Anything relying entirely on Pristine Star is giving Ber a several day head start on us for grinding.

First of all, why? We can still go and fight so long as we spend some time around Letty, and the Hero isn't too weak to go fight yet. Even if we vote to rest and get back our health if we are able to use our Astral we should beat him down.

Even if it is true that he's grinding, can he really grind that fast in a couple days without a party?

I just don't think Ber is that big a threat.
 
Guys, are you sure it's wise to rely on Pristine Star when you're in danger of potentially being outscaled by a Gamer analogue? You and Letrizia will both be wounded for several days while he's recovering and training!

Last fight we were exhausted and wounded, and he had allies. It was close but we won. I'm skeptical he's a threat.
-To match his combat ability in the last fight he'd need to put together a new team, one that is reasonably powerful and actually capable of working together effectively.
-Last fight our Astral rank was badly depleted, but we still won. Meaning all we have to do is chill and sleep and we'll be powering up an order of magnitude. I really doubt he can power up an order of magnitude in the same time.
-We still have one really good power-up we haven't claimed yet, and it is GETTING IN THE ROBOT. That's what I'm saving Arete for.

I really doubt this guy can put together a new team, pick up an order of magnitude power, and do all that before we can get in the robot. It's possible; like maybe he hires a kill team or gets his hands on something equivalent, then does some super forbidden technique and powers up, all in just a couple days. We have no clue what kind of bullshit this guy has. But I think the risk is low enough that we can wait and save up for GETTING IN THE ROBOT.

Also I just re-read Age and Treachery and realized both groups consist of two sexy women, one machine, and one man, and that in both cases the single man is the most powerful. Lol.
 
Last edited:
If it is an MMO type gamer, scaling up at maximum speed won't take that long. Esp if our Apocryphal is helping him. Like, have you guys played an MMO? If you're willing to sell your soul play on a 16+ hour schedule you can grind at an unholy speed.
 
Also I just re-read Age and Treachery and realized both groups consist of two sexy women, one machine, and one man, and that in both cases the single man is the most powerful. Lol.
Well, not quite. The gamer asshole's party actually had 3 women, we just killed the first one the instant she came through the portal, so we didn't really get much description of her.
 
I'd like to remind everyone that if we save Arete here we'd already be a quarter of the way to getting Once and Future. We can't get those extremely shiny EFBs if we don't start saving at some point. Besides, even if the Mire Wolf has acceptable levels of risk to me, it isn't riskless. We could still get rocked. Absolute safety and extra Arete are absolutely worth the single pick.

Not interested in Vanguard because its full benefit only shows up once upped our SL more and the blurb straight up says it doesn't help scale. Also it doesn't heal us. We don't benefit from it's regen. We'd still be just as vulnerable to attrition. It's essentially the same option we've been choosing over and over of getting more power in hopes it outpaces our wounds. We literally can't keep doing this. We voted to Hunt For Healing; how about we get some actual healing, huh?
 
Because I can admittedly see why that's a difficult choice... though if we can get 7 Arete and Maw it's no longer such a problem.

Second Stage is a heal. You stab yourself to enter it, then re-enter ordinary human form a day later fully healed.

Since Undying Vanguard hasn't gotten much momentum...

It had lots of omake power, though! Enough omake power and arguments can turn the tide!

And what are we supposed to do exactly? The only self-healing options are Pitiless Maw (which doesn't heal Letrizia) and Second Form (which isn't really a heal). Undying Vanguard gets us some extra stats to make up for our injured state I guess.

See my first comment in this post!

The second best option for getting ourselves back online while still helping Letrizia would be Offering/Vanguard, which I guess is why you're pushing it so hard. The problem with that is it puts us into Arete debt, which I believe exhausts us again? We just did that and it didn't work out so well.

Arete debt doesn't exhaust you, but it is a fairly punishing condition. Not as bad as Exhausted though. Still, you'd only need to earn 1.5 Arete before the next update to avoid it. Probably less since there have been fanworks since I last updated Arete, and with sufficient discussion you don't even need the fanworks.

I'll admit, the strongest argument for Second Stage to me is specifically that Gamer guy. Imagine his face when it turns out the Hidden Boss that almost wiped his party was actually super wounded in their last fight and has another stage besides.

i know right

just imagine if you can get form of rage too

Super spend build only possible with the tyrant beast! Ultimate waifu pandering with findross options and party buffs! Conceivably possible to get enough arete for before the update!

This seems pointless, Undying Vanguard already gives regeneration that's superior to Shine Bright! Unless you're literally only taking it for Gisena?

hmm I see

I think the base option gives us all the Healing we'll need. Let's save up the Arete and get something truly spectacular!

