"Best choices" is a little tricky. For instance, the little extra pay we get from our region is definitely suboptimal compared to the massive stat bonus you get from being from the capital, but it also influences our estate's income in the next book, possibly to the tune of thousands of gold. Plus it affects your political allegiances, project choices, etc.

And while there's a more-or-less optimized path through Sabres, Guns and Lords are a lot trickier. For example, I like to have a big investment in the rifles. But that means my character has to go to the capital to make sure the army buys the guns. If you want a playthrough where you stay on your estate to micromanage it, a rifle investment is largely useless. Our choice with decorations boosted our troops' morale at the cost of our reputation. Do you want to go all-in on making Hunter a saint? Would you rather pal around with Catarina or Cassius? Pay off some estate debt, or have cash on hand? Which romance to pick? Which endgame goal to pursue?
 
Last edited:
The other 2 would either make the ambassoder seem weak and phatitic, or make us seem cowardly, thus this one is the least likely to piss him off.
[X] "It would only be sensible to fear an enemy that so outnumbers us, Your Excellency."
 
Guns 7.10
[X] "It would only be sensible to fear an enemy that so outnumbers us, Your Excellency."

"Numbers?" Lord Cassius replies incredulously. "You would hide from a force which, I have been assured by your Lord Havenport, is inferior in both drill and equipment to yours, simply because of numbers?" He shakes his head and mutters something under his breath, something which you do not quite catch.

"I beg pardon, Your Excellency?" you ask.

"The Richshyr does not put stock in numbers. A Takaran officer always expects themself to be outnumbered and is taught that any foe, no matter how great they are in size, can be mastered," Lord Cassius replies. "Then again…" He waves his perfectly manicured fingers dismissively. "You are not a Takaran officer, are you?"

The comparison rankles in your mind, but the elegant diplomat is already moving on and heading for the door. "Regardless, there is no point in arguing over the matter now. The decision has been made, and there is no point in wasting time further, yes?"

With that, the ambassador walks out into the courtyard and calls for his horse and valet, leaving you alone in the map room.

-​

You depart Fort Kharan that morning.

Over the next few days, you make good progress. Though the trees hem your column on both sides, your outriders report no sign of partisan activity. It seems the Antari are too busy planting their spring crops to give you any trouble.

Instead, a growing feeling of dread haunts you as the days pass. The further you proceed along the road, the heavier the feeling grows. You can see that some of your other dragoons feel it as well, your veterans, those who have been with the army for years: an oppressive pall that dampens the moods of your best men.

Finally, on a morning a week out of Fort Kharan, Lanzerel falls back towards you and your fellow officers from his position at the head of the column.

"It's up ahead," he says, his eyes haunted.

You nod, your own dark mood matching your Staff-sergeant's as the memories of that bloody day in the past well up in your mind once more.

"I don't understand, sir," Blaylock says from your left, looking at the two of you with puzzlement. "What's up ahead?"

Your answer comes out hoarse and brittle, barely louder than a whisper. "Blogia."

Blogia.

Fear and powder smoke, banefire and steel, bloodshed, and death.

The memories strike you like blows to the head, too bright, loud, and too swift to stop. The crack of massed musketry, the hollow thunder of cannon, the trembling of the earth under the iron-shod hooves of Khorobirit's Church Hussars as they swept Wulfram's cavalry from the field in a tide of bane-hardened steel, the wings mounted on their back wailing as they charged home with their monstrous lances.

"Blogia?" Lord Cassius's too-cheerful voice pulls you bodily into the here and now. "Did I hear correctly? We are near Blogia? That is where your Duke of Wulfram was defeated by Prince Khorobirit, yes? Also, it is where you won your knighthood, is it not? I would very much like to see the field for myself." The Takaran's blue eyes sparkle with excitement. "Might you offer me a tour?"

You do not much relish the idea of heading back to that field again, especially if it is merely to indulge a foreign diplomat's curiosity.

Yet, surely, if you were able to impress upon him just how hard and how well your men had fought, perhaps you could win some respect from the arrogant Takaran.

"Perhaps," you reply, though you cannot imagine such a task will be very easy for you.

