I really like the idea of military awards that are Artifacts on their own right without being just, like, Artifact weapons or armor or such. One addition I'd suggest is an award or a set of awards given not to an individual but to a Sworn Kinship, granted for great deeds done together and specifically ones pulled off through teamwork and coordination rather than individual heroics. That'd seem fitting to me.
That's definitely a good idea.
I imagine most of the Realm's really big accomplishments were made by groups of DBs. And maybe something analogous to an ancient Roman triumph would be fitting in those cases. A huge parade celebrating the accomplishment, with the people who made it possible in the place of pride.
For the medal itself...maybe one big medal, broken into pieces, with each person wearing a piece. But what would it do? Giving it abilities to help the wearers work together would make sense, but why would DBs need a medal for that when they have Terrestrial Charms?
It could be specifically linked to a place, I suppose. A nation that you conquered or saved, generally. But what might that look like, specifically?
That's actually less constructive than you'd expect!
You see, when someone makes a post, and you reply to that post, but then you also add 500 words of homebrew, it drowns out the initial reply, attempts a subject shift, and breaks the continuity of the conversation - a hypothetical average reader following the thread is now having to follow multiple conversation threads at the same time. That's disruptive! If we all did it, maintaining multiple threads of conversation through quotations while producing "signal" every time to make up for the "noise" that accumulates over time, the discussion would swiftly become unreadable.
You understand this, of course. You're well practiced at forum posting. This kind of posting pattern only works if people regularly drop out of the conversation amidst the increasingly confused static of criss-crossing conversation and leave someone else with the last word. If someone were, hypothetically, very confident in their ability to tire out the other posters, though, that would make it a very effective way of getting people to stop posting and stop disagreeing with them.
If one were uncharitable, one might suggest that the purpose of such a topic shift is to crowd out other users, obstructing their ability to continue disagreeing with you by signaling "and now, if you continue this trivial argument instead of discussing The Good Content which I just posted, you're the one coming across as disruptive," in order to cow the people disagreeing with you into disengaging with you and giving you the last word. Not that I would ever accuse someone of doing that on purpose, of course.
No need to darkly theorize. I'll tell you straight up, it is meant to strangle the bad conversation. That's the point, and it's not meant to be hidden. Most people will absolutely give up on the argument and be happier for it.
It's not some scheme to steal the final word, though. People like you and me can't actually be dissuaded that way. But I don't want the last word so much as the next word - an unanswered point itches at me. And I think you're the same. By bundling the discourse with useful conversation, that unhealthy instinct of ours can be yoked to a wheel and put to work.
Anyway, as a show of good faith and in the spirit of following your ways of doing things:
I'm curious which Exigents people are most excited to read about in Miracles of the Divine Flame and Champions of the Divine Flame. Post here about your most anticipated Exigent!
You know, I'm honestly not sure what to expect in those, beyond the obvious. I assume the hints are in the KS updates I'm not getting.
Where should I look if I want to know more?
I'm sorry to drag you back into this whole affair, Sanctaphrax, but I'm pretty sure that the biggest issue people have with you during the Kickstarter is that you feel the need to comment on the content of the manuscript purely by getting secondhand information of other forum posts, caused by your apparent blood grudge against Exalted Kickstarters by which gazing upon the manuscript itself, for free, is an unclean act.
You'd think!
But even when the text is available without backing, so I can read it directly, or the comments are being made by someone else, the same dynamic repeats.
But, also… I, personally, am a really really late arrival to Exalted as a gameline. I've known about the game (through Keychain of Creation, natch) for a while, but my interest in the game was really sparked just after the Sidereal Kickstarter ended, IIRC.
...
I can't say anything about 2e because, TBH, I haven't read any mainline 2e material that wasn't copy-and-pasted into a wiki, and from reading the discussions of people who I respect, everything I've seen makes me want to avoid it like the plague. What it seems like is that all the cool stuff is bogged down by even more cringe shit from authors who were doing things to be edgy. Which then produced books that aged real poorly. Which then feeds into my confusion of why people are, to this day, refusing to move on from 2e. But I was not part of the White Wolf forums. I was not a part of the discussion of the game during its heyday. Those days are gone and I don't feel anything because I was never there. Yet it seems like for some people, that's what drew them to the game to begin with. I don't think I can blame them for that.
It's good to hear from someone who actually joined recently. Sometimes it feels like the doors are locked, and nobody ever comes in.
But as for Ex2, well, most of those same people who complain about it either joined during it or played through it. If it was that bad, they wouldn't be here. It has a lot more going for it than the chatter lets on.
And it should be plainly obvious why some people don't "move on", even people who'd probably prefer Ex3. You know full well just how much reading it takes to move onto a new edition of this colossal game. You don't need a reason to
not read many large books. Which is, by the way, why I'm not telling you to read Ex2.
Though, if you have the books available, reading through the chapter comics and checking out the art is actually very quick and easy. Might be worth doing; some of those comics stick in my mind to this very day.