- Location
- Elsewhere
Why what?Dovah whyyyyyy
Clown Academy (Mafia)
- Thread starter Terrabrand
- Start date
- Mafia
- Location
- Florida
- Pronouns
- He/Him
Also I want to point out my CFD reads were flawless. It gave me Rosen + Nictis town and they turned out to be hard town spots.
Clearly a tactic I should use more often.
Clearly a tactic I should use more often.
- Location
- Elsewhere
Also I want to point out my CFD reads were flawless. It gave me Rosen + Nictis town and they turned out to be hard town spots.
Clearly a tactic I should use more often.
Yeah, I think it's still worth lynching you over.
More so now, tbh.
Who was that?You think you can talk? My very first town read - scum the whole time
- Location
- Alabama
- Pronouns
- He/They
Yeah, I think it's still worth lynching you over.
More so now, tbh.
Who was that?
Nani
I also thought BB & Comi were scum, so bad reads abound.
- Location
- United States
- Pronouns
- He/Him
Nani
I was also already dead
<3
- Location
- Elsewhere
Hey, you trusted me for a while, so it isn't all bad.Nani
- Location
- Alabama
- Pronouns
- He/They
Ugh, don't remind me. I don't remember what night, but at one point I thought Oshha was the SK pretending to be vocal town
- Location
- Florida
- Pronouns
- He/Him
Ugh, don't remind me. I don't remember what night, but at one point I thought Oshha was the SK pretending to be vocal town
Watching your paranoia was great tbh.
- Location
- Elsewhere
I mean, I was concerned Oshha was real deepwolf Maf at the end of the game.Ugh, don't remind me. I don't remember what night, but at one point I thought Oshha was the SK pretending to be vocal town
- Location
- Central Standard Time
I mean, I'll be the first to admit that I rely too much on 1. Instinct and 2. Player Isolate Instinct (PII).
Which leads to fun stuff like false positives with confirmation effect.
- Location
- Southampton, Great Britain
- Pronouns
- He/Him
That was a good game and I'm sort of surprised that Town pulled it off. I felt we made some serious mistakes and were on the verge of losing at some points between killing our cop. It must have been frustrating for mafia to see town threw their lot in with the serial killer against them. But it worked for town so I am happy on how things played out.
I'm also still annoyed at Pawn being scummy. Until 1K got lynched, I didn't believe that Pawn was town and thought they were lying about being doctor until they flipped town.
I am also impressed by Tota. They had me fooled up until they roleblocked Ban and I genuinely thought they were a roleblocker miller.
I was also surprised when Happerry flipped town because I was certain there was at least one other mafia left.
And Dovah wasn't lynchproof. I actually thought they were lynchproof, but then mixing in fake powers alongside real power is a good move.
I'm also still annoyed at Pawn being scummy. Until 1K got lynched, I didn't believe that Pawn was town and thought they were lying about being doctor until they flipped town.
I am also impressed by Tota. They had me fooled up until they roleblocked Ban and I genuinely thought they were a roleblocker miller.
I was also surprised when Happerry flipped town because I was certain there was at least one other mafia left.
And Dovah wasn't lynchproof. I actually thought they were lynchproof, but then mixing in fake powers alongside real power is a good move.
- Location
- Southampton, Great Britain
- Pronouns
- He/Him
I would say that you were one of the best players in this game for town, but you grimly pied too many town members for me to say that in good faith.
Happerry
Bat out of Hell
- Location
- Kanto
Well, to be fair...
They were lying about being a doctor.
- Pronouns
- She/Her
Heya everyone. For the record Tota, you played fine. While I personally would have pushed for your lynch because I always want to lynch millers, your play was quite good for a newbie and you did pretty well when backed into a corner. (Maybe remember to be a bit more careful with your language? By the end of the game you were obvious scum solely from the fact that you continually kept using "they" to refer the towns and framing yourself as separate from them. It's not a HUGE deal, because by that point you were well caught anyway, but it's something to keep in mind so that it doesn't happen at a more important time in the future.)
Eh, I think my play this game could have been better. My quickdraw reads were, despite the criticism, not terrible (I think Nani was my major mistake but he played a strong game), but just in general I deeply struggled to get a handle on the game and deal with the pressure on my slot until I got overwhelmed. I'm unsure if I'll join the next game or not, though my ife has settled down at this point. I needed the break, at least. Thanks @Wyatt for being willing to swap in, for what you had to deal with you did a solid job!
