Magical Tinker Lyrical Taylor Worm/MGLN

Maybe, but it would be highly unusual for a magitech translation effect to translate something into a different language that the listener does not understand. And anyway it doesn't seem to be canon for this fic.
When do the characters in the MGLN series ever not understand what is being said? I can see some misunderstandings of intentions (in fact a lot of the conflict in the early series it built on them), but the words themselves always seem to be understood.

Edit:
As to it being relevant to this story? Well given that the author has stated that <-spoiler->, there's a very good chance that Taylor simply doesn't have the magic, tech, or knowledge needed to create an auto-translation effect. Alternately she does but it has never occurred to her to create one.
 
Last edited:
It's called profiling and stereotyping. It happens.

And no, they can't arrest her just for speaking German, but she's out and about as a cape and speaking German - it wouldn't hold water if she went to an unbiased court, but they could arrest her for being part of the E88 based solely on her vigilante activities and speaking German.
If this happens Dragon must also be arrested for ties to the ABB
 
Of course, they could justify it based on the fact that they believe her mother had ties to the E88 based on (among other things) the fact that she attacked a bunch of members of Marquis' gang (a known rival to the E88).

In that case, Taylor might point out that she was doing so because her cousin Amelia had disappeared (last seen in Marquis' care, as he was her father) at... hey, wait a damn minute, around the same time as Marquis was attacked by New Wave and the New Wave family adopted some girl named Amelia who they claimed Marquis had kidnapped. (Really I've got to wonder about that. Having Marquis falsely convicted of kidnapping her creates a paper trail that is not good for them.)
 
They can't send people to prison for breaking an informal agreement.
Correct.

The Endbringer truce, outside of the battles themselves, is enforced by the PRT ignoring all the other villains going after the trucebreaker.

Surprisingly enough, most villains rely on there being SOME kind of rule of law to prevent their enemies from just making an open attempt to oust them from their territory.

For reference, a similar treatment can be seen happening to the ABB after Bakuda did her city wide bombing rampage. She crossed the line, the PRT looked away, and then every villain in the city went after the ABB and destroyed it.

So it's enforced more or less via allowing an lynch mob to happen. Crappy world isn't it?
 
One thing people are likely overlooking however is that the Endbringer Truce exists to try and encourage people to help fight the Endbringers, and therefore mainly protects them and their assets. While it does mean an increase in cape activity in general, it is unlikely lynch mobs would form to take down some capes fighting that are both from factions providing no support in the Endbringer fight.

That said, that isn't the situation here. After all, Taylor is going to join the Endbringer fight. As such the Truce would be more likely to protect her than Skidmark, Squeeler, and Mush unless they suddenly decide to help in the fight as well. She is after all showing up to volunteer as well as turn them in rather than just calling in PRT/dropping them off and then going on her way to the rally point. While true that Skidmark and Squeeler might try claiming that she took advantage of the Endbringer Alarm to beat them, she could claim the battle started before, and that they continued attacking her when she tried disengaging to attend, forcing her to finish the fight. As she'd be showing up for the fight, and Skidmark, Squeeler, and Mush expressing no interest in doing so, odds are people would side with her so long as the Truce is concerned.

owrtho
 
At the same time, the PRT has little in the way of security or logistics for handling captured capes when mobilizing for an Endbringer battle, so handing them in would either lead to them being set free with a warning, or in their escaping on their own while security is weakened..
 
At the same time, the PRT has little in the way of security or logistics for handling captured capes when mobilizing for an Endbringer battle, so handing them in would either lead to them being set free with a warning, or in their escaping on their own while security is weakened..
Um, no? They've got the PRT troopers, the technological defenses, and all the capes that aren't allowed to fight Ziz. Which is quite a few.
 
omake - spellcasting
fake science ahoy!

omake - spellcasting
Before we begin delving deeper into advanced spellcraft we must touch on some of the history of this noble art. The earliest examples of which belong to the Asura and Deva civilisations found on the ruins of their home world Midgard. Unusually neither race was truly human despite similarities. These early magical pioneers via long and complicated song, instinctively shaping mana flows into the desired form. As should be obvious this led to long cast times for all of their spellwork, and was highly dependant on initial conditions. This unregulated type of spellcasting also led to the destruction of their world, we will never know what the intended purpose of the spell that ended all life on Midgard, but evidence suggests a runaway mana reaction of exponential growth that folded parts of their very planet into the dimensional sea, lost for all time and space.

Al-Hazard Spellcraft is safe, sensible and sane in comparison, mana is manipulated via a focus, be that Wand, Stave or more esoteric means. Imparting the necessary Mass, Energy and Motion needed for spellcasting, often accompanied by a short chant to focus the caster on the finer internal manipulation of mana through their linker core. None of these steps in inherently unreasonable, or generally unsafe on their own, but as should be obvious, developing new spells in more a case of trial and error than anything else. Al-Hazard spellcrafters tended to stumble upon new spells more by accident than design, as described in the few surviving texts discovered.

