To Struggle and Strive: The Combined Syndicates of America in 1932. A Kaiserreich Quest

You are ignoring content by this member.
[X] Plan: Winter is Coming V2
-[X] Organize the Combined Staff: Butler is unquestionably the chief commander of all soldiers fighting for freedom and liberty, but the staff and upper leadership have been greatly expanded by the integration of two new armies and their top generals. Making sure there are minimal teething issues and conflicts will greatly improve the efficacy of all the army's (and those of the air force and the navy)

-[X] Prepare partisan commands: We will lose territory to the federalists. That has been made clear by Chief Revolutionary Commander Butler, in a speech some have called defeatist. However, he has also made it clear that just because they have gained territory, he does not intend to make it easy for them to hold it, and that he trusts the workers and farmers of the nation will assist in him that. To that end, Butler is working to prepare underground cells in vulnerable territories to wreak havoc upon capitalist occupiers.

-[X] Prepare for winter: This winter is a bitter one. It is a winter of bloody conflict and refugee hordes. And it is also a winter of terrible storms, and it is only November. Food, shelter, fuel, and hope are in short supply. Those vital substances must be stockpiled and gathered, and measures taken to keep spirits high and bodies functioning. Ben Stevens and various local party cadres are working to minimize the hardships of the coming months, although their efforts may well be a snowball against an avalanche.

-[X] Integrate new trainers: With experienced soldiers from the Unity Army and Olson's Boys coming into the nexus of training camps in Michigan, the number of militiamen and fresh volunteers who can be trained to a more professional standard has greatly increased, but care must be taken to ensure these less-than-revolutionary trainers do not struggle with inoculating respect for the democratic nature of soldier's councils or teaching their trainees the nature of class warfare.

-[X] Expand equipment stockpiles: Bluntly, the military can never have enough guns, enough howitzers, enough shells, enough bullets. Even if there were a hundred rifles for every soldier, Butler would still want more. But there are not a hundred rifles for every soldier, although there are relatively few dire shortages. Still, preparations must be made for the inevitable losses of combat.

-[X] Improve backline logistics: While access to weaponry and ammunition is important, there are other important concerns that must be dealt with. The transport of massive quantities of food, uniforms, and other vital sundries must be prepared and organized, something Butler and his staff are working on. It is also a concern of the Economic Planning Commission.

-[X] Maintain medicinal supplies: With quarantines established, those who are sick must be cured too. What antibiotics that can be produced will be distributed, doctors and nurses press ganged, whatever that can be done will be done to keep the sick alive, at any cost except for the revolution.

-[X] Prepare partisan commands: We will lose territory to the federalists. That has been made clear by Chief Revolutionary Commander Butler, in a speech some have called defeatist. However, he has also made it clear that just because they have gained territory, he does not intend to make it easy for them to hold it, and that he trusts the workers and farmers of the nation will assist in him that. To that end, Butler is working to prepare underground cells in vulnerable territories to wreak havoc upon capitalist occupiers.

-[X] (De-Emphasize) Call for peace: We do not desire war. We do not want to kill so many sons and daughters of the working class, whether through bullets or blockades. We merely wish to see the will of the people expressed in a democratic fashion. The moral high ground is an advantage we must do our best to keep by emphasizing our desire for peace even as we prepare for war, a task the Propaganda Committee is working hard to accomplish.

-[X] (De-emphasize) Expand luxury production: Another part of your promises and a way to weaken the influence of the black market both, further attention can be devoted to the production of various luxuries such as perfume and musical instruments for civilian use. As per previous agreements, most of these enterprises are market-based, making their expansion rather controversial.

-[X] (De-emphasize) Examine What's Been Done: The chaos of the November Crisis has led to many individuals leading a variety of revolutionary initiatives, from the bands of artists using the rubble of Wall Street to make sculptures to the college professors transforming life on their campuses. The revolution is being led from below, to the resounding approval of all in the CAS. But it would be wise to investigate some of what has already been done.

-[X] (De-emphasize) Put refugees to use: Part of resolving that problem is getting refugees back to something more like ordinary life. Wherever there are gaps in our production lines, they can fill in to help keep the factories running. It will empty the camps, give them a sense of normalcy and something to occupy their time, and help keep the economy running. For those refugees who are simply capitalists fleeing gunfire, or their supporters, it can also give them a route for becoming good socialist workers.


