- Location
- Singapore
- Pronouns
- He/Him
Makes sense. A land route to Iceland and the UK is nothing to be sneezed at. A Tibet that has ancient magic will make for very interesting times with East/South Asian Politics.
I would assume Burroughs' tenancy to have all his female characters wear next to no clothes has been somewhat toned down here. I mean on Venus it kinda would make sense, but why the hell would someone wear only a bikini on goddamn Mars?
I wonder what a Gothic Horror world would look like.That makes sense, Gothic is pretty distinct from Pulp Adventure.
What bikini? The people of barsoom wore no clothing at all, just jewelry and weapon harnesses. Male and female alike. Barsoom was pretty equal opportunity in terms of eye candy as a setting.Sadly no completely Hollow Earth with a central sun in the middle
I would assume Burroughs' tenancy to have all his female characters wear next to no clothes has been somewhat toned down here. I mean on Venus it kinda would make sense, but why the hell would someone wear only a bikini on goddamn Mars?
I wonder what a Gothic Horror world would look like.
Aw, no Ranavalona the Cruel turning herself from one of the twelve wives of the old king's pro-European son into warrior-queen and sorceror-empress of all Madagascar and leading the Merina into gloriously pulpy victory over the Franco-Libertalian adventurers and corsairs and keeping then as a pet trading post to beat firearms out of?
I love how you turned the Cthulhu cultists into a more or less functional and sane religion. Even the apocalyptic stuff some believe in isn't really different then, say, the Book of Revelations
I like what you did with the Mi-Go. I mean, the fact that the Mi-Go respect humans to such a degree that they actively recruit our scientists to join their numbers would tend to suggest a strong possibility for peaceful co-existence.
The Yithians are already essentially body-jacking *space tourists*, you can play that up in a more positive way, making them overly inquisitive, and/or obsessed with trying out all sorts of different earthly foods, drinks, and other experiences.My personal take on the Mythos is that it isn't so bleak as many make it out to be. Whether due to unreliable narrators or my own reading between the lines, many of the challenges presented by the Mythos are quite surmountable.
The existence of the Mi-Go and Elder Race are proof that intelligent species can survive the cosmic fuckery and establish interstellar civilizations, and both are familiar enough that establishing regular contact with them is possible.
Ironically Cthulhu and the Mi-Go are both the result of me getting flexible due to the original stories those entities appear in being uh, frankly on the lower end of quality for Lovecraft.
Cthulhu, for all that he is hyped up by some readers as an insurmountable god, is at the end of the day a big psychic squid boi who had to go halvsies on Earth because the Elder Race fought him to a standstill - while him rising up could be devastating, it's actually possible that he could be put down with enough firepower.
As to the Cult, the Call of Cthulhu is not one of the better works (ironic considering Cthulhu's status as Mythos poster boy) and a big part of that is the Cult; racism aside, the idea that Cthulhu cares a whit for some hairless apes that picked up on his psychic emanations, or indeed that they could in anyway effect his plans or the time of his awakening, don't really square in my mind with the general themes of the Mythos. Indeed, maybe "being eaten last" is the best they could hope for.
Finally as to the Mi-Go, the whole plot is kind of silly so it's hard to tell what's really going on, but Akeley('s brain-in-a-jar) seems pretty jazzed about Yuggoth. As to what the Mi-Go want, if my interpretation is correct then Yuggoth's status as a mere isolated colony with some mining outposts makes the ones we've been dealing with the equivalent of backwoods space hicks.
Perhaps they want human scientists to make up for the dearth of their own technical or administrative class; maybe they value the input of a species with a genuinely alien outlook; maybe it's a weird hobby.
In any case, it takes a very particular type to have their brain removed and put in a jar, (although one gets the idea that Lovecraft, with his general horror for squishy biology, may have secretly favored the idea), so only a few have gone out and aside from a few visits home it's not clear what, if anything, they are learning that could help us.
Still - if we can survive Cthulhu, and not start a world war with the Deep Ones, and nobody opens a portal to Yog-Sothoth, and we don't ruin our own civilization, then we can probably establish proper relations with an Elder Race colony or the Mi-Go or maybe even the Yithians, and from there it's just trying to keep our eggs in many baskets.
Should be a snap
I mean, a lot of this supposed horror just comes from Lovecraft's turboxenophobia and existential dread at not being the center of the universe.
The horrors of the mythos would be a lot less inherently terrifying to someone who is familiar with today's view of Earth being of no particular significance, as well as general post-modernism.
