In the grim darkness of the far future of a few days from now, there is only war. Or blood. Depends on who wins the vote.

The option for people who want this argument to continue on forever.
So do you want me to switch to balance or no?
 
Poor Balance, once more not getting any votes in the beginning...

Which is why it's going to win.
 
Don't be disingenuous. The odds are a hell of a lot better than a coinflip when Form of Rage is taken into account.
I'm not. That is entirely honestly the odds I'm putting of us surviving completing the ring and a fight after to actually leverage the growth increase.

I may be being pessimistic, but our odds of dying have been skyrocketing, and with the weakest build they're going to jump again.
 
[X] Study the Blood
[X] Heedless War

I am the salt of my vote.
Logic is my body. Hubris is my blood.
I have voted over a hundred times.
Unknown to synergy, nor known to consequences.
Withstood countless arguments, awaiting for consolidation.
I am but Regret, yet there is only one Quest.
So As I Vote
Unlimited. Build Votes...!
 
What's the current vote count?

A quick question - if we heal Verschlengorge to Rank 5, would the Astral things attracted be strong enough to give us advancements? If so, farming Astrals might be safer then leveling in the Middle Temple, and for Heedless War could provide a way of getting more power that isn't the Middle Temple.

Hunger doesn't want to farm Astral Beasts, he wants to free the Ring! Recall his comments from Fending Off. The plan is Verschlengorge is somewhat healed is for Letrizia + stronger Verschlengorge to continue fending for themselves while Hunger and Gisena get the Temple done.

Some ideas for Defining Advancements taken from the Knight Commander. I don't know if this counts as fanwork, but if it does, that's cool. 500 wordsish?

Interesting concepts! You really captured the idea of a Defining Advancement well, though the +Rank from the second one is a bit excessive!

Enable Approval Voting and then we'll talk. That's how compromise options win.

They also win by coordination between two sides willing to de-escalate! Whether that's a feat the thread is capable of, is up to you guys!

This is a similar argument to what led to picking up Apex. I don't think continuing to kick the can down the road is a viable option anymore. We're clearly falling behind the level curve, based on the escalating risks.

Nah, it's considerably less greedy than Apex, and Apex was fine with good target selection.

[X] Study the Blood
[X] Bloodslayer


The fact is that this provides a hell of a lot of immediate power and quite a few low hanging fruit to grasp with the "extreme power" of Blood Advancements. That this still focuses on the Ring and doesn't introduce some other extraneous dongles to our build like pseudo-Graces tips it over the edge for me.

I'm going to just mentally repress the memory of our other Forms so the aesthetic contradiction doesn't break my brain. Our flesh body is our only body. Any update that might indicate otherwise is non-cannon.

You're just like a Vampire, with a second stage that's a lingering wraith considerably weaker than the corporeal body. And, of course, the final form of berserker fury when you must finally go all-out! Makes sense since your power stems from Blood...
 
Frankly based on our reliance on it I fully expect the first time we need it we are going to fail the roll and flat out die.
Here's an offer: Get a statement from Rihaku which says that, yes, we have a 50% chance (or better) of dying with the Ring vote, and I will swap to any vote of your choice for this vote. Fail to do so, and you will move your vote over to Ring.

Deal?
 
An unfounded assertion. Do you have any QM quotes which say we have a 50% chance of dying with that build?
Nope. But check the chances on each of the fights we've decided between and do the math. Taking the weakest build with another escalation like that and our odds are terrible. We'll have to take at least the middle option to be sure we can actually get the last preeminence, so that will make them worse. Then we have to spend all our arete and most of our picks on that, which will get us the ring. Which will delete the rank increases. Which will put us further behind when we now need to fight a sufficiently challenging opponent to actually leverage our shiny xp boost.

All together? The chance of death is ridiculous.
 
You're just like a Vampire, with a second stage that's a lingering wraith considerably weaker than the corporeal body. And, of course, the final form of berserker fury when you must finally go all-out! Makes sense since your power stems from Blood...

Thank you so, so much.

I was genuinely feeling tense and irritated at the idea of fucking up the currently cool aesthetic of our build. But this actually helped me relax a lot and probably saved my day. It even fits with the Decimator's Affliction!

Now I feel like I can actually fight for this.
 
