Voting is open
Combing will take time. Lobbing a few nukes at the unsalvageable ships will deny the Rachni the tech and gives us the time to leave before we have to cope with a major retaliation strike.
 
[x][TOW] Comb the wreckage thoroughly to remove everything you can tow or scoop out of space from the field of battle.
[x][LINE] Oh, no. Oh, hell no. You recognize the opportunity? So will the Rachni! There's still that huge fleet that came jumping to Hades Gamma out there, floating around free and uncommitted! You're one jump away from what must be a massive fleet base in the Caleston Rift! And those Rachni forces in the Hades Nexus? Where are they going to retreat if they decide that they can't hold their system, hm? Through here. And who's in the way of all those fleets? And all that's not even to mention how vulnerable Attican Beta is at the moment. No. The Terminus Alliance will just have to wait. You cannot hold this system.
 
@PoptartProdigy Would 'tow what can be repaired/salvaged, ID the rest of the Quarian wreckage (per option 1, but can probably be more rough and ready) and nuke it rather than scooping it up' be significantly faster than option 1? For a similar tech-denying outcome.

[x][LINE] Oh, no. Oh, hell no. You recognize the opportunity? So will the Rachni! There's still that huge fleet that came jumping to Hades Gamma out there, floating around free and uncommitted! You're one jump away from what must be a massive fleet base in the Caleston Rift! And those Rachni forces in the Hades Nexus? Where are they going to retreat if they decide that they can't hold their system, hm? Through here. And who's in the way of all those fleets? And all that's not even to mention how vulnerable Attican Beta is at the moment. No. The Terminus Alliance will just have to wait. You cannot hold this system.
 
Last edited:
[x][TOW] Comb the wreckage thoroughly to remove everything you can tow or scoop out of space from the field of battle.
[x][LINE] Oh, no. Oh, hell no. You recognize the opportunity? So will the Rachni! There's still that huge fleet that came jumping to Hades Gamma out there, floating around free and uncommitted! You're one jump away from what must be a massive fleet base in the Caleston Rift! And those Rachni forces in the Hades Nexus? Where are they going to retreat if they decide that they can't hold their system, hm? Through here. And who's in the way of all those fleets? And all that's not even to mention how vulnerable Attican Beta is at the moment. No. The Terminus Alliance will just have to wait. You cannot hold this system.
 
[X][TOW] Comb the wreckage thoroughly to remove everything you can tow or scoop out of space from the field of battle.
[X][LINE] Oh, no. Oh, hell no. You recognize the opportunity? So will the Rachni! There's still that huge fleet that came jumping to Hades Gamma out there, floating around free and uncommitted! You're one jump away from what must be a massive fleet base in the Caleston Rift! And those Rachni forces in the Hades Nexus? Where are they going to retreat if they decide that they can't hold their system, hm? Through here. And who's in the way of all those fleets? And all that's not even to mention how vulnerable Attican Beta is at the moment. No. The Terminus Alliance will just have to wait. You cannot hold this system.
 
[X][TOW] Take under tow any quarian vessels Malan identifies as salvageable or reparable.
[X][LINE] Oh, no. Oh, hell no. You recognize the opportunity? So will the Rachni! There's still that huge fleet that came jumping to Hades Gamma out there, floating around free and uncommitted! You're one jump away from what must be a massive fleet base in the Caleston Rift! And those Rachni forces in the Hades Nexus? Where are they going to retreat if they decide that they can't hold their system, hm? Through here. And who's in the way of all those fleets? And all that's not even to mention how vulnerable Attican Beta is at the moment. No. The Terminus Alliance will just have to wait. You cannot hold this system.
 
[X][TOW] Comb the wreckage thoroughly to remove everything you can tow or scoop out of space from the field of battle.
[X][LINE] Oh, no. Oh, hell no. You recognize the opportunity? So will the Rachni! There's still that huge fleet that came jumping to Hades Gamma out there, floating around free and uncommitted! You're one jump away from what must be a massive fleet base in the Caleston Rift! And those Rachni forces in the Hades Nexus? Where are they going to retreat if they decide that they can't hold their system, hm? Through here. And who's in the way of all those fleets?And all that's not even to mention how vulnerable Attican Beta is at the moment. No. The Terminus Alliance will just have to wait. You cannot hold this system.
 
