As far as I'm concerned the theory is a perfectly valid one. It's just her 'solution' to it that's the issue. I might recognize that gravity is at fault for pretty much every plane accident ever, but I don't decide building a device to permanently turn it off throughout the galaxy is the only way to deal with it.
sounds like something that wont exist for a long long time, in a galaxy far far away.
I'd prefer we have either a ship name that is meaningful to Revan.
True.
Except Force is a fundamental part of life, everything that lives, or has ever lived is connected to the force. We've seen what happens when things are forcibly stripped from the force*, and it's pretty horrible. The force isn't just space magic available exclusively to Force Users, it's a fundamental facet of nature that ties all life together. One could argue, that in SW, the force defines what isn't and what is alive. Even if you could cut off the galaxy from the force, we really don't know what the consequences of such an act are. I highly doubt it's just "Oh! No more Space Wizards I guess."
The Force is way more than just something that can be excised from a few sensitives and be called a day. The Force that Kreia's railing against is more along the lines of fate, of clear delineated moralities opposing each other in constant and pointless cycles. Kreai is opposing the very notion of Fate, and the idea of destiny, of predetermination, that goes far beyond disliking people who use the force. The Force is something that effects and supposedly guides every living thing and supposedly has a sentience of its own. Just killing/cutting off all force users is not going to work, and if she's that delusional to think it will, than she very much is insane.
I believe they have a connection. Just that there are funky things going on with it due to the whole pissing off their living planet thing they had going on.
More that if she's trying to go after sensitives exclusively to remove the Force's influence is crazy. And its less that I support predetermination, Destiny, or Fate (I despise the notion of fate/predestination and all that jazz). And more taking it into your own hands to actively remove Fate from the equation regardless of what other people want/uncaring of the consequences that I think makes it crazy. It's less that I think it's not a noble ideal, but more not giving a shit about the consequences of achieving the goal is the issue here. I know as much as I dislike Fate, I dislike someone unilaterally turning it off without asking permission much more.See, all you're saying is just making me think Kreia had a point.
Also, no one ever said anything about just excising the Force from a few sensitives. In fact, if you'd read my post more clearly, you'll note that I'm talking about the sensitives being the most affected by what happens, not the only ones the Force is removed from. And even that is merely to talk about the example we had. Heck, you seem conflicted on what Kreia wants to do - in the first part of your post, you're saying that Kreia wants to comprehensively eliminate the Force. The last part of your sentence calls her insane for only doing so with Force sensitives. Which do you actually think she's doing???
And according to you, the Force is apparently a sapient entity that is manipulating every single being in the galaxy into a specific path, makes morality black and white ... and it's a bad thing to remove it? Why exactly is predetermination something to fight for? What is so grand about having a destiny forced on people, on having people with supernatural powers push their will onto others?
If anything, that just makes me want to vote for Revan supporting Kreia.
Also, if you're going to tell me that opposing the notion of Fate and the idea of destiny/predetermination is insanity, I will slap you. Through the internet. Because you'd deserve it for saying something that stupid.
It actually is. One simply needs to look at the results of wounds in the force and thought bombs to see that. Keira's end goal was to feed the entire force to a wound in the force. That would have killed everything in the galaxy but droids.
Her goal wasn't to sever people from the force but to feed all of it to an wound in the force, IE someone like the Exile. Who wasn't actually severed from the force as far as I know. She deafened her self to the force after feeling the deaths of everyone she had a bond with at that one planet.
The notion of fate may not be insane, but it cannot be rationally believed. Suppose that I were a stubborn idiot who believes square circles can exist. Eventually you grow tired of my nonsense and brainwash me into believing that a square circle cannot exist.And according to you, the Force is apparently a sapient entity that is manipulating every single being in the galaxy into a specific path, makes morality black and white ... and it's a bad thing to remove it? Why exactly is predetermination something to fight for? What is so grand about having a destiny forced on people, on having people with supernatural powers push their will onto others?
If anything, that just makes me want to vote for Revan supporting Kreia.
Also, if you're going to tell me that opposing the notion of Fate and the idea of destiny/predetermination is insanity, I will slap you. Through the internet. Because you'd deserve it for saying something that stupid.
Because he's not controlled by the Force. "He's shaping his own way."
