them to run. All of them, the National Association as they called themselves, acted fast but not quite fast enough. When General Luttwitz led his Freikorps, his former soldiers, against the Reichstag – there was nobody there. When Wilhelm Kapp, civil servant and nationalist, led his contingent to the high offices of state – they found the doors barred and the offices under guard.

Naturally, they fired. They were fired upon.

There was something of a fracas.

There was more of a disturbance when General Ludendorff secured the Berlin telephone exchange. There was a disturbance across all of Germany when the General spoke of what was to come. A return to the structures of the Second Reich, absent the monarch. A strong, federal state under the guiding hand of the military. A clean, new Germany, shorn of the same politicking that had lost it the war.

First Army Corps in East Prussia raised their banners in homage, and with them half the army.

The banners in the Ruhr were red. In the wake of the same uprising that had almost decapitated the Communist Party, the Party went underground to bide its time. To agitate. To wait for a mistake.

Everyone in the leadership agreed that a coup d'etat was just such a mistake. A mistake that opened the doors to potential revolution.

As if not wanting to miss the chance, like someone desperate not to miss their train, the Communist Party seized northwestern Germany. The red flag flew over the Ruhr while a steady simmering of discontent began underneath it.

A letter went to Moscow. The bearded, neat little man in the Kremlin signed an order. Soviet ships began to dock at Lubeck.

By this time the shooting had already begun.

It took five more months for the guns to fall silent, for peace to return to Germany once more. The nation has mortgaged everything it has to win the war, to secure the future of the Weimar Republic, and that future looks shakier by the day. In the east, the Soviet Union has secured its southern regions and has armies headed for Warsaw. In the west, Germany faces a hostile France, a hostile Belgium and an occupation of the Rhineland by foreign forces that are waiting for an excuse to move.

Germany, moreover, is devastated. The eastern reaches have seen atrocities and worse, the Kapp-Luttwitz-Ludendorff putschists seizing Germany from the Oder-Neisse Line eastwards and holding the Polish border with extreme prejudice. The western parts of Germany have starved, the SPD Government making sure to purchase possible food supplies and deny them to the KPD.

The guns have fallen silent, by the beginning of August 1920. An uneasy peace born of exhaustion reigns over Germany.

The guns have fallen silent, and the long uneasy unstable peace has just begun.

This is a sequel to the thread on Spacebattles, Schwarz-Rot-Gold

Choose play options below:

Each turn will have ground-level perspectives as well as an overview, and some of those will recur. Choose three ground-level perspectives, three lives to follow through the chaos of Weimar Germany, that I will do my best to shoehorn into every turn:

[]The Soldier:
Fritz Muller has known little but war for most of his adult life. He was drafted at seventeen, and went to the front in 1914. Muller survived the war, survived the civil war that followed, and has put down his rifle in August 1920 to face a brave new world that he doesn't know how to navigate. His section is dead or crippled, his army has dissolved once more and the Kaiser that he took an oath to serve in 1914 is in Germany no longer. Fritz Muller has been naught but a soldier at war, and now he is one no longer.

[]The Merchant of Death: Gustav Krupp made a deal with the Devil in 1920, a deal to sell arms in conjunction with Sir Basil Zaharoff and Vickers Corporation. Sir Basil has sold arms the world over to anyone who can pay, and with Krupp's former war-plants now disassembled and being 'scrapped' in France by Zaharoff, German-pattern arms will be seen in every war from China to the Balkans. A brave new world, full of rich markets, now beckons.

[]The Communist: Ernst Thalmann is a former soldier, a decorated one, who did a bunk from the Army in 1918 for the sake of the November Revolution and the Uprising that followed it. Thalmann's side of the war has lost...this time. The next time will be different, and that is why Ernst Thalmann has remained in Germany – to organize the workers and make sure that they are in a position to take what is theirs by right. Weimar is unstable, and presents opportunities.

[]The Doctor: Professor Emil Fischer is a practicing surgeon and teacher at the Katharinenhospital in Stuttgart, and has seen the war close-up. Most of the severely wounded were dispatched to his wards for reconstruction, and before that he was a surgeon on the Western Front. Emil Fischer has seen death and conducted triage for five bloody years, and now comes peace. Dr. Fischer has doubts as to the durability of that.

[]The Detective: Detective Arthur Biermann is part of the Berlin Special Branch, trained by a Belgian detective and now coming to terms with his new duties – the Special Branch was founded to deal with terrorism, insurrection and sensitive tasks. With the new peace in the republic, that task will hopefully be of less importance. Biermann wouldn't bet on it.

