Magical Girl Raising Project Mafia Game

What's your opinion of the game so far?


  • Total voters
    27
More like, do you force someone to use their ability or is it merely redirection if they DO use it?
"I just, like, make them confuse people you know? They may think they are murdering their target when in fact it may be their best friend."
 
Then get Anon to get Bahn to target the person being protected. Killing a dad's kid seems very much like the kinda thing that'd get Revenge Modo activated if you're wrong.
Still, even if I'm being agressive, I can't deduce much more at this point unless our suspects confront each other.

I still have doubt about LDJ being legit either. Unless we see another color, LDJ's death scene had... strange stuff in it. And we cannot ignore the possibility of being investigation-immune.
 
I'm starting to feel an urge to stab someone. Accusations are stated, doubts are laid... And you guys don't talk fuck all about it or lay out your own thinking.
 
Sounds like a Survivor's goal...but you already claimed a investigation type role IIRC?

That's me mixing my IC trait of being a big fan of stories with my OOC trait of being a huge coward :V


You know, a two-maf group and a serial killer sounds like, uh... Not enough?
Two two-maf groups I can see.
[X] MrEgret

Mort, please switch your vote. Let's be honest, you're not getting Megaolix up, and it'd be bad if you could. Yeah, he's being aggressive, but that's how he's always been.

Formatting is hard on phone, remind me in a few hours so I don't forget when I have laptop access.
 
I'm starting to feel an urge to stab someone. Accusations are stated, doubts are laid... And you guys don't talk fuck all about it or lay out your own thinking.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but what have you said, beyond "Remember the Yan Idol" again?
I still have doubt about LDJ being legit either. Unless we see another color, LDJ's death scene had... strange stuff in it. And we cannot ignore the possibility of being investigation-immune.
Other than this, which, I mean, okay? Not really much I can do about it other than uncheck Mort from my "Not as sus" list. Frankly, I'm not quite sure I care which of the three die today.
 
Wondering about if a pair or one lone mafia is left. Wondering if Mortifer is legit or not. Wondering if immunities are in play here.

My thoughts are circling so much, I'm back to suspecting you a bit once more.
Can I advise you to take a break, maybe eat something nice? Sometimes you need to take a small break and keep your mind clear. Generally, it's when you start noticing the headache.
 
Can I advise you to take a break, maybe eat something nice? Sometimes you need to take a small break and keep your mind clear. Generally, it's when you start noticing the headache.
It's not an headache. rather, I have nothing to mull over.

This is a social game, jeez! And people are not posting! How the hell I can try to tell who is acting sus and not if no one post?!
 
I'm starting to feel an urge to stab someone. Accusations are stated, doubts are laid... And you guys don't talk fuck all about it or lay out your own thinking.

Sorry, I just got off of work and a ten minute break isn't enough to really lay out my thoughts out of what is known.

So, assuming the pair is legit (Or Bahn is secretly a murderous vigilante), that means either Mortifer is evil or the MrEgret/Pawn Lelouch pair is lying.

So the people that have some suspicions against are me, MrEgret, Mortifer, Assembler, and Bahn. I think that Assembler is only being suspected because of Bahn so I'm not not really considering them as a potential lynch target. Bahn is suspicous because we don't have proof that of his night actions, I'm suspicous because MrEgret could be covering for me, MrEgret might be covering, and Mortifer hasn't actually seen anything useful.

How about we do a similiar setup to what we tried last night? Anon directs Mortifer towards Assembler who uses the vest on themselves and Nanimani investigates me with one of MrEgret or Bahn being lynched tonight.

My thoughts on this is that currently Mortifer is considered the most suspicious but has the most useful power out of all of us if true so we give him a chance. If the vest is broken we lynch him tomorrow and if not then we look at the other suspect list.

Out of us three me and Bahn likely can't really react to Anon's power if we are telling the truth about our stated powers though MrEgret can so I want one of us to be investigated by Nanimani. I'm pretty sure LDJ was a cleaner with investigation immunity (why else has there only been one kill flavor which would narrow down the suspect list of the killer heavily?) so Nanimani's investigation should prove to be solid.

Out of the three of us Bahn has probably the weakest story and possibly the weakest power so I'd argue to lynch him today and have Nanimani investigate me tonight. If me and Mortifer both check out then MrEgret isn't looking so hot tomorrow. I do believe that MrEgret is a roleblocker but I'm iffy on if there is one or two mafia members left so he could be a mafia roleblocker which would have the single kill flavor still make sense.
 
Out of the three of us Bahn has probably the weakest story and possibly the weakest power so I'd argue to lynch him today and have Nanimani investigate me tonight. If me and Mortifer both check out then MrEgret isn't looking so hot tomorrow. I do believe that MrEgret is a roleblocker but I'm iffy on if there is one or two mafia members left so he could be a mafia roleblocker which would have the single kill flavor still make sense.
As pointed out however, Assembler may not take well IC the lynching of his 'daughter'. Unless proven evil anyway.