It wouldn't be an easy thing for your men, either, to see the field where so many fellow Tierrans had fallen. Of course, you suppose you might be able to use their discomfort to your advantage. If you could find the right words, you could turn your dead countrymen from fellows to be mourned into martyrs to be avenged.

That would put fire in your men's hearts and fight in their stomachs.

"Ah, Staff?" Lord Renard pipes up. "The field's safe to cross, ain't it? Been three years, wot."

Lanzerel shakes his head. "No, sir. If the Antari burned the dead after the battle, they didn't do a thorough job. There's bones everywhere."

The young lordling swallows hard, and it takes him a moment to regain his composure. "Ain't proper that. Ought to gather 'em together, those bones, burn 'em up," he says quietly, reverently. "Ain't going to find the Saints if they's left half rot on the ground."

[] I give the battlefield a wide berth to avoid unsettling the men.
[] I'll show my men where our countrymen died to stoke the fires of vengeance.
[] I'll use the opportunity to show off where my men and I fought.
[] I stage a short ceremony of remembrance for our Tierran dead.
 
This would be a good oppturnaity to cremate our dead, impress cassious, and get the respect of our men. Our charimsa is too low to make a speech that'd insipre our men but maybe our actions will win they're loyalty.
[X] I stage a short ceremony of remembrance for our Tierran dead.
 
"The Richshyr does not put stock in numbers. A Takaran officer always expects themself to be outnumbered and is taught that any foe, no matter how great they are in size, can be mastered," Lord Cassius replies. "Then again…" He waves his perfectly manicured fingers dismissively. "You are not a Takaran officer, are you?"
I don't think I'm the only one whos starting to realize that we'd rather be friends with competent anti-social assholes with a penchant for war crimes rather than aloof & incompetent idiots who think being outnumbered is a fun challenge rather than a serious strategic disadvantage that no general worth their salt would ever RUN TOWARDS. I swear, if every officer the Tarkens have is like this then they won't have much of a future as the rest of the world improves its technology to go beyond 1800s warfare. (well by rest of the world I mean us potentially lol).
 
Last edited:
I don't think I'm the only one whos starting to realize that we'd rather be friends with competent anti-social assholes with a penchant for war crimes rather than aloof & incompetent idiots who think being outnumbered is a fun challenge rather than a serious strategic disadvantage that no general worth their salt would ever RUN TOWARDS.
To be fair to Cassius, he's not expecting you to take on Khorobirit's whole army by yourself. However, he is disappointed that the hero who led the Forlorn Hope at Kharangia isn't showing a bit more backbone when the opposition they're likely to face is made up of starving serfs armed with whatever farming implements they brought from home.

However, I do think an elaboration of the Takaran mindset is in order. To quote Paul Wang:

Cataphrak said:
Where the Kian are about doctrine and material superiority, the Takarans are all about will.

As far as they're concerned, all of the careful organisation and the use of specialised weapons which the Kian engage in are crutches to allow a morally, spiritually, and mentally inferior people to stand up against a superior one, and the same sense of racial superiority which acts as a through-line in their civil society and foreign policy shows up here too.

Basically, Takaran officers are given wide latitude to choose when to engage, with the ultimate assumption that where possible, a Takaran formation will try to approach a Kian formation in a way which neutralises an advantage in long-range fire. However, if the choice is between braving the enemy's fire to close in and annihilate them, or withdrawing, there is no choice at all: the Takarans are expected to attack, to weather the rain of rockets and canister without breaking ranks or stride, and to run down the enemy regardless of the likely cost.

Takaran troops are equipped as best as possible to make sure they get through that fire with as few casualties as possible, but ultimately, the emphasis is on facing forward, no matter the odds, gritting your teeth, and going on, even if it looks like it's to certain death - because ultimately, it's an article of faith that Takaran will - Vybarvo'in Geicijin - will overcome any material difficulty, and that it is better to have one, unbreakable sword, than fifty flawed ones.

To the Takarans, trying to find a doctrinal, or a material way around the Kian is worse than cowardice. It's an insult to the will of the Takaran soldier, an implication that they might not have the mental or spiritual purity to press home the attack the way they're supposed to. The Kian are an inferior people with inferior will - if they weren't, they would have held on to their banecasting. In the end, that impurity will mean that they will break and run before the Richshyr does.

