A Regiment at War: A American Civil War Quest

I wonder when we get down further in the south will the Confederates split into their own civil war as the planters reveal themselves making the poor whites fight them for trying to save their positions from the north
No they will not. We will not be getting into that at all.

Honestly when I was researching the quest for details on the battle and campaign, I realised the first day was a chaotic mess of an accidental battle where both sides filtered in units gradually based around a Hill.

So it was a lot like First Bull Run, I went with that, added a dash of OTL Fishers Hill and then sprinkled some Gettysburg inspirations on top when I realised V Corps under Hancock had been the first infantry on the scene according to the quest.

So, in the Legacy portion, when I talk about the Union soldiers, officers and Generals who were at First Bull Run/Manassas and Fishers Hill/Stratsburg obsessing over the later, it's because I ended up very deliberately making it a Union First Bull Run, a cathartic 'we did it back to them' almost.

I even had it gifting the Union armies of the East a sense of Elan and invincibility that multiple Confederate officers claimed the Confederates achieved after First Manassas, for good and ill.

So yeah, I designed Fishers Hill to be a Northern reversal of First Bull Run.

My inspiration when coming up with the battle was indeed Gettysburg, just down in Virginia. Had the elements of Lee stealing a march to the north and the Union Army having to follow up as quickly as they could to confront him.
 
The Union armies or at least the Army of the Potomac getting cocky could be interesting. Especially the officers that were at First and Second Bull Run. Which to be fair isn't surprising. The Union is advancing pretty far into enemy territory. Virginia in Union hands, most of North Carolina and starting on South Carolina. And that's just the Eastern Theater while the Western Theater under Grant is making good progress too with Vicksburg being a big piece of the cake.

Edit: Though luckily people like Kearny, Grant and Yates aren't the type of people to underestimate their enemies even when things are looking good.
 
Last edited:

It's our duty as Yates to drill into future officer skill that they will NOT be any worshipping of any one strategy in disregard of other, and the the importance of delegation. We gotta do it until they're a 2 inch hole in every one of them skull.
 
The Union armies or at least the Army of the Potomac getting cocky could be interesting. Especially the officers that were at First and Second Bull Run. Which to be fair isn't surprising. The Union is advancing pretty far into enemy territory. Virginia in Union hands, most of North Carolina and starting on South Carolina. And that's just the Eastern Theater while the Western Theater under Grant is making good progress too with Vicksburg being a big piece of the cake.

Edit: Though luckily people like Kearny, Grant and Yates aren't the type of people to underestimate their enemies even when things are looking good.
They aren't getting cocky can say that. Too many earlier defeats and still the Rebs give them jabs and fight hard at every fight. Know they can fight and win but not cocky.

It's our duty as Yates to drill into future officer skill that they will NOT be any worshipping of any one strategy in disregard of other, and the the importance of delegation. We gotta do it until they're a 2 inch hole in every one of them skull.
This is a bit over the top, can you please tone it down? Thank you...
 
I wonder when we get down further in the south will the Confederates split into their own civil war as the planters reveal themselves making the poor whites fight them for trying to save their positions from the north

That would just instantly collapse the Confederacy's war effort and they know it.

Far more likely is that civil unrest and power struggles in the Confederacy result in politicking and assassination campaigns, but even that I would not expect to happen. You might see Confederate states seceding from the Confederacy and surrendering to the Union independently, but that's a very big if, given that none of the Carolinas or even Virginia have formally renounced their ties with the Confederacy within their own legislatures.

The more likely result is the Confederacy first running out supplies for the armies, then their armies running out of the will to fight, and then, if they keep fighting, running out of manpower to fight with as desertions and draft dodging escalate.
 
The Eastern Theater: October 5th, 1863 - October 18th, 1863
The Eastern Theater: October 5th, 1863 - October 18th, 1863



"Form up boys! At least a half dozen regiments out there get behind cover and prepare to defend yourselves!

Hundreds of men in blue were soon dismounting from their saddles as they ran to find what cover they could find as a slight rain descended from above. Ahead the crack of Spencer Carbines could be heard as skirmishers of the 10th New York and 4th Pennsylvania Cavalry engaged with oncoming Confederate cavalry.

Major General David McM. Gregg watched from several hundred yards behind his forward lines, currently held by his cousin, Colonel John Irvin Gregg's Brigade. "Looks like JEB has several brigades ahead of us doesn't it?"

"Reckon your correct sir. Looks to be another coming up behind those ahead of us, " replied Colonel Pennock Huey, commander of the 8th Pennsylvania Cavalry.