[X] [DEC] Write a declaration.
-[X] Make sure that the declaration is also issued by Long and Olson to present the revolution as a united front (even if that means the rhetoric may need to be toned down a bit.)

[X] [SYND] We do not wish to appear as foreign puppets. A moderate intervention would be ideal.
- [X] Try to get the Commune of France and the Union of Britain to issue declarations that if any other foreign power intervenes in the civil war (i.e. Canada) they will take it as carte blanche to intervene in full support of the CAS

[X] [BLACK] Track it. The presence of organized crime is concerning, but nothing else about it is really important. Have Schenck keep an eye on it, but other than that leave it alone.

[X] [PLANE] It seems a fair deal.
 
Last edited:
We need as much help as we can get from France, UoB, Mexico, etc. The Feds already see us as foreign for wanting to help our fellow man. They can decry us for being foreign puppets of commies, syndies, anarchists, whatever. They have the backing of Canada, Germany, and whatever capitalist and/or reactionary regime. The people will see whose cause is just!
The main problem I have with being very overt with soliciting foreign support is that pushing that too hard will create friction with Long and Olson, because the power most able to provide assistance - the Syndintern - will be engaging in some pretty obvious favoritism, no matter how much we counsel them otherwise. This front we created with Long and Olson needs to stay united.

As such...

[X] Plan: Sweat the Big Stuff, Rely On Our Subordinates, V2C--Logistics Edition
[X] [DEC] Write a declaration.
-[X] Make sure that the declaration is also issued by Long and Olson to present the revolution as a united front (even if that means the rhetoric may need to be toned down a bit.)
[X] [SYND] We do not wish to appear as foreign puppets. A moderate intervention would be ideal.
- [X] Try to get the Commune of France and the Union of Britain to issue declarations that if any other foreign power intervenes in the civil war (i.e. Canada) they will take it as carte blanche to intervene in full support of the CAS
[X] [BLACK] Legitimize it. This will be approved of by many Syndicalists, as it represents a compromise with material conditions that do not allow for the total abolition of the market, but it may aggravate Marxists and Fosterites.

I'm willing to go much more ham on soliciting support if and when Canada intervenes, but for now we have to remember that we may be firmly the senior partners of this front but it's still a front.
 
The main problem I have with being very overt with soliciting foreign support is that pushing that too hard will create friction with Long and Olson, because the power most able to provide assistance - the Syndintern - will be engaging in some pretty obvious favoritism, no matter how much we counsel them otherwise. This front we created with Long and Olson needs to stay united.

That's a fair counter, so I'll agree with that statement. That being said, I'll stick with my vote as a dissenting vote on behalf of the internationalists.

And I didn't vote for a plan yet, so:

[X] Plan: Sweat the Big Stuff, Rely On Our Subordinates, V2A--Workers Edition
[X] Plan: Sweat the Big Stuff, Rely On Our Subordinates, V2C--Logistics Edition

I'd say either of these plans are the most optimal for this week. Assuming this quest ends at Week 4 of 1934, that means we got four more weeks to actually strengthen the militant side of things.
 
I think it is a really big mistake to push this down. It only means we will lose more comrades to assassination.

-[] (De-Emphasize) Internal infiltration: There will be resistance to our efforts to create a more just and equitable society. Although many groups that oppose us have been driven out or defeated, others have merely gone to ground. They must be found, infiltrated, and broken apart, or we will face an exhausting and expensive resistance from counterrevolutionaries
 
I think it is a really big mistake to push this down. It only means we will lose more comrades to assassination.

-[] (De-Emphasize) Internal infiltration: There will be resistance to our efforts to create a more just and equitable society. Although many groups that oppose us have been driven out or defeated, others have merely gone to ground. They must be found, infiltrated, and broken apart, or we will face an exhausting and expensive resistance from counterrevolutionaries

That needs to be corrected. I will come up with an alternate de-emphasis while maintaining The Laurent's and Zaqwer's proposals.
 
