Magical Girl Raising Project Mafia Game
- Thread starter Andelevion
- Start date
- Mafia
-
- Tags
- fun times ahead mafia murder
- Location
- Central Standard Time
Assembler also can't be the cleaner, if one exists.
Of course, that's invalid if MrEgret is colluding.
- Location
- Massachusetts
I just have a question for everyone voting for either Pawn or myself.
Why is there a split in the vote? If the idea of a Maf power bloc between us is that concerning, then wouldn't it make sense to just go after one of the suspects at a time? Power role or no, wouldn't that make the game end sooner if your suspicions are correct?
Why is there a split in the vote? If the idea of a Maf power bloc between us is that concerning, then wouldn't it make sense to just go after one of the suspects at a time? Power role or no, wouldn't that make the game end sooner if your suspicions are correct?
Mortifer
Embrace your inner lunatic. Fun times guaranteed.
- Location
- Under a rock.
Oh wow, the vote tally's acting up in a Mafia Game? If only there was a way to count votes without the automated process so we didn't need to put more effort into making the automated process work only to have it mess up anyway
And you guys wonder why I didn't caer much for it?
@Bahn
If you happen to survive this day and night, how about asking something about LDJ or Joe? Can always ask if LDJ was cleaner or not, if Joe self-cleaned or not if BunnyLord told the truth... Or, if they can lie to you, ask others if either admitted to such.
@Bahn
If you happen to survive this day and night, how about asking something about LDJ or Joe? Can always ask if LDJ was cleaner or not, if Joe self-cleaned or not if BunnyLord told the truth... Or, if they can lie to you, ask others if either admitted to such.
Bahn
:D
- Location
- :D
I already asked Andelevion if the dead could lie to me if they so wished. Andelevion confirmed my suspicions of such.
That's why two of three of my Actions have been to ask verified dead innocents. The only one that wasn't verified innocent was my N1 question to JBJ.
To be honest, I don't feel MrEgret is the right answer. For one, he revealed his power quite early. Second, we know who he aimed for each night.
Aiming for Assembler N1 might have been weird, but it could still have been justified under disbelief of claim. Furthermore, accusing him cannot stand under a 'One killer left' theory because then, he always had someone vouching for him for power use each night.
Regardless, the moment no one claim to have been role-blocked is the moment we either lynch him, his target that night (if lying accusations from Egret) or I kill him if he happen to be guilty.
@Nanimani
If you want my opinion, either Bahn or Mortifer should be checked by you next night. Depending on who is being lynched anyway.
Aiming for Assembler N1 might have been weird, but it could still have been justified under disbelief of claim. Furthermore, accusing him cannot stand under a 'One killer left' theory because then, he always had someone vouching for him for power use each night.
Regardless, the moment no one claim to have been role-blocked is the moment we either lynch him, his target that night (if lying accusations from Egret) or I kill him if he happen to be guilty.
@Nanimani
If you want my opinion, either Bahn or Mortifer should be checked by you next night. Depending on who is being lynched anyway.
Of course, that @MrEgret (and @Assembler as well) still have less posts than BunnyLord is rather infuriating...
Nanimani
Probably listening to music
- Pronouns
- She/Her
...
[X] Vote Pawn Lelouch
Can't help but notice every plan you propose involves me investigating you specifically. Generally, it isn't a good idea to go with one of the small number of suspects telling you to investigate them pretty consistently. Gives that GF impression.
How about, instead, we lynch you, have Anon direct Mort at Assembler who uses his power, me investigate Bahn, and depending on if you turn up with the wrong color or not, either have Megaolix not act or use his power on MrEgret?
Nanimani
Probably listening to music
- Pronouns
- She/Her
Okay, consider this: I don't believe the one killer left theory. Like, I can accept it as a possibility, sure, but it isn't #1 on my suspicion list. So of course I still suspect him, as I can most certainly believe there's a possibility there's more than one killer.
If the following players survive and the killer is still not found, I would propose thus:
MrEgret lock Bahn.