"Not too worried sir. I have Gregg's brigade here on line with both McIntosh and Davies coming up with their brigades as we speak. Say I have just shy of four thousand men and four batteries of artillery here or nearby." Brigadier General James H. Wilson gave a reply as he lowered a pair of looking glasses from his eyes.

Gregg breathed through his nose as he spoke up. "Stuart is certainly trying to keep us back from finding out where Jackson has his army isn't he?"

"Slowed us down for weeks with this, though I guess you can say it's been years as well if you reckon in past campaigns. Granted I wasn't there so I'm not sure where I stack up."

Gregg glanced at Wilson as he continued to watch the deployments of his division, the man having been transferred to his command after William Averell had refused to work under Sebastian Yates due to him being a "political" officer. Averell was a decent commander and had shocked some with his transfer out to the West, but so far Wilson had proven his worth, having been recommended by General Grant for his abilities and courage. "I started with the Army of the Potomac back in the Peninsula in 62 and all through Antietam and the Overland Campaign. It was under Yates and Buford though we finally came into our own."

Gregg had come up within the Regular Army, having graduated from West Point, having ironically enough been classmates with J.E.B. Stuart for a few years. Working with John Buford, another veteran of various engagements with Native Indians had hardened him to campaigns but it had been the unleashing of the Cavalry Corps by General Yates that had allowed the cavalry arm and Gregg to shine. Several times Gregg had gone out on raids with his division and independent from Buford, giving him experience to prepare him for his current command.

Small arms fire increased as the dismounted Union cavalrymen began engaging, laying down a tremendous amount of fire as Gregg's Corps had been fully equipped with Spencer, Sharp, and Smith Repeating Rifles. A cavalry brigade could now put down the firepower of a Division, a withering display that had seen several Confederate assaults simply melt away, stopped in their tracks. Having a half brigade of horse artillery also helped, though Stuart's artillery was now getting involved as well.

A rider came up quickly, his uniform a bit muddy from puddles from the rain he had ridden through. "Sur! Beg yu'r padon but I'as out on the left and seen about a couple thousand of d'em Johnny Rebs coming up from th're." The man then realized he was talking to a Major General and quickly saluted. "Sorry sur, beg yu'r padon a'gan."

"Bet that is "Rooney" Lee's boys." Gregg guessed, knowing that William E. "Grumble" Jones had been killed before Charlotte a few weeks back. "Stuart must have his full Corps here."

James Wilson shook his head, spitting on the ground. "Reckon so sir, think he can rough up my division before help can arrive. Won't allow that to happen, though looks like he is getting his artillery into action."

Sure enough, Gregg spotted several batteries of artillery unlimbering ahead of where his lines were forming. "I am sure Captain Robinson's artillery can deal with them." Captain James M. Robertson commanded the First Horse Artillery Brigade, though two of his batteries were currently attached to Brigadier General Elon J. Farnsworth's division. Gregg mused for a moment. "Let's get a rider out to Farnsworth, he should be only a few miles away near Yonguesville. Also, send another to General Sheridan, should be between Blackstock and Hazelwood."

"Think Sheridan can get down here quick enough? Also what about Kilpatrick sir?"

"If Sheridan pushes, and he usually does, his lead division should get here I think. Kilpatrick should be out near Lemons and Buckhead so too far out for this fight. Besides, I think we have enough between you and Farnsworth though James. Boys had done pretty well accounting themselves the last few months."

"That they have sir. I'll get my boys deployed quickly." Wilson saluted and headed off to direct his division as Gregg watched on as the fight developed before them.





"From what has been gathered sir, it looks like the Confederates are strongly entrenching in the hills in northern Georgia and southern Tennessee from what we are getting from General Grant and the papers. General Beauregard is also reported masking General Sherman's forces around Jackson, Mississippi but neither has been very active in campaigning so far, it is believed that Beauregard has shifted some forces to the east, more specifically towards northern Georgia."

Sebastian found himself sitting in a parlor in Florence, South Carolina listening to his newest aide, Captain Robert Todd Lincoln, the young man had arrived a week ago fresh from Washington. The younger Lincoln was not as tall as his father but stood properly, bringing a smile to his face as he thought of the long lessons he had endured from both his mother and father on how one should conduct themselves while in the company of others. Wishing their approval and the way he was, he always made sure to follow the instructions to the letter, something his sisters teased him for to no end calling him a "suckup" and "kissass" regularly.

He chuckled out loud at that though, the Captain stopping his report as he got to Charleston and the Department of the South. "Should I continue sir?"

