- Location
- Here
I don't think Yui has to (or is likely to) be at all deceptive about the breadth of her experience. I think acting in charge (and her short-but-colorful track record is enough precedent), having a plan and having Maiko (and the rest) visibly defer to her is actually completely sufficient to be both completely honest and obviously the authority.Even if we mentioned that we're new to magical girling the demeanor and attitude is very much about inducting them into our plans and ways of doing things, and Yui's short-but-colorful track record of running around singlehandedly engaging incusions with violence or diplomacy as necessary certainly doesn't give the impression that she's a peer.
So I think I'm completely agreeing with you. Yui can protest her newbieness all she wants (and her OODA loop is much tighter than ours, so that's as it should be) without losing an ounce of perceived authority. But probably ending up somewhat more approachable than hypothetical nega-Yui with a very different management style?
Another point about grief thermodynamics. I think witches/magical girls are pretty clearly much more concentrated/energetic phenomena than most of the magical things around. Echo did some theorycrafting about how in order to get a lot of magic output, you need to have sustainable and structured but powerful emotions, and that the magical girl process sort of captures a girl at her peak useful emotional state (which I think gets at the idea of Potential) and then locks her into sustaining that. I don't remember it super well.
So, being the most magic-dense things around, grief seeds are a good match to the grief production of a magical girl, whereas everything else is usually so diffuse that you need an awful lot of it.
In some ways it also bears a resemblance to high end military hardware? Like, a latest generation fighter jet takes economic output equivalent to a few million person-hours of skilled labor in a technological society, but that concentration of resources can accomplish things that you couldn't accomplish with a few million person-hours not concentrated into such a high-performance machine. The analogy breaks down because a fighter jet isn't so useful (or at all, really) outside the system in which it is employed, whereas a magical girl has no equivalent context.