I will also allow one major timeline change:

[]Eagle Unbowed:
Poland has won on the Vistula, at a terrible cost in men and munitions. The eagle is as yet unbowed and unbroken, and the Soviets have been thrown back out of Poland – a peace of mutual exhaustion now reigns in eastern Europe, as the Soviet armies head east to deliver a coup de grace to the White Armies on Russian soil.

[]The Heir is Dead: Yakov Sverdlov was Lenin's protege, and he survived his influenza infection in 1919 to direct the decossackization of Ukraine in 1919-1920. Upon his death, the succession in the Soviet Union has been thrown once more into doubt, as the moderate internationalist Sverdlov has left a vacancy that Lenin has hesitated to fill.
 
Mechanics
Mechanics

Turns in this thread are intended to be six months' game time and no more than that. You are playing as the governing party, which at this time is the SPD, and is in coalition with two other parties – you will need to thus manage not only the Reichstag, public opinion and the stance of various German institutions, but also the stability of your own coalition. To do this, I will rely on a mix of numbers and narrative indicators:

Numbers: Since almost all empire builder threads have numbers that tend to go up, I will follow that tradition with no guarantee that they will go up. They are liable to go down rather often. The numerical indicators that you will manage are:

Budget: This is a notional indicator for how much you can spend. It is tied to not only the budgeted spending of the nation, but how much is possible to borrow and how much debt the nation already holds – I will background most of the finance, since I don't want to dump bond issuing, specie management etc onto the thread. Budget not spent rolls over to the next turn.

Coalition Stability: This is an indicator out of 100 that describes how stable your coalition is, and how satisfied your coalition partners are. If you have a simple majority, it describes how satisfied the parties that vote with you are. Below 10 and your government will collapse the following turn. The higher it is, the more options relevant to your own party's agenda will appear in turn. Coalition stability can be spent to pass legislation that the other parties oppose.

Stability: This is an indicator out of 100, that represents the stability of the nation: How likely is it to see paramilitary violence, assassinations, and so on. Circumstances of the world each turn can also sap stability, e.g. an economic depression. It is highly advised to keep this high. You will begin in Turn 1 with Stability at 15/100. Below 20 Stability, paramilitary violence is frequent and ethnic tensions are bleeding over into violence.

The Coalition: Coalition Stability is, naturally, affected by the coalition. Each party in your coalition has their own agenda, their own priorities with respect to legislation and their own agenda for governing – passive decay of coalition stability rises with more parties and more ideological diversity in governance. A ramshackle grand coalition will soon collapse into infighting. Addressing the governing priorities of other parties as well as yours can lead to ticking positive coalition stability instead of passive decay, though, so remember to ensure your partners are satisfied. The larger the coalition partner, the more you need to do for them. I will have an informational for the coalition.

Economic Management: The Weimar Republic saw the German economy tank in the 1920s, saw hyperinflation and hunger, and the reparations of World War I were a frequent feature of political discussion. As such, we will track economic indicators with notional values that are non-numerical, none of which are directly industrial save for food – you are not running a command economy here:

Currency: You have a gold-backed currency and a shortage of specie. Currency Stability ranges from Critical→Unstable→Shaky→Solid and it is advised to keep it at Solid. From Unstable onwards there are events that will further sap stability. The Currency indicator will have a short blurb describing issues to resolve.

Debt: In conjunction with Currency, Debt is a major issue. Debt will be tracked narratively and if it rises too far too fast, it will have massive knock on effects on the economy. World events can also move debt from safe to critical, for instance if an economic depression means nobody buys your bonds anymore.

Commodities: This is basic feedstock and is tracked for information's sake primarily. The one commodity you have direct distribution networks for is Food, and that is the one currently under focus.

Reparations: This is measured numerically in terms of Budget per turn. While the Allies decided on a payment schedule only in 1921, the Germans paid in gold, labor and commodities well before that, and you will be meeting provisional reparations targets until the payment plan is finalized. The schedule can be better or worse than historical.

Opinions: The various other players in the grand game of German rebuilding have their own ideas as to how it should proceed. As such, I will describe narratively the opinions of the other institutions:
The Army: Frankly, it is the army and not the navy or air force that acts as a major player in government. As a state-within-a-state, the German Army is bent on preservation of its powers and thus will naturally come into conflict with the state. I will show a warning if the army is critically restless – and remember, the army is not or cannot be allowed to become a monolith. You have to exploit its divisions and make use of them to survive.