"Ah yes sorry Robert, thought passed into my mind and caused me to chuckle. Continue please." Sebastian noticed Thomas squirm a little, always pressing Sebastian to pay attention during these meetings so he wouldn't have to go over it again. Sebastian smiled back at Thomas as Robert continued. "Of course sir, rather used to that with my father. Always comes at you with a story to tell..."

Robert cleared his throat for a moment, it was clear to all listening that he was making an effort to not influence things with just who his father was. "As requested sir, a report was forwarded by both Generals Hunter and Gillmore on operations around Jacksonville and Charleston."

Sebastian straightened a bit, having had to wait for a few days for the reports to arrive as he took on the new responsibility of the Department of the South. With adding that responsibility he had decided to accept the removal of the Department of Virginia from his command to help concentrate his efforts on the advance towards Atlanta.

"General Hunter reports he has around nine thousand men under his command in and around Jacksonville. He requests and I might add have put quite the emphasis on this, that he be able to march into Middle Florida, cutting the railroad at Baldwin and around Lake City as reports state that the Confederates are nearing complication on linking the Georgia and Florida railways there at Lawton, Georgia."

"If they achieve that how does it affect things for us?" Sebastian inquired, directly asking his assembled staff, working to catch up on the situation further south.

"I can answer that sir," John Babcock, Sebastian's Chief of Intelligence spoke up, Sebastian nodding in response for him to continue. "With the... drastic reduction of land owned by the Confederacy it is known that food and other supplies are being shipped from Florida to supply many units of the Confederate Army in both Georgia and South Carolina. A situation the Confederates are keenly aware of I might add sir."

Sebastian leaned back in his chair. "You think the advance is ill-advised John?"

"A couple of factors to keep of note, sir." Babcock began, Sebastian noting that the man was not using any notes as he spoke—a remarkable mind. "We know the Confederates have been moving troops around, the incursion into Florida could see more troops shifted there. We haven't confirmed anything but I am still getting resources up to cover the Department of the South. If that is the case I am unsure General Hunter will have enough men for his advance."

"You said he has nine thousand, right Robert? How many does Gillmore currently have outside Savannah and Charleston?"

Captain Lincoln looked down at several reports in his hand and took a moment to shift through them before replying. "General Gillmore reports he has just over nine thousand men under General Terry with the X Corps on Morris Island and close to eight thousand on Folly Island under General Schurz with XI Corps so about seventeen thousand around Charleston. General Saxton has around thirty-six hundred between Port Royal and Hilton Head as well and with other detachments looks like all together the Department of the South has about thirty thousand men."

"Hrm... and how many do we estimate the Confederates have against them?" Sebastian solicited, hoping his Intelligence Chief at least had some figures on hand.

"These are raw estimates sir so please don't accept them as gospel but from what I gathered from Generals Gillmore and Hunter it is estimated around fifteen to sixteen thousand in and around Charleston and points south with another estimated three thousand in Florida. We also know that Longstreet's command has pulled back behind Jeffrey's Creek just south of General Slocum's positions here in Florence with him shielding the approach to Charleston from the north."

"So Bragg has around let's say twenty thousand just to be safe and Longstreet has what another fifteen to twenty thousand?"

"Closer to sixteen thousand for Longstreet, he has Martin's cavalry working along the Creek to keep us on our toes it seems," Babcock answered much more confidently as he fielded the question.

Sebastian took a breath as he straightened in his chair. "Henry you have what? Around sixty thousand now with Getty with you?"

Henry Slocum, commander of the Army of the Cape Fear sat up in the chair he was sitting in and nodded. "Aye sir, it was nice to see his Corps coming down the road when he did. Was a bit worried Hardee and Longstreet would link up and hit us like at Greensboro."

Sebastian turned to Thomas real quick as Henry mentioned Hardee. "Any information from Meade on Hardee and his intentions? And yes I would rather avoid another Greensboro if we can help it..."

"Yes sir," Thomas spoke up quickly as he answered Sebastian. "Colonel Sharpe is up with General Meade and his last report has him investing Camden with the Seventh and Ninth Corps while he has Buford scouting and covering his flanks. General Meade has also requested that General Getty be returned to him as quickly as he can as he is worried, like General Slocum, about a link-up between Hardee and Jackson."

Sebastian nodded slowly... Meade had proceeded as quickly as he could but Hardee had been able to slow him down just enough to allow him to prepare positions at Camden which had stopped Meade's advance for now. Meade didn't believe he had the strength to launch a successful assault with the resources in his immediate vicinity to take the city either. "And how is Schofield doing?"

