[X] Your talent tore a hole in the universe and you stepped through.
-[X] Don't bother concealing that you're probably from an unconnected dimension.
[X] Ask more questions of your own.
-[X] What's a Realm?
--[X] Ask her more about traveling dimensions since it seems to be common knowledge.
----[X] Are there any Houses that I should avoid or any Houses that could help?

[Q] Start introducing yourself as 'The Doctor'
-[Q] Find a way to travel in a snazy Blue Police Box
--[Q]Figure out what a Police Box is
 
"I know from years of experience with him that he likes Dragon Age, so there's bound to be a Dragon Age dimension."

Man, how these guys are allegedly even remotely close to expies is beyond me. *cough @Nixeu cough* You're rather short on informati—

...It's the antimagic thing, isn't it? :facepalm: Really? The word used, in part, for historical witch hunters now automatically equals DA the moment antimagic is mentioned? Ffs...

(Not really directed at you, Simon)


I am just going to say that saying "CALLED IT, THERE'S A MAGIC-PHOBIC EVIL TYRANNY IN THIS WORLD" is boasting about one's ability to build elaborate speculative constructs from very slim pieces of evidence, to the point where the speculative constructs cannot possibly be right all the time or even most of the time.

Uh...

Did someone actually say that? If so, I missed it. But yeah, "calling it" doesn't really work when quite a few theories are in play.
 
Last edited:
What language is Melia speaking when she talks to her elementals? I mean, she's got a weird magic translator now, is it turning her words into Elementalese without her notice? Is she speaking in her home language? Do they just understand her when she speaks in Vanessa's language?

It feels like Melia should be asking a lot more questions than we're voting for but I can't think of any good ones other than a general sense of awe about the tech level.
 
What language is Melia speaking when she talks to her elementals? I mean, she's got a weird magic translator now, is it turning her words into Elementalese without her notice?

You don't think there's any such language. You're pretty sure they can recognize specific words and tones of voice, at the very least.



So I've been informed that's not everyone knew about the "Deathworlds Comment." Basically, prior to the creation of this quest, I mentioned (in Ignition, IIRC) that I was considering making all the dimensions deathworlds. I will neither confirm nor deny if this still holds true // if I followed through.
 
Last edited:
I am just going to say that saying "CALLED IT, THERE'S A MAGIC-PHOBIC EVIL TYRANNY IN THIS WORLD" is boasting about one's ability to build elaborate speculative constructs from very slim pieces of evidence, to the point where the speculative constructs cannot possibly be right all the time or even most of the time.

That, or boasting about being able to read Alivaril's mind and derive actionable information from zero or negligible actual evidence other than, say, "I know from years of experience with him that he likes Dragon Age, so there's bound to be a Dragon Age dimension." Which is the kind of thing that leads toward ragequit paths for me, not towards "respect the person who 'guessed' correctly."
I'd never say the latter. I'm terrible at predicting people. Nor is this a Dragon Age dimension. One aspect of it seems to have some parallels. Enough to make an analogy, anyway. Plus, I honestly was more expecting a masquerade.

As for the former...that's a bit more complicated. Again, I never quite guessed that specifically. I don't think anyone did. I just figured there might be a masquerade, or a government with an interest in someone with 'super-powers'.

I also don't expect my speculations to be constantly right. I tend to hypothesize a lot, but that's just what they are: hypotheses. Multiple ones, which could be possible or not. I essentially spit-ball what I think could be, based on the evidence. Usually stuff people haven't already pointed out. If they flop, they flop. Many hypotheses do.
...It's the antimagic thing, isn't it? :facepalm: Really? The word used for historical witch hunters now automatically equals DA the moment antimagic is mentioned? Ffs...
You also used a word for militant religious nuts. Religious nuts+Anti-magic is not a combo I see so often that I have all that many parallels.

Would you have preferred I stick to obscure references to Judaism and the Spanish Inquisition? Or should I just go full on Nazis? Neither of those seem like a more favorable comparison.

...French Huguenots? French Huguenots. If Louis had anti-magic, and the Huguenots had magic. Right. That's a much better analogy, thanks for bringing it up.
 
Last edited:
[X] Your talent tore a hole in the universe and you stepped through.
-[X] Don't bother concealing that you're probably from an unconnected dimension.
[X] Ask more questions of your own.
-[X] What's a Realm?

The way she presented her information thus far seems to me that though she might be biased she is unlikely to be outright lying due to how basic she considers the information. As such we are dealing with a complicated situation where lying to her and having her assume things could come back to bite us. Also we have a important opportunity here to learn more about dimensional travel unless we are dealing with entirely different kinds of dimensions/universes.
 
I somehow didn't catch the anti-magic fields in the update, and in your description I thought it was just "being opposed to the use of magic".
 
