Definitely finite, considering how sharply it scales. Kong himself was an infinite multiverse and he could take a Rank 11 on the basis of match up. It really depends on what it means by "suborn" here. Considering how range doesn't scale anywhere near as quickly as raw power for Rank, it would be much higher than the relative power. That said, considering we sacrificed the Crimson Flare Rank boost, I want to say like... Rank 14-15?
 
Last edited:
Ayt so due to being mentally paralyzed from the on-goings at work, I decided to not think about work and think about the consequences of our past actions.

Which left me mentally paralyzed too because what the fuck, not enough processing power left in my monkey brain.

That said, given the topics of indenture and how Gisena will have to go with us cause remittance and Adorie because of archmage shenanigans and how this what, takes up two slots of mitigation already?

What are we gonna do about Aobaru?

Does the Chains of Fate issue end when we finish our task? Or does it continue onwards if we do end up unable to destroy the Terminator guy as we leave for the next task?

Do we have to bring Aobaru with us? Cause man. Doom of the Baby Sitter right there.
 
That said, given the topics of indenture and how Gisena will have to go with us cause remittance and Adorie because of archmage shenanigans and how this what, takes up two slots of mitigation already?

What are we gonna do about Aobaru?

Does the Chains of Fate issue end when we finish our task? Or does it continue onwards if we do end up unable to destroy the Terminator guy as we leave for the next task?

Do we have to bring Aobaru with us? Cause man. Doom of the Baby Sitter right there.
Do we even want Aobaru to come with us?

I'm honestly unsure.

Gisena is obvious, because "Remittance" AND because, let's be real, she connected with Hunger in a way she basically never did with anyone else in her life. It doesn't matter if you see it as just friendship or potentially romance (though I OBVIOUSLY would push for the romance), I just can't imagine her deciding to stay behind. Especially because she KNOWS and UNDERSTANDS the ultimate purpose of the Accursed.

In her mage-sight Hunger was a constellation of infinite depth, power beyond reckoning extending into dimensions higher and lower, beyond even the furthermost limits of her Nullity. Even his current world-filling might was but a pauper's veneer, tissue-thin shell around the incandescent potential at his core.

The power of Progression was elegant. In the ordering of its forms it spelled out its name for any mind capable of perceiving it, even for those, like Gisena Allria, whose vision was limited to the uttermost shallows of that blazing sea.

The Lathe of Heaven. The object, the symbol, the pattern by whose revolution the world was re-created and destroyed. Fitting heraldry for Hunger's patron, given his ultimate objective. That too was implicit in the Lathe of Heaven, for those who knew where to look.

A kinder world than this.

A kinder world than this.

Also really, she's quite the thrill-seeker, and she'd likely grow bored confined to this little universe, and at some point she'd likely decide to leave it anyway. Might as well do it with a cursebearer at his side, don't you think?



Adorie... my first thought was that we might not have needed mitigation to bring her with us, then I realized the REAL problem.

It's NOT bringing her with us that's the real problem (though that is ALSO difficult, depending on the destination and its metaphysics).

It's Making sure our companions would be compatible with the local laws of reality.

Indenture makes it so that, say, Hunger will NEVER simply die on arrival because he runs on a different set of physical laws (which WAS, for example, mentioned in Even Further Beyond for people from Nameless' potential "internal universes")

Presumably the mitigation is spent not only to have them come with us, but ALSO, maybe even MAINLY, to make them survive in these worlds, and possibly to make their "powers" slightly more compatible with local metaphysics.



In any case, now Adorie is also basically tied to us. I though there was a chance she might have wanted to stay in Nilfel, but I suppose that won't happen anymore... unless, I suppose, we spend a mitigation charge on bringing the whole of Nilfel with us instead, possibly thanks to an equivalent of Heavenly Tomb.



I still think Aeira and Letrizia are likely going to stay here, probably as the new empress and her spy-mistress/ninja-assassin.