It gives you the healing you need, but not at the speed you want it.

I just don't think Ber is that big a threat.

He's a teleport-spamming Gamer with the ability to launch skyscraper-sized energy blasts that your most powerful current artifact (Evening Sky) could only barely redirect after Gisena had hit it with a focused Nullity. The only reason he left was because his Assess failed against you!

-We still have one really good power-up we haven't claimed yet, and it is GETTING IN THE ROBOT. That's what I'm saving Arete for.

The robot is currently broken!

Also I just re-read Age and Treachery and realized both groups consist of two sexy women, one machine, and one man, and that in both cases the single man is the most powerful. Lol.

Three women in his case, and the machine is the strongest in yours! It just can't use that power - it's broken.

And Gisena's effective level under Quantified World is a bit higher than yours!
 
Don't mind me.

"Draw a sexy Gisena," she tells me. Yeah, okay, I'll give it a shot.
Dang that's nice.

The shading almost makes it looks like her lipstick is smudged, though. I'm not sure if that should be ignored as unintentional, or if someone really should be asking Gisena additional questions about what she was doing while Hunger was unconscious.
 
Second Stage is a heal. You stab yourself to enter it, then re-enter ordinary human form a day later fully healed.

OK then. Shine Bright+Second Stage full heals us and Letrizia. And we later get to pull second form shenanigans on entitled isekai protagonist.

[X] The Mire Wolf
[X] Evening Sky - Shine Bright
[X] Forebear's Blade - Second Stage


I can be convinced to swap onto Undying Vanguard if that has better odds of winning.
 
wait, why is a significant portion of votes for pristine star + shine bright
it doesn't really make sense to pick star and bright together because then we heal our companions quick but heal ourselves at a mediocre pace, especially considering this is from wolf voters who don't need star for perfect healing
it'd be better to pick second stage to get another hp bar instead
 
wait, why is a significant portion of votes for pristine star + shine bright
it doesn't really make sense to pick star and bright together because then we heal our companions quick but heal ourselves at a mediocre pace, especially considering this is from wolf voters who don't need star for perfect healing
it'd be better to pick second stage to get another hp bar instead
star doesn't spend arete and we need to heal someone quickly, but not necessarily ourselves
 
@Rihaku, I would like to seek some clarification in regards to Second Stage; you have said when reverting from the second form back to the original human one, Hunger would be fully healed. You have also said that the second form would not have any of the maimed parts Hunger doesn't currently have (ie arm & eye).

Given that, would "fully healed" include regenerating his missing bits when Hunger returns to his human form again, or would it just mean he's back to whatever his peak condition is in his current state as a maimed individual?
 
OK then. Shine Bright+Second Stage full heals us and Letrizia. And we later get to pull second form shenanigans on entitled isekai protagonist.

[X] The Mire Wolf
[X] Evening Sky - Shine Bright
[X] Forebear's Blade - Second Stage


I can be convinced to swap onto Undying Vanguard if that has better odds of winning.

You could switch now to see if it builds momentum and then switch back if it doesn't! That particular option is already quite popular so you wouldn't lose much in the interim.

wait, why is a significant portion of votes for pristine star + shine bright
it doesn't really make sense to pick star and bright together because then we heal our companions quick but heal ourselves at a mediocre pace, especially considering this is from wolf voters who don't need star for perfect healing
it'd be better to pick second stage to get another hp bar instead

They don't want to spend the extra Arete. Understandable!
I'd like to remind everyone that if we save Arete here we'd already be a quarter of the way to getting Once and Future. We can't get those extremely shiny EFBs if we don't start saving at some point. Besides, even if the Mire Wolf has acceptable levels of risk to me, it isn't riskless. We could still get rocked. Absolute safety and extra Arete are absolutely worth the single pick.

Not interested in Vanguard because its full benefit only shows up once upped our SL more and the blurb straight up says it doesn't help scale. Also it doesn't heal us. We don't benefit from it's regen. We'd still be just as vulnerable to attrition. It's essentially the same option we've been choosing over and over of getting more power in hopes it outpaces our wounds. We literally can't keep doing this. We voted to Hunt For Healing; how about we get some actual healing, huh?

Mm, the option has no inherent scaling but it can certainly help you level if you use it intelligently. For example - Gisena now has more Protection, Con, and regeneration, so even though you can't heal she can tank and heal herself. Also, the extra Con and Agi would make you much tankier, and you're already very tanky due to Evening Sky. Note that you have a 90% chance to beat the Tyrant Beast despite being Exhausted, having .5 arms, having only 64% of your HP, and no depth perception!
 
