[X] vote hugh_donnetonno
The whole way that the end state moved say from high and shal into I feel a third party still leaves a bit of a weird taste in my mouth , and as stated yesterday I am fine with either because the fight felt ... to soft in a way ?
The executioner one today feels more like frustrated town tunnelling in my gut as it has the right feel of frustration that make it sound authentic.
The whole way that the end state moved say from high and shal into I feel a third party still leaves a bit of a weird taste in my mouth , and as stated yesterday I am fine with either because the fight felt ... to soft in a way ?
The executioner one today feels more like frustrated town tunnelling in my gut as it has the right feel of frustration that make it sound authentic.
hugh_donnetono
No use to complain
- Location
- Caught Out In The Rain
y'know @InterstellarHobo hasn't posted anything at all today 🤔
[x] Vote InterstellarHobo
Say something
[x] Vote InterstellarHobo
Say something
hugh_donnetono
No use to complain
- Location
- Caught Out In The Rain
Dark Souls this time, sorry. 😅
Fair warning, I have a final today so my activity might be a bit lower than my usual.
hugh_donnetono
No use to complain
- Location
- Caught Out In The Rain
Zone Q11
Monochrome Plebeian
- Pronouns
- He/Him/His
Voting on slankers will do no good. They won't respond to your vote anyway, so unless you want to rally against slankers, then your vote is effectively useless. Instead, why don't you give me your thoughts on Kingster? Do you want to see more content from him before you make your judgement?y'know @InterstellarHobo hasn't posted anything at all today 🤔
[x] Vote InterstellarHobo
Say something
Nictis
Best Sidekick
- Location
- Ninja Dave's Cookies
- Pronouns
- Any
Completely understandable, I'm just explaining what I can.
Very much this. I have caught scum so many times because they use logic trains that don't make sense if they're Town. Shalmoa's thrust with that is that I'm trying to discredit Shalmoa and also keep Hugh alive and above suspicion by marking Shalmoa as Executioner and then never doing anything about it. Which is pretty funny when Shalmoa knows how hard I go into voting people.
As for the rest of your post, going to do a review on Kingster soon. My impression was generally Town for a newbie. For right now I'm going to agree with Shalmoa and start policy voting non-voters.
[x] Vote Hugh_Donnetono
@hugh_donnetono Pinging, get a vote on the board.
Nictis
Best Sidekick
- Location
- Ninja Dave's Cookies
- Pronouns
- Any
Going to skip ahead in the pings a bit. This is a lot of people who aren't voting. I think only Seven has even made it clear who they would be voting if they had one down so far, so chop chop. Either get your votes out or get me an idea of who you would be voting if you weren't scared of hammer so I can use it to nail you down later.
- Location
- PA
Hrm.
For today the push that has my attention is actually the recent one by Zone, on Kingster.
Quiet-hunting isn't ideal but I suppose so long as we leave the Shalmoa case alone we'll have no further issues with him at this point, and like Scia said: that whole debacle reads to me more like a Town tunneling versus execution given his later demonstrated fustration…
[X] vote Kingster
For today the push that has my attention is actually the recent one by Zone, on Kingster.
Quiet-hunting isn't ideal but I suppose so long as we leave the Shalmoa case alone we'll have no further issues with him at this point, and like Scia said: that whole debacle reads to me more like a Town tunneling versus execution given his later demonstrated fustration…
[X] vote Kingster
hugh_donnetono
No use to complain
- Location
- Caught Out In The Rain
Sure but in my experience IH isn't usually like this? so there's probably something going on there. You're probably right that whatever it is is probably not gonna let up any time soon if it's already kept him busy for an entire day, but it still might be useful to provide some motivation.
And yes, this exactly, why do you think I beeped him
Fine, if that's not enough of a vote for you, how about this one?
[x] Vote Nictis
- Location
- Somewhere!
- Pronouns
- She/Her
-Rosen
Playing reasonably, has had progression both times. A little absent but honestly the shorter day today is catching me off guard as well and I feel like I'm going to see a lot of people slipping around that.
-Zone Q11
Seems to be hunting actively right now, nothing in particular I find suspicious about play.
-Shalmoa
I don't think Mafia!Shalmoa does D1, and the frustration today seems genuine. Maybe some sort of really complicated play to draw attention away from a teammate, as a possible scum interpretation, but I don't really see it and I'm not looking here presently.
-InterstellarHobo
...doesn't seem to be around?
-Hugh
Kinda torn on this. There are explanations for most stuff Hugh has been doing, the self preservation vote stands up, etc. And second highest activitity, so... I guess active enough in solving?
-Seven
I don't feel like I have a strong read here, but I like getting a reads list done up today. I don't think I agree with the reads, but that happens and my judgement is often pretty bad, so I wouldn't call that indicative of things.
-Zaelix
Hey, @Zaealix, could you expand on what you meant in #456 a bit for me? What things do you think Shadell said that went against the flow of town, how do you see the wagon, etc?
-Nictis
I am usually pretty bad at reading Nictis and I'm not feeling differently here. She's sick, too, so... I guess I'm not expecting a lot of presence?
-Scia
Busy, I feel like Scia is usually a little quiet, no strong read. Seems to be putting together stuff.
