- Location
- US
- Pronouns
- He/Him
As I see it, you should have had a 50/50 chance of having spotted the scum. You wouldn't have watched me or Tykan as one of us is almost certainly the scum, and the other is a terrible target since it would leave only one suspect alive. You wouldn't watch yourself, obviously. So you should have watched one of the Docs. Does that sound about rigjt?
- Location
- US
- Pronouns
- He/Him
Here's my guess at everybody's night actions, just for fun:
Tykan kills Totadileplayz
Tota protects Shadell
Shadell protects Scia
Scia watches Tota
The cheese stands alone
I do nothing.
Tykan kills Totadileplayz
Tota protects Shadell
Shadell protects Scia
Scia watches Tota
I do nothing.
- Location
- Oregon, USA
Any guesses on mine
Agh. This whole back and forth is overwhelming me a bit. I'm not experienced enough to tell who's arguments are more valid, and thus, while I have a gut on meso, I'll 'sheep' (a term I found on the mafia wiki, thanks Onedine
) @Shadell here. As the votes stand, you decide the lynch. I would also like your list of suspicions, in case you die here/the arsonisting kills multiple people.
Also, @Scia, the fact that you have no reason not to reveal who you watched and the results here makes me a little suspicious.
- Location
- US
- Pronouns
- He/Him
Who did you visit last night?Any guesses on mine
Agh. This whole back and forth is overwhelming me a bit. I'm not experienced enough to tell who's arguments are more valid, and thus, while I have a gut on meso, I'll 'sheep' (a term I found on the mafia wiki, thanks Onedine
As the votes stand, you decide the lynch. I would also like your list of suspicions, in case you die here/the arsonisting kills multiple people.
Also, @Scia, the fact that you have no reason not to reveal who you watched and the results here makes me a little suspicious.
I didn't visit anybody and Tykan claims to have visited me. We don't know who Shadell protected or Scia watched.
- Location
- US
- Pronouns
- He/Him
Oh, @Young Pyromancer also could you answer this?
- Location
- US
- Pronouns
- He/Him
I figured, that's why I tried to provoke some conversation about it and how likely it was you'd spotted somebody but the bait remained untaken.
- Location
- Oregon, USA
I visited scia. I'll have to look back on the event sequence to try to remember what I was thinking.
- Location
- Oregon, USA
Right, so day three I had just seen Scia claim, and I didn't know whether they were telling the truth or not. I hadn't seen anyone chime in yet, so I didn't have any more experienced players chiming in. I thus had only my own intuition. I thought that a fake claim by zae was not necessarily a mafia move, and instead was likely to be a powerful role trying to hide. This especially makes sense if you consider their claim: mafia are less likely to attack someone at night if they think they're bulletproof, and instead save them for an arsonist thing at the end. When I was viewing the vote count, I posted it by accident, as I was just trying to update it. I had been thinking about Tykan for a while, as I trusted shadell/onedine, but had been holding off because of hammer I think. However, once I made sure I wouldn't be hammering and the lynch seemed pretty unlikely to change, I voted on them.
Pretty sure that's what I was thinking. Might be wrong about some of the fake-claim parts.
Pretty sure that's what I was thinking. Might be wrong about some of the fake-claim parts.
- Location
- US
- Pronouns
- He/Him
Does anybody have any objections to us going ahead and voting?
- Pronouns
- She/Her
Okay, does anyone have any arguments they haven't made yet? At this point, I'm fairly comfortable just voting Tykan for the reasoning that's built since D3. Even if incorrect, I'm not seeing much that'll likely change my mind.
- Location
- Oregon, USA
Again, in case you die shadell, I would like you to post your list for the mafia if it isn't Tykan. There's a decent chance that igniting the arsonist thingy doesn't count as visiting, and so a maf might be able to get around scia that way.
- Location
- US
- Pronouns
- He/Him
I'm ready to go. Honestly I have been posting a lot more often than I should because the whole situation is making me anxious. If I have read the situation right and we vote Tykan we win. If I have read it wrong we lose, and if y'all vote me, I don't know what will happen.
I'd really like to get confirmation one way or the other whatever happens.
- Location
- Oregon, USA
Gah, this is so exciting!
- Location
- US
- Pronouns
- He/Him
I know, right?!
Sorry about that. Not really good sportsmanship on my part.
- Location
- US
- Pronouns
- He/Him
It's cool. You're in a frustrating spot. It's okay to be annoyed by that.
I am really impressed with your play. You had some bad breaks along the way but you have been consistently making the best of them and kept engaged instead of ignoring the game and making it dull for everybody. If it weren't for people who were willing to keep going in such situations, this game would be a lot less fun, and it is even better when they are really good at it.
- Pronouns
- She/Her
[x] Vote Tykan
Sorry. If you're town, you got caught in a bad read and a weird mechanic thing that really hit you hard in a way that's really left you little you can do to clear yourself for multiple days. If you're scum, you got caught up by weird coordination issues and have tried to play it off the best you can, while being very strongly outed for 3 days as people murdered the rest of your team first.
Either way, you've kept marching in a not great situation, which is, as Meso notes, really impressive.
Sorry. If you're town, you got caught in a bad read and a weird mechanic thing that really hit you hard in a way that's really left you little you can do to clear yourself for multiple days. If you're scum, you got caught up by weird coordination issues and have tried to play it off the best you can, while being very strongly outed for 3 days as people murdered the rest of your team first.
Either way, you've kept marching in a not great situation, which is, as Meso notes, really impressive.
- Location
- Oregon, USA
Day 5 Ends
Nictis
Best Sidekick
- Location
- Ninja Dave's Cookies
- Pronouns
- Any