Here's an offer: Get a statement from Rihaku which says that, yes, we have a 50% chance (or better) of dying with the Ring vote, and I will swap to any vote of your choice for this vote. Fail to do so, and you will move your vote over to Ring.

Deal?
No. Rihaku never actually answers any questions I ask. I think I'm too annoying.

You know what. Fuck it. The sooner hunger dies the sooner I can stop being an obsessive idiot.

[X] Heedless War

To suicide!
 
Last edited:
[X] Bloodslayer
[X] Study the Blood

blood


Anti-synergy is painful. Fingers crossed that later on we learn some trick so our wraith and rage forms are counted as having blood.
 
Nope. But check the chances on each of the fights we've decided between and do the math. Taking the weakest build with another escalation like that and our odds are terrible. We'll have to take at least the middle option to be sure we can actually get the last preeminence, so that will make them worse. Then we have to spend all our arete and most of our picks on that, which will get us the ring. Which will delete the rank increases. Which will put us further behind when we now need to fight a sufficiently challenging opponent to actually leverage our shiny xp boost.

All together? The chance of death is ridiculous.

Ah yes, our skyrocketing chances of death, which reached an entire... *checks notes* 1% with the Hunter Trio. We won't be going for the last preeminence until we actually have the Arete to spend on it, so as long as we play it safe with our target selection we should be fine. Pessimistically, even if we end up with, say, a 5% chance of death for three combats before the pure power options we take more-or-less even out the curve, that's still a 14% chance of death, likely reduceable further with tactics and/or meatshields. A far cry from coinflip odds.
 
[X] Speak to Letrizia

Blood is probably better, but I'm curious about getting some more concrete info to better plan our conquest.

[X] Balance

Balance never dies, deviations merely foretell a future regression to the mean. I like this because it does enough immediately without totally shutting the door on ruling ring.
 
[X] Study the Blood
[X] Bloodslayer


I'm going to just mentally repress the memory of our other Forms so the aesthetic contradiction doesn't break my brain. Our flesh body is our only body. Any update that might indicate otherwise is non-cannon.

The fact is that this provides a hell of a lot of immediate power and quite a few low hanging fruit to grasp with the "extreme power" of Blood Advancements. That this still focuses on the Ring and doesn't introduce some other extraneous dongles to our build like pseudo-Graces tips it over the edge for me.

But we have no other Forms.
You put 6k words to Form of Rage, at least vote for Saint or Balance or something. Don't give up hope.

(as your nemesis, it follows that bloodslayer is my least favored option)
Which, again, we need to survive a coinflip to get.
Stop pulling numbers out of nowhere. Tactics and effort have always helped with our odd, why would that stop now? We just need to play well and use the insurance we actually bought.

I don't think may people are convinced by doom and gloom, that just causes them to double down. Talk about how your option is better if you want to convince people.
Frankly based on our reliance on it I fully expect the first time we need it we are going to fail the roll and flat out die.
We haven't used it once; how are we relying on it? Stop salting about Form of Rage.
There's "not a good time" and then there's "We've got a 50/50 shot of surviving to actually use it" which is where I'm putting our odds.
I'm not. That is entirely honestly the odds I'm putting of us surviving completing the ring and a fight after to actually leverage the growth increase.

I may be being pessimistic, but our odds of dying have been skyrocketing, and with the weakest build they're going to jump again.
Skyrocketing? When this is literally the first complication we had. Don't be hyperbolic.
Nope. But check the chances on each of the fights we've decided between and do the math. Taking the weakest build with another escalation like that and our odds are terrible. We'll have to take at least the middle option to be sure we can actually get the last preeminence, so that will make them worse. Then we have to spend all our arete and most of our picks on that, which will get us the ring. Which will delete the rank increases. Which will put us further behind when we now need to fight a sufficiently challenging opponent to actually leverage our shiny xp boost.

All together? The chance of death is ridiculous.
So you're just making stuff up then? "Deleting the Rank increases" when we know the Ring will get an immediate massive power boost is a good one though. We'd have a 10x exp boost; we can fight someone 10 times weakeer and still Progress as we are. As long as we get Ruling Ring; we are set.

You changed for Heedless War while I was typing this, huh. You probably need a break; and you should also vote for the option you actually want to see. Remember that this is a forum game at the end of the day; no need to be overly invested.
 