The Judiciary: The judiciary is a relic of the Kaiserreich and judges serve for life. The judiciary is in the main anti republican and pro-monarchist, except for the south where things are a bit more nuanced.

The civil service: The bureaucracy without whom you cannot govern. The bureaucracy can in some cases even stall a coup by going on strike rather than continuing to govern – the gray suits of German ministries are not half as glamorous as the army or as outspoken as the judges, but they are in many senses more important. Keep them satisfied, and your legislation might actually be properly enacted.

In addition to this, I will in the status sheet show areas of critical instability and the turn options will address thing such as paramilitary violence. Most of these indicators are narrative and I am attempting to minimize numbers, and the turns will be complex and long by necessity. Daily updates are possibly a bit of a stretch.
You have five Ministerial categories and three dice in each. Each is a d100.
 
Last edited:
[X]The Soldier: Fritz Muller has known little but war for most of his adult life. He was drafted at seventeen, and went to the front in 1914. Muller survived the war, survived the civil war that followed, and has put down his rifle in August 1920 to face a brave new world that he doesn't know how to navigate. His section is dead or crippled, his army has dissolved once more and the Kaiser that he took an oath to serve in 1914 is in Germany no longer. Fritz Muller has been naught but a soldier at war, and now he is one no longer.

[X]The Doctor: Professor Emil Fischer is a practicing surgeon and teacher at the Katharinenhospital in Stuttgart, and has seen the war close-up. Most of the severely wounded were dispatched to his wards for reconstruction, and before that he was a surgeon on the Western Front. Emil Fischer has seen death and conducted triage for five bloody years, and now comes peace. Dr. Fischer has doubts as to the durability of that.

[X]The Detective: Detective Arthur Biermann is part of the Berlin Special Branch, trained by a Belgian detective and now coming to terms with his new duties – the Special Branch was founded to deal with terrorism, insurrection and sensitive tasks. With the new peace in the republic, that task will hopefully be of less importance. Biermann wouldn't bet on it.
[X]Eagle Unbowed: Poland has won on the Vistula, at a terrible cost in men and munitions. The eagle is as yet unbowed and unbroken, and the Soviets have been thrown back out of Poland – a peace of mutual exhaustion now reigns in eastern Europe, as the Soviet armies head east to deliver a coup de grace to the White Armies on Russian soil.
 
[X]The Detective
[X]The Merchant of Death
[X]The Soldier
[X]The Heir is Dead


Long live Chancellor, long live the Repiblic!
 
[X]The Merchant of Death
[X]The Detective
[X]Eagle Unbowed


We probably benefit more from a Poland that's still in existence rather than a Soviet Poland.
 
[X]The Soldier: Fritz Muller has known little but war for most of his adult life. He was drafted at seventeen, and went to the front in 1914. Muller survived the war, survived the civil war that followed, and has put down his rifle in August 1920 to face a brave new world that he doesn't know how to navigate. His section is dead or crippled, his army has dissolved once more and the Kaiser that he took an oath to serve in 1914 is in Germany no longer. Fritz Muller has been naught but a soldier at war, and now he is one no longer.

[X]The Doctor: Professor Emil Fischer is a practicing surgeon and teacher at the Katharinenhospital in Stuttgart, and has seen the war close-up. Most of the severely wounded were dispatched to his wards for reconstruction, and before that he was a surgeon on the Western Front. Emil Fischer has seen death and conducted triage for five bloody years, and now comes peace. Dr. Fischer has doubts as to the durability of that.

[X]The Detective: Detective Arthur Biermann is part of the Berlin Special Branch, trained by a Belgian detective and now coming to terms with his new duties – the Special Branch was founded to deal with terrorism, insurrection and sensitive tasks. With the new peace in the republic, that task will hopefully be of less importance. Biermann wouldn't bet on it.

[X]The Heir is Dead: Yakov Sverdlov was Lenin's protege, and he survived his influenza infection in 1919 to direct the decossackization of Ukraine in 1919-1920. Upon his death, the succession in the Soviet Union has been thrown once more into doubt, as the moderate internationalist Sverdlov has left a vacancy that Lenin has hesitated to fill.
 
[X]The Soldier: Fritz Muller has known little but war for most of his adult life. He was drafted at seventeen, and went to the front in 1914. Muller survived the war, survived the civil war that followed, and has put down his rifle in August 1920 to face a brave new world that he doesn't know how to navigate. His section is dead or crippled, his army has dissolved once more and the Kaiser that he took an oath to serve in 1914 is in Germany no longer. Fritz Muller has been naught but a soldier at war, and now he is one no longer.

