Not an actual siege. I doubt this battle is gonna last until 3 a.m. I meant what is stopping them from just continuously reinforcing the group coming in when the Dexter's office is just stuck inside. Is the plan actually to just keep beating those who come in up, and somehow overcoming the number disadvantage through sheer willpower here?
Uuuhhhhh
How is your plan changing their number again? Don't tell distraction I already made what I thought of your idea that we would actually distract them quite clear.
It's easy to see what stops them from constantly reinforcing the group coming in: the simple fact that they don't have unlimited numbers.
Yes the plan
is to beat those coming in and overcoming the number disadvantage, not via willpower, but via the simple facts that: most of our opponents are mooks even weaker than us, it is easier to fight several individual fights against one opponent each time than to fight one fight against the same number of opponents, so staying inside and reducing the number disparity is better than trying to be cute and do a flanking against opponents that don't have the discipline that would be disturbed by said flanking in the first place, and via protecting the actual best fighters there, our bosses, instead of hoping they'll survive long enough for us to try said ineffective flanking.
Let's be honest, you are never going to convince me, because I think that the very premise of your plan, that we can make a worthwhile distraction, is false, and most of the voters seems to, if not agree with me, definitely not be agreeing with you (seriously, the vote is 13 to 3 against you), so let's stop this argument, it has been going on long enough.
Edit:
Still, I forgot to adress this so might as well:
I digress though, the point is there are ways to smoke people out of a building here. The surprise attack actually do counteract that, since we would be able to spot them doing it and be in a position to jump them rather than needing to react to it from the inside once it starts and the office is still surrounded by the Thorn Gang. Heck, we may even be able to use it against them with some luck.
If they wanted to smoke us out, they wouldn't be jumping in with us, they would have begun with that, and if they decide to do it later, we can see it coming by the fact that those inside will have to get out before they do it, and us seeing that they're about to do that from the outside doesn't' help, because we have no way of telling it to those inside and will be too occupied with our own fighting to stop it, if we even see them prepare it in the first place.