[X] Plan: Sweat the Big Stuff, Rely On Our Subordinates, V3A--Workers Edition
-[] Support the Northern California Uprising: The Southern California revolt has been cut off from us, but those brave fighters have received ample support from our comrades south of the Rio Grande. It is the Red Guards in the north that we must focus our attention on now. Send men, send guns, send everything we can, help them hold Sacramento and secure northern California.
-[] Working improvements: Improving the conditions of the working class, even under the rigors of an all-out revolutionary war, was a demand of the coalition running the CAS. It will cost time, time that perhaps cannot be spared, but reducing hours, expanding breaks, and distributing more safety equipment are all relatively cheap measures to fulfill your promises.
-[] Reinforce quarantines: With disease after disease ripping its way through America, a humanitarian crisis of epic proportions has begun. Everyone is suffering, from coast to coast, and immediate measures need to be taken to prevent any of the several potentially catastrophic diseases from getting worse. Antibiotics cannot cure many of them, and there are not many viable vaccines. The only possible solution is to enact mass quarantines.
-[] Back allied workers: Long struggles with corruption, Olson with moderation. And with both allowing CAS-affiliated organizations to agitate and organize within their territory, we have an opportunity to rally those dissatisfied with their regime and increase our support across the nation. It is both a moral duty and a practical opportunity to assist the workers of Louisiana and Minnesota in their struggle for true liberation.
-[] Operation Paul Revere: Even as America's northern neighbor falls into chaos, it prepares to intervene in the revolution. Combined with the noose of ships and National Guards surrounding Boston, their target is obvious. We shall do our best to replicate the legend of Paul Revere and rouse the workers of the Northeast to overthrow their oppressors by supplying and supporting underground revolutionary and Longist groups.
-[] Naval co-option: One area that must be a special priority is to expand the infiltration of the Navy. Ships are blockading nearly every port, and armed sailors and Marines are patrolling sections of Long Island, Seattle, much of the Texas coast...which means they are vulnerable to persuasion. They must be persuaded to join our cause, lest our cities be pounded to rubble beneath their guns.
-[] Canadian comrades: Canada is falling into chaos. The navy was badly damaged in a battle outside Iceland, and rumors are spreading about King Edward VIII inviting in German troops to help intervene in America. Strikes and riots are paralyzing city after city, Quebec is aflame, and soldiers are deserting. The Union of Britain and the Commune of France have both been backing the underground revolutionaries, and Schenck's men have gotten in touch with them. It's time to light a fire.
-[] Try and sleep: The stress is starting to get to you. You are having nightmares about Petrograd and Moscow. You need to sleep. People make bad decisions when they are tired. You need to sleep.
-[] (De-Emphasize) Deal with production shortfalls: Another part of handling the wartime economy will be dealing with shortfalls. There have already been empty shelves, but it's likely to get worse before it gets better. A variety of proposals for helping deal with this problem have been suggested, ranging from propaganda encouraging people to reuse whatever they can to the sponsorship of artisanal production facilities for people to work in during their free time.
-[] (De-Emphasize) Call for peace: We do not desire war. We do not want to kill so many sons and daughters of the working class, whether through bullets or blockades. We merely wish to see the will of the people expressed in a democratic fashion. The moral high ground is an advantage we must do our best to keep by emphasizing our desire for peace even as we prepare for war, a task the Propaganda Committee is working hard to accomplish.
-[] (De-emphasize) Expand luxury production: Another part of your promises and a way to weaken the influence of the black market both, further attention can be devoted to the production of various luxuries such as perfume and musical instruments for civilian use. As per previous agreements, most of these enterprises are market-based, making their expansion rather controversial.
-[] (De-emphasize) Examine what's been done: The chaos of the November Crisis has led to many individuals leading a variety of revolutionary initiatives, from the bands of artists using the rubble of Wall Street to make sculptures to the college professors transforming life on their campuses. The revolution is being led from below, to the resounding approval of all in the CAS. But it would be wise to investigate some of what has already been done.

Dealing with production shortfalls is the best of the worst in terms of de-emphasizing. The rationale being that the black markets and assistance from the Sydintern will help fill some holes in the supply and equipment defecit. I considered de-emphasizing building defenses, but we probably don't have enough firepower to counter the junta's armed forces and those defenses will be needed to hold them back or at least buy time in the worst-case scenarios.

[X] Plan: Sweat the Big Stuff, Rely On Our Subordinates, V3B--Soldiers Edition
[X] Plan: Sweat the Big Stuff, Rely On Our Subordinates, V3C--Logistics Edition

V3B amd V3C are also the same plans as the V2 counterparts, just with the de-emphasis on production shortfalls.
 