Aobaru.. he could either become their "hero unit", or come with us. I think the first is more likely though
 
well, my first thought here was of Rwby's aura/semblances... which makes sense, I suppose.

After all Soul Evocation is basically a Semblance on steroids, and Archmage is "that" up to 11, seeing as it's

It's from Cathedrelion, actually! One's Absolute Territory, or Shroud, is the Light of one's Soul!

mh.. yeah, admittedly the ring has been shown to be able to awaken soul evocations. I should have understood it would have played a major part in awakening Archmage..

But does that really HAVE to result in its destruction? It certainly doesn't feel fair to it.

One thing you guys may be missing here is that it wasn't Hunger who decided to blow up the Azure. Gisena, the person he gave the Azure to, decided that she valued exterminating the Orcish threat over the Ring of Power.
 
So a Shroud equals to your Soul Evocation? Interesting. I wonder if Battle Magic fits into this at all; Unlikely given it had virtually no votes compared to Accretion and Soul Evocative..
 
Unfounded fears of Chains of Fate being procced even after we're done with this task aside, i find it more appealing to have Aobaru stay behind. Letrizia and Aeira too.

They've got their own roles and lives to lead here plus there's no sufficient hook or desire for them to be subjected to whatever bullshit Hunbear gets himself into afterwards.

Is this a ploy to increase word count for the forebear sword and Gisena? Merely a consequence of their genius, really.

'Sides, someone needs to ensure the Cult of Hunger survives. Need those prayer wishes for the cloak of sky after all.
 
Statement was made in jest.

If it turns out to be true though, then certainly it'd be funnier. Wishes for the wishing well, and enough mystical capitalism to make them reality.

Just like how Santa used to make'em.
 
Sure, it will probably be mostly redundant, but there might be some sinergy hidden in it! I doubt it could actually hurt!
Counterpoint: Sticking various magical Goops to your Soul absolutely could hurt. Ordinal Mages, for example, enjoy some benefits from having no other available magic systems.
I'm sorry, is she basically saying that Archmage sort of includes True Quintessence?! :eek2::jackiechan::lol:

Ok, maybe not True Quintessence, as SHE would be making the graces for us.. BUT CLOSE ENOUGH!


..also, "only". :rofl:
Archmage doesn't involve a Quintessence. The findross saturation is a benefit of Sophont Halo, I believe.

One thing you guys may be missing here is that it wasn't Hunger who decided to blow up the Azure. Gisena, the person he gave the Azure to, decided that she valued exterminating the Orcish threat over the Ring of Power.
I really don't think this works to balm the sting of losing Azure. Voting for Archmage is the proximate cause of the loss, what stings is that our Arete expenditure was used to break the ring. I'm not mad about it, now that I understand what happened, but the dodge that "Gisena did it" doesn't really address the underlying surprise that the Blurb's diagetic implementation involved unknown resource costs.

(Personally, I think it was a brilliant way to illustrate some of the potential applications of Artifice. It confirmed that Nova's Pressure alone can be used as a source of power for future gadgets.)
 
I really don't think this works to balm the sting of losing Azure. Voting for Archmage is the proximate cause of the loss, what stings is that our Arete expenditure was used to break the ring. I'm not mad about it, now that I understand what happened, but the dodge that "Gisena did it" doesn't really address the underlying surprise that the Blurb's diagetic implementation involved unknown resource costs.
don't forget that Hunger also agreed knowing what was happening. he wasn't the origin of the idea, but he still basically said 'go ahead' and followed through.
 
don't forget that Hunger also agreed knowing what was happening. he wasn't the origin of the idea, but he still basically said 'go ahead' and followed through.
meh. Hunger gave the Azure to Gisena, and he has never been interested in micromanaging any of his companions. When Gisena proposes to do her Uttermost by sacrificing the source of her first glimmer of non-Nullity magic... he's not really in any kind of position to throw shade.

