Prologue: Wrapping my head around Spiritrons...
[X] If an 'Assassin Jeeves' was in charge of the attendants, then she ought to find any non-combatant Servants in charge of the Museum or Library, they ought to know some things.
[X] About Spiritrons, the magic particles of data that made up the world of the Star-Cell

I had a hard time wrapping my head around Spiritrons, which is probably what made them stand out so much to me from the lecture. We were taught they're the essence of the soul, which… somehow allowed them to be used as computer data? It's not that Cainessa cared that much to slow down and explain more clearly for us. Anyway, entire worlds could apparently be made up of Spiritrons, including the Aquarius' 'Serial Phantasm' (Cainessa's term, she seemed more than reluctant to just say 'virtual reality') we were in now.

She then said another, older Spiritron World was created by the Moon-Cell, the Star-Cell's precursor. She talked quite highly of the Moon-Cell, one of the few things she ever talked highly about, going on to say that the Star-Cell was merely a man-made replica. I guess, I mean, it's not like any of us had the Moon-Cell here to judge. As for whether the Star-Cell being a replica of the Moon-Cell was the truth of the outside world… no, it couldn't be, Cainessa made clear she wouldn't just tell us that.

There in my room, one mostly identical to Sakura's, I did look over the oneirogen plants in my collection before I went to bed, that lecture having given me a thought. "Jasper?" I asked my valet, "I was thinking, maybe I could chance finding out more about the Moon-Cell by entering Cainessa's dreams? Except… no I couldn't."

"Why not? Sounds like a smart enough plan," Jasper said, "I wouldn't worry about the ethics of it, we are talking about someone who insulted your field of magic right to your face before you could even demonstrate it. I'd say it'd only be karmic for her."

Part of me was worried that Jasper only said that because he was programmed to agree with me, but if that was true, he really had to stretch to come to that conclusion. "Er, okay. But I'd still be magically spying on a potential enemy before the War properly begins, like just speaking practically, that could get me booted out before I summon anyone."

Jasper then smiled at me. "My liege, it shows the strength of your character, both moral and rational, that you'd even be debating this. I'm afraid most of the other players wouldn't have your foresight, they'd simply take any apparent advantage they could get," he said.

I smiled too hearing him compliment me, but did my words really win him over so quickly for him to change his tune like that? Plus, it just reminded me that other players would happily use those same underhanded tactics on me if they could.

My own dream that 'night' was a simple one, but still more a nightmare really. I was being shot out of an airlock into the depths of space, again simple but scary. While I was naturally trained to interpret such dreams, especially who could be sending them, I couldn't really nail down any definitive answer. A subliminal reminder by the Star-Cell of what the outside world could be? Me just having space on my mind after thinking about both Star- and Moon-Cells? Just me be all anxious about the upcoming War? Its simplicity at least made for an easy dream diary entry.

Sakura was quite generous in letting me recount my dream to her next morning, meeting again in the cafeteria. "Still, I don't think I'm qualified to give my own reading of it," she said, "My go-to response to nightmares is to just keep really busy and I hope I forget about them before long. Like, I had an unpleasant dream last night too, but you definitely had the scarier one."

"Er, do you want me to interpret that dream for you?" I asked, "Because I don't wanna make you recount anything you're not comfortable with, that helps nobody."

"Hey, it's fine. Bad dreams feel less bad if you have people to talk about them with. Okay, that's more a general rule," Sakura said, letting out a chuckle. "Mine was pretty simple too, nothing to do with space though, at least not 'outer'. Let's see, I was in this big fancy mansion, kinda like the Aquarius you could say, but there was barely any light and I was all alone. No maids or butlers, no family, no guests, nobody."

That one I again had to think over. True, most dreams I needed to think over, part of being an oneiromancer is realising just how complex they are. "My first thought was it could be a scene, a memory, from your avatar's life, though I kinda struggle imagining me having been an astronaut. You seem to have your mind set on a Servant, so it could be a scene from their life- No, you said your Servant was gonna be Roman, and a mansion like the Aquarius wouldn't look Roman. Hmm," I suddenly smirked, "Maybe 'cause Cainessa left us all in the dark with her lecture, that's how you feel after listening to her?"

Sakura had to grin hearing that. "Yeah, she sure did. In the dark, like my soul," she smirked as she quoted Blut.