You freely admit you're heavily motivated by curiosity.
Now I feel kinda bad for voting "fireworks" over "blood cave". :p
Solar-powered scientific calculator. Heck, even a stack of the tiny cheapo four-function calculators that people hand out like candy at conferences, people would be all over those.
Too bad the digits would be in an alien language. Still, would be popular with various accountants and the like, I imagine. May even replace their digits with those of the calculator.
So I've been informed that's not everyone knew about the "Deathworlds Comment." Basically, prior to the creation of this quest, I mentioned (in Ignition, IIRC) that I was considering making all the dimensions deathworlds. I will neither confirm nor deny if this still holds true // if I followed through.
I'd estimate about half of the worlds being deathworlds. Or all of them being half-deathworlds.
I wasn't aware of any reglious nuts with anti-magic fields in Warhammer. Not that I know Warhammer, beyond some 40k lore.
There are some antimagic people. Religious nuts like to weaponize them.

[x] Your talent tore a hole in the universe and you stepped through.
-[x] Don't bother concealing that you're probably from an unconnected dimension.
[x] Ask more questions of your own.
-[x] What's a Realm?
--[x] Ask her more about traveling dimensions since it seems to be common knowledge.
----[x] Are there any Houses that I should avoid or any Houses that could help?

The answer to the last question is likely to be very biased, though.
 
Last edited:
The last question is rather badly phrased. It would be better to ask "Can you tell me about the differences between the houses?". Melia isn't in a position to be helping anyone and frankly, the houses sound like assholes.

[X] Your talent tore a hole in the universe and you stepped through.
-[X] Don't bother concealing that you're probably from an unconnected dimension.
[X] Ask more questions of your own.
-[X] What's a Realm?
 
Last edited:
[X] Your talent tore a hole in the universe and you stepped through.
-[X] Don't bother concealing that you're probably from an unconnected dimension.
[X] Ask more questions of your own.
-[X] What's a Realm?
--[X] Whats Aura?
---[X] Ask her more about traveling dimensions since it seems to be common knowledge.
----[X] Are there any Houses that I should avoid or any Houses that could help?
 
@curiosity @DB_Explorer @DeepWaters @Bilbo Baggins @Grigori @Demojay and @Thanatanos sorry about pinging all of you but I changed the wording of the House question since it is badly phrased to "Can you tell me about the difference between the houses?" So if you want you can change it to this, keep it the way you voted or don't vote for it since as others pointed out this question answer would be most likely be biased or not even necessary
 
Last edited:
[x] Your talent tore a hole in the universe and you stepped through.
-[x] Don't bother concealing that you're probably from an unconnected dimension.
[x] Ask more questions of your own.
-[x] What's a Realm?
--[x] Ask her more about traveling dimensions since it seems to be common knowledge.
-[x] Ask more about Houses and differences between them.
 
Interesting that the Houses here are extreme traditionalists. I'm guessing part of a mageocracy of some sort before the Inquisition, or perhaps in the distant past before a scientific revolution (they produce complex fireworks) or industrialization. Why do I say this? Because their (apparent, very biased) reaction to an antimagic aura is to try to use a spell through it. You know, instead of a gun or a crossbow or using magic to hurl a boulder.

The Inquisition also likely has more than one trick. But I would say they're also more of a symptom than a cause. If, lots of if speculation in this post, If the Houses are strongly traditionalist and positioned themselves as nobility for thousands of years, then the current state of affairs changed massively before the Inquisition came along in the last few decades. Some big change in the structure of society happened, maybe even a while ago, so that Norms having an opinion actually counts for something now.
 
I somehow didn't catch the anti-magic fields in the update, and in your description I thought it was just "being opposed to the use of magic".
Ah. No, they have anti-magic auras. A fairly logical thing to give your witch-hunters, and it has been done in various other pieces of fiction. It was just the anti-magic and religious language/name that lead me to the Templars.
I'd estimate about half of the worlds being deathworlds. Or all of them being half-deathworlds.
I'd say they're all at least a little death-world. The level to which the population has adapted to the danger may vary wildly, though. Still, unless the danger is new, if there is a population, chances are they've adapted at least a little.
There are some antimagic people. Religious nuts like to weaponize them.
Now that you mention it...yeah, I vaguely remember something about like...rank Omega psykers?
Interesting that the Houses here are extreme traditionalists. I'm guessing part of a mageocracy of some sort before the Inquisition, or perhaps in the distant past before a scientific revolution (they produce complex fireworks) or industrialization. Why do I say this? Because their (apparent, very biased) reaction to an antimagic aura is to try to use a spell through it. You know, instead of a gun or a crossbow or using magic to hurl a boulder.
Eh. Given that the Inquisition also lacks fire-arms (they use knives instead, apparently), that might be for a reason.
The Inquisition also likely has more than one trick. But I would say they're also more of a symptom than a cause. If, lots of if speculation in this post, If the Houses are strongly traditionalist and positioned themselves as nobility for thousands of years, then the current state of affairs changed massively before the Inquisition came along in the last few decades. Some big change in the structure of society happened, maybe even a while ago, so that Norms having an opinion actually counts for something now.
At a guess, I'd say many of the Houses may have buggered off to other worlds, reducing the remaining House's numbers down to a level where they couldn't maintain as much power. They may have subsequently gone underground, as they weren't public enough figures for the Inquisition to find all of them.

