Yeah... Jenny Nicholson is hilariously good for someone who's entire set up is sitting on her bed talking to a camera.
I was looking through her other stuff and realised I've seen her Westworld video :D

But back to RPO she also has the Girls' Translation:

(That pinned comment... so many people totally fell for it :p)
 
Best never let anyone know what you did. The Oasis,(Going by the book) also serves as virtual class rooms and across the country communications/business/shopping due to the gas shortage. So collapsing that means many people will be after your head.

OASIS education probably isn't worth a whole lot, considering that the result of this is a universe of kids who know nothing but 80's trivia and are utterly disengaged with the world outside of the OASIS. There's no evidence of any moving on to better things or actual livable careers among the students. They might be a lot better off if they replaced the not-education in the OASIS with the real education of living in the actual real world and getting pissed off about how much it sucks.
 
OASIS education probably isn't worth a whole lot, considering that the result of this is a universe of kids who know nothing but 80's trivia and are utterly disengaged with the world outside of the OASIS. There's no evidence of any moving on to better things or actual livable careers among the students. They might be a lot better off if they replaced the not-education in the OASIS with the real education of living in the actual real world and getting pissed off about how much it sucks.
...no, he means actual education. There's an entire world dedicated to nothing but school. Like, actual school. Not 80s shit. Do you not remember the entire beginning of the book?

Also, another point in favor of not shutting the oasis off, it's literally replaced public education.
 
...no, he means actual education. There's an entire world dedicated to nothing but school. Like, actual school. Not 80s shit. Do you not remember the entire beginning of the book?

Also, another point in favor of not shutting the oasis off, it's literally replaced public education.

Alternatively: Shut OASIS off, and use a separate service, not infected by original nerd sin.
 
Alternatively: Shut OASIS off, and use a separate service, not infected by original nerd sin.
Alright, I am actually interested. What would you propose replacing it with in the universe of RPO? That's a worthy topic. Public Education is being provided to anyone with access to a helmet/terminal/whatever (Which would probably be cheaper than traditional school supplies), so what could you replace it with that would function as cheap as virtual reality, as widely accessible as virtual reality, and that has capabilities of a holodeck? Heck, another thing to add to the pile, it's way easier to keep control. Students can't assault others, they can't disrupt class physically, and a myriad of other things that would make teachers lives easier. This is one of the very positive things about RPO, even if it says negative things about the universe.
 
Break OASIS up into a series of separate services under public control?

You can keep education in a VR environment, but just overseen by Public interests and not you know, beholden to an infantalizing dystopian private enterprise for its operation and existance.
 
Last edited:
"Our private server schools do, in fact, allow our students to shot each other with lasers!" :V
 
Break OASIS up into a series of separate services under public control?

You can keep education in a VR environment, but just overseen by Public interests and not you know, beholden to an infantalizing dystopian private enterprise for its operation and existance.
"We provide a private alternative to public education, one that's in many ways logistically superior and otherwise superior to what the public sector could offer!"
"Oh, what a nice opportunity! Let's take it away from you and break it into pieces in accordance to our own vision!"

I'm all for state and private education coexisting, but through the government making its own infrastructure (this is what taxes are for!), not taking away someone else's.
 
I'm all for state and private education coexisting, but through the government making its own infrastructure (this is what taxes are for!), not taking away someone else's.

So a company that has a monopoly over almost every aspect of everyone's life is fine then? Some privately held corporation that could decide at a whim to start teaching, for example, undiluted Nazi propaganda?

(On the other hand, you're talking to woman that doesn't believe that any sort of private corporation should exist in the first place)
 
Listen, I'm all for privatization, but the OASIS is a) operating without any sort of accountability in their education, and b) is still just sitting in a chair alone, at the end of the day. No one moves in RPO.
 
So a company that has a monopoly over almost every aspect of everyone's life is fine then? Some privately held corporation that could decide at a whim to start teaching, for example, undiluted Nazi propaganda?
It has a monopoly (at best) over the stuff it invented/discovered/researched/developed. They just so happened to come up with something that's better than what the state offers. Even assuming that they have a monopoly on some patent that enables OASIS, patents have a finite lifetime specifically to balance the rights of the individual vs. the interests of the collective. If there isn't a patent that is the source of the monopoly, then the government is free to built its own infrastructure, just like it does in states with a healthy policy of public education.

Also, 'could' != 'will'. In fact, distinguishing between 'could' and 'will' is absolutely essential to society functioning, trust being possible etc. If society equated will and could, it would break down.
 
Also, 'could' != 'will'. In fact, distinguishing between 'could' and 'will' is absolutely essential to society functioning, trust being possible etc. If society equated will and could, it would break down.
You always plan for what could happen, even if it won't.

Because the alternative is being fucked when it unsurprisingly happen.
 
You always plan for what could happen, even if it won't.

Because the alternative is being fucked when it unsurprisingly happen.
You do. But you don't proverbially shoot people first and ask questions later. You don't infringe on people's right just because maybe they'll do something wrong in the future. Unless you think the trigger happy USAian cop mentality is the way people should behave.
 
You do. But you don't proverbially shoot people first and ask questions later. You don't infringe on people's right just because maybe they'll do something wrong in the future. Unless you think the trigger happy USAian cop mentality is the way people should behave.

Corporations aren't people. They don't have rights. And they should always be kept at gunpoint.
 
You know, I do find the whole 'Virtual school world' one of the few interesting ideas Ready Player one presents. I wish there was a story exploring something like that.
 
Corporations aren't people. They don't have rights. And they should always be kept at gunpoint.
Of course corps aren't people, but they don't need to be. They're just a legal tool for optimising the handling of some rights of the people (e.g. making collective ownership of stuff and bankruptcies more handleable etc.).
 
Corporations are certainly an optimizer.

A paperclip optimizer.
 
It has a monopoly (at best) over the stuff it invented/discovered/researched/developed. They just so happened to come up with something that's better than what the state offers.
So all the power should be with that company because they did it first?
As for 'the state,' seeing as it's the fault of corporations that it can't how is that an argument?

That's saying that the problem shouldn't be solved because the thing that caused the problem has all the power. The solution is to take that power away, not give in.
 

Yet another review/analysis.
(From the guys who do the We've Got Worm/Ward podcast.)
 
Back
Top