I like the Archmage more and more, tbh. thinking about what happens if we get something like Prowess (Realm of Evening) is getting me all hyped up. The blurb really wasn't kidding when it described Hunger's new utility suite as Reality Warping. He spent a little time during the first RoE learning to manipulate its basic functions. I hope that the quest survives long enough to see the Realm used to repair the cracks in the FB Blade.
 
I really don't think this works to balm the sting of losing Azure.

It's not intended to 'balm the sting,' it simply wasn't Hunger's plan in the first place. In-universe Hunger did not know how Archmage was to be brought about since it's Gisena's invention, and from Gisena's point of view she would of course take the action with the highest percentage chance against Dien (getting Archmage) if it was feasible. And from Hunger's perspective of course sundering the Azure is more palatable than losing to Dien with all the unthinkable horrors that entails, to say nothing of the personal importance of the task to Gisena. Hunger has always operated from a position of imperfect information; information on 'consequences' given from an omniscient perspective should never be taken for granted.

Ambitious efforts sometimes have risks; surely the voters did not choose to fight Procyon knowing for certain that Hunger would win!

Statement was made in jest.

If it turns out to be true though, then certainly it'd be funnier. Wishes for the wishing well, and enough mystical capitalism to make them reality.

Just like how Santa used to make'em.

Who needs a wishing well? You have Archmage! Mythos itself is merely a facet of Hunger's dominion these days.
So a Shroud equals to your Soul Evocation?

Mm, not really... it depends on how much of Cathedrelion one believes is canon!
 
Losing the Azure is actually quite painful, since Hunger went through the entire Temple arc to get it. The party's capabilities as a whole aren't diminished - rather the opposite, in fact - but Archmage probably should've mentioned a non-Arete cost required to awaken it; some people were against Broken Kaleidoscope simply because it sacrificed the ring. However, it's hard to argue against the exigency of our circumstances. Hunger himself accepted and assisted with the Azure's destruction, so we can only trust his judgment of its necessity, just as he trusted Gisena's.

At least Adorie can appreciate the amenities of Hotel Hunger while he deals with Dien? Recent events have taken a psychological toll on her. A stay in the Realm of Evening would be beneficial if time passes for her while the party's outside (might not be the case if it's similar to Heavenly Tomb), especially with the Mental Stability aspect of November Sky in play. She can continue to contribute without being exposed to Dien's machinations; even the ivory tower isolation of her youth is made retroactively meaningful.

It's an elegant solution, as is implementing Archmage by applying Hunger's control over the Realm of Evening to reality itself. Training to control its functions should translate to power beyond its confines now. It's (pleasantly) surprising that we received the Sky in process. Whether that was a Wish or not, it's worth considering Heavenly Tomb and/or the Imprisoner's Refinement Praxis line to see if that aspect can be improved upon. Gaining proficiency with our expanded capabilities is probably going to eat up Arete, though.

We're presented with a paralyzing plethora of options: calling upon monstrosities like the Epochal Thing, repairing the Blade, amplifying his own cognition, reverting or even reverse-engineering Dien's creation for augmentation, manifesting findross singularities to be subsumed by the Sophont Halo, etc. It's going to take time to get a sense of Hunger's newfound limits, though that's a good problem to have. I've always liked the Cloak's aesthetics, so Archmage being a stealth Evening Sky option takes the sting out of losing.

Hunger being the Forebear was guessed back when OaF first appeared as an advancement, but good god it's gratifying to see the theory confirmed at last! Fortunate that Never Better was victorious, can you imagine the cognitive dissonance of Just a Moment when this bomb dropped? Fine was flat-out wrong. Those versions of Hunger might never have unlocked OaF II, and we'd have been left wondering. It's a testament to the writing's strength that a mage option winning feels thematically compatible with this revelation, though I assume it would've been disclosed regardless of which option won.

This could be an opportune time to pull a partial Pittauro and reread the quest, to see which passages have gained new nuance; the Light of the Soul is also the light of hindsight. Speaking of looking back, I really enjoyed Away and regret that it dropped at a time when I wasn't able to spare much time and energy to comment on it. It's beautiful, blurbs and all. Burning Mirror of Desire is also kind of terrifying, since the Seal of Odyssial being broken means Nilul might be able to target Uly with it.

