Voting is open for the next 15 hours, 16 minutes
The genie isn't really open. The Hexgates, water filter, and food are infrastructure projects. They may have indirect usage but calling them military projects might as well be calling everything military projects.
Don't fool yourselves, of course they're military projects. They're tools of control. The Kirammans built the air purifiers, the water filters and the hydroponics which keep Zaun clean (ish) and fed. But that's not all they were built to do. What did Caitlyn Kiramman do with the air purifiers her family controls, in Season 2? She turned them off, to gas the Undercity. And now you see why the water purification plant was so carefully built on the Piltover side of the Pilt.
 
Last edited:
It's not like airports killed regular ports. Plenty of goods don't benefit from being shipped quickly as long as the exporter is loading X units a week and the importer is unloading X units a week. The Hexgates are probably busy just with people, communications, and perishables.
 
Even so it is a major loss of income as even the chem barons have to pay their workers and if there is no work....
It's not though? the Hexgates aren't strangling trade passing through the under city/Zaun. Their expanding the range of locations that they can ship to and acquire goods from. Trade is changing, not moving away from the under city. If anything, with a greater sum of ports of call within profitable range for Piltover, more dockhands will be needed as merchant houses escalate their shipping operations to sort through goods and store them while bulk deals are negotiated between the new foreign powers Piltover is trading with.
 
Don't fool yourselves, of course they're military projects. They're tools of control. The Kirammans built the air purifiers, the water filters and the hydroponics which keep Zaun clean (ish) and fed. But that's not all they were built to do. What did Caitlyn Kiramman do with the air purifiers her family controls, in Season 2? She turned them off, to gas the Undercity. And now you see why the water purification plant was so carefully built on the Piltover side of the Pilt.

Hext tech is like dynamite
using for civilian porpuses is a prototype for weaponization on itself

>portable magic controlling device
>hex crystals

"Maybe instead of supressing and stabilizing,we can instead enhace,so..... hextech staffs so mages can launch death lasers" -some noxian engineer

"Sure,we were planning to buy a new batch of magic stabilizers to help local mage population,im sure we can use a couple dozens to tinker with without impacting the population negatively or leave a track"
-some noxian civilian administrator

"Dont ask for permission ti change the world" is very much a reality here

You cant have both the cake of personal hextech powered magic stabilizers and avoid the concept of portable "magic enhacers"
 
Don't fool yourselves, of course they're military projects. They're tools of control. The Kirammans built the air purifiers, the water filters and the hydroponics which keep Zaun clean (ish) and fed. But that's not all they were built to do. What did Caitlyn Kiramman do with the air purifiers her family controls, in Season 2? She turned them off, to gas the Undercity. And now you see why the water purification plant was so carefully built on the Piltover side of the Pilt.
Yes, the feeling a bit vengeful enforcer turned them off because she didn't care about the consequences as an enforcer and put her people, other enforcers first.

The actual council wouldn't be liable to do this because they care about their personal comfort and the benefits far more than they do enforcer lives. They don't care enough about controlling Zaun to spend the money they did on the water treatment plant or Hydroponics. That's what they finance the enforcers for. The water filtration plant was outright a vanity project for most of the people voting for it.

Most things can be turned military purposes by the enterprising mind. That isn't typically why there invented outside times of war.
Hext tech is like dynamite
using for civilian porpuses is a prototype for weaponization on itself

>portable magic controlling device
>hex crystals

"Maybe instead of supressing and stabilizing,we can instead enhace,so..... hextech staffs so mages can launch death lasers" -some noxian engineer

"Sure,we were planning to buy a new batch of magic stabilizers to help local mage population,im sure we can use a couple dozens to tinker with without impacting the population negatively or leave a track"
-some noxian civilian administrator

"Dont ask for permission ti change the world" is very much a reality here

You cant have both the cake of personal hextech powered magic stabilizers and avoid the concept of portable "magic enhacers"
Actually the show demonstrates it really isn't that simple. I believe Mel struggled to accomplish anything worthwhile with Hextech with as many of the bright minds of Piltover and Noxus she could gather when Jayce left, to little avail. Without jinx's help, it took Jayce and Victor years to get Hexgates working. At the end of the day Hextech isn't the kind of science your run of the mil tinkerer can just brute force with numbers and financing.

Any would be band of Noxus nobles looking to break into the Hextech weapons market by weaponizing regulators probably burns through a few dozen regulators, a handful or so of scientists, and a mage or three before throwing a fit and canceling the entire project.
 
Actually the show demonstrates it really isn't that simple.

This isnt the show

Because portable hextech was rare
(Cait rifle,the hex hammer,jinx guns,viktor laser and claw)

This means the amount the production and maintainance is artesanal and limited to what was avaible to jayce and viktors lab
And stable hexgems were recent development

This means artesanal and easily hideable production and maintainance is no longer here,and then jayce,jinx and viktor go awol (along the hextech notes)

Noxus was trying the equivalent of making a functional warplane from left over notes and bits here and there

This isnt the case here:

We made magic regulators a thing and we are aiming to make them (if we havent already in some capacity) widespread

3 infrastructure projects,hexcores developed years ahead and magic regulators as the pillar for mage law reforms

It means factories making hextech devices,as well hextech crystals,engineers trained on the making,modfying and usage of them as well their inner workings

Jayce,jinx and viktor are at the bleeding edge lf hextech sure
But hextech is no longer super secret tech that barely left the lab

There is likely a small horde of engineers that could build you a zapper if you gave them a few months

You can have hextech making a change or you can have no hextech weapons
You cant have both
 
Last edited:
It's not like airports killed regular ports. Plenty of goods don't benefit from being shipped quickly as long as the exporter is loading X units a week and the importer is unloading X units a week. The Hexgates are probably busy just with people, communications, and perishables.
OTOH, the truck very much did kill the oxencart.

