Congregation of Despair (Mafia - Second Attempt)

Lot of people have just been either busy or not here, it's strange. @QTesseract Heads up, you're about to be lynched. Got about six hours left to sway it.
 
@Dovah I want to kind of go in-depth on your point vis a vis Day 1s, because I think there's some interesting things to discuss there, but I'm not really in a head space to do it right now. If I don't do it by morning, feel free to tag me.
Not sure if this counts as morning for you, @Broken Base.

In other news, @QTesseract, you have a 5-person wagon on you in a 14 person game. On the one hand, nobody here is above bussing. On the other hand, that's over a third of the game size, which is concerning.

Since it's just an inactivity lynch I'm not adding my vote--I see you lurking and presumably you'll post, and I don't want L-2 for inactivity even 2.5 hours before Day's End.

After rereading the day, I've really got nothing. Comi is a total null read, but they said they'd be busy anyway. Broken Base ... immediately posted about it being a cult game, and a whole one person (Nictis) has really brought up possibilities beyond that. It would bug me more, but the flavor so perfectly fits a cult game that it feels wrong somehow for it to not be. Personally I suspect a cult (because of course) and a third party myself, but I'm not sure whether that's just my own tendency to want multiple opposing scum leaking through. TMR's null, QTess is null, all new players are null. Absum is null, DimensionalGuy is null ... at this point I'm just going to go make a reads list. I need to have one anyway, since it's something I fell out of the habit of making lately.
 
1. ComiTurtle Null.
2. Nictis Null-Town, not that that ever does anyone any good.
3. QTesseract Null.
4. Happerry Null
5. TheMaskedReader Null
6. Nanimani Null-town, but I don't know how to read Nani.
7. Dovah Me.
8. Broken Base Null town.
9. Absum Null.
10. Swarmingu Null with a side of "be more active Day 2 when we have things to discuss."
11. DimensionalGuy Null
12. Yun Null
13. Oshha Null
14. 1KBestK Null

Oh, yeah, that did a lot of good.
 
Thanks for the heads up @Nictis . Kind of unfortunate, in that I just plain have no real time to play this game today due to irl; unfortunately, that also means I can't readily regather this lynch via my reads, since I have had way less time to view the thread than normal. I think my only real reads on this point are a slight suspicion on Nictis, which I'm not really sure how to treat. On one hand, he hasn't really done anything out of the norm for him, on the other hand, he's normally scum. I'd really rather not roleclaim day 1 even to get off the lynch if I can possibly avoid it, and town's color is pretty much useless.

I'll see what I can fit in now before day ends.
 
I have no scum reads and I think the current wagon is going to be totally useless for us as far as information. No one's defending QTess, no one's doing anything, but I'm unsure where to go with that.
 
Oops I kinda pissed away the morning and was busy in the afternoon.

Anyway I don't really object to the inactivity lynch, I'd expected QT to respond overnight.

I kinda want to support a secondary lynch just to build a log but I'm not sure which. So I'll at least make a list of suspicious stuff in case I get emptied of red stuff tonight:
- Something felt off to me about TMR's reads list and I feel like BB has been defending them (though that could just be coincidence)
- Comiturtle's disappearance after memeing and saying that the memes were intentionally suspicious 2 days ago
- Ossha and 1K, but I think that would've been rerolled if so. Maybe not if there's a third?
- Nictis. I'm especially worried that scum is similar to my first game.
- The thing with Happerry
- Yun also is a bit suspicious but similar to Nictis it seems to be a posting style thing. In their case though I've blundered once so right now I'm less willing to focus on them.

Most other people read pretty null, but I'll admit I only did a skim before posting this. I could probably find something suspicious for them all if I took a bit more time though. It's called healthy paranoia :V
 
And a second post to say that I'm feeling kinda weirdly out of focus right now so I'm not too fond of that list, but I'd rather post it for the reason given.
 
[X] Null
[x] Lynch TheMaskedReader

Honestly. I would prefer a nanimani lynch over them, just looking through the thread. Their arguments appear to have more substance than they actually do, which is never a good sign; it's the opposite of the balance town wants to strike, or at least off orthagonal to it. However, I also don't like TMR's posting overly. Particularly their reads list is somewhat useless; not abnormal for day one reads, no, but still not enough to make me want to save them.

As much as I hate doing this, I'm going to claim: I am a tracker. It's not a great power role, honestly, so it's not too big adeal to have to claim, I suppose, but It's somewhat unfortunate. I'm a quiet tracker, as seems to be the usual for SV, and I am a member of the king's Court.
 
[X] Lynch TheMaskedReader

My gut feeling plus something from my own role makes me believe QT enough that I don't want them to get to lynched. I got enough against TMR, but I don't want QT getting the lynch anymore.
 
That said, QT could have posted their claim more than just a few minutes before the day ends.
 
That said, QT could have posted their claim more than just a few minutes before the day ends.
So we've got ~5 minutes to decide this.
I just want to point out that waiting to the last minute to claim is a scum tactic, and QTess has previously fakeclaimed some insanely difficult role to fake and successfully won off of it.

Problem is, I'm not voting right now, and I shouls be, which means I actually need to decide between the two of them.
 
At least this gives some info to look at depending on flip over it just ending on QTess.
 
Back
Top