- Location
- Earth
FWIW: I do not feel like I had terribly much support in the hugh monofocus.
- Location
- Earth
This is a good note but shady as hell to try to argue that a newbie should actually have a reasonable explanation for their actions ready at a moment's notice.
CTRosen
Rock Man
- Location
- Northwest PA
- Pronouns
- He/Him
There wasn't any truly widespread focus from what I can tell, just some broad support on the case itself until focus shifted over to the Zone/Shadell stuff. My judgment is that Hugh and Shalmoa themselves did the most to keep that interaction going, and both dropped it once it came close enough to EoD to truly justify self-pres votes.
- Pronouns
- Any
Zone's interaction with Shadell is the other case of this:
Lynch her D2 if she keeps slanking. D1 has a total of 72 hours including a couple replacements. Slanking should not be a thing at all in this game.
I need more context. @Shadell, why did you stay on Rosen's wagon?
I didn't get the memo that you guys aren't used to playing without Majority, so people (especially town) ganging up on Rosen is the equivalent to willaging to me.
...in case I misunderstood your post and you wanted to ask me what these terms mean:
- Willaging = Villager / Town acting Wolfy / Scummy
- v!Player / w!Player = Player when they play as villager / wolf
Wow, uh... I understand Nictis' answer, and where I come from, most players are also very lenient on newbies, but I just couldn't believe the same thing is happening here.
I am flabbergasted. I thought my homesite was the only place filled with uh... "kind-hearted souls" except for me.
[X] Shadell
Don't even bother hiding behind excuses. Remove the safety wheels and just hit me with all you got, because otherwise I will hunt you down.
Your personal read on me is fine, but ultimately wrong. Nothing I can do to convince you out of this: You just have to get to know me mid-game.
Me constantly asking for Shalmoa's help is my personal best choice to avoid backreading because I'm a lazy player. (Having said that, this game's D1 output is so low that I'm actually backreading.)
Again, it wasn't like you were trying to evaluate her, just push her. You flat out ignored Shal's answer that Shad's behavior is normal. But you continued to push the idea that it was scum and parked your vote on her even after she dismantled your push.
Nictis
Best Sidekick
- Location
- Ninja Dave's Cookies
- Pronouns
- Any
I'm kinda stuck in two different reads of a situation with three possibilities. I don't really have a read on Hugh, and my read on Shalmoa is based on Shalmoa's actions around Hugh. I'm viewing it as either they're both Town and scum have just let it suck all the air of the room, or they're both scum and doing a strange kind of performance where they pivot out at the last moment while still getting credit if the other dies. Except if we kill one and they're Town that'll just make us need to confirm the other as well.
I'm feeling like taking out someone who has largely stayed away from it but still pushed it on. Which I'm recalling as Zaealix in particular. I'll need to check on that.
I'm feeling like taking out someone who has largely stayed away from it but still pushed it on. Which I'm recalling as Zaealix in particular. I'll need to check on that.
- Location
- Earth
I'm still of the opinion that Zaea's thought process is really pure, even if it also ends up being not even remotely townie when evaluated without the context of Zaealix. I think of the more LHF votes, this would be one of the worst.
- Location
- Earth
I'm gonna ask you the same question I've asked basically everyone else then:
If I flip scum, who do you think needs to be investigated next? If I flip town, who do you think needs to be investigated next?
hugh_donnetono
No use to complain
- Location
- Caught Out In The Rain
- Pronouns
- Any
Hugh
Zone
These are pretty straightforward from what I've posted, no?
Nictis
Best Sidekick
- Location
- Ninja Dave's Cookies
- Pronouns
- Any
Third vote on Rosen initially and second to back off. I'm pretty sure I've mentioned before that this just seems strange and not really like Zaealix.
sees Hugh post.
Uhh.
Uhhhhhhhhhh.
- Pronouns
- Any
Thanks @ hugh
Are you against switching to zone?
CTRosen
Rock Man
- Location
- Northwest PA
- Pronouns
- He/Him
Kinda had the same reaction to seeing this. Not that I'm feeling particularly insecure right now, but Hugh's vote being left there kinda strikes me the wrong way.sees Hugh post.
Uhh.
Uhhhhhhhhhh.
Nictis
Best Sidekick
- Location
- Ninja Dave's Cookies
- Pronouns
- Any
hugh_donnetono
No use to complain
- Location
- Caught Out In The Rain
yeah it is kinda concerning😰
now that you mention it, it is pretty interesting that shalmoa would hop on my pokewagon instead of any of the various other viable ones, huh... 🤔sees Hugh post.
Uhh.
Uhhhhhhhhhh.
CTRosen
Rock Man
- Location
- Northwest PA
- Pronouns
- He/Him
I rescind my previous post, I'm not sure why I had that initial reaction to it when this is probably just a better way of looking at it.
Nictis
Best Sidekick
- Location
- Ninja Dave's Cookies
- Pronouns
- Any
You have no idea how glad I am to have a gun right now.
Zone Q11
Monochrome Plebeian
- Pronouns
- He/Him/His
I have unreasonably high standards when it comes to newbies.
Yes and no. In my latest post that you quoted (P#330), I had already accepted that Shadell's argument to not switch votes was reasonable (which has nothing to do with Shalmoa FWIW).
I did not specify that Shadell was scum anymore after my push had been dismantled, but I indeed kept pushing her nonetheless "for some reason" no matter what her alignment was.
Do whatever you want with this, but it is what happened.
hugh_donnetono
No use to complain
- Location
- Caught Out In The Rain
- @-Rosen - light sus, wouldn't mind if he got voted, mostly have my vote there to put that money where my mouth is and to see if anyone chooses to jump on it (cough).
- @Zone Q11 - has some weird... I suppose biases? that I don't think are helpful but seems to be playing pretty well besides that. light town.
- @Shalmoa - light sus, wouldn't mind if he, got voted, didn't actually vote for him cuz I didn't think his wagon would need help
- @InterstellarHobo - ih why
- @hugh_donnetono - definitely scum
- @Seven - seems to be playing alright? light town
- @Cyricubed - seems like he knows what he's doing? moderate town
- @Zaealix - definitely zaealix
- @NemoMarx - could be posting more I think. null.
- @Nictis - definitely nictis
- @Scia - way more active than usual, which is good but also unusual. null.
- @Kingster - has that newbie town vibe, but also many have pointed out some pretty good points as to why the things he's done have been sus. null.
- Location
- Earth
-Rosen: Strangely set on ignoring even considering town!Shal as a world. I don't feel -Rosen's expanding his hunting to try and catch anything here, but there might be shenanigans I just missed. Scumlean.
Zone Q11: I can follow along with his presses, he commits to his presses, and I don't feel like he's actually misrepresenting anything. Culture clash, slightly shady continued shading of Kingster, but overall townlean.
InterstellarHobo: MIA, null read, possible POE scum.
hugh_donnetono: More interesting as an anvil than dead. Possibly POE scum, but I'm not actually reading them as that?
Seven: Pretty pure progression, clean arguments, townlean.
Cyricubed: Feels the purest of anyone pushing on me. Townlean, but quieter than usual.
Zaealix: Too pure to be a wolf. Townread.
NemoMarx: Pretty pure, does not commit easily, townlean.
Nictis: Feels like actually hunting. Leaning towards town!Nictis arrangement again. Some slightly scummy pushing, but current arrangement is properly interesting.
Scia: Null read, I feel like she's committed more than usual this game but gamestate is leaving her absent in the way it usually does when she's actually town.
Kingster: Townread, for reasons I've stated several times.
In short, I want to kill -Rosen, hugh, and IH in basically that order at the moment.