[X]The Doctor: Professor Emil Fischer is a practicing surgeon and teacher at the Katharinenhospital in Stuttgart, and has seen the war close-up. Most of the severely wounded were dispatched to his wards for reconstruction, and before that he was a surgeon on the Western Front. Emil Fischer has seen death and conducted triage for five bloody years, and now comes peace. Dr. Fischer has doubts as to the durability of that.

[X]The Detective: Detective Arthur Biermann is part of the Berlin Special Branch, trained by a Belgian detective and now coming to terms with his new duties – the Special Branch was founded to deal with terrorism, insurrection and sensitive tasks. With the new peace in the republic, that task will hopefully be of less importance. Biermann wouldn't bet on it.

[X]Eagle Unbowed: Poland has won on the Vistula, at a terrible cost in men and munitions. The eagle is as yet unbowed and unbroken, and the Soviets have been thrown back out of Poland – a peace of mutual exhaustion now reigns in eastern Europe, as the Soviet armies head east to deliver a coup de grace to the White Armies on Russian soil.
 
[X]The Soldier: Fritz Muller has known little but war for most of his adult life. He was drafted at seventeen, and went to the front in 1914. Muller survived the war, survived the civil war that followed, and has put down his rifle in August 1920 to face a brave new world that he doesn't know how to navigate. His section is dead or crippled, his army has dissolved once more and the Kaiser that he took an oath to serve in 1914 is in Germany no longer. Fritz Muller has been naught but a soldier at war, and now he is one no longer.

[X]The Doctor: Professor Emil Fischer is a practicing surgeon and teacher at the Katharinenhospital in Stuttgart, and has seen the war close-up. Most of the severely wounded were dispatched to his wards for reconstruction, and before that he was a surgeon on the Western Front. Emil Fischer has seen death and conducted triage for five bloody years, and now comes peace. Dr. Fischer has doubts as to the durability of that.

[X]The Detective: Detective Arthur Biermann is part of the Berlin Special Branch, trained by a Belgian detective and now coming to terms with his new duties – the Special Branch was founded to deal with terrorism, insurrection and sensitive tasks. With the new peace in the republic, that task will hopefully be of less importance. Biermann wouldn't bet on it.

[X]Eagle Unbowed: Poland has won on the Vistula, at a terrible cost in men and munitions. The eagle is as yet unbowed and unbroken, and the Soviets have been thrown back out of Poland – a peace of mutual exhaustion now reigns in eastern Europe, as the Soviet armies head east to deliver a coup de grace to the White Armies on Russian soil.

I've been binging Babaloyn Berlin for the past twelve hours... Let's go!
 
We probably benefit more from a Poland that's still in existence rather than a Soviet Poland.
In normal circumstances, I'd agree with you, but with only the German Republic between the Soviets and the French, it would probably be much easier to renegotiate rearmament and reparations. It'd also strenghten our relations with Central Europe, since we'd be the major bulwark against the Union's expansionism along with Romania and the Czechs.

It'd also bring an interesting dynamic into a quest: a clear external enemy to guard against. Especially since the Triad is now toothless and exiled in Sweden and the KPD is vanishing into the woodworks.
 
Last edited:
[X]The Soldier
[X]The Merchant of Death
[X]The Detective
[X]The Heir is Dead
Fritz Muller felt human, and I'd like to see more of him.
In normal circumstances, I'd agree with you, but with only the German Republic between the Soviets and the French, it would probably be much easier to renegotiate rearmament and reparations. It'd also strenghten our relations with Central Europe, since we'd be the major bulwark against the Union's expansionism along with Romania.

It'd also bring an interesting dynamic into a quest: a clear external enemy to guard against. Especially since the Triad is now toothless and exiled in Sweden and the KPD is vanishing into the woodworks.
Well, yeah., but there is also the fact that the Soviets can just swoop in, immediately? And I'm not looking forward to German War 2, seeing as we just kicked out the Spartacists.
 
Last edited:
[X]The Soldier
[X]The Merchant of Death
[X]The Detective
[X] The Heir is Dead

Edit. The Center Holds
 
Last edited:
Well, yeah., but there is also the fact that the Soviets can just swoop in, immediately? And I'm not looking forward to German War 2, seeing as we just kicked out the Spartacists.
I don't think that would happen, we have a decent army and the Soviets are hundreds or thousands of kilometers from Moscow, after a gruelling campaign against the Polish. They need to regroup and secure their gains. If we were still fighting a war, you'd be totally right, but we can put most of our army in the East. We'd also immediately be supported by pretty much everyone who would crap their pants at a Red Germany under Soviet thrall. A Socialist Poland is bad for Central Europe and the Balkans, us being communists would be a disaster for the Western Capitalist nations.
 