Moon musing on the potential rehabilitation of the Yozis was a nice callback to the Malfean project groups at the tail end of the Odyssey. Perhaps the Unshattered Kaleidoscope encompasses Shards where that takes place, but reform is reserved for entities with the wisdom not to court their own destruction. Attacking Odyssial's children is an achievement worthy of a Darwin Award. This is simply natural selection in action; Dien would be proud.

Qaf's defection and Sacheverell's suicide are fitting reactions to Odyssial's Scouring of the Shire Malfeas. The former's 'indenture' paints the amusing picture of the All-Piercer as a Cursebearer getting Geas tasks, which would be strange for all involved. The interlude contains a lot of other tantalizing tidbits, like the HMK having expanded to encompass nearly all of probability space. Pretty cool, but also pretty concerning, especially since Odyssial considers him disturbing. Could be reflective of the Lunar focus on Attributes as opposed to Skills, being rather than doing. Hopefully he didn't manage to kill Lea.
 
I had to search on google for what Cathedrelion was. funny enough it DOES find one of your old posts as a search result :V

One thing you guys may be missing here is that it wasn't Hunger who decided to blow up the Azure. Gisena, the person he gave the Azure to, decided that she valued exterminating the Orcish threat over the Ring of Power.
That's not really the point to me.

It's not that it wasn't Hunger's choice to propose it, It's that Hunger went through it with basically zero hesitation after all we went through to save it.

It's a bit like.. well, we went through a LOT of effort to save someone from eternal torture, but then sacrificed him as soon as it was convenient.

Now, to be fair, the ring is NOT a person, and while it would not WANT to die, it was also prepared for it before we saved it... but I expected some more sympathy/loyalty for our "servant ring".

Even just a "I don't want to, but it's either a ring or a universe" scene would have been fine, I think, but Hunger basically go "ok, let me see if my sword agrees"!

So a Shroud equals to your Soul Evocation? Interesting. I wonder if Battle Magic fits into this at all; Unlikely given it had virtually no votes compared to Accretion and Soul Evocative..
well, if accretion is the "weight" of the pressure, basically the gravity of your soul, and Soul evocation is the "Light of your soul", some power that represents your inner nature (and we basically rule-lawyered it a LOT to bring it to Archmage level), the closest analogy I can imagine for Battle Magic would be that its spells are basically.. well, cheat codes on the rules of reality.

They allow you to do one specific thing, while leaving everything else unchanged and/or unaffected.

Your attacks suddenly do more damage, even if you're not actually using more strength. A lightning is going to pass through this specific slice of space, act on whatever it hits for a few seconds, and then disappear. You can heal a specific type of injury, basically deleting it or exchanging it for a lesser one, but not anything else...

Counterpoint: Sticking various magical Goops to your Soul absolutely could hurt. Ordinal Mages, for example, enjoy some benefits from having no other available magic systems.

On the other hand they can also boost each other, and while ordinal purist get a 2x growth rate, that's not really THAT great of a boost at the very high tiers, especially when you can get multiple synergistic systems.

Then again, Haeliel right now is a high cursebearer, so presumably >tier 3 omnipotent, so she can likely be an ordinal purist while also using other magic systems, because logic is optional at those levels somehow.

I didn't really mean Quintessence, is just... well, she's giving us support graces. She's basically making us a sorcerer then, and integrating graces into Archmage!

It's not intended to 'balm the sting,' it simply wasn't Hunger's plan in the first place. In-universe Hunger did not know how Archmage was to be brought about since it's Gisena's invention, and from Gisena's point of view she would of course take the action with the highest percentage chance against Dien (getting Archmage) if it was feasible. And from Hunger's perspective of course sundering the Azure is more palatable than losing to Dien with all the unthinkable horrors that entails, to say nothing of the personal importance of the task to Gisena. Hunger has always operated from a position of imperfect information; information on 'consequences' given from an omniscient perspective should never be taken for granted.

