What's the most Cringeworthy Alternate History you've ever read?

I like the implication that Shaggy was never captured as it's a personal photo rather than a mugshot. Could be because he's the best at running, could be a reference to rest of the cast being dropped the season after Scrappy first appeared, could be both.
 
I like the implication that Shaggy was never captured as it's a personal photo rather than a mugshot. Could be because he's the best at running, could be a reference to rest of the cast being dropped the season after Scrappy first appeared, could be both.

Cops took one look at Shaggy and figured he couldn't have been culprit... only too late to realize he was the mastermind of all of it.
 
I mean of course it couldn't be Shaggy, he has his own Planation left to him by one of a number of rich old money uncles he has and is apparently well enough off to give away a fortune in gemstones to charity... Also has been a private school teacher(sure it was a school for monsters but still.)

Besides who wants to push someone who may or may not still be a werewolf and knows both Dracula and a warlock.
 
Also, you have to wonder about the economic conditions of the Scooby-Do AU, where there's all these closed amusement parks and attractions, and people are bad enough that they will try scaring paper away in order to get the land....
 
According to the Reddit post the wikibox is from the United States is in the middle of a total economic meltdown in the late 60s and the gang are roving vigilantes using their investigative skills to seek out corruption at its source.
 
Also, you have to wonder about the economic conditions of the Scooby-Do AU, where there's all these closed amusement parks and attractions, and people are bad enough that they will try scaring paper away in order to get the land....
There's actually a Cracked article that makes that exact argument.
The criminals are all super-geniuses, and not one of them can make an honest living.

Almost every locale in the Scooby-Doo universe looks like the economy has just taken a nosedive. Even their nice "vacation" spots look like bad neighborhoods in Detroit. In the 25 episodes of the original Scooby Doo, Where Are You? cartoon, our gang comes across four deserted mansions, two abandoned castles and an empty ski resort, amusement park, ghost town, mine, Hawaiian village, airfield and mill. And of the 27 villains the gang encounters, 23 are motivated by monetary gain via theft, smuggling or land speculation. The Mystery Machine crew isn't running into domestic disputes or drug-related crimes. They are dealing exclusively with people who need money so badly that they voluntarily squat in the basements of abandoned houses for the off-chance of landing a paycheck. And if the villains don't need money, they need work. The remaining four motives? Winning a dog show, getting an acting gig, revenge for getting fired and a hatred of robots. Those who don't need money or work are acting out of a hatred for robots, the quintessential job stealer. And Scooby-Doo villains are not run-of-the-mill criminals: They all have the uncanny ability to manufacture realistic monster costumes, project full-scale holograms and carve out high-tech hideouts in abandoned mineshafts. Many of them already had impressive vocational skills prior to their criminal lives -- three of the villains were PhDs, two were lawyers, one had the ability to produce near-identical forged paintings, one could repair boats, one was a magician, one was a stuntman and one could hypnotize people. See that? That's the educational system, art world, maritime engineering and entertainment industries -- all in the toilet. Each of these villains showed creativity, intelligence, diligence and ambition. In our world, they would easily be employed, maybe even famous. But, in the universe of Scooby-Doo, it simply wasn't enough. The Scooby gang ran into a new, desperate genius every single week for decades. Either brilliance is simply run-of-the-mill in their universe, or else the entire economy has collapsed, and what we're witnessing is the death throes of society itself. Although there are signs that the sandwich ingredient and dog marijuana industries are booming, so it's probably the former.
 
There's actually a Cracked article that makes that exact argument.
To engage with this seriously for a moment...

In the 25 episodes of the original Scooby Doo, Where Are You? cartoon, our gang comes across four deserted mansions, two abandoned castles and an empty ski resort, amusement park, ghost town, mine, Hawaiian village, airfield and mill...

To be fair, the Scooby Gang is systematically and preferentially seeking out reputedly haunted and monster-beset locations, which almost by definition are going to be abandoned mansions and so on, not places people are actually using.

The abandoned amusement park schtick is basically truth in television for the late '60s and '70s, because the rise of passenger jet aviation and the interstate highways meant a huge number of local amusement parks basically shriveled up and died, with the customer base all going off the Disneyland or Six Flags or whatever. Likewise with abandoned resorts, ski and otherwise; tourism patterns were changing all over the country.

Likewise the abandoned mills (this was when the term 'Rust Belt' started to come into vogue).

Deserted mansions, well, that's not all that new either. At this point there were a fair number of big, sprawling homes left over from the late 19th century, often not particularly modernized, and without a booming class of new millionaires looking to move into them and modernize (remember, this was back when taxes on the rich were significant).

...

Also, remember, the masterminds doing this shit are mostly not doing it for a day to day paycheck. They're doing it so they can make a killing on a real estate deal or something. That implies that they have a day job, or something like it- the ability to engage reputably with the economy and make real estate deals in their own name. It implies that they have some startup capital, and a plan for the property- that they could do something profitable with it if only they could buy it really fucking cheap.

These aren't desperate people. They're people who have a plan that could plausibly make a buck, that they've decided to turn into a plan that makes two bucks with a bit of creative criminality.
 
Last edited:
I'm very annoyed to discovered "The Death of Russia" has an Images of thread in the Alternate History Books and Media section of AH.com. Because if there's one thing a Genocide fic, it's clear a bunch of mini-fan content. I'm just very annoyed something that seems nakedly just "What if Russia freaking died violently" has such a fanbase.
 
Further on the scooby gang.
Presuming (i have not really watched the series) they remain only within United States over the 25 episodes.
That's still almost a whole continent to pick from.
 
My main issue with TDoR isn't the premise. The idea of the Soviet Union breakup going violent and causing a civil war that goes nuclear is an interesting premise. The main issue I have with it is how much the author seems to actually wish this had happened to Russia. Like I get being pissed off at the leadership due to what its done since the breakup(or honestly ever since the Tsardom) but the Russian people themselves deserve the right to live like every other person on the planet.
 
*snip a pretty good/informative post*
Also, in Scooby Doo! Mystery Incorporated, it's revealed that it's all deliberate.

TL;DW, turns out Crystal Cove, the heroes' hometown, secretly has a Lovecraftian entity underneath, its presence causing people to turn mean and petty, and deliberately spreading misery and discord to fuel its emergence into the world.

Granted, that show has its own continuity, as the Scooby Doo franchise in general seems pretty fast and loose with canon for the most part.
 
Back
Top