Our joking around was interrupted though by what sounded like a confrontation. Two men were arguing about something by the door, one a more austere, grey military-looking type, the other a tanned, long-haired man who looked more like a sports star to me. It was hard to make out what they were saying exactly, with them being far enough away and the reverb in the room. Eventually the sports star type just groaned and walked away, the military type doing the same in the other direction.

Seeing we'd been staring right at him, the sports star walked right up to us. For a second I shuddered, fearing being reprimanded, but instead he sighed and said, "Sheesh, sorry you guys had to see that. Not one of my proudest moments."

"That's okay, happens to all of us," I said the first thing to come to mind.

Sakura however got lost in thought for a second, before she said, "Hold on, you're Felix de Carvalho, aren't you?"

Felix laughed, "Correctamundo, how'd you guess?"

"Oh, er, just a hunch," Sakura said, shrinking down a little, "Guess it'd be like, your aura, I mean your figurative one," she specified, "You fit what description I've heard, and you do kinda have the 'star power' presence you'd expect."

"Wow, I'm impressed. You're more analytical than you give yourself credit for. Don't you agree?" Felix then said, suddenly turning to talk to what looked like air. Unless…

"You've already summoned your Servant?" I asked on instinct, as I thought he couldn't just be talking to nothing.

"Correct again. Normally I'd introduce you, helps he's the social type, but y'know, I'm kinda not allowed to till prelims are over. Them's the rules," Felix said. He then looked downcast for a second, going against his usual nature. "Yep, figured out the 'truth of the outside world' alright. Normally I'd just tell you what it is, but thing is… I kinda can't. Like, I don't think the Star-Cell counts it if you're told, it's something you're 'sposed to figure out on your own. Dumb I know, but again, them's the rules."

Sakura first mumbled, "Should've known," but then said, "Oh, that reminds me. How many of those 'non-combatant Servants' do you think are around? Like you said, they can't tell me, but I thought they could at least give me an idea about the outside world."

Felix shrugged. "Probably a question better suited to the Overseer, but I'll do my best to answer. Let's see, you'd already have heard about Jeeves, then you've got Caster Jafar running the Library. Hey, don't let his rep turn you off him- oh yeah, and I'm not spoiling anything by telling you his name. He's an administrative Servant, he's required to give it out. Then, ooh boy, we've got Luisa Casati running the Museum. Guess she's qualified, they say her old house became a super-famous museum itself, but boy, imagine summoning a Berserker to run a museum. There's also Gatekeeper, not anyone you'd have met yet, but you'll know him when you see him. I'm a little hazy beyond that, like I know there's a Servant running a betting racket, but yeesh, I try staying away from that stuff. Also know there's a 'scenario writer' on hand, and oh yeah, Metatron."

That name sure stood out. "The Metatron? But isn't he an angel?" I asked.

"Oh, he was human at one point, which I guess lets him in here. He's the ultimate record-keeper of this Holy Grail War, super-important guy, but not easy to get in contact with. Like, they say even our library and museum are nothing compared to all he knows and sees. Good thing we don't have to fight him, eh?" Felix finished.

Sakura just smiled at that remark, if shivered a little, before she stood up to say, "Well, I oughta meet with this Jafar and even Casati. They could help me out, and besides, I owe it to them for using their Library and Museum, the ones they've been assigned anyway, so casually. Thanks for the info."

"Hey, anytime," Felix said, but then added, "Oh yeah, one more thing. That guy I got into an argument with? That's Stathis Smaragdis, he's one of those players I just can't stand, all serious business y'know. Still, much as I don't wanna hand it to him, he's looking to be a serious contender, so watch out for him."

Both Sakura and I nodded. But still, was the Grail War something worth just taking casually? That kinda didn't add up…



Sakura headed first to the Library, given it was closer. Unsure how to exactly go about speaking with Jafar, she just went up to the front desk and asked, "Hi, er, could I please speak with the head librarian?"

There was some muttering behind the counter, but soon some nearby bookcases parted and rearranged themselves like a great unfolding curtain as the first Servant Sakura had seen walked out. The Caster class she'd been told, so that generally meant he was a mage himself, in function at least. A sceptre-carrying Iranian man in royal robes, he opened with a groan, "What is it? Some administrative error, can't find a book, fight started up? Just get this over with."