I suspect Mortifer because he has yet to give a solid argument. On another note, There may be 'confusion immunity' in play regarding Anon, which is why I would suspect Nani. Far reach, I know, but I gotta build a theory on everyone before breaking down who is less likely than another.
 
Don't mind me, I'm dealing with grief the only way I can - grief seeds by sleeping it away.
Participate already. You may be next if killer judges it's important to kill survivors.

Anyway, I'll rethink what i think.

-Those I believe I can trust-
AlphaDelta: Do I even need to explain at this point?
MrEgret: Frankly? Because of what happened N2. TPK was judged too dangerous to live. He also vouched for me while I did not state my power yet. If he was part of mafia, he should have blocked TPK, who had stated his power, while I would have been killed, whose powers were still unknown except that I did not go out. Or anyone else, really.
By virtue of trusting MrEgret: Pawn lelouch. if I believe Egret legit, then i should believe his claim to have roleblocked pawn N3.
Anon: Random redirections, no obvious stated evil action taken.

-Those I still doubt-
Nanimani: Admitted to visiting deads N1, and N2, but could have been taking refuge in audacity. Unverifiable actions. Odd power given picture shown. Certainly looks like someone who would have done the killing flavor. Was redirected by Anon N3, but maybe confusion immune?
Mortifer: SHOULD have observed TPK N2, but didn't. Unverifiable actions. Seelie name is a kind of fairy and those can be pretty cruel too. One thing going for him: Being redirected N1 by Anon. But partner could have been doing the crime.
Bahn/Assembler: Daughter and Father? Could certainly be bullshitting. Could be family wanting to come out alive at any cost. Have been the most useless duo yet. Assembler did not wish to protect TPK N2. Assembler cleared by Anon, but could desire of protecting daughter override guilty check?

Those are my feelings. Maybe I'm wrong. Maybe I'm right. but keep this in mind: TPK was aimed at by BOTH killer groups N2. DESPITE logic dictating someone else with a power could be watching/protecting given claimed role. He was judged too dangerous to leave alive.

It's a bit telling by itself.
 
Current Vote Tally

Mortifer - Megaolix
Pawn Lelouch - Anon
Megaolix - Mortifer
MrEgret - Nanimani
 
[-] Unvote Megaolix
[X] Vote MrEgret

There you go Nani.

I suspect Mortifer because he has yet to give a solid argument.

That's because there is no solid argument. Apart from the fact that I was redirected into someone and that someone didn't die, which only clears me of having killing powers, I have nothing to back me up apart from saying "X wasn't visited."

Like, I don't know what you're expecting here. I haven't seen anything useful. I might be able to tomorrow, but for now, nothing. Nobody I've watched has been visited, and at this point I kinda wish I didn't promise to watch you so that the night killers felt safe to take you out. Because all that promising to keep an eye on you that night seems to have done is have someone insist I'm suspicious, to the point of changing your answer as to why every time you bring it up.

Yeah, I'm suspicious. There's no proof I'm good. There's no proof I'm evil, but (I'm incapable of giving a reason why I'm good/None of my Night Actions are verified/I was quiet a lot in the first few days so I dug myself into a hole), pick one for whatever reason you're using in your next argument.


Seelie name is a kind of fairy and those can be pretty cruel too.

Are we really using my name as evidence that I'm evil now?

Okay, lets unpack that a bit.

The etymology of the word Seele comes from old languages, from words that meant 'Happy,' 'Lucky' or 'Blessed.' The Seelie Court of Fae was in contrast to the Unseelie, derived from words meaning 'Unhappy, Misfortunate, Unholy'.

The main contrast of the Seelie and Unseelie is between Dark and Light. The Seelie are the Light, and these are the fairies who help humans, reward kindness, and give warnings if accidentally offended. Yet, they are prone to mischief and will avenge insults, but these are the good guys of the fairies. Their main issue is not realising how their pranks might effect humans.

The really cruel ones you're thinking of are the Unseelie, who will attack without being offended, beat travellers, killed cattle, and the closest they had to benevolence was when they'd grow fond of a human and decide to keep it as a pet.

There are ways to spin Seelie as evil, yes, but its hardly 'The Seelie Court is full of cruel fairies so someone named Seelie is really suspicious.' It's a name. It's no more inherently suspicious than any other names.
 
Hmmm. And what about your own ideas of who is the killer?

I'm almost ready to suggest to block Bahn, redirect Assembler and Nani watch Bahn if only to clear that duo completely. But that still leave us with who do we lynch today.
 
I'm almost ready to suggest to block Bahn, redirect Assembler
Blocking me I can understand, since my Night Action is hard to clear/check.
Redirecting the protection role though? Wut...just why? Assembler was even RB'd on N1 when two kills happened (JBJ and LDJ).
Assembler - Roleblocked on N1 so can't be the SK.
That should clear him of any KILL powers as of now (which are the ones we should be looking out for most at this point).

It doesn't make sense to me that you're ignoring the work put into the list now when before you referenced it a good bit.
Like here:
Going to take your list from before since it still apply.

Why does it not seem to apply anymore?

*Paranoid cap on*
 
Back
Top