We will kidnap her also. We will kidnap anyone interesting and make them join our crew.

Edit: I am mostly joking but it would be funny if we ended up kidnapping Whitebeard himself.

Pretty sure Whitebeard would be the one doing the kidnapping. Or as he calls it, adoption.

Edit: Oh my God. War over who gets to be the real Grandfather to the Straw Hats. Battle for Grandfatherly supremacy.
 
Last edited:
if Garp's around there's no way that Robin would join up, because he's the Hero of the Marines and she's spent most of her life running from them.
and I really like Robin
EDIT: current Tally for those interested
Adhoc vote count started by RavensDagger on Apr 12, 2020 at 4:46 PM, finished with 119 posts and 92 votes.
 
Last edited:
[X] Bartolomeo Joins (and pays back his debt to Nami)
[X] Tashigi stays behind (And becomes a good little Marine lapdog, just like Contessa wants))

Let's leave at least someone for Contessa ok?
 
Last edited:
[X] Tashigi stays behind (And becomes a good little Marine lapdog, just like Contessa wants))
[X] Bartolomeo Joins (and pays back his debt to Nami)

Barto - great DF user, ofc we want him
Who is gonna take care of Smoker if Tashigi is forced into a pirate crew, I see more problems with her joining than not
 
[X] Tashigi joins (Not so terribly willingly, but she'll get over it)
[X] Bartolomeo Joins (and pays back his debt to Nami)

We have a big ship, and therefore need a big crew. But not as big as Garp, because then all glory goes to him, not the rest of us, and we probably won't grow as much. Also, it's funnier to get away from him repeatedly, I think.
 
[X] Tashigi joins (Not so terribly willingly, but she'll get over it)

[X] Bartolomeo stay behind (Nami pouts for days)
 
[X] Bartolomeo Joins (and pays back his debt to Nami)
[X] Tashigi joins (Not so terribly willingly, but she'll get over it)
[X] Garp catches up, but only once we're on the ship. Now we're wanted for kidnapping a Vice Admiral!
 
I can't recall the quest name (it has been a while), I didn't participate and only heard by word of mouth. It was on spacebattles, I think. And it was ran by Ganurath or TPK....

But I do remember it being cited on multiple occasions as a point that the suicidally crazy write-in may not be crazy enough to work, it's just suicidal.
Maybe it was TPK, then. Or somebody else.
Here you go:
forums.sufficientvelocity.com

Going Full Kubo (Bleach Quest) [GOOD END]

You ready the blade and- What the hell are you doing? You set the blade’s tip back onto the roof carefully, and rethink your options. There’s something about the way the challenge was phrased that nags at you, but you’re not sure what it is. It seems simple. The zankaputo you picked up...

You might be thinking of Kid. Barty never became a Supernova, only Blackbeard was added to the group.
Blackbeard was never known as a Supernova, though he did get added to the group when they became known as the Worst Generation.

I'm really hoping for both to join the crew. They're just so.. wildly different from one another. Their image, personalities, upbringing, beliefs, everything about Tashigi and Bart are complete opposites. It seems like it'll be fun to have them both as new crew-mates just to see how that contrast plays out.
... Are you gonna make me start shipping Tashigi and Bart now?

Opposites do attract afterall...

Barto, on the other hand, doesn't have any real ties to an organization and is just as impressionable. Kidnapping him seems totally fine.
Erm... Bart's the head of the local (Loguetown) mafia...

Didn't Luffy just sort of grab Robin at first?
Nope, Robin stowed away on the ship.
 
Last edited:
[X] Bartolomeo Joins (and pays back his debt to Nami)
[X] Tashigi joins (Not so terribly willingly, but she'll get over it)
[X] Garp catches up, but only once we're on the ship. Now we're wanted for kidnapping a Vice Admiral!
 
[X] Tashigi joins (Not so terribly willingly, but she'll get over it)
[X] Bartolomeo stay behind (Nami pouts for days)
[X] Garp and Smoker catches up, the journey ends here.
 
[X] Tashigi joins (Not so terribly willingly, but she'll get over it)
[X] Bartolomeo Joins (and pays back his debt to Nami)
[X] Garp and Smoker catches up just as everyone gets on the ship, then Dragon (the AI, blame Contessa and her damned hat) and Monkey D. Dragon with amnesiac Sabo in tow show up before they can cast off.

Having AI Dragon show up is something of a troll option, thankfully at this point I don't think she needs to obey authority IIRC.
 
[X]Bartolomeo stay behind (Nami pouts for days)
[X] Tashigi joins (Not so terribly willingly, but she'll get over it)
[X] Garp catches up, but only once we're on the ship. Now we're wanted for kidnapping a Vice Admiral!
 
[x] Tashigi stays behind (And becomes a good little Marine lapdog, just like Contessa wants))
[x] Bartolomeo Joins (and pays back his debt to Nami)
 
[X] Tashigi joins (Not so terribly willingly, but she'll get over it)
[X] Bartolomeo stay behind (Nami pouts for days)
 
We have a big ship, and therefore need a big crew. But not as big as Garp, because then all glory goes to him, not the rest of us, and we probably won't grow as much. Also, it's funnier to get away from him repeatedly, I think.

I think that could actually be easily dealt with by just having Garp not solve all the problems and fight all the battles. I mean if he does decide to stick around, I could easily see him deciding that fighting all the crews battles for them would just weaken them, and it would be better to stand back a bit to let the crew grow up to be strong enough to fight their own battles. Raven did mention that he might be tempted to try and train them to be "proper marines". And as a vice-admiral, he would obviously not be joining the team permanently. Better then to help the crew stand on their own instead. I mean he is rather obviously someone who believes in "tough love".

Yeah, he would admittedly still be there in the background as a constant safety net, and we would know that there is no true danger in most battles since Garp would help save the crew if things really went to hell. But that is already the case with QA who we know would act if Taylor was about to die, so I don't think thats a big deal.
 
Back
Top