Sakura stiffened a little, knowing she was actually talking to a Middle Eastern magus right out of a storybook. She immediately bowed and said, "Ah, no, everything's fine, last I checked. I just thought with prelims almost over and me being a Master, I should really get to know all the Servants that have already been summoned. Well, publicly anyway. Er, anyway, I'm Tohsaka Sakura."

"Seriously, I got called out here for that?" Jafar said, but properly introduced himself anyway, "Ja'far ibn Yahya al-Barmaki." With Sakura not quite recognising the name, he then flat-out said, "Grand Vizier Jafar."

"W-wow, that is… something," she said. Having established her limited historical knowledge, she asked, "From the 1,001 Nights and those movies? So the Star-Cell really can summon fictional characters?"

"The Star-Cell holds the collective records of Earth, and those happen to include every work of fiction eve made. So yes, that's well within its capabilities, that a 'Jeeves' is walking around right now should've made that obvious. However," Jafar then said, "I am without a doubt historical, much as the world of fiction would dare try claim me. Anyway, is that all?"

This wasn't the behaviour one would expect from a Grand Vizier, less Machiavellian and more just fed up in general. Still, Sakura asked, "I know you can't just tell me, but well, I was also hoping for a hint about the truth of the-"

"-Outside World?" Jafar finished for her, "You've met the Overseer at least, didn't she at least give you that clue about the Aquarius' name? Alright, if one requires assistance, I suppose that is my task. Miss Tohsaka, you'll note how earlier I had to specify 'Earth'. Do keep that in mind."

With Jafar departing, it was Beryl who turned to Sakura and said, "I suppose I should've given you a heads up. This was my first time meeting Jafar too, but Jeeves already warned me he could be on the prickly side."

"No, it's okay," Sakura said, "Like, I don't think he was just annoyed or anything. The impression I got was more, well, that something was weighing heavily on his mind, like he'd been through a lot."

"…I suppose that may be," Beryl just said to that.

Upon heading to the Museum to meet with its curator, this Luisa Casati, Jafar now definitely seemed the preferable sort. "My, what an unremarkable girl," the gothic redhead Casati said of Sakura before Sakura got a chance to say anything, "Tell me, do you honestly see yourself as Master material with fashion sense as plain as yours. You lack style, darling, true flair. That Mikoto for instance at least dresses up for the occasion, and that Cainessa, well her dark coat, pale-like, and bone-like visage at least makes an impression."

A flustered Sakura just said, "Hey, l-look, I didn't come here for fashion advice or whatever!"

"Then what on 'Earth' did you come here for?" Casati sighed, "Some asinine question about the outside world? Dear girl, if you have to ask, you'll never know." She then however examined Sakura more closely, before she beamed, "Still, such plainness does mean you could be the perfect scaffold to be redesigned through my vision. The 'girl next door' look is so trite, I'm picturing something far more daring, more unconventional."

Beryl had to step in. "Thank you, but my mistress' outfitting is mine to oversee," she said.

Casati's face scrunched up, before she sighed and said, "Suit your own miserable selves. Just remember, true art is for the bold."

"Wait, you're a Berserker, aren't you?" Sakura then asked, "Sorry, but it's just seems like a weird Servant to summon as a non-combatant, especially as a curator."

"Hmph, what reason the Star-cell may have for summoning one of my Class, I truly couldn't care. All I know is I'd be dead bored summoned as almost any other class, Berserker and Avenger are the only ones based upon actual emotions, after all," was the answer Casati genuinely gave, "not simply on whether one has a sharpened stick or a longer sharpened stick."

It was then Sakura went deep in thought, before she thought to ask Casati, "About this museum. I know it's the only one world like it inside the Star-Cell, but… is it the only one like it, period? Does even the outside world have a place like this?"

Casati laughed at that, "There is no collection in existence like the one run by me! So yes."

Sakura then formed a grin. "In that case, between words like 'Aquarius' and singling out 'Earth', and hearing Yakumo dream of falling out an airlock, I… I don't wanna lock in my answer right now, but I think I've got an idea what the outside world's really like."

"You do?" Beryl had to ask.

"Hmhm, well then, no harm in hearing it," Casati grinned, seemingly actually amused by something again.

"Okay. Again, don't know for sure, but I think we're-

[ ] -deep underground, in a virtual simulation in a fallout bunker."

[ ] -in space, because something real bad's happened to Earth."