The modern spellcasting method relies more on understanding the very fundamental nature of mana, or quantum dimensional interface rejection reaction to use the more scientific term, can be manipulated via the three forms. Mass, the act of pulling mana into a cohesive, dense whole. Energy, the act of "heating up" the mana, making it far more reactive. Motion, the actual shaping of the spell into it's purpose, this is a delicate step as the difference between spells of widely different functions can be quite similar to the untrained novice.
Each step can be broken down into mathematical formulae, allowing casters to quickly shape mana into spells, with repeatability being extremely high as each calculation only varies by a small amount.

As should be apparent, the mathmagical calculations become more complex as spell complexity increases, it takes less effort to throw balls of mana around than to perform even a localised dimensional fold. Computational devices are almost a necessity for higher tier magic, though an experienced caster may be able to cast them without a device, only a true savant will be faster without a device than with.



Dimensional Transfer and other long range movement magic...
 
Are any Empire capes going to the Simurgh fight? And if so, will there be any nazi accusations aimed at Taylor, if she ever speaks belkan/"german" with them? I can just imagine her blowing up fantastically at the accusers, ranting about how nazis are scum and her language has no bearing on her views.
 
OK guys, everyone has had their say about the unwritten rules.
Time to back away from the discussion.


By Author Fiat the Endbringer Truce is law, actually a subsection of the International S-Class threat Treaty.


Please if you want to argue about the Endbringer truce, this isn't the thread for you.
I wont argue with anyone about it. If you want to continue please do it elsewhere, and don't include me. I don't care.
 
Are any Empire capes going to the Simurgh fight? And if so, will there be any nazi accusations aimed at Taylor, if she ever speaks belkan/"german" with them? I can just imagine her blowing up fantastically at the accusers, ranting about how nazis are scum and her language has no bearing on her views.
Not sure. I know Kaiser attended the Leviathan fight, but it's happening on his turf and he couldn't just ignore it without losing authority.
 
Are any Empire capes going to the Simurgh fight? And if so, will there be any nazi accusations aimed at Taylor, if she ever speaks belkan/"german" with them? I can just imagine her blowing up fantastically at the accusers, ranting about how nazis are scum and her language has no bearing on her views.
I'm also waiting for a national socialist scum rant, in german.
 
Excellent question, really. All we know is, Belkan devices speak German, while Midchildan devices speak English, and all the human-types speak Japanese. In space.

No, we, the viewer, see the device speaking in English/German/whatever. (let's forget the everyone speak japanese for a time, because that certainly wouldn't be the only series that fell victim to such a thing) It's a decision to give a certain style to device style, but really does not give any indication on what language they actually speak.
 
Unwriten laws.

By name it says that they were never writen down, thus it can not be part of some goverment law or treaty, since that would mean they were infact, writen down.
 
I'm find with them speaking German if the Belkans that ended up on Earth settled in Germany. Having Belkan == German would break my SoD. For Nanoha canon ^^ (what Bki said) is my head canon.
 
My general headcanon for Belkan was that it is a language that is supposed to sound like German and has some of the same 'rules' so they just used German in the show to avoid having to invent a new language.

As a result when Annette ended up on Earth, German was the closest language that felt 'right' and she used that for her 'native tongue'.
 
Unwriten laws.

By name it says that they were never writen down, thus it can not be part of some goverment law or treaty, since that would mean they were infact, writen down.

The problem is there's no indication in canon that the Endbringer truce - under which the Protectorate purported to have the right to have Taylor put in the Birdcage for learning Sophia's identity, is actually part of the unwritten rules rather than being a real law that is legally binding.

As a result when Annette ended up on Earth, German was the closest language that felt 'right' and she used that for her 'native tongue'.

Doesn't really make sense... she'd still have to learn German, and at that point it'd be simpler to just learn English (which she also did). It seems pretty clear that, as little sense as it makes, Belkan really is German in this fic.
 
Last edited:
The problem is there's no indication in canon that the Endbringer truce - under which the Protectorate purported to have the right to have Taylor put in the Birdcage for learning Sophia's identity, is actually part of the unwritten rules rather than being a real law that is legally binding.
To me it sounds like the Endbringer truce was part of the unrwritten rules that got made, in some form, into actual law. It's necessary for it to exist for there to be the large collaboration for the Endbringer fights we see. For the PRT to be able to openly act on it it needs to be legal for them to do so.
 
Language in the Nanoha universe is inherently magical: incantations have magical power.

The aliens from the TSAB speak perfect Japanese, and so does the British admiral.

I have no problem with subtle cross-dimensional harmonics influencing human language into analogous forms even between branches of humanity who have no reason to speak the same language.
 
So to bring this away from the wrath of the Mods, how do you guys think Simurgh plans are going to completely implode in its face?
 
Back
Top