- Location
- a place
Yes, "having power = bad". I've already covered it in both gravity example and pointing out that this universe is already as it is due to powers that are(i.e. fucking Hidden Masters who were never reviled because they are vast universal concept, but because they are cunts). This entire line of discussion is just pointless fucking navel gazing that ignores reality of situation - it is either Hunger happy awesome time, universe remaining in current status quo before getting nuked or everyone dies, the end. It is just clutching at pearls about "but what if we do a bad thing" when the bad thing is already fucking going on.
I mean, crucially, having the power to throw a fireball or whatever isn't what's bad, it the fact that a huge amount of Hunger's power involves social memetic stuff and a passive warping of everything in the world towards his own ends via Rank, which we kind of speck into pretty heavily. Sufficient Rank as far as I can tell is not particularly different then Arthur's potential Golden Chains power, with all the questions about agency and free will that entails.
Too actually be constructive here and bring up arguments I think could actually ameroliate those concerns, I think Pittauro made a extremely good point about the fate and destiny seemingly being preexisting structures here. Moreover, the Surgeon himself proves the threat of a Rank singularity is already possible without progression. Hunger specifically attaining that sort of power might actually make people more able to express autonomy against such external forces then otherwise would because of his preexisting desires for individual freedom and consensus based decision making for things that affect groups of people.
One living in real situation with real consequences. Despite what you people want to claim, Hunger is not omnipotent and his ability to convince people into stuff is not unlimited. We are on hard clock as Dien is exterminating countless innocents because of a dumbass, so we don't exactly have time to sit down and talk. We can't acquiescent to his demands, he doesn't seem keen on listening so the only way is to Cut Through.
And what is there to talk, really? That we should cripple ourselves to Shogun can indulge his rule boner? At this very moment there are entire multiverses of people suffering under yoke of this or that force; crippling ourselves means not being able to help them, which is just unacceptable. Despite what our philosophers want to think, Hunger is a force of good and just like him there are forces inherently malicious to humanity out there. Going "b-but who will watch the watcher" is irrelevant in the face of such suffering.
You can't reason Aobaru out of hole he got Apo's into. At this point it is not even Aobaru, but trying to convince Shogun that he should go against his very nature. Only way I can think of is to make him our lieutenant as we conquer countless realities, but that still doesn't address the fundamental difference between us.
Rihaku did straight up tell us convincing him is a viable strategy and beating him without humilation is enough to get him to join our side. Not proccing Apocryphal onslaught is a pretty realistic goal to have here, and I think your actually making decent arguments to help convince him now that your engaging with what people are saying instead of memeing. For instance -
Yes and no. Apocrypha just pushes thing along, but these were already there. It didn't create Procyon ex nihilo, it was already searching for Letrizia so Apo just pointed it at us. Republic was already looking at Shards and Association was already doing dangerous Astral experiments. Given everything long standing survival of humanity is very much in doubt. There are too many sleeping terrors on this galaxy.
Likewise, Apo targeting us is a good thing. We are capable of fighting and defusing its procs better than many others, which is entire point of being a Cursebearer, taking on the brunt of curses to protect humanity. It sucks locally to be next to cosmic lightning rod, sure, but they will also benefit from our rule in the long run so it works out. And this bears reinforcing - imagine humanity far beyond ours, one that can perceive world deeper than we can, that can feel harder and that can love stronger. The world Hunger has potential to bring is not merely a paradise, but a realm which allows humanity to be vastly more than we are right now. Especially since soon enough we can do a Nameless and undo all damage done by Apo so far anyway.
I actually think this is a really great point to make that I think their'd be value for Hunger to point out IC, and I'll add on to it. Even aside from the shards, look at the Shadowmonster from our first RoE trip which would have threatened the Human Sphere if allowed to possess Aeira that was so far beyond us that our only hope was a nonviolent solution if we didnt scare it was Haeliel's sigil. Even setting aside that the universe here was a powderkeg, their are plenty of things from outside that threaten it from without, and Hunger ruling for a time could do a immense amount to set up protections for it from other outside forces, especially if we can get any defenses to scale as our power does while we continue on to our future geass tasks.