TheLastOne
Person of impeccable tastes (for destruction)
Well yes, given that the alternative is handing ultimate cosmic power to all the people who, to take an example at random, think gay people deserve to burn in hell for all eternity and breaking the Consensus that slaps them with Paradox if they try to enforce this, I am entirely comfortable with that. You say that the natural state for humanity is to be Awakened, but... that... doesn't really seem to be the case? Like, back before the Order of Reason, there still weren't many mages. The vast majority of humanity are counted among the Masses. Did something change from a glorious past where everyone was Enlightened? Some sort of great Darkening?
Heh. World of Darkness. Appropriate.
But yeah, I don't really think that view is valid given the sheer rarity of Awakening. And the Technocratic attitude that doesn't trust most people with ultimate power... is, uh, something I wholeheartedly agree with. For every Superman, there's a Darkseid. For every Daisy Johnson, there's a Lash. A strictly material global Consensus that posits power as something in the hands of the masses is a Consensus that protects Sleepers from mages, and while you can say "well working out how to Ascend everyone is a job for you; the players!", the fact that it needs to be because nobody else has a fucking clue how to do it does not fill me with confidence that I will succeed at such, or indeed confidence that this is the side I should be putting my faith and player-character powers of plot progression with.
We actually do have rules that while new souls are rare, all new souls naturally Awaken. It's only in future incarnations, broken and loaded down with sins and scars and failures, that you will fail to Awaken.
So yes, the natural state of humanity is Awakened and sleep is a fail state. It might not be your fault you failed to awaken - lots of things can darken a soul that have nothing to do with that persons decisions, but it is a collective failure.