Ambitious efforts sometimes have risks; surely the voters did not choose to fight Procyon knowing for certain that Hunger would win!
technically, they did, mostly because of defensive wishes.

It was still a stupid decision by the way, I'll always stand by that.

Voters should have fallen back and farmed picks!


That said, my "problem", insofar as there actually IS a problem (debatable), is mostly that I expected Hunger to at least hesitate a moment before destroying the Ring he spent so much effort to save, and that swore loyalty to him in exchange.

Let me put it like this: if the key to unlock Archmage had been to sacrifice Aobaru or Letrizia for it, beyond the possibility of resurrection, would Hunger STILL have done it?

I expect he might consider it, especially if they were willing... but he'd hesitate a LOT.

Now, he certainly doesn't have that level of loyalty to the ring.. but I STILL expected SOME hesitation!

Who needs a wishing well? You have Archmage! Mythos itself is merely a facet of Hunger's dominion these days.
And with our dominion over space, we can probably put Nilfel in our pocket before leaving for the next universe!

Mm, not really... it depends on how much of Cathedrelion one believes is canon!
...I mean, they DO have giant robots piloted by teenagers...

This could be an opportune time to pull a partial Pittauro and reread the quest

and thus "pulling a Pittauro" becomes slang in the Rihaku community!

Yes, I AM proud of myself for it :V
Losing the Azure is actually quite painful, since Hunger went through the entire Temple arc to get it. The party's capabilities as a whole aren't diminished - rather the opposite, in fact - but Archmage probably should've mentioned a non-Arete cost required to awaken it; some people were against Broken Kaleidoscope simply because it sacrificed the ring. However, it's hard to argue against the exigency of our circumstances. Hunger himself accepted and assisted with the Azure's destruction, so we can only trust his judgment of its necessity, just as he trusted Gisena's.

Yeah, basically this.

It just came out of nowhere, especially because Broken Kaleidoscope SPECIFICALLY mentioned that, while Archmage didn't.

Sure, the fact the ring was involved in awakening a soul evocation could be predicted. Possibly even its connection to the Imprisoner.

The fact it would require the destruction of the Azure? THAT was unexpected, as did the aplomb/calmness with which he appeared to accept the need for it.


Burning Mirror of Desire is also kind of terrifying, since the Seal of Odyssial being broken means Nilul might be able to target Uly with it.
Yeah, except that Unshattered Kaleidoscope hard-counters it.

Basically you're just giving Odyssial another, even stronger self to control.
 
Yeah, except that Unshattered Kaleidoscope hard-counters it.

Basically you're just giving Odyssial another, even stronger self to control.
I was speaking from the perspective of a hypothetical enemy; Nilul's one of Odyssial's staunchest allies at this point, so manifesting another incarnation under his control is a feature, not a bug! The original can examine and incorporate insights from the clone, get Mirrored again, and so on until he hits the Essence cap or some other limit at which she can no longer reflect his power. The Incompetents' Society sure has come a long away. Look at Nilul, engaging in actual combat! Fighting her mother, no less! I'm tempted to shed a tear.
 
A short poem, inspired by the inscriptions on the Forebears Blade

oh dream of fairness, thy dreamer dreamt yet of a world more kind / and 'tis a dream that's held by many an ever-quaking mind.
by your shining firmament-light let its enemies be blind / to your fury, and to your glory, and the mercies you rescind.
 