[ ] -in a bunch of pods, being projected backwards in time."

[ ] ...Sorry, spoke too soon. I still can't say."

[ ] Write-in
 
Last edited:
[X] -in space, because something real bad's happened to Earth."

In one myth of Aquarius, Ganymedes revolts against being taken by Zeus by pouring all of Ambrosia, Water and Nectar from the cup on Earth causing a massive flood.

Also this version ends up with Zeus taking pity on Ganymedes and turning him into a immortal constellation in the sky, thus Aquarius.
 
Last edited:
[X] -in space, because something real bad's happened to Earth."

It's more than obvious
 
[X] -in space, because something real bad's happened to Earth."

Well, even setting aside all the focus put on earth this chapter, the mention of the Moon Cell kinda clinched it. Somewhat unrelated, but at least Felix seems decent enough.
Talking about Beryl reminds me I never settled on a faceclaim, or much of a design at all, for her. This came to mind (especially the hair) but might be a little... much even with the sci-fi elements. I also figure picturing her as Hisui wouldn't be that far off either, though I'd liek to hear what others think
Hm, yeah that image is maybe a bit much and Hisui strikes me as a tad too stoic compared to the level at which Beryl emotes. I haven't spend a lot of time looking for faceclaims, but after a cursiory glance, the best I could find would be this one
 
On a behind the scenes note, it took me quite a while to narrow down which Servants I wanted to have run the library and museum. Jafar was always a consideration for the library, but I had more than a couple of others of my Servants in mind for the role like Christina, Ludwig, and the Grimms. Given Jafar's NP carries the risk of him reducing his Master to a paranoid wreck, you can see why the Star-Cell would have him be a non-combatant

Picking the Museum Servant was harder though, and I'll even admit Casati, while locked in now, is a bit of stretch (her old place became the Peggy Guggenheim Collection, and she was a collector and patron herself). I didn't have any other current Servant of mine in mind for the role, but three Servants I've considered writing up, Ennigaldi, St. Helena, and Catherine the Great could have fit
 
Vote closed
Prologue: Having gave her answer...
[X] -in space, because something real bad's happened to Earth."

Having gave her answer, regardless of just how certain she was of her theory, it sure seemed to register with the Star-Cell. Sakura then felt the floor below her shaking, the whole Museum now looking like it was phasing in and out, crackling with static if not looking like it was glitching. She could see Casati grinning at her, while Beryl beside her nodded and then waved to her. Sakura then learned why, as in a flash Beryl and everything else was gone.


A trembling Sakura now found herself in what at first looked like a black void, before white lines started appearing to outline the 'room' around her, her world now constructed out of what looked like wireframes. She tried calling out, only to hear nothing in return. Breathing deep, she took a step forward into… wherever this was.

With every so many steps forward though, what started as just white lines over darkness was joined by further points of light that shone out. It wasn't before long that she found herself surrounded by stars and nebulae. In space, just like she said.

Then, square by square, what looked like a spaceship or some other futuristic vessel started being filled in around her. Not just its walls and floor, but also rows and rows of what reminded her of cryogenic pods.

She then stumbled backwards when out of nowhere a giant shining door materialised in front of her, with a series of… holographic keycards or something, them bearing figures like knights, mages, chained people, masked men in hats, some sort of minotaur, all inserted themselves into gaps in the door.

Sakura started hyperventilating as she reached towards this door, with her head moving to the side once or twice as if in hope that Beryl would show up beside her again, but no luck. It then turned out she didn't even need to pull this door open, for it then opened inward in front of her, with nothing but blinding light on the other side.

Sakura then clenched her teeth and just ran on in, then opened her eyes to find she now stood on a circular, golden platform with seven stained glass arches around her, and countless cards rotating around in the void beyond. She then felt something in her hand, with her looking down to see that the lottery ticket she'd seen in the Museum had now appeared in her hand. A glittering light then appeared in the centre of this circle… but so did something else.

"Potential Master," a voice then crackled, a dark-green silhouette then appearing on the other side of the platform, looking like a glitch in reality, "Summon your Servant, and I shall determine your worth. Round 1!"



I then stumbled into the Museum only to see Sakura vanish into thin air. "Wait, w-what just happened?!" I asked Beryl and the Curator in an instant.

