There were (not on this site mind). Well there probably still are on the website that he fled to, but it has closed registration due to paranoia.
1) The rise of the SS as described by him makes no sense in the AANW situation. The SS reached the position it did in the Nazi state because the Wehrmacht failed to deliever. In the AANW-verse the Germans won and there is no way in hell the Wehrmacht would be dissolved.
Not to mention that the Wehrmacht would never have ALLOWED itself to be dissolved. The Nazi empire was built on the principle of tons of competing power-structures, but of all of them the Wehrmact was the one that could collectively at any time have kicked the whole sandcastle over.
Yeah, about the treatment of Germany.
...
Even if you disagree with the A4's postwar attitude towards Germany, it's kind of understandable how they arrived at their conclusions.
Let me put it this way: Morgenthauing Germany may have made sense in 1960.
Ten years passes.
1970. No change.
Ten years passes.
1980. No change.
Ten years passes.
1990. No change.
THAT is the problem. The ability of the A4 to maintain a head of rage and determination to spend ludicrous amounts of money on the military against no clear threat. And the ability of them to view the deindustrialized, beaten down, depopulated (and it would be, because holy shit any German with any skills would have tried to emigrate anywhere) Germanies as still being a threat of any sort.
In fact I would argue that the total population of the germanies in this TL should probably be 50 million or less.
That's actually one of the more plausible things given just how wacky OTL Chinese (ultra)nationalists were. The thing is, such people never reached the reins of power in our history due to cooler heads screwing them over in their own pursuit of power.
There is no rational reason for them to gain power in the AANW verse either. The reason we got them in North Korea was that basically they turned Imperial Japaneseism into communism, changed the Emperor into the Kims, and made Koreans the master race. The dynamics just aren't the same in China! It's this weird hatred of China that is just absurd.
And India is even weirder, since a lot of the problems they had in OTL was due to things like the pseudo-socialist policies and the permit Raj, and I see no reason whatsoever that would be different here.
There is this massive flip without any good justification.
.