"He has reached the town of Chester with Gregg's Cavalry scouting out down as far as Winnsborongh where they report elements of Jackson's Army are located. Gregg and Stuart got into a pretty sharp fight but Gregg came out on top from what reports we have gotten. Looks like Jackson is holding Hardee's flank across from Camden, keeping Schofield from cutting him off and keeping us from Columbia." Thomas spelled out the picture of what Sebastian's Department was dealing with and gave Sebastian more focus. "His forces are still a bit spread out, leaving Parke's III Corps around Charlotte as it looks like D.H. Hill is still operating in western North Carolina."

"That man keeps appearing, doesn't he? Would rather like to meet him someday, curious to see what he has to say about me." Sebastian chuckled. He had fought Hill several times over the last year, defeating him in every engagement, though Hill had shown he certainly didn't lack skill or ability. "What's the situation with Howard?"

"Ah sir, one moment..." Eyes shifted back to Lincoln as he went through several reports, Sebastian looking over at Thomas and smiling as Robert reminded him of his Chief of Staff. "Ah, here it is. He has the majority of his Army at Catawba View on the Catawba River. Looks like he is covering the river while shielding Salisbury and General Schofield's northern flank."

Sebastian took in the information organizing it the best he could in his mind as he formulated options in his head. "I know we got a bit off-topic but this does give me an idea of what we are facing. John, do you have numbers on what we think Jackson and Hardee have in terms of troops?"

Colonel Babcock quickly began rattling off numbers to answer Sebastian's question. "Jackson's Army has been widdled down from the various campaigns but we estimate he has around twenty-five thousand in the field right now, though he could be reinforced by Hardee or maybe forces from Georgia or out west. Hardee we think has around thirty-five thousand though Meade reports he has only seen Breckinridge and Hill's Corps around Camden. We think French is watching Slocum's approach from the east. Also, we believe Hill has around eight to ten thousand men total himself, so I would put the total Confederate forces against us at around one hundred to a hundred ten thousand, give or take."

"We easily outnumber them, sir." Sebastian's Inspector General, Colonel Owen Gladstone spoke up cheerfully.

"We usually do Owen, yet they continue to hold us back and push back against us. They are also on shrunken interior lines which helps them and hurts us." Sebastian crinkled his nose, noting Gladstone quickly looked a bit dejected. Sebastian quickly moved on but wondered if he needed to have a separate conversation with Gladstone to smooth any rustled feathers. "How are our logistical efforts?"

"I do believe that is me, sir." Brigadier General Samuel B. Holabird half chuckled as he rubbed his beard. "We continue to bring up supplies the best we can. My staff has arranged for sixty to seventy rounds per soldier within their haversacks, and another one hundred in local trains. Afraid we are suffering a bit of a shortage after that though, the higher rate of consumption with the Breechloaders does make it harder to keep up with replacing ammunition. That, on top of partisan attacks and our railways still having to catch up, it will most likely be a few months before I can safely say we will have ample reserves again."


"That for all Armies? And is there anything we can do to help that along?" Sebastian asked, a bit worried as he continued to push to upgrade the weapons used by his soldiers.

"Well sir, General Barnard and his engineers are doing wonders, don't want to knock them at all. With some heavier rains, we have had to switch to more wagon trains as the temporary rails are taking a while to lay or rains are rising the rivers to make the crossing hard to bridge."

"We are going as quickly as we can, as Samuel said, but admit it hasn't been easy. The USMRR has been helping considerably but we are still running behind schedule. It might help if we shifted some infantry to help build, which would help our Labor Corps, which has been doing yeoman's work alongside my engineers and USMRR. I would also suggest a Rail Tsar so to speak be put in charge would help considerably."

"Oh, that would indeed help. Hasn't happened too much but sometimes trains get rerouted or schedules changed due to special requests or other...erm.. meddling." Samuel Holabird quickly chimed in.

Sebastian scratched his chin. "I take it that means someone in complete control and can overrule others when it comes to trains and their function?"

"Exactly sir. I recommend Herman Haupt for the job. The man knows everything about railways and has done wonders supporting the Army of the Potomac. He might be an overbearing man but he gets the job done." Barnard answered, clearly having put some thought into this. "Another would be Thomas Scott, but I don't know too much about him but he has worked with Secretary Staunton since the beginning of the war and helped organize support of the war effort with the railways."

"Another suggestion would be establishing some more depots closer to the fronts, sir." Holabird speaking once more." Currently, our main depots are back in Goldsboro, Wilmington, and back in Virginia. The issue is how far forward we want to put them. Afraid they could be raided by partisans or enemy cavalry. Oh and to your question about ammunition yes sir, that's for all armies. General Slocum's is the easiest to supply being close to Wilmington and all and the railways are mostly intact. The rest are further back and taking us more time."

