Homura's emotions could not be converted into grief cubes, and the dokawraith was as kyubey said she was a great mass of curses, now tell me what is birthed from curses again? what inside of Homura's soul is so different that what was taken from it could not be converted? After all other girls have fallen to wraiths before and this (i believe) has not happened before.
I think you mean to say 'to much'
Interpretation is evil cause its not the amount that she had, although she had alot, its the fact that it is different from anything the wraiths have encountered before.
true but witches are birthed from Curses.
Or that Homura is from a different reality and had something in her soul gem that prevents the emotions taken from it from being transformed, witches cause transformations no?
Explained as an side effect of Homura's new mental magic.
explain further please.how did they act like witches?
Wrong, all emotion is comparative to the force that once overturned the universe it is why wraiths hunt down emotions the only thing that stood out to them about Homura's was that she had a massive amount of the emotional energy in the first place which is why the wraiths sent the large one to feast and turn the energy into a safer form (the amount was excepted the fact that they couldn't change it was not, the fact that it changes them is because they cant change it).
We established this already we are disagreeing on why It cant be digested.
The kyubey of this universe has never seen a Witch before so the things that would make up a witch would look different from anything he has seen before.
And yet Homura has no will to fight anymore if her will was stronger then the Wraiths her magic would not have been consumed in the first place, her own will is not why the wraiths cant eat the magic, the amount of emotions/magic is not why the wraiths cant change the magic my believe is that Homura's Witch is why the wraiths 'cant' handle her powers. If they are acting more like witches then its because a witch is involved.
Witches are made of Curses, a magical girl curses the world when in the depths of despair (aka like how Homura wanted to become a monster to destroy this horrible world) however due to what Madoka is shown to do aka kill the witch and then comfort the girl making sure they can die with their hope intact, kyubey has never seen curses before or rather not what curses can end up being.
Homura has no ties to this world, for madoka is not a part of it, it is why she does not wish to be a Magical girl is beacuse she has no attachments, her emotions are from her view a likely forgery due to the fact that her Mental magic can be used on herself. Her feelings are strong but she has no desire for them because she see's them as fake.
It is not the power of the emotions that they cant handle it is that there is something different in the emotions that they cannot handle once again we agree on this we just don't agree on why it is.
Due to the fact that they are based on Buddhism does not mean that they will follow all the things in Buddhism once again we have different interpretations.
No she 'can' become the 'Devil' not that she already is, she can, time is in motion and it is not a fixed thing, also just to be sure has the wraith arc been excepted as canon or is it just popular fandom?
Huh, did not know that. I've only read up to Volume 2.
Article: Referred to as Spatial Reconstruction Magic (空間再構成魔法 Kūkan Sai-kōsei Mahō) by Asian fans. In plain language, a user of this class of magic temporarily becomes the 'goddess' of a limited domain of space, gaining the ability to change, create, or destroy objects within it -- including distances and spatial coordinates. Humans appear to be shielded from manipulation to a degree, though their position may still be freely rearranged. Distinct from the 'object modification' described in the Material Magic section above -- where the qualities of an existing tool or implement are reinforced as it temporarily undergoes a highly stylized transformation -- inanimates affected by Spatial Reconstruction experience a permanent, unstylized alteration.
Speculah regarding Spatial Reconstruction began to surface after Homura intervened in the confrontation between Sayaka and Kyoko in Episode 5: Viewer discussion concluded that the complete redrawing of the wall layout, the floor, and the lighting in the background art following Homura's use of 'teleportation' was suspiciously unnecessary -- it would have been far easier for the animation staff to reuse previously completed artwork. If this was not in fact a production error, the theory followed that the ability used by Homura to save Sayaka may have been something on the order of reconstructing the space within the corridor, rather than mere teleportation or the use of a 'Time Bubble.' It should be noted that the alteration of the wall is presented unchanged in the scene recap at the beginning of Episode 6.
Outside the context of theory, Witches and their Familiars canonically employ magic within the spectrum of Spatial Reconstruction in the manifestation of their Labyrinths. Movement subjectively experienced by persons drawn into a Witch's Labyrinth does not necessarily indicate or overlap any analogous travel within 'real' space; observed space within a Witch's domain comprises thus of 'spoofed coordinates.' Ergo, the manipulation of the position or lay of objects in a given space figures fundamentally into the magical repertoire of a typical Witch. The 'cartoonization' attack used by H.N. Elly and her Familiars against Madoka may classify an offense implementation of Spatial Reconstruction.
Homura, I always thought had some form a basic dimensional magic, aka detaching herself from time and storing things in a pocket world. However she lacks the power to freely remake the world around her (in the anime) otherwise she would have been able to beat Walpurgisnacht long ago.
Yeah, it is very tricky. Time Stop is a powerful ability but only because of its utility, not its power. Any other power that seems to be similar kinda starts to fall apart since why didn't she defeat walpurgisnacht that way. Also I guess people were focusing too much on sheer power then rather what makes sense.
It also requires a lot of power to stop time, enough that channeling that power into a brute force attack would probably level the city.
These were early theories before people learned of the whole situation. Cant blame them for not taking all the facts in the anime considering when theses ideas happen before said info is available.
I am aware however Homura is not 'Stopping time' however in terms of power what she is doing is far less energy hogging as a true Time stop would be.
Magic works by providing power that is controllable via emotions (in the Pmmm setting) now stopping time would take alot of power... unless of course you want to die the instant that you do it.
How do you know that a "true timestop" would be very energy-hogging?
Well there are 2 ways to truly time stop