Muahahaha! You fools! You all fell into my devious trap! All of the guild choices are great! How will you choose?!
But in all seriousness, all the guilds are great, though I will say, I really don't want to have to come up with more guilds on the fly/spend even longer on guild intros. Especially since I honestly do think these are the most fun options.
Not by best work, but eh.
Damn You Saturday!
I definitely think we don't need other options, Other guilds don't really compare with these ones (except Blue Pegasus, which is really unlikely to gain as much interest.)
I mean, is there even ONE person interested in Quatro Puppy?
Now, you made a really good job in making every option attractive.
[][Guild] "...I want to join Mermaid Heel."
[][Guild] "...I want to join Phantom Lord."
[][Guild] "...I want to join Fairy Tail."
[][Guild] "...I want to see a few more places before choosing."
So...Mermaid Heel is the "not as interesting" one to me. I dislike the "only female" rule, and there aren't really that many interesting characters there.
So, as I always expected it to be... Fairy Tail or Phantom Lord.
Chasing your dream or conquering your fear.
Both interesting, both worthy.
But only one has a boy we need to trounce at Uno
[x][Guild] "...I want to join Phantom Lord."
jokes aside, I want to try bringing the two guilds closer. Make it a proper rivalry instead of outright hate.
Maybe we could push things so that they could make joint s-class trials, for example, as a way to compete.
Or, if the magical games don't happen soon enough, we could push our master to organize some kind of private tournament/challenge. I imagine many would be interested in it (Natsu and Laxus at the very least).
[][Tail] "...Want the world to be safe and good and clean. For everyone."
[][Tail] "...Want everything to be happy. Like before."
[][Tail] "...Want to prove that my magic isn't weak."
[][Tail] "...Want to reach the end of my path. Wherever that may be."
[][Tail] "...Want to find a reason to live. To stay living."
I'll go for
[x][Tail] "...Want to prove that my magic isn't weak."
After all, is an objectively hard goal to reach that we really believe we can achieve. And the other feel a bit too out there to me. Like if we were trying to sound cooler.
i want to other guilds like Cat Shelter
Wasn't Cait Shelter the Wendy's fake guild? I don't think it really counts.
I mean, Wendy and Charle were the only true members, the others were all illusion/ghosts!
and really, we already saw the three best guilds. The ONLY other true contender would be Blue Pegasus I think.