"How many wagons are we using by chance?"

"About seven thousand sir, with another fifteen hundred ambulances and around fifty thousand mules and horses pulling them," Holabird replied, some soft whistles heard as it became apparent just how massive an effort it took to keep Sebastian's armies in the field and supplied. Sebastian took off his hat and scratched his head. "Huh, hell of an effort. Alright well, where do you propose we put the new depots?"

Holabird pulled out a small locale map and tapped on several locations as he spoke. "Charlotte is an obvious choice and with Parke's Corps holding it should be relatively secure or we can put it in Chester, which is where General Schofield currently has his main army. I would recommend either Chesterfield or Rockingham to support General Meade's army, though Rockingham would be more secure and has the railroad going towards Cheraw as well, which is almost complete. Chesterfield would be closer though. Another here in Florence to support General Slocum, though we could put it further back in Marton to our east, or further north in Darlington closer to Cheraw or Cheraw itself for both Armies."

"As to the partisan attacks General," this time it was Thomas replying, he adding in now. "I do believe we can pull some forces off from the front to help in the short term. We also have several new regiments arriving and the artillery we retrained for infantry duties should be finishing it up soon. Could give them experience and help release the infantry when they arrive. Just a thought sir. If we don't, it might be a little rough but our efforts aren't going to waste."

"We also have rescued about ten thousand prisons from various camps that couldn't be evacuated by our advance. Mostly around Salisbury and Charlette. Though some of those unfortunate souls are not ready to return to the fight any time soon..." Jacob Monsoon added, a look of disgust apparent.

Sebastian had seen some of those rescued and the treatment they had received had been downright despicable. Unfortunately, however, Sebastian had heard the camps for Confederate prisoners were not much better further north, though he had made he effort to see those he had captured were well treated as much as he could. The camp at New Bern was a prime example, with over three thousand Confederates currently there with more coming in and out as they were sent further north or paroled.

"So might not be much of an option right now, as sounds like those men need time to rest and be rehabilitated or just sent home to recover. Either way, it seems we have quite a lot of options and questions on the table." Sebastian let out a soft sigh as he worked through the problems that came up with his push forward that affected his armies. "We almost need to figure out if we can't continue to push on Columbia or shift our priorities."

Thomas took point quickly as Sebastian brought up the next part of the campaign. "I think we need to see it through and take Columbia, sir. We have put great effort towards it and it would be a hell of a victory for us to secure it and set us up for a push on Atlanta down the line. That said I am not sure General Meade's forces can do much at this time, not unless we send him reinforcements with the return of the Eighteenth Corps and perhaps some from the Army of the Potomac. We could also just march on Columbia with the Army of the Potomac from the north and General Slocum's forces here from the east and keep Meade in place to fix Hardee in Camden."

Thomas took a quick breath as he continued giving options. "There is also the possibility of shifting down towards Charleston, having General Gillmore push the attack there and directing General Slocum's army against Longstreet and see if we can't evacuate and take the port, another moral victory with taking the city where the war started. Could at the same time push the Army of the Potomac towards Columbia but could see some reinforcement from Hardee and others to maybe concentrate on him. He does have our largest force though and quality commanders within it and should be able to take anything thrown at it. Those are the options as I see them, sir." Thomas, always formal finished summarizing the options ahead.

"There is also about the push into Florida as well General." Captain Lincoln added on, being a bit more relaxed with the conversation.

"Yes several options ahead of us it seems and I am afraid another couple of battles coming up as well." Sebastian had much on his mind as he spoke. "We could also certainly halt all operations until our supply situation improves as well..." Sebastian's words trailed off as his officers spent several more minutes discussing strategy and where the Military Division of the Roanoke would take.




Well all its been a while since this was officially updated but I wanted to give you all a Christmas gift so here it is! Another update! Some views from the front and some cavalry action for ya and a lot of speaking on problems the Armies are dealing with, where to take the direction of the offensives and a few other options as well! Hope you all enjoy your holidays and enjoy the update!