So it really depends on the specifics of the technology in question. Depending on cost and throughput, it could make traditional seashipping obsolete, or it could dramatically improve the economic activity of Piltover's ports.

From what we've seen in the show, IIRC, the Piltover teleporter is one way. That means that you'd want to ship everything to Piltover conventionally, transship it in the ports of Zaun or Piltover, then ship it out via teleport.
 
Last edited:
[X][Progress Day] Show Off All The New Technology
[X][Speech] Just Jayce and Jinx
[X][Willpower] Spend Zero

Any analysis of Viktor as I'm a little unsure if he want the fame?
 
Last edited:
[X][Progress Day] Show Off All The New Technology
[X][Speech] All Three of Us.
[X][Willpower] Spend Zero

Any analysis of Viktor as I'm a little unsure if he want the fame?
Victor does want fame, or at least recognition, but being one of the faces of progress on a blown out of proportion progress day probably isn't quite what he had in mind. Add that to nerves, the natural worry that his two born teasing menace partners potentially saying something embarrassing, the possibility some problematic thought is said aloud or his failing health rates it's head, and Victor seems rather reasonable.
 
It's not though? the Hexgates aren't strangling trade passing through the under city/Zaun. Their expanding the range of locations that they can ship to and acquire goods from. Trade is changing, not moving away from the under city. If anything, with a greater sum of ports of call within profitable range for Piltover, more dockhands will be needed as merchant houses escalate their shipping operations to sort through goods and store them while bulk deals are negotiated between the new foreign powers Piltover is trading with.

In canon, Silco, arguably the most informed person on this issue, complained about how Hexgates made Zaun "fall further behind". And he made equal access to them one of the conditions for his deal with Jayce. Hexgates are pretty damn important.

But I also don't buy that they can be the uber weapon that can drop a bomb or skyship flotilla wherever in the world. Other nations have their own magics or ways to shut them down.
 
In canon, Silco, arguably the most informed person on this issue, complained about how Hexgates made Zaun "fall further behind". And he made equal access to them one of the conditions for his deal with Jayce. Hexgates are pretty damn important.
Framing it in competitive terms would seem to imply that Silco's concerned about the balance of power between Zaun and Piltover, rather than about Zaun doing worse in and of itself.
 
In canon, Silco, arguably the most informed person on this issue, complained about how Hexgates made Zaun "fall further behind". And he made equal access to them one of the conditions for his deal with Jayce. Hexgates are pretty damn important.

But I also don't buy that they can be the uber weapon that can drop a bomb or skyship flotilla wherever in the world. Other nations have their own magics or ways to shut them down.
One has to remember that Silco in someways considers Zaun an extension of himself, and he was very much further behind with advent of hexgates. It made them wealthier, more connected, and gave them greater need for control over real estate to build up warehouses fit to store the increased range of goods piltover will see as a port. As a man hellbent on freedom to rule Zaun himself, they were something that needed to be turned to his ends or gotten rid of.
 
Last edited:
Got bored,decided to do some incorrect quotes,
Jinx, holding a toy lightsaber: I'm Darth Vader!
Caitlyn: I'm done with everyone's bullshit.
-
Caitlyn: I've met a lot of pricks in my time, but you, Jinx, are a fucking cactus.
-
*Jinx is cleaning the house and she finds an empty bottle of orange juice*
Jinx: Clear orange juice?
Jinx: Oh, it's empty.
Caitlyn, who has been watching the entire time: I live with an idiot. I live with an idiot. I live with an idiot.
-
Caitlyn: I'm just remembering that my second year in America someone asked me to "Validate their Parking" which was the first time I heard that phrase and after blinking stupidly for a full five seconds I said "Well, parking is very hard but I'm sure you did really well."
-
Jinx, writing in her diary with a glitter gel pen: I'm losing my sense of humanity. Nothing matters. God is dead. There's blood on my hands.
-
Caitlyn: Look, Jinx, if you can fit your head down the gun's barrel, you can assume it doesn't have a non-lethal setting.
-
Caitlyn: *shatters a window and climbs through it*
Caitlyn: *turns around and helps Jinx through it* Breaking and entering is wrong Jinx.
Jinx: Okay.
-
Caitlyn: Why are you talking to yourself?
Jinx: It's called a soliloquy, bitch.
-
Jinx: What are you drinking?
Caitlyn: Vodka.
Jinx: Straight?
Caitlyn: No, gay. Why?
-
Jinx: Sometimes I get so caught up on being gay that I forget I'm actually bi.
-
Caitlyn: I'm sad.
Jinx: Don't be sad, because sad backwards is das.
Jinx: And das not good.
-
Jinx: The greatest trick the devil ever played was getting me banned from an all you can eat pizza buffet.
Caitlyn: Why'd you get banned?
Jinx: Touched the rat.
Caitlyn: … What rat?
Jinx: Chunky Cheese.
-
Jinx: *in a jail cell* What about my Miranda rights!? You're supposed to say I have 'the right to remain silent'"! NOBODY SAID I HAD THE RIGHT TO REMAIN SILENT!
Vi: *in the cell next to her* You have the right to remain silent, what you lack is the capacity.
If you wish to,feel free to reply with more
 
Last edited:
*Jinx is cleaning the house and she finds an empty bottle of orange juice*
Jinx: Clear orange juice?
Jinx: Oh, it's empty.
Caitlyn, who has been watching the entire time: I live with an idiot. I live with an idiot. I live with an idiot.
Caitlyn, a month later: "Jinx, why did you put an empty orange juice bottle back in the refrigerator?"
Caitlyn: "Wait, it's not empty?"
Jinx: "I invented clear orange juice."
 
Voting is open for the next 15 hours, 16 minutes
Back
Top