We're starting a vote today and I was just thinking about some of the remaining decision points:

  • What is Gisena's strategy for exterminating the Orcs?
    • Finding Dien
    • Killing Dien
    • Rules of engagement on infested Republic worlds
    • Diplomacy with other shards
    • Risk Tolerance for the teens
    • Party Tactics - Closing the Fist?
  • What does Hunger get out of the remaining picks he grinds from Strife Without End?
    • Lots of echoes
    • Regular EFBs?
    • Praxis Picks
  • Is Hunger ready to conquer the Human Sphere?
    • Missing a chance to complete the Indenture task is very risky
    • But, Apocryphal should be gearing up for another hit anytime now
    • Can Hunger realistically expect to control his territories without HtQ, SitS, or RoS?
    • Does Letrizia have an opinion?
  • Is Aobaru going to steal Nova?
    • Could Hunger kill Nova, if it were being piloted by Aobaru?

My prediction is that this vote update will be about Strife Without End + general Strategy from Gisena, and then the next update will have Hunger come roaring out of the RoE into a fist-fight with Etrynome+.
 
It's not that it wasn't Hunger's choice to propose it, It's that Hunger went through it with basically zero hesitation after all we went through to save it.

Hunger did save it. His primary objective in the Temple Arc was to relieve the Ring of its suffering; the Crimson would not have gone to near such lengths to prevent the Azure's demise, but simply could not truck with the horrific suffering that had been inflicted upon it. Whether the Azure was free, (humanely) subordinated or annihilated at the end of his campaign mattered relatively little in comparison to removing it from that fate. Power was a secondary consideration that was wholly preserved.

The Azure means much more to Gisena than it does Hunger; how could he show less forthright resolve than her, in the face of this enemy?

And with our dominion over space, we can probably put Nilfel in our pocket before leaving for the next universe!

It takes substantial miitgation just to bring one person across Geas tasks. Taking a nation is overambitious.
 
It takes substantial miitgation just to bring one person across Geas tasks. Taking a nation is overambitious.
even if it was, say, mostly confined to the Realm of Evening?

then again, we just don't have good examples of what Decimator mitigation can offer. I don't think we ever saw possible options, except MAYBE with Seram...

..I wonder just how much power is required for FULL mitigation. We saw how even Haeliel only fully mitigated indenture, and we have no idea if that's just "she really lived that long", or if she for some reason decided to focus on Indenture even above Apocryphal...

Hunger did save it. His primary objective in the Temple Arc was to relieve the Ring of its suffering; the Crimson would not have gone to near such lengths to prevent the Azure's demise, but simply could not truck with the horrific suffering that had been inflicted upon it. Whether the Azure was free, (humanely) subordinated or annihilated at the end of his campaign mattered relatively little in comparison to removing it from that fate. Power was a secondary consideration that was wholly preserved.

The Azure means much more to Gisena than it does Hunger; how could he show less forthright resolve than her, in the face of this enemy?
my point stays that the ring is a LIVING thing, at least for some measure of "alive".

We're not talking about sacrificing a piece of jewelry or a random magical artifact. It's a bit more like sacrificing an android, in a way.

then again, maybe I'm just overestimating the amount of "sapience/soul/metaphysical value" a ring's life has.

The sacrifice might be necessary, but I remain surprised at the way they talked about it. That matter of fact "sure, the ring doesn't want to die, but it can't stop us from killing it anyway"
 
random musing: the Apocryphal Curse being 'may you Live in interesting times' may be why it doesn't want to kill Hunger. Then again, that would suggest that the Curse stops affecting Hunger if Hunger temporarily dies, which would be mighty abusable Edit: and I thiiink is canonically not the case, so this logic is likely inaccurate.
 
Last edited:
It's probably worthwhile to point out that Hunger has canonically did things comparable to kidnapping children as hostages to compel their parents as per the Temple Arc to defeat The Tyrant, and this is causing far less death then say, the War Crime:Okay method of conquest that's gotten so much praise after it thankfully lost the vote. The Azure is a eons old Tyrant who put Sten people's through oppression atleast as great the Tyrant did back in Hunger's home. While that doesn't justify the sheer torture it went through, especially since said torture also caused the deaths of countless other beings slaughtered by the Temple's people over millenia, it's not exactly a innocent actor.

So, it's not really that out of character to Hunger in my eyes.
 
Back
Top