-Kingster
D1 Vote progression is weird, and especially the land on Shadell didn't seem very well evidenced? Suspicious to me, albeit maybe some cultural stuff at play. P#458 is sort of an explanation for this, but if anyone on the wagon was opportunistic Mafia, Kingster might be the best fit. I think the secondary explanation is someone who's just following people they find compelling and that might explain all the moving around. I think this might depend on how you read the wagon, basically.
Playing reasonably, has had progression both times. A little absent but honestly the shorter day today is catching me off guard as well and I feel like I'm going to see a lot of people slipping around that.
-Zone Q11
Seems to be hunting actively right now, nothing in particular I find suspicious about play.
-Shalmoa
I don't think Mafia!Shalmoa does D1, and the frustration today seems genuine. Maybe some sort of really complicated play to draw attention away from a teammate, as a possible scum interpretation, but I don't really see it and I'm not looking here presently.
-InterstellarHobo
...doesn't seem to be around?
-Hugh
Kinda torn on this. There are explanations for most stuff Hugh has been doing, the self preservation vote stands up, etc. And second highest activitity, so... I guess active enough in solving?
-Seven
I don't feel like I have a strong read here, but I like getting a reads list done up today. I don't think I agree with the reads, but that happens and my judgement is often pretty bad, so I wouldn't call that indicative of things.
-Zaelix
Hey, @Zaealix, could you expand on what you meant in #456 a bit for me? What things do you think Shadell said that went against the flow of town, how do you see the wagon, etc?
-Nictis
I am usually pretty bad at reading Nictis and I'm not feeling differently here. She's sick, too, so... I guess I'm not expecting a lot of presence?
-Scia
Busy, I feel like Scia is usually a little quiet, no strong read. Seems to be putting together stuff.
-Kingster
D1 Vote progression is weird, and especially the land on Shadell didn't seem very well evidenced? Suspicious to me, albeit maybe some cultural stuff at play. P#458 is sort of an explanation for this, but if anyone on the wagon was opportunistic Mafia, Kingster might be the best fit. I think the secondary explanation is someone who's just following people they find compelling and that might explain all the moving around. I think this might depend on how you read the wagon, basically.
hugh_donnetono
No use to complain
- Location
- Caught Out In The Rain
Hammer is currently 6, and the largest wagons are currently all at 2; you can put one vote anywhere you want without risk of things getting screwy
but also
but also
oh my god people 😂 😂 😂 😂 😂 😂
hugh_donnetono
No use to complain
- Location
- Caught Out In The Rain
Oooof, good luck, it's a doozy 😂
- Location
- PA
Back in D1 again, more re-reading…
It occurs to me NemoMarx was the first to mention the possibility of a Godfather when I spitballed about intel shenanigans, possibly for Hugh to pick up on and start the great Shalmoa tunnel…
But eh. I doubt that will lead to anything important.
Apparently Kingster found Shaddell suspicious before I found any of the posts that lead me to think of Shaddell as going against the flow of town…
…Okay, #226 where Shaddel turns to pressure Ori could count maybe. And being the last vote before Shalmoa spotted the hammer rules likely did not help.
*frowns* man gut feel is not as reliable as I thought../
It occurs to me NemoMarx was the first to mention the possibility of a Godfather when I spitballed about intel shenanigans, possibly for Hugh to pick up on and start the great Shalmoa tunnel…
But eh. I doubt that will lead to anything important.
Apparently Kingster found Shaddell suspicious before I found any of the posts that lead me to think of Shaddell as going against the flow of town…
…Okay, #226 where Shaddel turns to pressure Ori could count maybe. And being the last vote before Shalmoa spotted the hammer rules likely did not help.
*frowns* man gut feel is not as reliable as I thought../
Zone Q11
Monochrome Plebeian
- Pronouns
- He/Him/His
That is correct. I did not notice the "Town vs Mafia" before, but the fact that this is written completely eliminates the possibility of third parties in this game; it's just Town vs Mafia.
The thing is: I don't know IH as well as you do. FMPOV, IH just happens to be slanking for over 36 hours in a 48 hour day phase, so... that's obviously NAGL.
I did say I think you were doing X, but it is not certain that you were actually doing X.And yes, this exactly, why do you think I beeped him
For all I know, you might purposefully avoiding my push on Kingster because you are scumbuddies with him or smth.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Zone Q11
Monochrome Plebeian
- Pronouns
- He/Him/His
...hm? Zaealix, who are town?
Zone Q11
Monochrome Plebeian
- Pronouns
- He/Him/His
...I am not getting anything out of this.
Nemo, Gun To Head give me your Top 3 suspects.
Nictis
Best Sidekick
- Location
- Ninja Dave's Cookies
- Pronouns
- Any
Voting for yourself doesn't count Hugh. Thanks for placing a real vote though.
Fine, if that's not enough of a vote for you, how about this one?
[x] Vote Nictis
hugh_donnetono
No use to complain
- Location
- Caught Out In The Rain
Nagl?
Nictis
Best Sidekick
- Location
- Ninja Dave's Cookies
- Pronouns
- Any
Breaking this down:
Rosen: Light Town
Zone: Light Town
Shalmoa: Hard Town.
Hobo: Not present.
Hugh: Light Scum but too active to kill.
Seven: Null to Light Scum.
Zaealix: Read pending.
Nictis: Null Read (Per usual)
Scia: Light Town question mark?
Kingster: Most Scum but not hard Scum.
This about right for you?
Nictis
Best Sidekick
- Location
- Ninja Dave's Cookies
- Pronouns
- Any
Not A Good Look.