Last edited:
[X] The Soldier: Fritz Muller has known little but war for most of his adult life. He was drafted at seventeen, and went to the front in 1914. Muller survived the war, survived the civil war that followed, and has put down his rifle in August 1920 to face a brave new world that he doesn't know how to navigate. His section is dead or crippled, his army has dissolved once more and the Kaiser that he took an oath to serve in 1914 is in Germany no longer. Fritz Muller has been naught but a soldier at war, and now he is one no longer.
[X] The Detective: Detective Arthur Biermann is part of the Berlin Special Branch, trained by a Belgian detective and now coming to terms with his new duties – the Special Branch was founded to deal with terrorism, insurrection and sensitive tasks. With the new peace in the republic, that task will hopefully be of less importance. Biermann wouldn't bet on it.

I want to see these two and wouldn't mind any of the others.

[X] The Heir is Dead: Yakov Sverdlov was Lenin's protege, and he survived his influenza infection in 1919 to direct the decossackization of Ukraine in 1919-1920. Upon his death, the succession in the Soviet Union has been thrown once more into doubt, as the moderate internationalist Sverdlov has left a vacancy that Lenin has hesitated to fill.

I like the possibility of being the West's bulwark against the Communism as it seems like an interesting position to play from.
 
I don't think that would happen, we have a decent army and the Soviets are hundreds or thousands of kilometers from Moscow, after a gruelling campaign against the Polish. They need to regroup and secure their gains. If we were still fighting a war, you'd be totally right, but we can put most of our army in the East.
Yes, but a SFSR is not the best neighbor to have when our goals ought to be demobilization, restoration of normal peace, and all that fun stuff.

I will admit that it would be fun, though.
 
Yes, but a SFSR is not the best neighbor to have when our goals ought to be demobilization, restoration of normal peace, and all that fun stuff.
Versailles is going to break our backs, especially since in the original thread we agreed to pay larger reparations in exchange for a deferment. With a large part of our industry destroyed, we need to renegotiate the terms, and a commie Poland is perfect excuse for that. We can't have peace with a collapsing economy, and our army is still small enough that demobilization would be pointless.
 
Versailles is going to break our backs, especially since in the original thread we agreed to pay larger reparations in exchange for a deferment. With a large part of our industry destroyed, we need to renegotiate the terms, and a commie Poland is perfect excuse for that.
That can go another way, the French way. Where we lose the entirety of our little bit of remaining industry and have Entente troops everywhere while Foch cackles like a madman.

I wouldn't trust the Entente to be fair in renegotiation.
 
[X]The Soldier: Fritz Muller has known little but war for most of his adult life. He was drafted at seventeen, and went to the front in 1914. Muller survived the war, survived the civil war that followed, and has put down his rifle in August 1920 to face a brave new world that he doesn't know how to navigate. His section is dead or crippled, his army has dissolved once more and the Kaiser that he took an oath to serve in 1914 is in Germany no longer. Fritz Muller has been naught but a soldier at war, and now he is one no longer.

[X]The Doctor: Professor Emil Fischer is a practicing surgeon and teacher at the Katharinenhospital in Stuttgart, and has seen the war close-up. Most of the severely wounded were dispatched to his wards for reconstruction, and before that he was a surgeon on the Western Front. Emil Fischer has seen death and conducted triage for five bloody years, and now comes peace. Dr. Fischer has doubts as to the durability of that.

[X]The Detective: Detective Arthur Biermann is part of the Berlin Special Branch, trained by a Belgian detective and now coming to terms with his new duties – the Special Branch was founded to deal with terrorism, insurrection and sensitive tasks. With the new peace in the republic, that task will hopefully be of less importance. Biermann wouldn't bet on it.

[X]The Heir is Dead: Yakov Sverdlov was Lenin's protege, and he survived his influenza infection in 1919 to direct the decossackization of Ukraine in 1919-1920. Upon his death, the succession in the Soviet Union has been thrown once more into doubt, as the moderate internationalist Sverdlov has left a vacancy that Lenin has hesitated to fill.

Ah, I was an spectator in the last thread, I hope I can contribute to this story for now on!
 
Voting is open
Back
Top