How should the Army of the Cape Fear (Slocum) proceed?
  • [] Continue east-southeast and march on Columbia.
  • [] Continue east and reinforce General Meade's Army of the Roanoke.
  • [] Turn south and march on Charleston.
  • [] Hold its current position at this time.
How should the Army of the Roanoke (Meade) proceed?
  • [] Assault Camden and attempt to take the town and then march on Columbia.
    • [] Wait until reinforcements arrive and then assault?
    • [] Don't wait for any reinforcements and assault now?
  • [] Break the siege and attempt to march south to Columbia and meeting up with the Army of the Cape Fear?
  • [] Hold their current positions and pin Hardee's Army in place if possible.
How should the Army of the Potomac (Schofield) proceed?
  • [] Continue to march south and attempt to take Columbia?
  • [] Shift positions and move to reinforce General Meade's army?
  • [] Hold current positions and keep Jackson in place before it?
How should the Army of West Virginia (Howard) proceed?
  • [] Continue to push south and attempt to secure Western North Carolina?
  • [] Hold their current positions and keep the rear secure?
How should the forces outside Charleston (Gillmore) proceed?
  • [] Launch assaults to try and force the enemies position and take the city if possible?
  • [] Send out probes and keep as many Confederates pinned to defend the city as possible?
  • [] Hold current positions and continue the siege?
How should we proceed in Florida (Hunter)?
  • [] Push out from our holdings and attempt to push to secure the railway and keep the Confederates from finishing their link up?
  • [] Send a limited force forward to try and delay the Confederates as much as possible?
  • [] Hold current positions and wait for more troops to arrive?
Should we return the XVIII Corps (Getty) to General Meade's Army?
  • [] Yes, they are needed at Camden as quickly as possible and will even out the Armies.
  • [] Negative we should keep them with the Army of the Cape Fear (Slocum) at this time.
Should we send reinforcements to General Meade from either the Army of the Potomac (Schofield) or the Army of the Cape Fear (Slocum)?
  • [] Yes send from the Army of the Potomac.
    • [] I Corps (Reynolds)
    • [] II Corps (Richardson)
    • [] III Corps (Parke)
    • [] V Corps (Hancock)
    • [] VI Corps (Sedgwick)
    • [] XXIV Corps (Sheridan)
  • [] Yes from the Army of the Cape Fear
    • [] IV Corps (Sturgis)
    • [] XII Corps (Williams)
    • [] XXII Corps (Cox)
  • [] No they are currently good with what they have.
Should we appoint "Railway Tsar" to help with the coordination of our trains and the railways?
  • [] Yes we should, it helps us in many ways and means we have one person controlling our rearward efforts.
    • [] Appoint Herman Haupt?
    • [] Appoint Thomas Scott?
    • [] Appoint someone selected by the War Department?
  • [] No we don't need this right now, our supplies are arriving and our current forces are handling it well.
Should we move depots to support the Armies closer to the front lines?
  • [] Yes we should [Select for each other below]
    • [] Army of the Cape Fear
      • [] Florence (current Army location)
      • [] Darlington (Between the AotR and the AotCR)
      • [] Marton (A bit further back)
      • [] Keep it at Wilmington
    • [] Army of the Potomac
      • [] Charlotte (A bit further back in the rear - III Corps there)
      • [] Chester (current Army location)
    • [] Army of the Roanoak
      • [] Chesterfield
      • [] Cheraw (Could support both AotR and AotCF)
      • [] Rockingham (Further back in North Carolina)
  • [] No we shouldn't yet, lets see how things play out before we completely shift things around.
Should we detach some infantry from the Armies to help build bridges and railways as well as reinforce our garrisons against partisans?
  • [] Yes we should, it will help us in the long run even if it temporarily weakens us on the frontlines.
    • [] Keep them until our new regiments arrive and can take their place?
    • [] Keep them until the areas are secured and the new troops are in place and have been installed for several weeks?
  • [] No we shouldn't, we need all the troops we can get right now fighting.
What should we do with the rescued prisoners?
  • [] Use those healthy enough to take up a musket again and use them to garrison our rear areas. Send the sick and those unable to fight home.
  • [] These men have been through a traumatic experience, send them home and allow them to rest back in the North with their families.
 
Last edited:
It's great to see this back, and also great to see that the Cavalry Corps of the Potomac have finally risen up and matched that of the James/Roanoke.

It's a hell of a Christmas present.

My initial thought is to go with a plan of strategic separation and fully utilising our numbers, assaults on Charleston by Slocum and Gillmore, Meade reinforced by Getty to attack Camden, Hunter striking up towards Lake City, Howard to strike at Wilmington and Schofield to attack Jackson and attempt to conquer Columbia.

Our commanders are competent, and have the numbers, each of them have proven themselves, and the Confederates only have so many field armies to respond, attacking all across so many theatres at once forces them to choose.

Fight and defend a single city, and lose the other four, or stand and defend them all and lose all five.
 
Last edited:
Merry Christmas to you all guys. And hey Yates got a very good present of almost taking all of North Carolina which should be all soon.