"Relax, she did exactly what any of you Masters are supposed to do. Figure out the truth of the world," the Curator, who I'd only later learn was the Heroic Spirit Luisa Casati, said yet added, "Well, enough of the truth of the world to have passed the first trial, anyway. She ought to be back with her own Servant any time now, well if said Servant's good enough to get past our Gatekeeper."

"Huh, to think in just a few moments, I won't be Sakura's main assistant anymore. And despite her hopes, I don't think it'll be Augustus," Beryl muttered, then said, "Either way, I do know she will come back. S-she must, 'cause that 'Gatekeeper' can't be that powerful this early on, right?"

I clutched my head, trying to recall any possible clue I'd uncovered about what this outside world could really be. "They said 'Aquarius' was a clue. Aquarius means water and cups, but it's also the Zodiac, so gods, fate and… stars. Because we're told that Grain and people like us Liners and A-Rays can't show up on regular Earth, right? So we gotta be in space, right… leaving Earth, because we're carrying humanity's relics and knowledge with us," I gasped, realising the truth of it all, the 'world' now glitching out around me.

"Liege Amemiya!" I heard Jasper call out behind me, "Please, look around this room while you still can. Keep one of the relics in mind, or-or just think of a legendary person!"

Too late. I'd already vanished, and unlike Sakura I hadn't even chosen a catalyst.

I first stumbled slowly through the wireframe corridor which turned into the cosmos, which just recalled my airlock dream and made me break out into a run to get this all over with, especially being told what Sakura could be facing at the end of this corridor. Then came the ship and its cryogenic pods, then the looming doorway, then…

I walked right into that great platform at the end but gasped when I couldn't see Sakura anywhere around. What I could see though was a giant green glitchy creature standing right in front of me. "Summon your Servant, so-called 'Master'," they said to me, "The clock is ticking!"

GATEKEEPER, On the Day of Summoning (Tutorial Fight), those words for some reason materialised above me.

I-I don't have a catalyst, I wanted to tell this Gatekeeper, but feared what reason they'd have. But as a glowing light then appeared in my hands, I thought to myself, But… I'm still here, I can still summon a Heroic Spirit. Only then did my Servant appear before me:

[ ] A raven-haired woman carrying a quill dipped in nightmares.

[ ] A musical maid with a pistol for a baton.

[ ] A bespectacled brunette in alchemic armour.

[ ] A horseback warrior anointed by the angels.
[ ] A mage slayer blown in by the wind.
 
Last edited:
[X] A mage slayer blown in by the wind.

FUCK YES! DOROTHY! LESSGO!

*ahem*

More seriously, we need someone taking this seriously, Sakura and her Trans-Emperor of the Sun won't and Yakumo, while better, is still a bit laid back for war.

Also

OMG! IMAGINE THE DOROTHYXELGARBUS FLUFF!
 
I also wanted to say that, since this is a second choose-your-Servant vote (if a little more in line with how it works in Extra) it's gonna be another two day-er, possibly a three day-er
 
[X] A horseback warrior anointed by the angels.

forums.sufficientvelocity.com

Arlequine Lunaire's Character Compendium

So, unlike my previous genderbent Servants where there was some basis in their life (or in Kafka's case, the lack of an explanation is the explanation), I don't really have much of a reason with Bolivar, other than his costume looking very Takarazuka-like, and for one big Utena reference of...

I mean, if we want somebody to take this war serious, the military leader with little patience for the tomfoolery of others sounds like a good pick. Personal opposition aside, the angel anointing should also add some further thematic links. I don't necessarily think Simone and Elagabalus would get along with each other, but I do think they have plenty of room for interactions.

The choice aside, this is a pretty good spot to use Gatekeeper that plays to his strengths. Although, there goes Blut's gamer servant. I guess someone should go over the list and just pick out the egiest option. :V
[X] A horseback warrior anointed by the angels
Minor point, but you seem to be missing the period at the end of your vote, which can already be enough to throw the tally off.
 
OMG! IMAGINE THE DOROTHYXELGARBUS FLUFF!