Thank you so, so much.

I was genuinely feeling tense and irritated at the idea of fucking up the currently cool aesthetic of our build. But this actually helped me relax a lot and probably saved my day. It even fits with the Decimator's Affliction!

Now I feel like I can actually fight for this.

I'm in the same boat! Now i really hope that we can give blood to our form of rage, which would personally make the aesthetic even better. I would argue that an form of pure rage that spills constant blood makes thematic sense! Perhaps transform his own rage into blood to fuel his fury?
 
Current vote count?

Form of Rage is now Stage 5.3 with this build. Fear it.

Note that a 90% chance of victory, given equal stats and a 1 stage difference, is overwhelming, not unwinnable. For example, what would you say the odds are of victory for:

A) A pure stats build with Thousand Cuts
B) The exact same build without Thousand Cuts

We would expect build A) to win via either alpha striking or being able to play a defensive attrition strategy over 90% of the time, so a 1 rank disparity would not, at this stage, be sufficient for B to defeat A. Now, if we were at high Ranks rather than Mid...

[X] Bloodslayer
[X] Study the Blood

blood


Anti-synergy is painful. Fingers crossed that later on we learn some trick so our wraith and rage forms are counted as having blood.

I'm surprised you guys didn't see this coming when Bloodmight experienced its last-minute resurgence! The thread has been better than average at Predictionism of late.

Thank you so, so much.

I was genuinely feeling tense and irritated at the idea of fucking up the currently cool aesthetic of our build. But this actually helped me relax a lot and probably saved my day. It even fits with the Decimator's Affliction!

Now I feel like I can actually fight for this.

Don't thank me, thank Letrizia! And buy her EFB!
 
They also win by coordination between two sides willing to de-escalate! Whether that's a feat the thread is capable of, is up to you guys!
So what you're saying is that if we the players achieve a great feat of diplomacy then our build will improve... sounds like the sort of achievement that would grant Hunger +Rank!

(seriously. plz gib rank 4 compromise.)


No. Rihaku never actually answers any questions I ask. I think I'm too annoying.

You know what. Fuck it. The sooner hunger dies the sooner I can stop being an obsessive idiot.

[X] Heedless War

To suicide!
dont do it! if you need a breather, toss a vote to us SWORD BROS and then turn off notifications overnight so that you don't wake up to rage-inducing vote tallies.
 
Last edited:
Ah yes, our skyrocketing chances of death, which reached an entire... *checks notes* 1% with the Hunter Trio.

Except we didn't take the hunter trio, now did we? We nearly took one with 10%.

You changed for Heedless War while I was typing this, huh. You probably need a break; and you should also vote for the option you actually want to see. Remember that this is a forum game at the end of the day; no need to be overly invested.
Probably. Doesn't matter.

dont do it! if you need a breather, toss a vote to us SWORD BROS and then turn off notifications overnight so that you don't wake up to rage-inducing vote tallies.
I refuse to care any more. I'm going to attempt to get Hunger killed with every vote because it seems like it will be significantly more entertaining than trying to prevent people from being so greedy they walk into a dragon's open maw.
 
Last edited:
Anti-synergy is painful. Fingers crossed that later on we learn some trick so our wraith and rage forms are counted as having blood.
I'm not especially hopeful on that front, since they seem to make a point of not having blood. But... we saw in this update that our corpse did stick around.

We might could be a zombie and a ghost at the same time! Archer guy thinks he's so cool, he's not the only one who can be in more than one place at once.
 
Skyrocketing? When this is literally the first complication we had. Don't be hyperbolic.
This being the first time a roll has gone kinda bad against us is not the same as saying "the odds aren't getting worse."

It's legit for us to be trying to break out of the pattern of having to repeatedly take choices where all options have, say, a 5-10% chance of important character deaths. Because we can't live there forever.

I refuse to care any more. I'm going to attempt to get Hunger killed with every vote because it seems like it will be significantly more entertaining than trying to prevent people from being so greedy they walk into a dragon's open maw.
...I was trusting your judgment on "not get us killed" issues, and find this rather frustrating. Not even asking you to campaign for it, just... you seem to have a better sense for how to craft not-get-killed votes than I do. I can't keep track of how the system works very well.
 
Back
Top