Probably need to read the update again to make sure I remember the troops numbers for both sides and their current positions but things are looking good. Need to make sure our logistics can support our armies.
 
I have to say, with the increasingly pulled-back perspective we have and the emphasis on logistics as much as tactical maneuver, this all reminds me as much of HOI4 as anything. Although, alas, we lack panzer divisions to conduct proper breakthroughs and encirclements.
Our commanders are competent, and have the numbers, each of them have proven themselves, and the Confederates only have so many field armies to respond, attacking all across so many theatres at once forces them to choose.

Fight and defend a single city, and lose the other four, or stand and defend them all and lose all five.
I'm inclined to agree with this general plan, although I intend to wait until the map has been produced before working out anything in detail. The Confederates are retracting their lines of defense and digging in, which means we're going to have to oversaturate their lines of defense and prevent any more rapid maneuvers that Jackson is so effective at.

That being said, if you'll recall from the last update, distant as it is, we made certain decisions regarding railroads and logistics that placed a heavy importance on capturing Columbia before we've exhausted our momentum and can prepare for a final campaign on Atlanta. Given that, I'll strongly urge that our focus be on securing the state capital itself, with other attacks fundamentally being pinning maneuvers to prevent the rebels from concentrating their forces in reaction.

For Florida, I'm not sure about Hunter's character and ability to handle himself in such an autonomous, uncertain position, but attacking the region and preventing the Confederacy from having any safe backyard whatsoever strikes me as a sound idea. I'm inclined to tell him to wait until he has all his forces gathered up before launching an attack, as we're confident we have roughly more than the enemy and this reduces the possibility of him blundering into a trap out of haste.

Regarding the prisoners, send those poor bastards home. Having them act as garrisons is begging for a spree of atrocities from traumatized, angry soldiers wanting some payback.
 
Sending them home may negatively impact the homefront. Maybe make sure they've got a couple of weeks of good eating and recovery before doing so?

But yes, using them immediately for garrison duties is a bad idea. It'd be preferable to send them north to a camp somewhere in New England to recover even if we don't send them home.
 
Sending them home may negatively impact the homefront. Maybe make sure they've got a couple of weeks of good eating and recovery before doing so?

But yes, using them immediately for garrison duties is a bad idea. It'd be preferable to send them north to a camp somewhere in New England to recover even if we don't send them home.
There is only two options for what to do with them :p
 
I have to say, with the increasingly pulled-back perspective we have and the emphasis on logistics as much as tactical maneuver, this all reminds me as much of HOI4 as anything. Although, alas, we lack panzer divisions to conduct proper breakthroughs and encirclements.

I'm inclined to agree with this general plan, although I intend to wait until the map has been produced before working out anything in detail. The Confederates are retracting their lines of defense and digging in, which means we're going to have to oversaturate their lines of defense and prevent any more rapid maneuvers that Jackson is so effective at.

That being said, if you'll recall from the last update, distant as it is, we made certain decisions regarding railroads and logistics that placed a heavy importance on capturing Columbia before we've exhausted our momentum and can prepare for a final campaign on Atlanta. Given that, I'll strongly urge that our focus be on securing the state capital itself, with other attacks fundamentally being pinning maneuvers to prevent the rebels from concentrating their forces in reaction.

For Florida, I'm not sure about Hunter's character and ability to handle himself in such an autonomous, uncertain position, but attacking the region and preventing the Confederacy from having any safe backyard whatsoever strikes me as a sound idea. I'm inclined to tell him to wait until he has all his forces gathered up before launching an attack, as we're confident we have roughly more than the enemy and this reduces the possibility of him blundering into a trap out of haste.

Regarding the prisoners, send those poor bastards home. Having them act as garrisons is begging for a spree of atrocities from traumatized, angry soldiers wanting some payback.
Yeah that is the worst part with this. We.moved away from the more tactial part and onto the strategic level and outside the direcring battles. Its been a but of a struggle to write at this level.
 
Yeah that is the worst part with this. We.moved away from the more tactial part and onto the strategic level and outside the direcring battles. Its been a but of a struggle to write at this level.
I'd hardly describe it as a bad thing! HOI4's a good game, and thinking about the civil war on this highly strategic, logistical perspective is extremely interesting. That being said, I can understand how you'd find it difficult to write.
 