Well in the event Dorothy doesn't win the vote, there's always omakes I guess

Also, surprised Edgedancer didn't go over the other options like last time

Although, there goes Blut's gamer servant. I guess someone should go over the list and just pick out the egiest option. :V

I won't say exactly who I have in mind for Blut, but off the top of my head my edgiest Servant would probably be Celtchar (well, there's also another contender for that title, but I was so uncomfortable with that sheet I didn't even threadmark it).
There's also Margaret Garner, but she's less 'edgy' and more 'downright depressing'
 
Last edited:
I mean, if we want somebody to take this war serious, the military leader with little patience for the tomfoolery of others sounds like a good pick. Personal opposition aside, the angel anointing should also add some further thematic links. I don't necessarily think Simone and Elagabalus would get along with each other, but I do think they have plenty of room for interactions.
Counterpoint; this isn't a war of armies, but of Individuals. Besides which, Dorothy is a Magus Killer and, say what you will about the Extra format, half of a HGW's participants are magi, so, as much as she'll hate it, it's open season for her.

Besides, the grumpier we make her, the sweeter the fluff with Elagabalus will be.
 
Also, surprised Edgedancer didn't go over the other options like last time
Ah, well, it mostly comes down to me not having figured out who the "bespectacled brunette" is, so if I can't do a full break down of everyone, it didn't really seem worth it to do it partially. Although, I guess I might as well link the sheets I did figure out in case someone else wants to take a look.
-A raven-haired woman carrying a quill dipped in nightmares.
forums.sufficientvelocity.com

Arlequine Lunaire's Character Compendium

(False) Foreigner of Humanity (Artist: MoeLiliy) "Magic doesn't create, it summons... And it's fate's cruel joke that you've summoned vermin like me" True Name: Franziska Kafka Alternate Classes: Berserker (of self-loathing), Caster, Avenger, Rider, Watcher Source: History Region: Central...
-A musical maid with a pistol for a baton.
forums.sufficientvelocity.com

Arlequine Lunaire's Character Compendium

Avenger of the Orchestra "I put everything into my music, my life, my love, my darkened heart. If you can't see its majesty, there's a seat in Hell's auditorium for you!" (By Maekawa Suu) True Name: Hector Berlioz Alt. Classes: Caster, Berserker, Archer (Gunner), Assassin, Faker, Voyager...
- A bespectacled brunette in alchemic armour.
?
-A horseback warrior anointed by the angels.
forums.sufficientvelocity.com

Arlequine Lunaire's Character Compendium

So, unlike my previous genderbent Servants where there was some basis in their life (or in Kafka's case, the lack of an explanation is the explanation), I don't really have much of a reason with Bolivar, other than his costume looking very Takarazuka-like, and for one big Utena reference of...
-A mage slayer blown in by the wind.
forums.sufficientvelocity.com

Arlequine Lunaire's Character Compendium

Foreigner of Kansas (by Poimx. Source under 'see all') "Alright, let's get this over with. Tell me which witch you want dead this time." True Name: Dorothy Gale Alt. Classes: Assassin, Voyager, Caster, Rider Source: Public Domain Fiction, The Wonderful Wizard of Oz Region: USA, Oz...

Looking back on it, I also kinda skipped over combat capabilities, didn't I? Well, to cover our two top runers at least:

Simone: All around pretty solid, with a decent amount of flexibility that lets them adapt to the opponents strength without actually requiring a specific match up. Not powerful enough to be broken in terms of raw power, but an excellent match for an Extra style grail war.

Disengage is great for prodding the enemy Servant for information about their abilities without having to worry about over-extending and reveal information themselves. Alongside with Amemiya being able to gather information, it should work pretty well to leverage Rider's versatility into forming an effective strategy tailored to their opponent.

Knight of Owner: Too low a rank to become a huge game changer, but the added versatility is nice bonus. Also, it never hurts to be able to pull out a gun. (Side note: If you're still bothered with Knight of Owner being locked to Lancelot, you could probably just swap it out for Martial Blessing. It's technically more focused on being able to use NP off-class rather than using regular weapons at NP level, but it's close enough that it should work just fine when used at a lower rank than Rama's. Granted, it's not like being able to use Liberator's Swordas a Noble Phantasm as a NP that's just ranked down when compared to the version they'd have as a Saber would be odd for a Rider in the first place, but that's whatever.)

Spark of Rebellion might get limited use if the format forces one on one fights without allies, but man, if we ever run into a Master-Servant pair with a strained relationship, this skill can pull some nasty shenanigans on them.

Strategy: A pretty good force multiplier for both their own Noble Phantasm and for the general playstyle of gathering information on a specific opponent to then formulate a game plan for the proper showdown. It ties the entire design very neatly together.