Of course, they might always have ruled the world from the shadows, and the Inquisition brought their actions into the light, perhaps breaking their secret control over the world in the process. Maybe that's why the Inquistion is so common and accepted. There are a lot of possibilities here, so we should probably try and narrow it down.
 
Hopefully our elementals aren't injured by anti-magic fields.

It's very worrying that our portals can be detected at range. This suggests that Vanessa is either much better at magic than Morgan or much more alert for specifically portals. I would be extremely surprised if the Inquisitors can't sense the same thing. Every entry to this plane needs to be treated as an insertion into hostile territory and we don't have good enough stealth.

If they have fireworks, they almost certainly have firearms. The tech trees are extremely closely related. This is especially the case if Melia is hearing fireworks with whistles, which are a chemistry thing rather than a mechanical thing and indicate that this civ can do electrolysis.
 
Hopefully our elementals aren't injured by anti-magic fields.

It's very worrying that our portals can be detected at range. This suggests that Vanessa is either much better at magic than Morgan or much more alert for specifically portals. I would be extremely surprised if the Inquisitors can't sense the same thing. Every entry to this plane needs to be treated as an insertion into hostile territory and we don't have good enough stealth.
Honestly, I'd have to say the entry to every plane should probably be treated that way, now that we know that we can be detected. We can't really say for sure if this is the only place with that kind of magic. If we aren't detected, great, but we should at least consider the possibility for every jump.
If they have fireworks, they almost certainly have firearms. The tech trees are extremely closely related. This is especially the case if Melia is hearing fireworks with whistles, which are a chemistry thing rather than a mechanical thing and indicate that this civ can do electrolysis.
Maybe, maybe not. While they are closely related, that doesn't necessarily mean anyone has thought of it. It's odd, but it can happen.
 
Last edited:
[X] Your talent tore a hole in the universe and you stepped through.
-[X] Don't bother concealing that you're probably from an unconnected dimension.
[X] Ask more questions of your own.
-[X] What's a Realm?



.... wait what if we feed a firework to a fire elemental?
 
Maybe, maybe not. While they are closely related, that doesn't necessarily mean anyone has thought of it. It's odd, but it can happen.
At the very least they have grenade launchers, since basically all you need for that is to turn a perfectly normal firework mortar on its side and point it at someone, and finding out that that can kill someone is a completely normal workplace accident when you're just starting out figuring out fireworks.
 
At the very least they have grenade launchers, since basically all you need for that is to turn a perfectly normal firework mortar on its side and point it at someone, and finding out that that can kill someone is a completely normal workplace accident when you're just starting out figuring out fireworks.
Ah, but there's a possibility they simply never actually worked on weaponizing gun-powder. It's unlikely, but if magic was the power of the ruling class for a long enough time, then they may have squashed that idea before it could bear fruit. If so, then use of explosives in weaponry may simply not be something they've thought of, yet. Grenade launchers are also a bit more complicated than that.

Also, the idea for firework mortars seems to have sprung from the military ones, not the other way around. Can't say for sure, but the first mortars were around in the 1400's. They might still be using rockets.
 
[X] Your talent tore a hole in the universe and you stepped through.
-[X] Don't bother concealing that you're probably from an unconnected dimension.
[X] Ask more questions of your own.
-[X] What's a Realm?



.... wait what if we feed a firework to a fire elemental?
Probably the same if you feed a firework to a candle. Firecrackers in particular stay in place when lit and make an explosion that snuffs out the flame.
 
[x] Your talent tore a hole in the universe and you stepped through.
-[x] Don't bother concealing that you're probably from an unconnected dimension.
[x] Ask more questions of your own.
-[x] What's a Realm?
--[x] Ask her more about traveling dimensions since it seems to be common knowledge.
-[x] Ask more about Houses and differences between them.
 
much more alert for specifically portals.
It's probably mostly this one. It sounds like people from different Realms popping in to Earth is a regular occurrence, and she needs to get to them before the Inquisition can. I bet the only reason she makes it is because unlike her, they can't drop everything and rush over. Must be a pain, being on-call to explain to idiots..

Though I am very curious to know what she thinks of Morgan's lesson plans and notes on our Anchor, if her society is straight-up better at magic than his. We'll get to that after we get settled in.

e: I find it funny that we asked for a cooking set and ended up in a location with vastly superior cooking supplies the very next jump.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top