Alright. Time to build a timeline.
Slight color coding included. Purple is personal note, Red is wagon level, Green is time or page gaps.
Day 1 Starts. Page 4.
1K makes a near immediate comment about not being aligned with Cyricubed.
Hobo claims that Byzantine scumslipped in the pre-game based on a jokepost and Stormtroopers being armed.
-Broken Base (My Slot) lightly pushes for more info on this.
-Broken Base (BB) then states that Hobo and Byzantine are unlikely to be aligned scum.
ComiTurtle (Comi) memevotes Dawiusz
[1] and casts doubt on BB.
-BB explains thought in response and questions Hobo on the lack of vote.
-Hobo votes Byzantine.
[1]
Tykan memevotes Meso.
[1]
1K gives thoughts on the last game.
Byzantine claims to not be Scum or in a Quick Topic.
(Not!Scum=/=Town)
Dawiusz (Daw) memevotes Comi.
[1]
Nanimani (Nani) memevotes Cyricubed.
[1]
Page 5.
Daw lightly suspects Byzantine's response to scumslip mention.
(Unlikely to be allied, potentially a light case of shading?)
-Byzantine explains intended tone.
-BB casts doubt by saying that the tone didn't read like that.
(Noting mostly because people tried to tie BB to Byzantine, need to see what's with that.)
-BB then votes Byzantine
[2] for what is claimed to be tone but feels like disengaging.
(Why you gotta do the suspicious things BB? This pressure feels bad to me T.T)
Rosen enters with another case of RQS.
Daw presses X to doubt Byzantine and claims Hobo as probably Town. Also expresses concern of getting hammered.
BB responds to Rosen's questions by giving a decent answer, an explanation for the lack of answer, and info on how she plays as scum.
(If I had replaced Daw instead this would probably be who I would vote)
BB questions Daw on the lack of vote.
-Rosen claims to be watching Daw and the conversation.
BB pushes Tykan to flesh out their memevote on Meso.
(I don't get this one)
Tykan responds to Rosen and unvotes Meso from BB comment.
[0]
Daw explains basic new player vote conservativeness. Doesn't want to vote too early basically.
-BB and Daw butt heads over game ideology. I'm mostly going to ignore this from here on out to save space.
(I will say that I personally agree with both sides here. Wagons form pressure and gather reactions, but sometimes the subtler touch is better)
1K and Byzantine give serious answers to Rosen's question.
Daw unvotes Comi.
[0]
Byzantine votes Daw for shading them.
[2] (I think this is where people decided that BB and Byzantine were connected, but it just looks like Byzantine piggybacking off of a line by BB that was prefaced with "I'm not sure that this is scummy")
Page 6.
(
Post 127) BB pushes on Daw for playstyle.
(I'm unsure if this is a matter of ideology or not. She's not here so I can't exactly ask. I can start to see why people were linking BB and Byzantine though.)
Hobo memevotes Rosen
[1] and answers questions questionably.
LDJ and Comi respond to Rosen's questions shortly.
-Rosen pushes LDJ for answers, gets a response from LDJ explaining the answers, and immediately votes LDJ.
(For what is frankly bullshit.) [1]
-1K calls Rosen on the bullshit and compares the LDJ answer to the BB answer. Rosen responds by claiming BB as his biggest Town read and LDJ as his biggest Scum Read.
Page 7.
Byzantine remarks that 1K is putting an odd amount of effort into defending LDJ.
(NAI I say)
-Rosen meanwhile is making a complete mockery of himself from last game.
-LDJ gives IRL explanation for short answer.
(Combination of a lack of interest in the questions, and not having a proper keyboard. I sympathize)
Page 8.
Nani responds to Rosen's questions while explicitly calling it nice as a fun question rather than a game move.
Byzantine questions the likelihood of a Gunsmith
(Probably doesn't mean much, noting in case if I see more of this later)
Byzantine mentions that Nictis controlled the conversations last game and was scum... And hints that the lurkers should get more attention.
Rosen questions Nani for thoughts
Meso and QT give explanations for lack of activity and an intent to post more later.
Page 9.
BB asks 1K about reads on BB and Rosen, also states null to slight town read on LDJ
(Matches my own thoughts at this point)
1K acknowledges bias towards/against Town Leader types, Rosen nitpicks 1K over bias ideology
(is that even a thing? Not sure how else to phrase it)
-Rosen votes unvotes LDJ
[0] and votes 1K
[1] for letting her bias influence her reads.
(Gotta say, I didn't see this when I voted Rosen Day 1. It's not making me regret it though.)
BB is townreading Rosen and not reading 1K. Seems to imply that she knows 1K's scumrange.
(I am curious about this, since 1K's only scum game had her acting basically the same and fooled me completely)
Page 10.
For the list's and my own sake, I'm going to ignore the argument between 1K and Rosen in this. Some people comment in defense of 1K, Rosen continues to try and impress his view of things on the thread. Most of the page is wasted on this.
BB unvotes Byzantine
[0] and pressure votes Daw
[3]
Tykan and Hobo question Rosen for a Comi read and question the LDJ read from Rosen's response.
Page 11.
BB is paranoid about 1K.
Hobo unvotes Rosen
[0] and votes Byzantine
[1] because " I still think Byzantine has the best odds of being scum. "
(Seems to be for the pre-game scumslip?) Also questions BB on Daw vote.
-BB provides quote and explanation.
BB is still paranoid about 1K and asks others to help go over her.
-Rosen responds by explaining that he's suspicious of 1K for not having a serious scum read on BB. Also that if 1K flips as scum to pressure LDJ.
(Rosen seems to have forgotten 1K defending other players in every other game.)
Byzantine is lightly townreading Hobo and scumreading Daw.
BB likes Byzantine read post
Hobo suspects Byzantine (Slip) then BB (Distancing from Hobo with very quick switch to Daw... Many pages and a full day later) then Daw (general thread suspicion?) followed by Rosen (Bad behavior, but identical so not really suspicious to Hobo)
Huh, thought I was on Page 14. That might have been when I got distracted just reading the thread and then fell asleep though.
That's kinda annoying. Will mention that for any other Rosen stuff, the only other thing I had really seen during Day 1 from him was him calling our basic courtesy towards new players stupid. For reasons I don't have time to explain at the moment (Will be explaining post game anyways, since Rosen doesn't seem to keep reading after dying) I disagree, and decided that if they didn't care for the new player courtesy I wouldn't bother extending the 'Don't lynch repeatedly' courtesy. Rosen doing the exact same shit after claiming that he would stop doing it because it gets him lynched is going to get him lynched if we're not extending the courtesies of 'This is just how he plays' and 'We lynched him last game.'
Sorry, when rereading Rosen has gotten even more aggravating to me. I do not regret lynching him.