In terms of Noble Phantasm, Palomo & Nevado are a decently strong option for a frontal attack with some nice side benefits, while Cinca Angeles is once again highly versatile and can be applies in a multitude of ways. The least of which is basically pulling an Ionioi Hetairoi and just kinda noping out of this being one on one duels.

Dorothy: An incredibly match up dependant Servant, even more so than Elagabalus and with less general ability to fall back on from the looks of it. So yeah, I'm not sure to which extend we want to pull a "the QM won't throw a fight at us we can't win" but when Dorothy struggles, she's going to struggle hard.

Fairy Contract might help with making allies and avoiding escalation, but I doubt it's going to get us very far in a war where confrontation is inevitable.

Innocent Monster looks like more of a lore skill, which is neat in terms of design, but has little application in actual battle.

Magus Killer is extremely volatile that can range from a game changer to effectively useless. In other words, a prime example of her relying on a good match up, rather than having solid foundation that allow her to adapt. That being said, a lot of high level servants have a high mana stat, even if they specialize in physical combat, so it's not as bad as it might be.

Self-Modification does give her some decent combat options, however, it's still limited to enhancing her as a physical hand to hand fighter. That's probably not going to cut it when having to go up against a martial while only having middling strength.

For Noble Phantasm, we have one that's once again entirely match up dependant with No Place Like Home (which sadly isn't just dropping a house on somebody's head), although the chance to get lost is a kinda iffy downside even at the best of times. Twister over the Rainbow meawhile is oddly much more reliable (assuming we have no twist team fight thrown our way) despite being very hard to control, thanks to a tornado being something that's hardly ever ineffective, even without a good match up, and giving Dorothy an option that doesn't require her to engage in hand to hand with possibly disastrous strength. It's only one trick, but it's a good one.
I won't say exactly who I have in mind for Blut, but off the top of my head my edgiest Servant would probably be Celtchar
Assassin of Bloodlust. Well, the title would fit, if nothing else.
Counterpoint; this isn't a war of armies, but of Individuals. Besides which, Dorothy is a Magus Killer and, say what you will about the Extra format, half of a HGW's participants are magi, so, as much as she'll hate it, it's open season for her.

Besides, the grumpier we make her, the sweeter the fluff with Elagabalus will be.
So, you raised this point just as I was in breaking down their combat abilities and I'm going to say that from a practical point of view, Simone wins hands down. Short of pulling a Gawain and using a Servant so overhwelmingly powerful that they don't need to worry about strategy, Simone is the next best thing thanks to having the adaptability to perform well regardless of match up. As a niffty side-effect, this also pulls a lot of agency in our hands by giving us the tools to strategize rather than being reactive, which is great for a Quest narrative.

Funnily enough, between a low magic score, an anti-dodge NP, high mobility and the ability to create what amounts to magic heat sinks that can misdirect the green twister, Simone might as well be custom build to hard counter Dorothy. Although, it's not like that's going to be relevant. Probably.

We also don't really need a Servant to go after a Master. They're pretty squishy by default (and to be entirely honest, I somewhat doubt we'd be allowed to just skip over the Servant battle by assassinating the Master in the first place, so it's kind of a moot point).

All of that being said, personality is very important here, so it's perfectly understandable to not care about any of that and just vote based on which charater you thing you're going to prefer reading about. Like, I'd probably still vote for the handsome charming general that has a good mix between social skills backed by philosophical deepth and pragmatic ruthlessness, even if the skills connected to that personality weren't of such a high quality.
 
For Noble Phantasm, we have one that's once again entirely match up dependant with No Place Like Home (which sadly isn't just dropping a house on somebody's head),

Twister Over the Rainbow does allow Dorothy to do exactly that

About Dorothy, I was thinking of changing her class from Foreigner to Archer (as I guess 'a water bucket' and 'a house' count as projectiles). While Oz definitely doesn't conform to standard Earth logic, I've been told since it's still on Earth and not space or anything (well, except in that one Heinlein story, funnily enough) that it makes Dorothy a real stretch for the class

I should also note that the Parameters are generally the thing I give the least attention to when writing my sheets. Like I do try to make them at least plausible for the Servant in question, but in a mechanics-lite Quest like this they'd be mostly an afterthought (which'd be different in the event I was running something mechanics-heavier)
 
Back
Top