HalfTangible
Only half sane (it's less cringe)
- Location
- Valkyrie, Primus
A lot of technological advancement both in settings and in our real world is less about inventing a new idea whole cloth (little in our world is, in fact) and more about taking previous ideas and improving on them, or taking something that doesn't work and discovering something new that makes it work.
Something I find irksome is that you'll have PCs that want to form a modern-style democracy or whatever because that's "just the way things ought to be", but I call bullcrap on that, that's what you the player think it should be. Which isn't a problem on its own, mind, but your character doesn't have any reason to think this way. You didn't grow up in a modern democracy, you grew up as a guild factor's daughter, or in a society where noble blood *literally* can give you magical powers to be better than everyone. Imagine how insane it would sound to somebody to suggest that a dragon blood should have no more say in the government's operations than a random rice farmer appropo of nothing.
It's obvious that you're doing this for a meta reason rather than an in-world one and moreover it's *boring*.
Democracy didn't start out as giving every person in a country the right to make decisions that would affect the whole country, it started out as an outgrowth of oligarchy. Constitutional monarchy came about because the noble class was sick of giving up their power to their king. We had steam engines for centuries before the industrial revolution, it was only when coal was discovered that steam power suddenly had a use (coal is a very dirty source of energy but it used to be plentiful on the earth's surface and it burned easily so it made for a good source of heat).
If you're going to advance society or tech in some way start by building off what's already there. In one game I was in a charlatan in a store was selling firewands that didn't require firedust to shoot. My Night Caste was curious how that worked so he stole it and examined it. He found that the wand had been made by breaking a fire-aspected hearthstone and sticking one of the shards into the gun's mechanism. In the south, the gun reloads essentially automatically, but this sort of weapon is also flimsy and will only last for so long before it needs to be repaired in full or given a replacement hearthstone shard.
Which immediately raises questions like "okay, what if the hearthstone was air aspected instead, could I shoot lightning?" or "how small do the shards need to be for this to work, would one hearthstone be able to equip a size 5 battle group?"
And really I think that's what advancement like this comes down to. Don't give me an endpoint, or even what you think is an endpoint, give me something that's interesting to play with and leads to new ideas. If you want your character to think everyone deserves to be equal under the law how do you square that with things like the dragon's blood? Both in the sense of it being a counter-argument, and in how you'd make a system that counteracts that sort of influence. If your Cynis thinks total abolition is necessary and right how do you advance that cause when your opinion is frankly not that popular even in your own house?
I'm not here to hear a treatise on how your moral philosophy is the BEST EVAR, or to see you bring modern tech I already know about into a medevial world, I'm here to see how you bring your ideas into the world and how the world reacts to them. If you want to bring things like modern democracy or cars into Exalted, fine. But how are you going to do that? What drives you to decide these are good ideas, and how are you going to make it happen in this unique setting?
Something I find irksome is that you'll have PCs that want to form a modern-style democracy or whatever because that's "just the way things ought to be", but I call bullcrap on that, that's what you the player think it should be. Which isn't a problem on its own, mind, but your character doesn't have any reason to think this way. You didn't grow up in a modern democracy, you grew up as a guild factor's daughter, or in a society where noble blood *literally* can give you magical powers to be better than everyone. Imagine how insane it would sound to somebody to suggest that a dragon blood should have no more say in the government's operations than a random rice farmer appropo of nothing.
It's obvious that you're doing this for a meta reason rather than an in-world one and moreover it's *boring*.
Democracy didn't start out as giving every person in a country the right to make decisions that would affect the whole country, it started out as an outgrowth of oligarchy. Constitutional monarchy came about because the noble class was sick of giving up their power to their king. We had steam engines for centuries before the industrial revolution, it was only when coal was discovered that steam power suddenly had a use (coal is a very dirty source of energy but it used to be plentiful on the earth's surface and it burned easily so it made for a good source of heat).
If you're going to advance society or tech in some way start by building off what's already there. In one game I was in a charlatan in a store was selling firewands that didn't require firedust to shoot. My Night Caste was curious how that worked so he stole it and examined it. He found that the wand had been made by breaking a fire-aspected hearthstone and sticking one of the shards into the gun's mechanism. In the south, the gun reloads essentially automatically, but this sort of weapon is also flimsy and will only last for so long before it needs to be repaired in full or given a replacement hearthstone shard.
Which immediately raises questions like "okay, what if the hearthstone was air aspected instead, could I shoot lightning?" or "how small do the shards need to be for this to work, would one hearthstone be able to equip a size 5 battle group?"
And really I think that's what advancement like this comes down to. Don't give me an endpoint, or even what you think is an endpoint, give me something that's interesting to play with and leads to new ideas. If you want your character to think everyone deserves to be equal under the law how do you square that with things like the dragon's blood? Both in the sense of it being a counter-argument, and in how you'd make a system that counteracts that sort of influence. If your Cynis thinks total abolition is necessary and right how do you advance that cause when your opinion is frankly not that popular even in your own house?
I'm not here to hear a treatise on how your moral philosophy is the BEST EVAR, or to see you bring modern tech I already know about into a medevial world, I'm here to see how you bring your ideas into the world and how the world reacts to them. If you want to bring things like modern democracy or cars into Exalted, fine. But how are you going to do that? What drives you to decide these are good ideas, and how are you going to make it happen in this unique setting?