No idea, I am afraid.
It seemed sudden, yeah. I hope Comi is going to answer my question about that.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts!
Hugh's Perfectly Normal Mafia Game Where Nothing Weird Happens Whatsoever
- Thread starter hugh_donnetono
- Start date
- Mafia
No idea, I am afraid.
It seemed sudden, yeah. I hope Comi is going to answer my question about that.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts!
LostDeviljho
Flame Dragon Princess
- Location
- The glorious Pacific Northwest
- Pronouns
- Any
Excellent question, will let you know once I figure it out.
In all seriousness, I'm running exclusively off vibes at this point, and most of my vibes attached to players are actually "hey this guy feels kinds towny to me" or just a complete lack of impression.
If process of elimination is a valid reason then Logos, RoachTV, and ComiTurtle, but I wouldn't put any stock in that tbh. I rerear the whole game but it would be a lie to claim I have suspects.
So, we still don't know much about Nictis then.
@Nictis Why was it important to you to learn in detail about Zaealix's abilities?
Nictis
Best Sidekick
- Location
- Ninja Dave's Cookies
- Pronouns
- Any
Why was it important... WHY was it IMPORTANT? Wies, you're calling me here and questioning why we want to know someone is an AGENT of the ALIEN THREAT. Thankfully we've cleared that up so we can put our trust in Z once again, but what they said could have been a red flag! A sign! Proof that they are colluding with THE ENEMY!
Zaealix came here, said they checked on you, and declared openly they thought you were likely towncore. I don't see how that indicates that they could be the enemy. If Zaelix is mafia and you are not, what has the mafia win by making you look more trustworthy?
- Location
- PA
A number of things are possible.
Just because someone is proven town does not mean they're going to be suspicious of the right people- see Zone chasing the Shalmoa wagon all the way down to the end last game. It's plausible for the mafia to declare they 'trust' a dude who's barking up the wrong tree, and add weight to his wagon that makes that lynch happen…
And then from there, they can, among other things, try to steer the person to continue to make bad lynches, to betraying the person via changing their mind on the matter publicly, possibly via pointing out little critiques in the wagon as it formed, or other trickery.
Lots of plays to be made if you have a singular public voice guiding the town, frankly.
buys cheap towncred for Z
Thanks for explaining how Zaealix could be mafia, but I preferred Nictis to answer that question.
Anyway, I am still suspicious of Nictis' questioning. It seems to me it was better handled to be like: "Cool, but you could still be mafia so I will keep an eye on how you vote and what you say"
I am not sure if we could have deduced whether Z was town if they had answered "I actually do know the faction and the abilities" or "the latest option" .
So, I wonder, what was the purpose of that question then?
Anyway, I am still suspicious of Nictis' questioning. It seems to me it was better handled to be like: "Cool, but you could still be mafia so I will keep an eye on how you vote and what you say"
I am not sure if we could have deduced whether Z was town if they had answered "I actually do know the faction and the abilities" or "the latest option" .
So, I wonder, what was the purpose of that question then?
First of all, imma apologize for being quiet so far today. My notifications haven't been notifying me of posts here and I forgot.
Something in my role description leads me to believe that, to quote Wizards of Waverly Place, everything is not what it seems.
A miller is a townie that returns mafia to cop checks.
Thanks Ori, I see why that's interesting. So...
Obviously Zae lists three non-Mafia roles which Nictis is not according to their investigation. Which would be fine, since Miller Town would always return not-those. But then, Zae previously appears to confirm that they *did* indeed see Nictis as Town...
So then, I suppose my question to @Zaealix is, why did you say Nictis was Town?
Zae's being clearly vague, which I assume is some restriction from their role, but could also possibly maybe be avoiding being caught in a lie I suppose, or maybe even just... Lying. But I'd assume the former.
Obviously Zae lists three non-Mafia roles which Nictis is not according to their investigation. Which would be fine, since Miller Town would always return not-those. But then, Zae previously appears to confirm that they *did* indeed see Nictis as Town...
So then, I suppose my question to @Zaealix is, why did you say Nictis was Town?
Ok yeah, if true, that explains how the question is significant.
LostDeviljho
Flame Dragon Princess
- Location
- The glorious Pacific Northwest
- Pronouns
- Any
Unless my PM lied to me (possible) they did not.
- Location
- [REDACTED]
Always happy to share! Could I ask you to reciprocate? Who are you most suspicious of at the moment, and is there any particular reason why? Have the Miller reveals affected your stance significantly?
I am still suspicious of Roach for reasons below quoted, and it is possible their most recent question was trying to throw shade at Zaealix.
Which reminds me: @Nictis you clearly have a different read on Roach consideren they are one (albeit Minor) of your three town reads. Could you explain your reasoning or is it a gut feeling?
I also am suspicious of Ori:
This seems to me a change that doesn't check with the "meh, but in a slighty townie way" read of scia. Ori, what did change so you became fine with yeeting Scia instead of Roach for example which you were plain meh about?
I also don't understand why you reacted to the Miller reveal by voting Zaealix. What is your reasoning?
And to your last question, Walker, yeah, it made me trust Nictis more.
LostDeviljho
Flame Dragon Princess
- Location
- The glorious Pacific Northwest
- Pronouns
- Any
Well there aren't a ton of votes and the only real ones are for Zae, but Zae is also one of my top three townie vibes so...
[x] Vote RoachTV
A vote for the bottom three.
[x] Vote RoachTV
A vote for the bottom three.
@ComiTurtle you're let to post today, I'm curious to know you're current thoughts. What's your current top three scum reads, if you have any?