[X] Plan: Sweat the Big Stuff, Rely On Our Subordinates, V3A--Workers Edition
[X] [DEC] Write a declaration.
-[X] Make sure that the declaration is also issued by Long and Olson to present the revolution as a united front (even if that means the rhetoric may need to be toned down a bit.)

[X] [SYND] We do not wish to appear as foreign puppets. A moderate intervention would be ideal.
- [X] Try to get the Commune of France and the Union of Britain to issue declarations that if any other foreign power intervenes in the civil war (i.e. Canada) they will take it as carte blanche to intervene in full support of the CAS

[X] [BLACK] Track it. The presence of organized crime is concerning, but nothing else about it is really important. Have Schenck keep an eye on it, but other than that leave it alone.

[X] [PLANE] It seems a fair deal
 
[X] Plan: Winter is Coming V2

[X] [DEC] Write a declaration.
-[X] Make sure that the declaration is also issued by Long and Olson to present the revolution as a united front (even if that means the rhetoric may need to be toned down a bit.)

[X] [SYND] We do not wish to appear as foreign puppets. A moderate intervention would be ideal.
- [X] Try to get the Commune of France and the Union of Britain to issue declarations that if any other foreign power intervenes in the civil war (i.e. Canada) they will take it as carte blanche to intervene in full support of the CAS

[X] [BLACK] Track it. The presence of organized crime is concerning, but nothing else about it is really important. Have Schenck keep an eye on it, but other than that leave it alone.

[X] [PLANE] It seems a fair deal
 
[X] [BLACK] Legitimize it. This will be approved of by many Syndicalists, as it represents a compromise with material conditions that do not allow for the total abolition of the market, but it may aggravate Marxists and Fosterites.

[X] [PLANE] It seems a fair deal.
 
Long in any timeline is whatever ideology gets him the most power. He's a chameleon that way. In this case, the racists and industrialists jettisoned him, so he came to us.
 
[X] [DEC] Write a declaration.
-[X] Make sure that the declaration is also issued by Long and Olson to present the revolution as a united front (even if that means the rhetoric may need to be toned down a bit.)
[X] [SYND] We do not wish to appear as foreign puppets. A moderate intervention would be ideal.
- [X] Try to get the Commune of France and the Union of Britain to issue declarations that if any other foreign power intervenes in the civil war (i.e. Canada) they will take it as carte blanche to intervene in full support of the CAS
[X] [BLACK] Track it. The presence of organized crime is concerning, but nothing else about it is really important. Have Schenck keep an eye on it, but other than that leave it alone.
[X] [PLANE] It seems a fair deal.
 
I'm curious now, we know Britain, France, and Mexico are providing assistance on behalf of the Third International. Anything from the Chileans or Norwegians? (SRI is presumably locked in its own civil war with the rest of Italy)
 
[X] Plan: Sweat the Big Stuff, Rely On Our Subordinates, V2B--Generals Edition
[X] Plan: Sweat the Big Stuff, Rely On Our Subordinates, V2C--Logistics Edition

[X] [DEC] Write a declaration.
-[X] Make sure that the declaration is also issued by Long and Olson to present the revolution as a united front (even if that means the rhetoric may need to be toned down a bit.)
[X] [SYND] We do not wish to appear as foreign puppets. A moderate intervention would be ideal.
- [X] Try to get the Commune of France and the Union of Britain to issue declarations that if any other foreign power intervenes in the civil war (i.e. Canada) they will take it as carte blanche to intervene in full support of the CAS
[X] [BLACK] Legitimize it. This will be approved of by many Syndicalists, as it represents a compromise with material conditions that do not allow for the total abolition of the market, but it may aggravate Marxists and Fosterites.



[X] [PLANE] It seems a fair deal.
 
[X] [BLACK] Track it. The presence of organized crime is concerning, but nothing else about it is really important. Have Schenck keep an eye on it, but other than that leave it alone.
 