They existed. They were a thing. The fetishization is problematic, but... they existed. they were a thing.Here's a question: are the Barbary Pirates still a thing? Given the setting and the demands of Pulp (the inventors of the "Bikini Slave Girl" trope), I could see them still operating out of North Africa and providing a market to all the Unscrupulous players in the Empire. Mind you due to the uncomfortable orientalist and fetishist flavor, I could totally see you just cutting it and would not mind at all. Although I would be more than Abit interested to see how Pulp Corsairs work
Up to a point. The psychic demigods that casually eat civilizations and planets are pretty freakin' horrifying- but most of the other Mythos stuff just wouldn't seem that weird if it weren't being explicitly played up as horrifying.I mean, a lot of this supposed horror just comes from Lovecraft's turboxenophobia and existential dread at not being the center of the universe.
The horrors of the mythos would be a lot less inherently terrifying to someone who is familiar with today's view of Earth being of no particular significance, as well as general post-modernism.
John Carter is still attempting to overthrow their tyranny in a one-man facepunching campaign, isn't he... and Dejah Thoris still keeps getting kidnapped over and over...Yeah it'll be a while till we get to Mars, so I'll mention that the "Old Martians" rule tyrannically over the "Red" and "Green" Martians.
Hm. Sounds like the Raj is going full Peshawar Lancers (but on a higher technological base), and the Chinese Science Dictatorship actually sounds like the logical endpoint of something I came up with once. Clearly the autocrat of northern China is modeled after "Fu Manchu, but take out the racist characterization and just make him a very badass mad scientist who happens to be Chinese."
I like it.
...
Also I have some fairly specific and detailed thoughts about John Carter of Mars and the logic that motivates his background, but that might actually be something to bat back and forth with @ScottishMongol . I've read the first half of Burroughs' Barsoom novels myself and, again, I have some thoughts.
When the Red Church is more orthodox than you, you are most certainly doing something very very wrong.... Would i be right to say that every other Christian denomination in the world is yelling Heresy at the top of their lungs.The dominant branch of the Anglican Church in India now considers Jesus an incarnation of Vishnu
When the Red Church is more orthodox than you, you are most certainly doing something very very wrong.... Would i be right to say that every other Christian denomination in the world is yelling Heresy at the top of their lungs.
Pah! Who needs syncretcism when you can stick to the True Holy Faith and have SUPER SCIENCE!!!!! Jesuits Rock!noooo you can't alter your fundamental dogma to assimilate with local customs that's heresy!!!!!!
vs
haha syncretism machine goes brrrrrr
That is fair for the rules of this setting I guess... But by the same token Id argue that a world with Magic would need someone to arbitrate Orthodoxy and truth even more than in our world, Mainly because those who use their magic for dark purposes could disguise themselves in religon. For instance, Say Im a demon? What if I feel like Dammning someone by disguising myself as a Angel, give them powers, and tell people to go burn someone alive? Of course the pressing thing I think would be the issue would be getting a truely international Repesentation in the Church Higher ups, So we don't just have one culture saying what is and what not heretical for the Universal Faith. All in all, I am very curious to see how its actually ebing debated in the Church ITTL..One of the (many, many) inspirations for TTL is the way magic has been viewed historically, as inseparable from religion.
This is an "Agimat" (Talisman) Vest worn by a Filipino Revolutionary during the Philippine Revolution ca. late 1890s-early 1900s. It contains Folk-Catholic prayers in a Filipino peasant's butchered Latin, and instructional diagrams on when or where the shirt would work.
This, if you'll permit me, is magic, and a magic not quite associated with Christian orthodoxy, but there are abundant examples of practitioners of folk magic the world over and throughout history who sincerely believed they were casting spells for Christian purposes; there's numerous examples of individuals in the Early Modern Period put on trial for witchcraft whose defense was "no, your honor, I'm a good Christian witch who serves God" (or, in one case "yes I'm a werewolf, but I'm a Hound of God who transforms into a werewolf to battle demons", which uh, fucking metal).
But I digress. You can clearly see how I drew the line from the Filipino talisman vest to a magic-augmented revolt backed by the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom's superpowered martial artists, but really just consider, in a world where magic is real and the agents of multiple world religions seem to exist (and that's a staple of the genre - Indy may have found the Ark of the Covenant, but he also saw Kali eat a dude's heart), then who's to say what orthodoxy even is?