[X][TOW] Comb the wreckage thoroughly to remove everything you can tow or scoop out of space from the field of battle.
[X][LINE] Oh, no. Oh, hell no. You recognize the opportunity? So will the Rachni! There's still that huge fleet that came jumping to Hades Gamma out there, floating around free and uncommitted! You're one jump away from what must be a massive fleet base in the Caleston Rift! And those Rachni forces in the Hades Nexus? Where are they going to retreat if they decide that they can't hold their system, hm? Through here. And who's in the way of all those fleets? And all that's not even to mention how vulnerable Attican Beta is at the moment. No. The Terminus Alliance will just have to wait. You cannot hold this system.
 
[x][TOW] Comb the wreckage thoroughly to remove everything you can tow or scoop out of space from the field of battle.
[x][LINE] Oh, no. Oh, hell no. You recognize the opportunity? So will the Rachni! There's still that huge fleet that came jumping to Hades Gamma out there, floating around free and uncommitted! You're one jump away from what must be a massive fleet base in the Caleston Rift! And those Rachni forces in the Hades Nexus? Where are they going to retreat if they decide that they can't hold their system, hm? Through here. And who's in the way of all those fleets? And all that's not even to mention how vulnerable Attican Beta is at the moment. No. The Terminus Alliance will just have to wait. You cannot hold this system.
 
[x][TOW] Comb the wreckage thoroughly to remove everything you can tow or scoop out of space from the field of battle.
[x][LINE] Oh, no. Oh, hell no. You recognize the opportunity? So will the Rachni! There's still that huge fleet that came jumping to Hades Gamma out there, floating around free and uncommitted! You're one jump away from what must be a massive fleet base in the Caleston Rift! And those Rachni forces in the Hades Nexus? Where are they going to retreat if they decide that they can't hold their system, hm? Through here. And who's in the way of all those fleets?And all that's not even to mention how vulnerable Attican Beta is at the moment. No. The Terminus Alliance will just have to wait. You cannot hold this system.

For now I vote this. If we have a real chance to hold here we could stay. We just destroy 5 dreadnoughts so I think we do destroy a major rachni force. Problem is we don't know if their reinforcements are as strong or weaker than it. We still have Beshkar so we could pull this off. But I'm not sure so let's get out of there.
 
The Battle of Trenton was pretty impressive. I think its pretty clear that he improved substantially over his military career, and that he was better on the strategic rather than tactical level, especially as he matured as a strategist...
Okay, to be fair, the man who accepted the surrender at Yorktown was in many ways a better and more 'grown' man than the man who got his command humiliated during the French and Indian War twenty years earlier.

As to Trenton- well, frankly, a big part of the success was in knowing to attack the enemy at a time when they were utterly unprepared to defend themselves, in a place that was utterly unprepared for defense. I'm not dismissing this, it is very much a part of generalship, as is strategy, as is holding together a defeated command.

The thing is... this conversation began with "what famous general is Mira like?" And honestly, Mira IS good at fighting pitched battles in roughly symmetric conditions. She's been doing very well at that. She's got a much better track record at symmetric, conventional warfare than Washington ever did, while at the same time having far less experience of truly irregular warfare, at least in her time as president of Virmire.

To me the big interesting butterfly here is that by the end of the war we would be a multi-species polity under a unified government structure that has more military and economic power than the average Citadel associate race (assuming things go well). I don't recall ME having anything besides "unified single-species government" and "lawless anarchy," though I could be mistaken. Regardless, it will be interesting to see how the Council deals with the situation.

I kind of wish we had signed the declaration of independence. If it were a done deal the Council would probably overlook it for now given the pressing Rachni threat and it would frame the starting point for post-war negotiations. If we do it now it would be a lot more provocative.
There is literally no reason we can't sign a declaration of independence if we want to. I'd be flabbergasted if Poptart doesn't give us a chance to arrange exactly that.

I for one am cautiously in favor of it, though I'd like us to seriously consider joining the Citadel if we can parlay our status into associate membership. I suspect the next two thousand years will go a lot better with us on the inside looking out than on the outside looking in.
 
There is literally no reason we can't sign a declaration of independence if we want to. I'd be flabbergasted if Poptart doesn't give us a chance to arrange exactly that.

I for one am cautiously in favor of it, though I'd like us to seriously consider joining the Citadel if we can parlay our status into associate membership. I suspect the next two thousand years will go a lot better with us on the inside looking out than on the outside looking in.
Sure, but doing it now is more of a deliberate middle finger than it would have been to do it before.

Anyways,

[x][TOW] Comb the wreckage thoroughly to remove everything you can tow or scoop out of space from the field of battle.
[x][LINE] Oh, no. Oh, hell no. You recognize the opportunity? So will the Rachni! There's still that huge fleet that came jumping to Hades Gamma out there, floating around free and uncommitted! You're one jump away from what must be a massive fleet base in the Caleston Rift! And those Rachni forces in the Hades Nexus? Where are they going to retreat if they decide that they can't hold their system, hm? Through here. And who's in the way of all those fleets? And all that's not even to mention how vulnerable Attican Beta is at the moment. No. The Terminus Alliance will just have to wait. You cannot hold this system.
 