Eh, I think my play this game could have been better. My quickdraw reads were, despite the criticism, not terrible (I think Nani was my major mistake but he played a strong game), but just in general I deeply struggled to get a handle on the game and deal with the pressure on my slot until I got overwhelmed. I'm unsure if I'll join the next game or not, though my ife has settled down at this point. I needed the break, at least. Thanks @Wyatt for being willing to swap in, for what you had to deal with you did a solid job!
- Location
- Cincinnati, OH
- Pronouns
- He/Him
I admittedly probably fucked up by not revealing I was the jailer before I died, since I was probably making a lot of clues on being the jailer (and that's why I got hit at night).
- Location
- Florida
- Pronouns
- He/Him
The only really egregious thing was lynching Cyri over Dova. Cyri was basically outed at that point and same with Tota. You kill the wildcard source of kills and then hit the remaining source.
You knew who they were so even a possible lylo was the best option imo.
- Location
- US
- Pronouns
- He/Him
That was a fun game to watch. I changed my mind about Dovah and Pawn each about ten times.
- Location
- United States
- Pronouns
- He/Him
As the second dead in the game it kinda hurt but I did gain more information than I should on my death and was playing with an obviously higher amount of information than basically everyone else at that point. And well personally I have the meta that when I die people stop reading my posts and ideas and it did feel like that happened to me which was as always frustrating if not funny.
On that note @Pawn Lelouch find a way to include that in my Meta Role
.I didn't read all that in depth post death but I was very adamant on the Cyric/QT/
I have to agree, the day Pawn was lynched, you were already fairly clear, but since you lived that night to learn that SK could go through jailing, you should've just revealed because that would've helped a ton for town. Trying to be hidden about it only hurt you because those in the know picked up but those that thought you had a weird theory thought it was just that. You were doomed to die at the point of revealing that "theory" so better to get it out there for everyone.
I don't know how the 5 member scum team started but I think given that theory having weight in the game it wasn't unreasonable to kill mafia first, probably should've been totadile though since they also thought they had jailer alive.
- Location
- Elsewhere
No, in that case there was almost a perfect roadmap to victory after killing the SK. Literally the only wrong choice was Happs, but the scum team was weaker than was thought, so in all cases killing me was the best move.As the second dead in the game it kinda hurt but I did gain more information than I should on my death and was playing with an obviously higher amount of information than basically everyone else at that point. And well personally I have the meta that when I die people stop reading my posts and ideas and it did feel like that happened to me which was as always frustrating if not funny.
On that note @Pawn Lelouch find a way to include that in my Meta Role
I didn't read all that in depth post death but I was very adamant on the Cyric/QT/Nictisscum team and while I was wrong on one, I was surprised both to see scum kill Nictis of all people (who I personally thought was undoubtly suspect at the time of their night kill, and that none really pushed on QT/Cyric for such an amount of time.
I have to agree, the day Pawn was lynched, you were already fairly clear, but since you lived that night to learn that SK could go through jailing, you should've just revealed because that would've helped a ton for town. Trying to be hidden about it only hurt you because those in the know picked up but those that thought you had a weird theory thought it was just that. You were doomed to die at the point of revealing that "theory" so better to get it out there for everyone.
I don't know how the 5 member scum team started but I think given that theory having weight in the game it wasn't unreasonable to kill mafia first, probably should've been totadile though since they also thought they had jailer alive.
- Location
- United States
- Pronouns
- He/Him
Didn't do the math, no chance to accidentally give scum a majority the next day if they were 3 remaining assuming an impossible mislynch?
- Location
- Elsewhere
A mislynch would result in losing, yeah. It was theorized 5v3v1, so lynching Maf made it 4v2v1, worst case next day was 2v2v1, essentially a Town loss, best case was (impossible, but) 4v1.
- Location
- Florida
- Pronouns
- He/Him
If there was 3 remaining they lost if they mislynched Happerry yes.
However the setup was always 5/0 or 4/1. 5/1 never should have been considered a realistic option imo.
And it still offered up better odds than potentially playing kingmaker for sk.