Personally, I just feel as though the timescales aren't really believable. Jakku was what, a year after Endor? There is just no way that the rebellion conquered the Galaxy that quickly. I find the splintering and subsequent mop-up we see in the X-wing series to be much more realistic. Not to mention that the Wikipedia article implies that the Empire lost most of its fleet strength at endor, which just doesn't compute for me: the Star Wars Galaxy is a huge place, and would need a huge Navy to actually maintain control over it, deal with pirates, etc.
I also have a real problem that the NR even could get wiped out by the destruction of a measly 6 planets, compared to the vast size of the galaxy. Or at least the idea that their fleet was destroyed along with the planets. What about (again) stuff like anti-piracy patrols?
This. The Legends New Republic was stupid sometimes, but at least they were not crippled to the point of being incapable of governing.What I know is that Palpatine won.
He won because he kept Mothma, Ackbar, Leia et al so terrified of him - even after his defeat and death - that they gutted and lobotomized the New Republic, resulting in a government that couldn't do...anything, really.
And so the DisCan New Republic was utterly annihilated without a real fight by the same type of foe their Legends counterpart annihilated time and time again.
I also have a real problem that the NR even could get wiped out by the destruction of a measly 6 planets, compared to the vast size of the galaxy. Or at least the idea that their fleet was destroyed along with the planets. What about (again) stuff like anti-piracy patrols?