[X][TOW] Take under tow any quarian vessels Malan identifies as salvageable or reparable.

[X][LINE] Oh, no. Oh, hell no. You recognize the opportunity? So will the Rachni! There's still that huge fleet that came jumping to Hades Gamma out there, floating around free and uncommitted! You're one jump away from what must be a massive fleet base in the Caleston Rift! And those Rachni forces in the Hades Nexus? Where are they going to retreat if they decide that they can't hold their system, hm? Through here. And who's in the way of all those fleets? And all that's not even to mention how vulnerable Attican Beta is at the moment. No. The Terminus Alliance will just have to wait. You cannot hold this system.

Now would be a good time to pull out, before the greed sets off danger.
 
[X][TOW] Comb the wreckage thoroughly to remove everything you can tow or scoop out of space from the field of battle.
[X][LINE] Oh, no. Oh, hell no. You recognize the opportunity? So will the Rachni! There's still that huge fleet that came jumping to Hades Gamma out there, floating around free and uncommitted! You're one jump away from what must be a massive fleet base in the Caleston Rift! And those Rachni forces in the Hades Nexus? Where are they going to retreat if they decide that they can't hold their system, hm? Through here. And who's in the way of all those fleets? And all that's not even to mention how vulnerable Attican Beta is at the moment. No. The Terminus Alliance will just have to wait. You cannot hold this system.
 
[x][TOW] Comb the wreckage thoroughly to remove everything you can tow or scoop out of space from the field of battle.
[x][LINE] Oh, no. Oh, hell no. You recognize the opportunity? So will the Rachni! There's still that huge fleet that came jumping to Hades Gamma out there, floating around free and uncommitted! You're one jump away from what must be a massive fleet base in the Caleston Rift! And those Rachni forces in the Hades Nexus? Where are they going to retreat if they decide that they can't hold their system, hm? Through here. And who's in the way of all those fleets? And all that's not even to mention how vulnerable Attican Beta is at the moment. No. The Terminus Alliance will just have to wait. You cannot hold this system.
 
[x][TOW] Comb the wreckage thoroughly to remove everything you can tow or scoop out of space from the field of battle.
[X][LINE] Oh, no. Oh, hell no. You recognize the opportunity? So will the Rachni! There's still that huge fleet that came jumping to Hades Gamma out there, floating around free and uncommitted! You're one jump away from what must be a massive fleet base in the Caleston Rift! And those Rachni forces in the Hades Nexus? Where are they going to retreat if they decide that they can't hold their system, hm? Through here. And who's in the way of all those fleets? And all that's not even to mention how vulnerable Attican Beta is at the moment. No. The Terminus Alliance will just have to wait. You cannot hold this system.

@PoptartProdigy, will we be able to retreat without engaging the Rachni if their fleets arrive from the Hades Nexus or Caleston Rift? (If you can't say, just give me Mira's best guess) Also, we're evacuating the damaged ships at the same time as we're searching the wreckage, right?
 
[X][TOW] Comb the wreckage thoroughly to remove everything you can tow or scoop out of space from the field of battle.
We broke their local fleet and that giant armada on the far side of Attica is a couple of hours away unless they try to fight through our fortifications. We have some time to loot recover the fallen.

[X][LINE] Oh, no. Oh, hell no. You recognize the opportunity? So will the Rachni! There's still that huge fleet that came jumping to Hades Gamma out there, floating around free and uncommitted! You're one jump away from what must be a massive fleet base in the Caleston Rift! And those Rachni forces in the Hades Nexus? Where are they going to retreat if they decide that they can't hold their system, hm? Through here. And who's in the way of all those fleets? And all that's not even to mention how vulnerable Attican Beta is at the moment. No. The Terminus Alliance will just have to wait. You cannot hold this system.
Now is not the time to put our neck on the chopping block in the vague hope that help will come.
 
[X][TOW] Comb the wreckage thoroughly to remove everything you can tow or scoop out of space from the field of battle.
[X][LINE] Oh, no. Oh, hell no. You recognize the opportunity? So will the Rachni! There's still that huge fleet that came jumping to Hades Gamma out there, floating around free and uncommitted! You're one jump away from what must be a massive fleet base in the Caleston Rift! And those Rachni forces in the Hades Nexus? Where are they going to retreat if they decide that they can't hold their system, hm? Through here. And who's in the way of all those fleets? And all that's not even to mention how vulnerable Attican Beta is at the moment. No. The Terminus Alliance will just have to wait. You cannot hold this system.
 