By the way, we are two votes away from a three way tie right now. Expected since Rihaku went for the Devil's Advocacy early this time.

My arguments against Vanguard:
- It still doesn't fucking heal us
- As per the option, doesn't help scale
- Requires more time to social our companions for full effect, time which could be spent grinding instead
- Literally the same thing we've been doing over and over of taking more power in hopes of outpacing our wounds, which got us in this situation

Shine Bright+ Second Stage
- Spends way too much Arete
- Only Second Stage is kind of worth it
- Seriously it's four Arete. That's like a 1/6th of an EFB.

Shine Bright+ Prisitine star
- Shine Bright is not a very good purchase in my opinion, basically. Don't think it's worth the extra pick.


it doesn't really make sense to pick star and bright together because then we heal our companions quick but heal ourselves at a mediocre pace, especially considering this is from wolf voters who don't need star for perfect healing
it'd be better to pick second stage to get another hp bar instead
Stage costs Arete. Pristine also does enhance the healing of Bright somewhat.
Mm, the option has no inherent scaling but it can certainly help you level if you use it intelligently. For example - Gisena now has more Protection, Con, and regeneration, so even though you can't heal she can tank and heal herself. Also, the extra Con and Agi would make you much tankier, and you're already very tanky due to Evening Sky. Note that you have a 90% chance to beat the Tyrant Beast despite being Exhausted, having .5 arms, having only 64% of your HP, and no depth perception!
Yeah, but not cleanly, which is dangerous given our condition. Also doesn't help us heal. When we voted for Hunt for Healing.

Inserted tally
Adhoc vote count started by Genesys on Jun 1, 2020 at 1:32 AM, finished with 145 posts and 33 votes.
 
[X] The Plumed Offering -
[X] Forebear's Blade - Echo of the Forebear + Undying Echo + Undying Vanguard - 7 Arete.
 
Given that, would "fully healed" include regenerating his missing bits when Hunger returns to his human form again, or would it just mean he's back to whatever his peak condition is in his current state as a maimed individual?

The latter.

Yeah, but not cleanly, which is dangerous given our condition. Also doesn't help us heal. When we voted for Hunt for Healing.

Hunt for Healing is looking for a way to heal Letrizia!

And Undying does help you heal in that it raises your CON and thus your natural healing speed. It also helps you escape attrition in the future because Gisena can tank and heal herself!
 
And Undying does help you heal in that it raises your CON and thus your natural healing speed.
If we could rely on our natural healing speed we wouldn't be in this situation. I suspect that won't change even with more Constitution. Even Pristine's guarantee of healing fully in 2 weeks is more reliable in my opinion.

And sigh, people are once again voting for maximum Arete expenditure. Plumed Offering plus Pristine Star answers our needs in a perfectly satisfactory manner while gaining us Arete. We have basically been doing this time and time again where we choose the short-term "cooler" option, while ignoring moderation. We have to stop doubling down sometime. There's no need to put seven Arete down the drain here.
 
If we could rely on our natural healing speed we wouldn't be in this situation. I suspect that won't change even with more Constitution. Even Pristine's guarantee of healing fully in 2 weeks is more reliable in my opinion.

And sigh, people are once again voting for maximum Arete expenditure. Plumed Offering plus Pristine Star answers our needs in a perfectly satisfactory manner while gaining us Arete. We have basically been doing this time and time again where we choose the short-term "cooler" option, while ignoring moderation. We have to stop doubling down sometime. There's no need to put seven Arete down the drain here.
It's because of the Gamer dude.

If we aren't scaling hard we are going to die.
 
It's because of the Gamer dude.

If we aren't scaling hard we are going to die.
Just recovering our strength and not being fucking exhausted would be a pretty significant and rapid increase in the scale of threat we present. Saving up some Arete for Maw would make us extremely dangerous to Gamer because if we can get in close and start cutting we're likely to heal ourselves faster than he can beat on us.

We were fighting at a small fraction of our effective strength in the last match, so just recovering the full use of the powers we already have represents a major and potentially very rapid upgrade in our capabilities.
 
Last edited:
Just recovering our strength and not being fucking exhausted would be a pretty significant and rapid increase in the scale of threat we present. Saving up some Arete for Maw would make us extremely dangerous to Gamer because if we can get in close and start cutting we're likely to heal ourselves faster than he can beat on us.

We were fighting at a small fraction of our effective strength in the last match, so just recovering the full use of the powers we already have represents a major and potentially very rapid upgrade in our capabilities.

Not sure about that. If we were at 91% of our power circa Evening Sky and went to 84% at the end of Age and Treachery...
 
Back
Top