[X] [DEC] Write a declaration.
-[X] Make sure that the declaration is also issued by Long and Olson to present the revolution as a united front (even if that means the rhetoric may need to be toned down a bit.)
[X] [SYND] We do not wish to appear as foreign puppets. A moderate intervention would be ideal.
- [X] Try to get the Commune of France and the Union of Britain to issue declarations that if any other foreign power intervenes in the civil war (i.e. Canada) they will take it as carte blanche to intervene in full support of the CAS
[X] [PLANE] It seems a fair deal.
[X] [BLACK] Legitimize it. This will be approved of by many Syndicalists, as it represents a compromise with material conditions that do not allow for the total abolition of the market, but it may aggravate Marxists and Fosterites.
[X] Plan: Sweat the Big Stuff, Rely On Our Subordinates, V2C--Logistics Edition
 
[X] Plan: Sweat the Big Stuff, Rely On Our Subordinates, V2B--Generals Edition
[X] Plan: Sweat the Big Stuff, Rely On Our Subordinates, V2C--Logistics Edition

[X] [DEC] Write a declaration.
-[X] Make sure that the declaration is also issued by Long and Olson to present the revolution as a united front (even if that means the rhetoric may need to be toned down a bit.)

[X] [SYND] The struggle must be an international one. Send every soldier you can spare!.

[X] [BLACK] Track it. The presence of organized crime is concerning, but nothing else about it is really important. Have Schenck keep an eye on it, but other than that leave it alone.

[X] [PLANE] It seems a fair deal

While I like the write in for the Syndies, I want their manpower and tanks. They've built for mechanized warfare. As for the plans, I have no idea. They're all too big and complicated, and my eyes gloss over. Generals and Logistics Edition look good enough to me.
 
[X] Plan: Sweat the Big Stuff, Rely On Our Subordinates, V3A--Workers Edition
[X] [DEC] Write a declaration.
-[X] Make sure that the declaration is also issued by Long and Olson to present the revolution as a united front (even if that means the rhetoric may need to be toned down a bit.)
[X] [SYND] We do not wish to appear as foreign puppets. A moderate intervention would be ideal.
- [X] Try to get the Commune of France and the Union of Britain to issue declarations that if any other foreign power intervenes in the civil war (i.e. Canada) they will take it as carte blanche to intervene in full support of the CAS
[X] [BLACK] Legitimize it. This will be approved of by many Syndicalists, as it represents a compromise with material conditions that do not allow for the total abolition of the market, but it may aggravate Marxists and Fosterites.
[X] [PLANE] It seems a fair deal
 
Last edited:
[X] [DEC] Write a declaration.
-[X] Make sure that the declaration is also issued by Long and Olson to present the revolution as a united front (even if that means the rhetoric may need to be toned down a bit.)

X] [SYND] The struggle must be an international one. Send every soldier you can spare!.

[X] [BLACK] Track it. The presence of organized crime is concerning, but nothing else about it is really important. Have Schenck keep an eye on it, but other than that leave it alone.

[X] [PLANE] It seems a fair deal

Just an updated vote regarding the "small" stuff. Everyone believes the pilots are beaten in their negotiations, so I'll go with the rest and take the deal. And added the caveat for officially declaring.
 
I really think we're better off legitimizing the Black Market rather than just tracking. Like, what do we expect tracking it to do exactly? It'll still be a thing so long as we're not producing and distributing the needed luxury goods ourselves.

And in fact, we're de-emphasizing that, so might as well legitimize the market so we actually have some authority over it and can prevent it from being used for nastier stuff.

And on that note:
-[] (De-emphasize) Expand luxury production: Another part of your promises and a way to weaken the influence of the black market both, further attention can be devoted to the production of various luxuries such as perfume and musical instruments for civilian use. As per previous agreements, most of these enterprises are market-based, making their expansion rather controversial.
Luxury production wasn't just a thing to weaken the influence of the black market, but also another part of our promises to groups like the Syndicalists. They're probably not gonna be very happy that we're now de-emphasizing it, so legitimizing the black market makes for a good olive branch.
 
[X] Plan: Sweat the Big Stuff, Rely On Our Subordinates, V2B--Generals Edition
[X] Plan: Sweat the Big Stuff, Rely On Our Subordinates, V3A--Workers Edition


[X] [BLACK] Legitimize it. This will be approved of by many Syndicalists, as it represents a compromise with material conditions that do not allow for the total abolition of the market, but it may aggravate Marxists and Fosterites.

I hate to do this, but Chimerguard has a point.
 
Back
Top