@Pawn Lelouch can you redo your Iso of IH and Shadell for me and tell me what you get from it?
IH is still my primary town read today. IH had been scum reading Meso consistently so the EOD wagon makes even more sense and I do think it was a correct idea within the context of that EOD gamestate.
General impression of Yun is someone feeling highly pressured, and arguing poorly/in bad faith to try to avert it.
This impression is pretty strong right now.
I think I'm more inclined to vote elsewhere today.
This is the only post that is slightly off to me. But even then, this could pretty easily be a case of just reading Yun well, rather than having TMI to give insight onto them.
For Shadell I dislike a lot of her early stuff regarding Zaelix, namely bits like saying he is a bad hit and yet keeping the vote up. And then jumping in on him as the least bad vote, which on Day 1 is frankly a mindset for a vote that hits town way above rand and I'm not sure that she believes that honestly? (Noting to myself in general, TRing Pyrros/Meso, SRing IH/Cyri here)
Personally disagree with Shadell's interpretations regarding GTH stuff, since it is very useful as a way to get a proper idea of where the thread is at, and a better view of the gamestate, where having that out in the open is useful for reads like the Zaelix one and for organizing town. But tbh this section is NAI, since this is the type of thing she's been against in other games. This is more of a personal comment/opinion.
That's kinda it tbh? The points Shadell makes are overall agreeable but don't make me feel super strong in either direction. And at this point I'm just going to ignore the done too much to be scum due to advancing the gamestate enough to be actively detrimental read. On read back there's less here than I thought and while I'm not scum reading her, that first section isn't enough for that, I'm not sure I can town read her with this gamestate being a rough look for all 3 of us by this point. So null.
And I have a kind of recent read of Pyrros town from null. Namely, look at his recent posts. They aren't good in terms of content but that doesn't matter. What I like here is his mindset and how vehemently he defended his views + the reasoning for it. I think that as scum he doesn't go on an impassioned section on why he's right in terms of how he's doing it and theory rather than just saying something minor and/or deflecting. Its something that could easily be received poorly in his position as the most null player in the game from most views, which is something he or a scum mate would recognize.
So I basically am town reading IH and Pyrros, where I think that scum are within Meso/Shadell/you as of yet. I uh, just am having a lot of issues with actually muddling out who the two are in this scenario, which is a concern. But this is where I'm at now.
@Pawn Lelouch @Cyricubed so, dumb idea or not so dumb idea, but I'm worried about the extent of mid-game fatigue we have going, and my inclination is to try to do something to shake things up. Specifically, I was thinking of asking every player to tell us the best reasons to scumread themselves, but I'm a bit worried on what this might entail.
Dumb idea for the same type of reasons that I said Pyrros doing posts about himself were dumb. Just a waste of time that won't give actionable info.
