[X] Focus on a balance between the two (Gain +20 Editor Points, 7 Suggestions per turn)
Don't Miss Your Deadline! (Manga Editor Quest)
- Thread starter zamin
- Start date
- Original Modern
- Location
- USA
- Pronouns
- He/They
[X] Focus more on the post-editing process (Gain +30 Editor Points, 5 Suggestions per turn)
- Location
- Italy
mh... that source is a bit sus[X] Focus on a balance between the two (Gain +20 Editor Points, 7 Suggestions per turn)
- Location
- USA
[X] Focus more on the post-editing process (Gain +30 Editor Points, 5 Suggestions per turn)
So it's too late to properly argue this point, but +30 editor points is actually more valuable, especially with us getting more manga. +10 Editor points is worth 3~5 popularity on any manga we choose while 2 suggestions is worth 2~3 popularity on the manga (with a max of 4 even with top tier and 100+ rolls best I can tell).
Furthermore:
We want roughly at least 10 points per manga to catch the easy boosts and as a general pool to push things over the minimum threshold.
Also, mechanically, we want to concentrate our suggestions -- 1 suggestion is worth less than the no suggestions reroll. For 2 suggestions, they need the upper thresholds to definitely be worth more than the reroll. At 3 suggestions is where we can assume even with good suggestions will be worth much more than the free reroll.
So it's too late to properly argue this point, but +30 editor points is actually more valuable, especially with us getting more manga. +10 Editor points is worth 3~5 popularity on any manga we choose while 2 suggestions is worth 2~3 popularity on the manga (with a max of 4 even with top tier and 100+ rolls best I can tell).
Furthermore:
We want roughly at least 10 points per manga to catch the easy boosts and as a general pool to push things over the minimum threshold.
Also, mechanically, we want to concentrate our suggestions -- 1 suggestion is worth less than the no suggestions reroll. For 2 suggestions, they need the upper thresholds to definitely be worth more than the reroll. At 3 suggestions is where we can assume even with good suggestions will be worth much more than the free reroll.
- Location
- Italy
I was already thinking about the first point (editor points more valuable all else being equal), but I admit I wasn't considering the "no suggestion means reroll, and reroll >1 and about equal with 2 suggestions".
also... well, we've been told we actually get to choose if we lean towards editor points or suggestions thanks to John's action. I kinda prefer to pick the so unlocked option then, and it makes sense here.
[X] Focus more on the post-editing process (Gain +30 Editor Points, 5 Suggestions per turn)
Also... we don't know how many points we lose when we do Overtime. It would be nice if it was still only 10 less points, but I doubt it. It's probably half.
- Pronouns
- he
[X] Focus more on the post-editing process (Gain +30 Editor Points, 5 Suggestions per turn)
- Location
- USA
Kinda wish I had been able to be active earlier to share this information, but what will be will be. It's possible the GM will leave the vote open a bit longer since it probably won't change what gets written in the next update
- Location
- Italy
it happens. It wouldn't be the first time a last-minute argument changes the results, so no reason to lose hope yet.
Lance ryder
Ha! Fool i was the double man all along!
- Location
- local asian kfc
- Pronouns
- He/Him
[X] Focus more on the post-editing process (Gain +30 Editor Points, 5 Suggestions per turn)
- Location
- USA
You're right, although I'm pretty sure a good number of people won't check back in until the next time our GM triggers an alert. We've already hit 60 votes, so I dunno how many more people there'll are to vote, lol
[X] Focus more on the post-editing process (Gain +30 Editor Points, 5 Suggestions per turn)
Additional argument to pick +30 editor points, is both there's always a chance for series that we think already good like current chapter Subaru, so we didn't edit it...
...but most importantly, the suggestions themselves dependant on rolls, like the first chapter of Ramen Ninja, where we fail the idea roll, and gave a malus of -10 to section we attempt to make better.
...but most importantly, the suggestions themselves dependant on rolls, like the first chapter of Ramen Ninja, where we fail the idea roll, and gave a malus of -10 to section we attempt to make better.
Week 2 Rolling (Popularity)
zamin
The Watcher in the Dark
Alright guys, I'm going to be closing the votes in... let's say 5 hours. That should give me enough time to get home and freshen up a bit before I start writing the next update.
In the meantime, it's time to do this week's Popularity scores. If you haven't seen this before, you can check out how Feedback Mechanics work in the Mechanics informational, but the TLDR is "roll 2d6 + the manga's Popularity Bonus to get the final Popularity score".
As a reminder, here is what the series currently look like:
I'm going to need three rolls from you guys. As always, please let us know which one you're rolling for before you do the roll. If nobody has rolled within an hour, then I'll do it myself.
- Space Racer Subaru-kun (Chapter 2): 3 + 3 = 6
- Our Daughter is Actually a Vampire! (Chapter 2): 6 + 4 = 10
- My Secret Ninja Sensei Needs to Stop Training Me (Chapter 2): 8 + 0 = 8
Last edited:
- Location
- The Star Kingdom of Manticore
My Secret Ninja Sensei Needs to Stop Training Me (Chapter 2): 2d6 + 0