[X] Plan: Christmas in Columbia
-[X] Continue east-southeast and march on Columbia.
-[X] Hold their current positions and pin Hardee's Army in place if possible.
-[X] Continue to march south and attempt to take Columbia?
-[X] Continue to push south and attempt to secure Western North Carolina?
-[X] Send out probes and keep as many Confederates pinned to defend the city as possible?
-[X] Send a limited force forward to try and delay the Confederates as much as possible?
-[X] Negative we should keep them with the Army of the Cape Fear (Slocum) at this time.
-[X] No they are currently good with what they have.
-[X] Yes we should, it helps us in many ways and means we have one person controlling our rearward efforts.
--[X] Appoint Herman Haupt?
-[X] Yes we should [Select for each other below]
--[X] Army of the Cape Fear
---[X] Florence (current Army location)
--[X] Army of the Potomac
---[X] Chester (current Army location)
--[X] Army of the Roanoak
---[X] Chesterfield
-[X] Yes we should, it will help us in the long run even if it temporarily weakens us on the frontlines.
--[X] Keep them until the areas are secured and the new troops are in place and have been installed for several weeks?
-[X] These men have been through a traumatic experience, send them home and allow them to rest back in the North with their families.

The gist of this plan is to remain on-focus with our previous strategic decisions and focus on capturing Columbia. With the state's capital fallen, the Confederate position in South Carolina will become untenable and it'll be a tremendous political victory for the Union. Thus, our overall army movements should either be intent on capturing the city or pinning down Confederate troops so they cannot move to participate in the siege.

For our extended armies, namely Hunter and Howard, I'm a little more cautious. I don't see any reason why Howard shouldn't be able to secure the rest of NorCal, and it'll help secure the legitimacy of the new state government. Hunter, meanwhile, is in a more tenuous position. We don't know much about his character as a general, and the intelligence in the region is very murky. I'm inclined to tell him to wait until reinforcements can be pulled from the Southern Front before beginning his proper attack on Florida, and in the meantime to stall rebel movements with smaller detachments.

Meade's army has taken a battering and is attempting a potentially dangerous outflanking maneuver, so I'm having it reinforced with Getty's and Reynold's Corps, which should minimize the danger of the march. Logistically, a Railroad Tsar sounds like a fine idea and I'll take the recommended candidate. For the new logistical hubs, let's set them up as close to the front lines as feasible - we can detach additional guards, and the shift in rebel strategy will mean fighting will only grow more supply-hungry. Finally, putting up ex-prisoners to interact with rebel civilians is simply a poor idea bound to end in tears and a PR shitshow.
 
Last edited:
Okay, my plan


[X] Plan: The Broadest Front
-[X] Turn south and march on Charleston.
-[X] Assault Camden and attempt to take the town and then march on Columbia.
—[X] Wait until reinforcements arrive and then assault?
-[X] Continue to march south and attempt to take Columbia?
-[X] Continue to push south and attempt to secure Western North Carolina?
-[X] Launch assaults to try and force the enemies position and take the city if possible?
-[X] Push out from our holdings and attempt to push to secure the railway and keep the Confederates from finishing their link up?
-[X] Yes, they are needed at Camden as quickly as possible and will even out the Armies.
-[X] No they are currently good with what they have.
-[X] Yes we should, it helps us in many ways and means we have one person controlling our rearward efforts.
—[X] Appoint Herman Haupt?
-[X] Yes we should [Select for each other below]
--[X] Army of the Cape Fear
---[X] Florence (current Army location)
--[X] Army of the Potomac
---[X] Chester (current Army location)
--[X] Army of the Roanoak
---[X] Chesterfield
-[X] Yes we should, it will help us in the long run even if it temporarily weakens us on the frontlines.
—[X] Keep them until the areas are secured and the new troops are in place and have been installed for several weeks?
-[X] These men have been through a traumatic experience, send them home and allow them to rest back in the North with their families.

This is a bit different than Templar's plan. Personally I feel like we should press as hard as we can across all fronts. By reinforcing Meade's Army, giving him a full roster of extremely competent officers and the numbers to match both Confederate armies in the area, I have full confidence he'll at least pin Jackson down.

The Army of the Potomac, our largest force, should be able to break through and seize the Capitol of South Carolina, we have high morale and high confidence and the numbers. I feel we can push Jackson back, or at least hold him long enough for Meade to strategically flank him.

On the other fronts, my plan is to use how thinly spread the Confederates are to pressure them everywhere we can with the maximum amount of aggression, we know they're having desertions, we know their troop quality is dropping, we know their numbers are shrinking, if we press them on all fronts, with our current momentum, in all five locations, then something will break, very likely multiple somethings, and we can use the momentum to collapse chunks of the Confederate defensive line and pressure Columbia heavily, even if the possibility off failing to capture it with Schofield, Meade threatening its flank comes to pass, Jackson will still see multiple strategic locations threatened or taken, and likely be forced to retreat eventually.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top