[x][TOW] Comb the wreckage thoroughly to remove everything you can tow or scoop out of space from the field of battle.
[x][LINE] Oh, no. Oh, hell no. You recognize the opportunity? So will the Rachni! There's still that huge fleet that came jumping to Hades Gamma out there, floating around free and uncommitted! You're one jump away from what must be a massive fleet base in the Caleston Rift! And those Rachni forces in the Hades Nexus? Where are they going to retreat if they decide that they can't hold their system, hm? Through here. And who's in the way of all those fleets? And all that's not even to mention how vulnerable Attican Beta is at the moment. No. The Terminus Alliance will just have to wait. You cannot hold this system.

So...whats Rachni high command even going to interpret this as?
 
[x][TOW] Comb the wreckage thoroughly to remove everything you can tow or scoop out of space from the field of battle.
-[x] But prioritize towing damaged and salvageable ships along with life pods so that
Acquire targeting solutions for nukes to destroy remaining tech, ready to launch and FTL for the relay.
[x][LINE] Oh, no. Oh, hell no. You recognize the opportunity? So will the Rachni! There's still that huge fleet that came jumping to Hades Gamma out there, floating around free and uncommitted! You're one jump away from what must be a massive fleet base in the Caleston Rift! And those Rachni forces in the Hades Nexus? Where are they going to retreat if they decide that they can't hold their system, hm? Through here. And who's in the way of all those fleets? And all that's not even to mention how vulnerable Attican Beta is at the moment. No. The Terminus Alliance will just have to wait. You cannot hold this system.

I want to be ready for a snaff-you-Rachni in case a big fleet jumps in.
If none does all the debris is valuable hi-tech stuff we can use, but plan for the worst hope for the best.
 
[x][TOW] Comb the wreckage thoroughly to remove everything you can tow or scoop out of space from the field of battle.
[x][LINE] Oh, no. Oh, hell no. You recognize the opportunity? So will the Rachni! There's still that huge fleet that came jumping to Hades Gamma out there, floating around free and uncommitted! You're one jump away from what must be a massive fleet base in the Caleston Rift! And those Rachni forces in the Hades Nexus? Where are they going to retreat if they decide that they can't hold their system, hm? Through here. And who's in the way of all those fleets?And all that's not even to mention how vulnerable Attican Beta is at the moment. No. The Terminus Alliance will just have to wait. You cannot hold this system.
 
[x][TOW] Comb the wreckage thoroughly to remove everything you can tow or scoop out of space from the field of battle.
[x][LINE] Oh, no. Oh, hell no. You recognize the opportunity? So will the Rachni! There's still that huge fleet that came jumping to Hades Gamma out there, floating around free and uncommitted! You're one jump away from what must be a massive fleet base in the Caleston Rift! And those Rachni forces in the Hades Nexus? Where are they going to retreat if they decide that they can't hold their system, hm? Through here. And who's in the way of all those fleets? And all that's not even to mention how vulnerable Attican Beta is at the moment. No. The Terminus Alliance will just have to wait. You cannot hold this system.

Now better safe then sorry, we already expanded our "audacity" for the day
 
[ X ][TOW] Comb the wreckage thoroughlyto remove everything you can tow or scoop out of space from the field of battle.
[ X ][LINE] Oh, no. Oh, hell no. You recognize the opportunity? So will the Rachni! There's still that huge fleet that came jumping to Hades Gamma out there, floating around free and uncommitted! You're one jump away from what must be a massive fleet base in the Caleston Rift! And those Rachni forces in the Hades Nexus? Where are they going to retreat if they decide that they can't hold their system, hm? Through here. And who's in the way ofall those fleets? And all that's not even to mention how vulnerable Attican Beta is at the moment. No. The Terminus Alliance will just have to wait. You cannot hold this system.
 
[x][TOW] Comb the wreckage thoroughly to remove everything you can tow or scoop out of space from the field of battle.
[x][LINE] Oh, no. Oh, hell no. You recognize the opportunity? So will the Rachni! There's still that huge fleet that came jumping to Hades Gamma out there, floating around free and uncommitted! You're one jump away from what must be a massive fleet base in the Caleston Rift! And those Rachni forces in the Hades Nexus? Where are they going to retreat if they decide that they can't hold their system, hm? Through here. And who's in the way of all those fleets? And all that's not even to mention how vulnerable Attican Beta is at the moment. No. The Terminus Alliance will just have to wait. You cannot hold this system.
 
Voting is open
Back
Top