Nani investigate Bahn
Anon redirect Assembler on Bahn
Mortifer watch me.
That would, once and for all, clear that duo, as well as severely limits the killer's options to act without being caught.
I'm starting to think killing Redshirt was not out of strategy, but more of desperation because the killer NEEDS shady players alive to blend in.
Nanimani
Probably listening to music
- Pronouns
- She/Her
Why would you redirect the protector? Use it on Pawn Lelouch. You know, like someone who wants to let the protector do their job.
Because there are enough issues that I cannot trust that duo yet. For all I know, the actual 'vest' could confer protection from your investigation too.
- Location
- Central Standard Time
Then why redirect Assembler to Bahn and investigate Bahn?
Also, I'm probably next :/
Also because I want to absolutely lock the duo, in case we have two killers alive. And suppose Pawn is lynched and not the killer... Well, Bahn is protected like this.
And if a kill still happen regardless? Well, that will fall down to either Mortier or Nanimani. Bahn will be protected that way. The killer cannot afford to get me if Mortifer is watching me. Nani cannot die that way either since doubt would fall only on Mortifer. Same for Mortifer as Nani would be only suspect left. if Assembler die? If innocent, should clear Bahn who will tell if Egret did block him. Basically, if we're not catching the killer now, I want to absolutely corner him.
Well, if bahn is locked, Nani could alwasy investigate someone else, I guess.
It probably sucks that yes, you're the only safe to target. Maybe you should think who is evil harder?
@Pawn Lelouch
At any rate, the reason Nani voted for you to makes me wonder. Perhaps you should ponder yourself who is evil? Because you're kinda... The best sacrifice to make today, really.
That or we lynch Alpha and force the killer to act on Innocent lefts.
- Location
- Massachusetts
If we redirect Assember's protection to Bahn and investigate Bahn, and Megaolix's theory that the vest blocks investigation is true, then that should be proof enough that they're not on the level, right? Because I'm rather dubious of an ability that blocks investigation being entirely benign. If I recall, investigation immunity is traditionally a Mafia ability.
No exactly since it would make Bahn read Innocent no matter what.
I suppose that really, Nani could read someone else. Maybe Mortifer or you, Egret.
Nani seems to believe there are still two mafs acting out there to explain evading blocks and redirects. I'm not so sure myself. And given abilities at play, I wouldn't be surprised by some immunities being in play.
Of course, I'm still not too sure about Nani either.
Blargh, you confused me. The vest blocking reading is just a wilder theory of mine. I'm not too sure about it. But I suppose we don't really need both Assembler protection and Nani's reading on Bahn. Assuming both are legit of course
Nanimani
Probably listening to music
- Pronouns
- She/Her
But seriously, if there's only one alive, RB one, redirect the other to the RB'd one. Simple, easy.
Despite the fact I was redirected last night. You go with thinking there's only one mafia, and you find one of the four people who can't have killed in that situation suspicious. You consider "But what if the vest blocks investigations" as a way that maybe my investigation was fooled, but then you think sending me at the person who'd have that vest on them tonight is in any way a good idea.
You're really kinda fucking up here, and it's getting me annoyed. Can you not see the contradictons in what you're spouting?
Yes, I'm fully aware you just can't give that up. You know.
Despite the fact I was redirected last night. You go with thinking there's only one mafia, and you find one of the four people who can't have killed in that situation suspicious. You consider "But what if the vest blocks investigations" as a way that maybe my investigation was fooled, but then you think sending me at the person who'd have that vest on them tonight is in any way a good idea.
You're really kinda fucking up here, and it's getting me annoyed. Can you not see the contradictons in what you're spouting?
Mortifer was redirected N1
You were redirected N3
Assembler was stated by you to be Innocent.
Quite frankly, if Pawn comes up Innocent, then I'll be forced to believe there's an immunity at play. That or Anon and you are colluding.
Nanimani
Probably listening to music
- Pronouns
- She/Her
Or you're wrong about there only being one person. That is also possible.