TL;DR Takaran warfare relies on an unholy combination of Yamato-damashii and American exceptionalism backed by anime weeaboo bullshit katanas and Prussian discipline.
 
Guns 7.11
[X] I stage a short ceremony of remembrance for our Tierran dead.
You set up camp on the edge of the battlefield and steel your nerves for the trial that is to come. Then, with Lord Renard in tow, you head out into the field of Blogia.

The terrain itself is much as you remember it, but now it is littered with the wreckage of two armies. Wherever you go, the ground is littered with discarded weapons turned to rust by time, scraps of cloth so faded that you cannot even tell if they had once been Tierran orange or Antari homespun, and bones; so many bones that they jut out from the ground in jagged pale edges like a field of stark white grass.

It is difficult enough to figure out whether one bone belonged to a Tierran or an Antari, jumbled together as they are. You must rely upon close inspection: the battered brass of a sabre hilt, the withered strands of a Kentauri sword knot, the shredded ruin of a cuirassier's riding boot, still clinging to the leg of its wearer. Perhaps Elson's bones are among them. Your heart fills with quiet dread each time you sift through the skeletal tangle, lest you find your friend's silver signet ring around a bleached-white finger.

But you do not, and you are not certain whether to thank or curse the Saints for that.

You set the men to building a pyre, not the rough piles of kindling and firewood of the sort used for field cremations but a proper one: carefully cut logs placed crosswise in a square, doused in lamp oil.

By sunset, all is in readiness.

You assemble your men. Linen-wrapped bones in hand, you say a few words of remembrance for the dead. There are no sounds save the whisper of the evening breeze when you place the bundle on the pyre and light the oil-soaked wood. The ceremony itself is all rightness and decorum, but that does not hide the emotion that fills the air, mingling with the smoke as the ashes of the dead are blown skywards by the cold wind.

The pyre burns quickly, but some of your men stand even after the last of the wood burns out, and the embers start to fade. Others come to you, veterans of the battle, their expressions forced into impassivity as they thank you.

You pretend not to see the tears in their eyes.

-​

Throughout the next week and a half, your column continues working its way northwards. At first, you make good progress, leaving the field of Blogia far behind you.

With each passing day, you begin to see the half-skeletal forests around you return to life, fresh, broad-leafed greenery sprouting on branches once denuded by the cold of the fleeting winter. With the warm breeze in your faces and no sign of hostile partisans, you and your men even begin to relax a little in your saddles, free to enjoy the sight of spring returning to the trees and the small hamlets which sit alongside the road as you pass them by. It is rather pleasant, all things considered.

Unfortunately, it also does not last.

The warmth of spring has long since driven the last snow from the roads, but that does not mean your progress is entirely smooth. Not all the snowmelt has drained away, and in more than one place, they have turned the stretches of unpaved dirt road into a glutinous morass, capable of slowing your column to a crawl. It takes nearly a day to cross the first of these bad spots, even though it is barely five hundred paces from one end to the other. Again and again, such setbacks slow your squadron's progress as it heads further north.

Worse is yet to come.

-​

On the fourteenth day out from Blogia, as you are resting and feeding your horses, you find the unmistakable stench of rot emanating from some of the fodder bags. At once, you set your men to throwing out any feed with any sort of discolouration or strange odour.

Ten minutes later, Sandoral approaches you with a sour expression on his face. "I regret to inform you, sir, that almost all of our feed reserves have been fouled: we are down to our last four bales of fodder," he reports.

You do some quick arithmetic in your head. You find yourself frowning at the result. "That would barely suffice for a day's supply."

Your subordinate nods grimly. "The horses will starve before we reach the King's Army, sir."

"Sandoral!" Lieutenant Blaylock pushes his way into the conversation, rare worry plain on his features. "What's this I hear about the horses starving?"

When you and Sandoral explain the situation to him, Blaylock relaxes. "Is that all?" he scoffs. "That's hardly a problem, sir. There are villages all along the road. They've got fodder, we've got guns. Simple enough, if you ask me."

"We ain't footpads, Blaylock," Lord Renard exclaims, inserting himself into the impromptu staff meeting with a pointed look. "Ain't nothing stoppin' us from buying fodder from th' locals, like gentlemen."

"What about food for our men?"

Sandoral shakes his head. "We've still enough food for the men. Barring any major incidents, we'll be able to make it with a little bit to spare, so there should be no need to worry about that, thank the Saints."

"Which ain't help the fact that y'can't feed a horse on hardtack and salt pork," Lord Renard remarks bitterly. "Do that, they get sick." A sheepish pause. "Trust me. I've tried."

"At least it's one less thing we'll have to worry about," you reply.

Your officers nod, though they still wear expressions of unease as they await your decision.

[] "If we ration carefully, our fodder supplies could last."

[] "We'll buy from the locals."
-[] "This is my responsibility as squadron commander; I shall take on the cost myself." (-120 Wealth)
-[] "The purchase of supplies should be the responsibility of each individual troop commander."
-[] "Perhaps we might require each man to take personal responsibility for feeding his mount?"

[] "We can take what we need from the Antari villagers."
 
I don't think I'm the only one whos starting to realize that we'd rather be friends with competent anti-social assholes with a penchant for war crimes rather than aloof & incompetent idiots who think being outnumbered is a fun challenge rather than a serious strategic disadvantage that no general worth their salt would ever RUN TOWARDS. I swear, if every officer the Tarkens have is like this then they won't have much of a future as the rest of the world improves its technology to go beyond 1800s warfare. (well by rest of the world I mean us potentially lol).

Cassius just wants an excuse to get his hands dirty.
 
To be fair to Cassius, he's not expecting you to take on Khorobirit's whole army by yourself. However, he is disappointed that the hero who led the Forlorn Hope at Kharangia isn't showing a bit more backbone when the opposition they're likely to face is made up of starving serfs armed with whatever farming implements they brought from home.

However, I do think an elaboration of the Takaran mindset is in order. To quote Paul Wang:



TL;DR Takaran warfare relies on an unholy combination of Yamato-damashii and American exceptionalism backed by anime weeaboo bullshit katanas and Prussian discipline.

How in God's name are these people a Great Power?

They expect to be outnumbered, they despise the concept of "tactical retreat", and they believe that Takaran Will shall triumph over minor details like canister shot.

As a numerically inferior army with superior troops, it is vitally important that they choose their engagements carefully. It is essential that they withdraw without hesitation whenever the exchange rate might not be in their favor. Instead, we learn that they are expected to scream "Ten thousand years" and charge in against the Spiritually Inferior Cowards. How is this supposed to end any differently for them than it did for the Japanese?
 
How in God's name are these people a Great Power?

They expect to be outnumbered, they despise the concept of "tactical retreat", and they believe that Takaran Will shall triumph over minor details like canister shot.

As a numerically inferior army with superior troops, it is vitally important that they choose their engagements carefully. It is essential that they withdraw without hesitation whenever the exchange rate might not be in their favor. Instead, we learn that they are expected to scream "Ten thousand years" and charge in against the Spiritually Inferior Cowards. How is this supposed to end any differently for them than it did for the Japanese?
The Takarans may be brave to the point of foolhardiness, but they're not stupid. Recall that Takaran officers have a lot of room to decide when to pick a fight. However, when they do commit, they do so with all the fervor of a banzai charge. More often than not, it works, given the bane-enhanced equipment at their disposal, and even if the Takarans do wind up dead to a man, they take a lot of round-ear barbarians with them.

Again, allow me to quote the author.
Cataphrak said:
The Takarans (and Er-venne in general) have, to some extent, earned their arrogance through having the most terrifyingly efficient war machine on the planet. Facing a Takaran army means facing perfectly ordered regiments, each armed with rune-muskets, capable of blocking your musket fire with walls of earth spontaneously raised from the ground. It means facing artillery capable of firing cannonballs that HOME onto your senior officers. It means having to defeat some of the finest heavy cavalry in the world, armed with swords that can shear through blocks of marble effortlessly, wielded by soldiers who have drilled with those same swords for DECADES.

The Takarans really only have one considerable rival: the Kian, who field the largest land army in existence, and were only able to keep up by inventing infantry "fire and movement" tactics and then building their entire army around it.

The Altrichs vam Takara is immensely arrogant because they think that no nation is capable of challenging them except the Kian. After all, without overwhelming numbers, it would take nothing short of an industrial revolution and all of its attendant innovations to create an army capable of matching the Takarans in open combat.

That last bit is not foreshadowing in any way shape or form.
 
TL;DR Takaran warfare relies on an unholy combination of Yamato-damashii and American exceptionalism backed by anime weeaboo bullshit katanas and Prussian discipline.
Ohhh yeah, they're not gonna have a good time when we invent machine guns, barbed wire, and mustard gas, I hope their spirit can help them when they're suffocating from invisible gases, being shredded to paste by razor wire, and torn apart by machine guns.
 
They're also very good at logistics. If the rotten fodder thing happened to a Takaran unit, the quartermaster would be given a ceremonial sword and then left alone.
 
Ohhh yeah, they're not gonna have a good time when we invent machine guns, barbed wire, and mustard gas, I hope their spirit can help them when they're suffocating from invisible gases, being shredded to paste by razor wire, and torn apart by machine guns.
Easy there, Jonny. We're still at a pre-Napoleonic level of warfare here, the invention of the not-Dreyse needle gun notwithstanding.

Also, you all still need to vote. So far, only Laurent has put in a word about how they want to solve the issue of starving horses.
 
The Takarans may be brave to the point of foolhardiness, but they're not stupid. Recall that Takaran officers have a lot of room to decide when to pick a fight. However, when they do commit, they do so with all the fervor of a banzai charge. More often than not, it works, given the bane-enhanced equipment at their disposal, and even if the Takarans do wind up dead to a man, they take a lot of round-ear barbarians with them.

Again, allow me to quote the author.

I understand that Takarans are, man for man or unit for unit, vastly superior to any other nation. I know that they field regiments of absurdly experienced war-wizards. They have tremendous advantages, but if Cassius's description is at all accurate, then they throw those advantages away without a second thought.

If you "don't put stock in numbers", as Cassius says, then you end up fighting battles where the enemy has an absurd numerical and material advantage. Since you field armies of veteran war-wizards, you might win those battles. You might advance through the rockets and the cannonballs and the canister shot. You might rout the enemy and claim the field of battle!

However, all of the Inferior Cowards you killed will be short-lived weak baneless peasants. Of which the Kian have a great many. All of the Courageous Takaran Soldiers who died will be long-lived mighty banecasters. Of which you have considerably fewer.

It's possible that Cassius is just engaging in hyperbole, but the "Invincible Will" attitude leads to a Takaran battalion engaging a Kian division because it would be cowardly to seek a doctrinal or material way around being vastly outnumbered. If Cassius is accurate, and not just being insufferable, then this is Imperial Japan levels of stupid.
 
[X] "We'll buy from the locals."
-[X] "This is my responsibility as squadron commander; I shall take on the cost myself." (-120 Wealth)


I'm voting this way because I think it is in-character, but I want to emphasize that this is abnormal and our superiors would probably slap us on the wrist if they heard about it. In this time period, armies generally live off the land, and paying for what they take is considered unusual. I believe that Wellington paid in Spain, but he was a general for a very rich nation, and he was in friendly country that he wanted to remain friendly.

Given our army's behavior in Antar so far, taking what we want at saberpoint is only natural.
 
Ohhh yeah, they're not gonna have a good time when we invent machine guns, barbed wire, and mustard gas, I hope their spirit can help them when they're suffocating from invisible gases, being shredded to paste by razor wire, and torn apart by machine guns.

We're a fair ways off from that. At best we'll have bolt-action rifles, which might be enough to bring us to parity.

Of course, the Takarans will probably copy those once they realize how useful they are, and start producing them in their factories, which are far better than the ones we have.

That's why I'm anticipating a use-it-or-lose-it war within twenty years. That's just speculation, mind you.

[X] "We'll buy from the locals."
-[X] "This is my responsibility as squadron commander; I shall take on the cost myself." (-120 Wealth)
 
Back
Top